Exegetical and Hermeneutical Commentary of Ecclesiastes 4:10

For if they fall, the one will lift up his fellow: but woe to him [that is] alone when he falleth; for [he hath] not another to help him up.

They; one of them, the plural being put for the singular, as Jon 1:5; Mat 21:7; 1Ti 2:15. Or both of them successively.

Fall, in any kind, into any mistakes and errors, or sins, or dangers and distresses.

Will lift up his fellow; hold him up if he be falling, or raise him up if he be fallen.

Fuente: English Annotations on the Holy Bible by Matthew Poole

10. if they fallif the oneor other fall, as may happen to both, namely, into anydistress of body, mind, or soul.

Fuente: Jamieson, Fausset and Brown’s Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible

For if they fall, the one will lift up his fellow,…. That is, if anyone of them fall, the other will lift him up, as they are travelling together, in whatsoever manner; if one falls from his horse, or out of his carriage, or into a ditch, the other will endeavour to raise him up again: this, as it is true in a natural, so in a figurative and metaphorical sense, with religious persons especially;

“if one of them falls upon the bed, and lies sick,”

as the Targum paraphrases it, his friend and brother in a religions community will visit him, and sympathize with him, and speak a word of comfort to him, and pray with him, which may issue in his restoration. So the Targum,

“the other will cause his friend to rise by his prayer;”

or if he fall into outward distress, poverty, and want, his spiritual friend or friends will distribute to his necessity; if he falls into errors, as a good man may, such as are of the same religious society with him will take some pains to convince him of the error of his way, and to convert him from it, and to save a soul from death, and cover a multitude of sins; and if he falls into sin, to which the best of men are liable, such as are spiritual will endeavour to restore him in a spirit of meekness;

but woe to him [that is] alone when he falleth! for [he hath] not another to help him up; no companion to raise him up when fallen; no Christian friend to visit and comfort him when sick, to relieve him under his necessities, when poor and afflicted, or to recover him from errors in judgment, or immoralities in practice; and especially if he has not Christ with him to raise him up, keep, and uphold him.

Fuente: John Gill’s Exposition of the Entire Bible

“For if they fall, the one can raise up his fellow: but woe to the one who falleth, and there is not a second there to lift him up.” Only the Targ., which Grtz follows, confounds

(Note: With Munach and Rebia in one word, which, according to the masora, occurs in only four other places. Vid., Mas. magna under this passage, and Mishpete hateamin 26 a.)

with ; it is equivalent to , Isa 3:9, or , Eze 13:18. Haehhad is appos. connecting itself to the pronominal suff., as, e.g., in a far more inappropriate manner, Psa 86:2; the prep. is not in appos. usually repeated, Gen 2:19; Gen 9:4 (exceptions: Ps. 18:51; Psa 74:14). Whether we translate by qui ceciderit (Ecc 11:3), or by quum ceciderit (Jerome), is all one. is potential: it is possible and probable that it will be done, provided he is a , i.e., a true friend ( Pirke aboth, ii. 13).

Fuente: Keil & Delitzsch Commentary on the Old Testament

(10) Woe.The word occurs only here and in Ecc. 10:16, but is common in post-Biblical Hebrew.

Fuente: Ellicott’s Commentary for English Readers (Old and New Testaments)

10. For if they fall Better, “For if one fall.” The illustration is drawn from travelling, but it may be applied to any of the numerous mishaps of life. “God never made an independent man.” Each depends on another.

Fuente: Whedon’s Commentary on the Old and New Testaments

Ecc 4:10 For if they fall, the one will lift up his fellow: but woe to him [that is] alone when he falleth; for [he hath] not another to help him up.

Ver. 10. For if they fall, the one will lift up his fellow. ] Provided that they hold together and be both of a mind. That which is stronger shoreth up that which is weaker. While Latimer and Rid ley lived, they kept up Cranmer, by intercourse of letters and otherwise, from entertaining counsels of revolt. Bishop Ridley, being prisoner in the Tower, had the liberty of the same, to prove, belike, whether he would go to mass or not, which once he did. And Mr Bradford, being there prisoner, and hearing thereof, wrote an effectual letter to persuade him from the same, which did Mr Ridley no little good, for he repented, &c. a Bishop Farrar also being in the King’s Bench prisoner, was travailed with by the Papists at the end of Lent to receive the sacrament at Easter in one kind, who, after much persuading, yielded to them, and promised so to do. But, by God’s good providence, the Easter evening, the day before he should have done it, was Bradford brought to the same prison, where, the Lord making him his instrument, Bradford only was the means that the said bishop revoked his promise, and would never after yield to be spotted with that Papistical pitch. b Dr Taylor for like cause rejoiced that ever he came into prison, there to be acquainted with that angel of God, John Bradford: so he called him, for the good he received from him. c One man may be an angel to another in regard of counsel and comfort; nay, a God to another, as Moses was to Aaron. “Though he fall, he shall arise,” for the Lord puts under his hand. Psa 37:24

But woe to him that is alone. ] Because Satan is readiest to assault when none is by to assist. Solitariness, therefore, is not to be affected, because it is “the hour of temptation.”

For he hath not a second to help him up. ] As Elizabeth Cowper, the martyr, in Queen Mary’s days had, who, being condemned, and at the stake with Simon Miller, when the fire came unto her she a little shrank thereat, crying once, Ah! When Simon heard the same, he put his hand behind him toward her, and willed her to be strong and of good cheer; for, ‘Good sister,’ said he, ‘we shall soon have a joyful and sweet supper. It is but winking a little, and you are in heaven.’ With these and the like speeches, she, being strengthened, stood still and quiet, as one most glad to finish that good work. d It was therefore a devilish policy in Julian and other heathen persecutors to banish Christians into far countries one from another, and to confine them to isles and mines, where they could not have access one to another.

a Acts and Mon., fol. 1930.

b Ibid., 1457.

c Ibid.

d Ibid., 1981.

Fuente: John Trapp’s Complete Commentary (Old and New Testaments)

if: Exo 32:2-4, Exo 32:21, Deu 9:19, Deu 9:20, 1Sa 23:16, 2Sa 11:27, 2Sa 12:7-14, Job 4:3, Job 4:4, Isa 35:3, Isa 35:4, Luk 22:31, Luk 22:32, Gal 2:11-14, Gal 6:1, 1Th 4:18, 1Th 5:11

but: Gen 4:8, 2Sa 14:6

Reciprocal: Gen 3:1 – he said Jdg 13:23 – his wife Ezr 1:4 – help him Mar 6:7 – two and

Fuente: The Treasury of Scripture Knowledge

Ecc 4:10-12. For, if they fall If one or more of them fall in any way; as into any mistakes, and errors, or sins, dangers, or distresses. The one will lift up his fellow Will hold him up, if he be falling, or raise him up, if he be fallen. If two lie together, then they have heat They will be sooner warm in a cold bed and a cold season. So virtuous and gracious affections are excited by good society; and Christians warm one another, by provoking one another to love and good works. But how can one be warm alone? How can the warmth and fervency of true Christian love and zeal be retained by him who stands aloof from, and has no intercourse with, his fellow-Christians? If one prevail against him If an enemy, visible or invisible, might easily prevail against either or any of them, if not associated with others, two or more, uniting their counsels and efforts, will be able to withstand him; and a three-fold cord is not quickly broken If a man have not only one, but two or more friends to assist him, he is so much the more secure against all assaults, and therefore the more happy. Thus, in our spiritual warfare, we may be helpful to each other as well as in our spiritual work. And next to the comfort of communion with God, is that of the communion of saints. For they that dwell in love dwell in God, and God in them.

Fuente: Joseph Bensons Commentary on the Old and New Testaments