Exegetical and Hermeneutical Commentary of Ecclesiastes 9:5
For the living know that they shall die: but the dead know not any thing, neither have they any more a reward; for the memory of them is forgotten.
5. For the living know that they shall die ] The writer in one of the strange paradoxes of the mood of pessimism finds that though life is vanity, it is yet better than the death which he looks upon as its only outcome. There is a greatness in the very consciousness of the coming doom. Man, knowing he must perish and lamenting over his fate, is nobler than those that are already numbered with the dead. There is a pride even in the cry with which those who enter on the arena as doomed to death greet the sovereign Power that dooms them:
“Ave, Csar; morituri te salutamus.”
“Hail to thee Csar, hail! on our way to our death-doom we greet thee.”
They were nobler then than when their bleeding and mangled car-cases on the arena were all that was left of them.
neither have they any more a reward ] The words exclude the thought (in the then phase of the Debater’s feeling) of reward in a life after death, but the primary meaning of the word is that of “hire” and “wages” (Gen 30:28; Exo 2:9), and the idea conveyed is that the dead no longer find, as on earth, that which rewards their labour. There is no longer even death to look forward to as the wages of his life.
So we have in Shakespeare:
“Thou thy worldly task hast done,
Home art gone and ta’en thy wages.”
Cymbeline, Act iv., Sc. 2.
for the memory of them is forgotten ] The Hebrew gives an assonance between “reward” ( sheker) and “memory” ( zeker), which it is hard to reproduce in English. “Reward” and “record” suggest themselves as the nearest approximation. For the thought see note on ch. Ecc 1:11. Even the immortality of living in the memory of others, which modern thinkers have substituted for the Christian hope, is denied to the vast majority of mankind.
Fuente: The Cambridge Bible for Schools and Colleges
See Ecc 8:12, note; Ecc 8:14, note. The living are conscious that there is a future before them: but the dead are unconscious; they earn nothing, receive nothing, even the memory of them soon disappears; they are no longer excited by the passions which belong to people in this life; their share in its activity has ceased. Solomon here describes what he sees, not what he believes; there is no reference here to the fact or the mode of the existence of the soul in another world, which are matters of faith.
The last clause of Ecc 9:6 indicates that the writer confines his observations on the dead to their portion in, or relation to, this world.
Ecc 9:6
Now – Rather: long ago.
Fuente: Albert Barnes’ Notes on the Bible
Ecc 9:5
For the living know that they shall die.
A funeral sermon
I. Whence it is that the living attain the sure and infallible knowledge of their own death.
1. There be many things from whence we may collect the necessity of dying.
(1) We may collect it by those harbingers and forerunners of death, diseases, pains, and natural decays which are incident to all men.
(2) The observation of deaths universal empire over all other things, and over all other men, may give us a certain knowledge that we also must shortly die.
(3) We may certainly know ourselves mortal by knowing ourselves sinful creatures. There is a double necessity of death on account of sin. As a punishment. As a purgation of it.
2. Now, though, by these and other such-like considerations, we may arrive at a certain knowledge that we shall die; yet the particular circumstances of the time and manner of our death are known to God only.
(1) He only knows the critical and punctual time of our death; for He hath determined it, to a very moment.
(2) In what manner our death will appear to us, we know not: this is a secret of Gods own breast.
II. Whence it proceeds, that men are so stupidly irrational, that, though they all know they. Shall die, yet so few seriously prepare themselves for it.
1. Men are generally so immersed in the businesses and pleasures of life, that these swallow up all serious thoughts of death and preparations for it. They are employed about other things: like a heap of ants, that are busily toiling to get in their provision, without regarding the foot that is ready to crush them. Such are the impertinent and vain cares of men! The riches and honours, which are but the dust and smoke of this world, have so blinded our eyes, that we cannot discern the near approaches of death; and thus, while we, Archimedes like, are busily drawing projects and designs in the dust, and are wholly intent about vainer speculations than his, we mind not the alarm, nor perceive the enemy is upon us, till we are stricken dead through the reins.
2. Men delay serious preparations for death, because they generally look upon it as afar off.
(1) Men reckon old age a vast while off.
(2) Most men presume that they shall live to extreme age.
(3) Men think a few of their latest days and thoughts are enough to prepare them for death. Think you your souls can then vigorously bestir themselves when they are grown stiff with age; when your faculties are benumbed, and your spirits congealed past the thaw of a fire?
3. Men generally put off serious thoughts of dying because of the terrors and insupportable dread which such apprehensions bring with them. And therefore death is called (Job 18:14) the king of terrors: a king that comes attended with a thousand phantoms and frightful apparitions.
III. Application.
1. If we all certainly know that we must die, this might teach us so much wisdom as not to set our affections eagerly upon anything in this present world; a world which we must shortly leave.
2. Since we all know that we shall die, let this serve to exhort us seriously to prepare for our death. Some sad instances there have been of those who, having neglected this great work till the end of their life, have then spent that little remnant of time which they had in crying out for more. But if we have carefully prepared ourselves for death, it will be to us a repose instead of a terror. (Bp. E. Hopkins.)
Fuente: Biblical Illustrator Edited by Joseph S. Exell
Verse 5. The living know that they shall die] This is so self-evident that none can doubt it; and therefore all that have this conviction should prepare for death and eternal blessedness.
But the dead know not any thing] Cut off from life, they know nothing of what passes under the sun. Their day of probation is ended, and therefore they can have no farther reward in living a holy life; nor can they be liable to any farther punishment for crimes in a state of probation, that being ended.
Fuente: Adam Clarke’s Commentary and Critical Notes on the Bible
The living know that they shall die; whereby they are taught to improve life, whilst they have it, to their greatest comfort and advantage.
The dead know not anything, to wit, of the actions and events in this world, as this is limited in the end of the next verse. Compare Job 14:21; Isa 13:16.
A reward; the reward or fruit of their labours in this world, which is utterly lost as to them, and enjoyed by others. See Ecc 2:21. For otherwise, that there are future rewards after death, is asserted by Solomon elsewhere, as we have seen, and shall hereafter see.
Is forgotten, to wit, amongst living men, and even in those places where they had lived in great power and glory; as was noted, Ecc 8:10.
Fuente: English Annotations on the Holy Bible by Matthew Poole
5. know that they shall dieandmay thereby be led “so to number their days, that they may applytheir hearts to wisdom” (Ecc 7:1-4;Psa 90:12).
dead know not anythingthatis, so far as their bodily senses and worldly affairsare concerned (Job 14:21;Isa 63:16); also, they know nodoor of repentance open to them, such as is to all on earth.
neither . . . rewardnoadvantage from their worldly labors (Ecc 2:18-22;Ecc 4:9).
memorynot of therighteous (Psa 112:6; Mal 3:16),but the wicked, who with all the pains to perpetuate theirnames (Ps 49:11) are soon”forgotten” (Ec 8:10).
Fuente: Jamieson, Fausset and Brown’s Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible
For the living know that they shall die,…. Death is certain, it is the demerit of sin, the appointment of God and the time of it is fixed; it may be known that it will be, from the word of God that assures it, from all experience which confirms it, and from the decline of nature, and the seeds of death in men. This “the living” know that live corporeally, even the wicked themselves, though they put the evil day far from them; and so good men, that live spiritually, being quickened by the Spirit and grace of God, and live a life of faith and holiness; they know they shall die, though Christ died for them, and has abolished death, as a punishment and a curse, and took away its sting, and made it a blessing; wherefore it is desirable to them, as being for their good: but there are some things about death they ordinarily know not; they do not know the time of their death; nor the place where they shall die; nor of what death they shall die; nor in what circumstances, both outward and inward: of these the Targum understands the passage;
“for the righteous know that if they sin, they shall be reckoned as dead men in the world to come, therefore they keep their ways, and sin not; but if they sin, they return by repentance;”
but the dead know not anything; this is not to be understood of their separate spirits, and of the things of the other world; for the righteous dead know much, their knowledge is greatly increased; they know, as they are known; they know much of God in Christ, of his perfections, purposes, covenant, grace, and love; they know much of Christ, of his person, offices, and glory, and see him as he is; they know much of the Gospel, and the mysteries of it; and of angels, and the spirits of just men, they now converse with; and of the glories and happiness of the heavenly state; even they know abundantly more than they did in this life: and the wicked dead, in their separate spirits, know there is a God that judgeth; that their souls are immortal; that there is a future state; indeed they know and feel the torments of hell, the worm that never dies, and the fire that is not quenched: but this is to be interpreted of their bodily senses now extinct, and of worldly things they have now nothing to do with; they know not any thing that is done in this world, nor how it fares with their children and friends they have left behind them; see Job 14:21; nor therefore are they to be prayed unto, and used as mediators with God. The Targum is,
“and sinners know not any good, so that they do not make their works good while they live; and they know not any good in the world to come;”
neither have they any more a reward; not but that there will be rewards in a future state, in which everyone shall have his own reward; there will be a reward for the righteous; they will receive the reward of the inheritance, though it will be, not of debt, but of grace; and particularly in the millennium state, Ps 58:11; and every transgression of the wicked will receive a just recompence of reward; to whom the reward of their hands will be given them, Heb 2:2; but the sense is, that after death there will be no enjoyment of a man’s labours; he will not have the use, profit, and advantage of them, but his heirs that succeed him, Ec 4:9;
for the memory of them is forgotten; not the memory of the righteous with God, for whom a book of remembrance is written, and whose names are written in heaven; these are had in everlasting remembrance, and their memory blessed: but the memory of wicked men; who, though they take pains to perpetuate their names, which they give to their lands, yet the Lord causes their memory to cease, and they are forgotten in the place where they lived; not only among the righteous, as the Targum, but among others, Isa 26:14; even among those that enjoy the fruit of their labour; they will scarce think of them any more, or, however, in a little time they will be quite forgotten by them.
Fuente: John Gill’s Exposition of the Entire Bible
He sarcastically verifies his comparison in favour of a living dog. “For the living know that they shall die; but the dead know not anything, and have no more a reward; for their memory is forgotten. Their love, as well as their hatred and their envy, has long ago perished, and they have part no more for ever in all that is done under the sun.” The description of the condition of death begins sarcastically and then becomes elegiac. “They have no reward further,” viz., in this upper world, since there it is only too soon forgotten that they once existed, and that they did anything worthy of being remembered; Koheleth might here indeed, with his view shrouded in dark clouds, even suppose that God also forgot them, Job 14:13. The suff. of , etc., present themselves was subjective, and there is no reason, with Knobel and Ginsburg, to render them objectively: not merely the objects of their love, and hatred, and envy, are lost to them, but these their affections and strivings themselves have ceased (Rosenm., Hitzig, Zckl., and others), they lie ( Kevar ‘avadah ) far behind them as absolutely gone; for the dead have no part more in the history which is unfolding itself amid the light of the upper world, and they can have no more any part therein, for the dead as not living are not only without knowledge, but also without feeling and desire. The representation of the state after death is here more comfortless than anywhere else. For elsewhere we read that those who have been living here spend in Sheol, i.e., in the deep (R. , to be loose, to hang down, to go downwards) realm of the dead, as rephaim (Isa 14:9, etc.), lying beneath the upper world, far from the love and the praise of God (Psa 6:3; Psa 30:10), a prospectless (Job 7:7., Job 14:6-12; Job 18:11-13), dark, shadowy existence; the soul in Hades, though neither annihilated nor sleeping, finds itself in a state of death no less than does the body in the grave. But here the state of death is not even set forth over against the idea of the dissolution of life, the complete annihilation of individuality, much less that a retribution in eternity, i.e., a retribution executed, if not here, yet at some time, postulated elsewhere by the author, throws a ray of light into the night of death. The apocryphal book of the Wisdom of Solomon, which distinguishes between a state of blessedness and a state of misery measured out to men in the future following death, has in this surpassed the canonical Book of Koheleth. In vain do the Targ., Midrash, and the older Christian interpreters refer that which is said to the wicked dead; others regard Koheleth as introducing here the discourse of atheists ( e.g., Oetinger), and interpret, under the influence of monstrous self-deception, Ecc 9:7 as the voice of the spirit (Hengst.) opposing the voice of the flesh. But that which Koheleth expresses here only in a particularly rugged way is the view of Hades predominating in the O.T. It is the consequence of viewing death from the side of its anger. Revelation intentionally permits this manner of viewing it to remain; but from premises which the revelation sets forth, the religious consciousness in the course of time draws always more decidedly the conclusion, that the man who is united to God will fully reach through death that which since the entrance of sin into the world cannot be reached without the loss of this present life, i.e., without death, viz., a more perfect life in fellowship with God. Yet the confusion of the O.T. representation of Hades remains; in the Book of Sirach it also still throws its deep shadows (17:22f.) into the contemplation of the future; for the first time the N.T. solution actually removes the confusion, and turns the scale in favour of the view of death on its side of light. In this history of the ideas of eternity moving forward amid many fluctuations to the N.T. goal, a significant place belongs to the Book of Koheleth; certainly the Christian interpreter ought not to have an interest in explaining away and concealing the imperfections of knowledge which made it impossible for the author spiritually to rise above his pessimism. He does not rise, in contrast to his pessimism, above an eudaemonism which is earthly, which, without knowing of a future life (not like the modern pessimism, without wishing to know of a future life), recommends a pleasant enjoyment of the present life, so far as that is morally allowable:
Fuente: Keil & Delitzsch Commentary on the Old Testament
5. The living the dead The idea is, that though the living know that they must die, yet this very consciousness, acting in other directions, enables them to enjoy some pleasures. “Under the shadow of death they can still be merry.” The dead, sunken in unconsciousness, have no longer any faculty for enjoyment.
A reward That is, advantage of any sort.
The memory of them Not that they are forgotten, which would be contrary to the grammar of the clause, and to that plain, palpable look of things now under discussion, but that they forget every thing which is the basis of the statement of the next verse. “After life’s fitful fever,” they lie down in oblivion of all things.
Fuente: Whedon’s Commentary on the Old and New Testaments
Ecc 9:5 For the living know that they shall die: but the dead know not any thing, neither have they any more a reward; for the memory of them is forgotten.
Ver. 5. For the living know that they shall die. ] Hence that proverb among us, As sure as death. Howbeit, that they think little of it to any good purpose, appears by that other proverb, I thought no more of it than of my dying day.
But the dead know not anything.
Neither have they any more a reward.
For the memory of them is forgotten.
a Augustine.
b Bernard.
Fuente: John Trapp’s Complete Commentary (Old and New Testaments)
the dead know not any thing. See and Compare Ecc 9:10. Psa 6:5; Psa 30:9; Psa 31:17; Psa 88:11. Isa 38:18, Isa 38:19.
a reward = any advantage [to them].
memory = the faculty of remembering. See note on “them”, below.
them. The Hebrew suffix “them” must be taken as the subject in all the four nouns alike. As in Ecc 9:6, the possessive pronoun “their” is, and must be, taken alike in each case.
is forgotten = ceases to exist, as in Psa 77:9, where it is parallel with “clean gone for ever “and “evermore”, and in the next verse here(Ecc 9:6), where it stands parallel with “perished” and “for ever”.
Fuente: Companion Bible Notes, Appendices and Graphics
the living: Ecc 7:2, Job 30:23, Heb 9:27
the dead: Job 14:21, Psa 6:5, Psa 88:10, Psa 88:11, Isa 63:16
for the: Ecc 2:16, Ecc 8:10, Job 7:8-10, Psa 109:15, Isa 26:14
Reciprocal: Gen 5:5 – and he died Deu 31:14 – that thou must die 2Sa 14:14 – we must Psa 59:11 – Slay Psa 88:12 – in the land Psa 89:48 – What Ecc 9:10 – for Isa 38:11 – General Luk 20:32 – died 1Co 15:55 – is thy victory