Exegetical and Hermeneutical Commentary of Ecclesiastes 9:12
For man also knoweth not his time: as the fishes that are taken in an evil net, and as the birds that are caught in the snare; so [are] the sons of men snared in an evil time, when it falleth suddenly upon them.
12. as the fishes that are taken in an evil net ] The words paint vividly the suddenness of calamities which defeat all men’s purposes and plans. The imagery was a natural one in any country, and meets us in Hosea 7; Eze 12:13; Eze 32:3; Pro 7:23; but it is interesting to note a parallel in the poetry of Greece. So schylus:
,
, .
“Who upon the towers of Troa
Castedst snare of closest meshes,
So that none, full-grown or youthful,
Could o’erleap the net of bondage,
Woe of universal capture.”
Agam. 347 350.
We may compare the parallels, for the illustration drawn from the “snare of the fowler,” of Psa 91:3; Psa 124:7; Pro 1:17; Pro 6:5.
Fuente: The Cambridge Bible for Schools and Colleges
Ecc 9:12
Man also knoweth not his time.
Blessed ignorance
If ignorance is bliss, tis folly to be wise. This applies to our ignorance in relation to the future. It is mercy that has woven the veil.
I. If we knew our future, enjoyment would be impossible. Suppose we knew all the bereavements, sufferings, adversities that are before us, and the time, circumstances, and place of our death, would there be any pleasure for us on this earth?
II. If we knew our future, duty would be impracticable. With all the dark events of our future clearly marked out before us, we should stand aghast, and be utterly unfit for the ordinary duties of life.
III. If we knew our future, life would be intolerable. It would be utterly impossible for our fragile natures to bear such a vision. (Homilist.)
Mans ignorance of the time of his death
These words suggest a few thoughts concerning death.
I. It is inevitable. His time: that is, his time to die; fixed by an irrevocable decree (Heb 9:27). Science, art, wealth, all have been tried, to avoid death; but all have failed.
II. It is insidious. The fish is pursuing its own course through the waters, in search of its prey, and unconscious of danger, when, all at once, it finds itself hopelessly entangled in the folds, or caught in the meshes of the fishers net, and there is no escape. The bird is following its instinct, in quest of food, when the limed twig or the baited trap, on which it alights, robs it of its freedom, and consigns it into the hands of the fowler. As blind, oftentimes, is man himself to the coming stroke which is to smite him to the dust.
III. It is unexpected. Boast not thyself of to-morrow, etc. Take heed, for in such an hour as ye think not, etc. (T. Manton, D. D.)
Man knoweth not his time
I. Consider the evidences of the fact–that man knoweth not his time.
1. With respect to men in general, they do not know the time of their visitation. This is evidently the case with the impenitent and unbelieving, who disregard the tokens both of the favour and displeasure of God. The founder melteth in vain, and the wicked are not plucked away. The day of opportunity is lost, perhaps never to be regained. Nor can Christians themselves be wholly acquitted of the charge of inattention. Too apt are we to deprive ourselves of the gracious presence of the Saviour for the want of a little more humility and self-denial.
2. Man knoweth not his time as to the seasonable performance of various duties. Sometimes we have had, loud calls to humiliation and prayer, when, like Israel of old, we have given ourselves up to joy and gladness, slaying oxen, and killing sheep, eating flesh, and drinking wine (Isa 22:13). Sometimes we have had a favourable opportunity of bearing our testimony to the important doctrines of the Gospel, or the equally important duties of practical religion: yet we have neither had a heart nor a tongue to speak, when a few words might have had a very happy effect.
3. We do not know the time when afflictions will come, or when we shall be delivered out of them. God has an appointed time for both. All events are safe in His hands, but they are at the same time concealed. His counsel shall stand, and He will do all His pleasure. We can no more advance or retard Gods work than we can hasten the rising sun, or hinder its going down (Isa 60:22).
4. We know not the time of our continuance in life or departure out of it.
5. We know not the day of judgment, or the final period of all things. Our ignorance in this respect is best suited to that state of subjection to the wisdom and sovereignty of God in which we are placed, and to the nature of that economy which He has established, as well as to the limited extent of our frailties.
II. Inquire the reason why man is left in ignorance of particular times and seasons.
1. It tends to do honour to the Divine government (Pro 25:2).
2. The knowledge of times and seasons would be injurious to us rather than advantageous. Hereby faith, hope, and patience, so much adapted to a probationary state, are kept in continual exercise; and by being exercised are strengthened and increased.
improvement:
1. This subject teaches us to repress a prying and inquisitive temper, and the wish of being wise above what is written (Deu 29:29; Joh 21:21-22).
2. Learn to be thankful for that degree of information which God has been pleased to impart. All that is necessary to be known, both as to faith and practice, is sufficiently revealed; and the more necessary the knowledge, the clearer is the revelation. (B. Beddome, M. A.)
Expectation of long life unwise
I. Why men are so apt to expect to live long in this world. It needs no proof that they are apt to expect that their lives will be prolonged even to old age. It is the inward thought, hope and expectation of those in the morning, in the meridian, and even in the decline of life, that they shall live many days, if not many years. The health they have enjoyed, the dangers they have escaped, the preservation they have experienced, the means they have used and intend to use to lengthen out their days, all serve to corroborate and confirm their pleasing expectation that their lives shall be long continued. But their dread of death is another strong and powerful reason why they cherish the expectation of living to the latest period of human life.
II. Why it is unwise in persons of all ages, characters, and conditions to harbour and cherish the expectation of living long in this world.
1. Because God has designedly concealed the length of their days.
2. Because they are continually liable to innumerable unknown and unavoidable causes of death.
3. Because God, in His providence, is continually and solemnly warning them against such vain expectations. He is continually taking away the child before the youth, the youth before the man, the man of twenty before the man of forty, the man of forty before the man of fifty, or sixty, or seventy, or eighty, or any of a greater age. He promiscuously takes away the useless and the useful, the learned and unlearned, the rich and the poor, the religious and irreligious.
4. It will appear still more unwise and absurd for men to form and cherish high hopes and expectations of living long in this world, if we consider how expressly and repeatedly God, in His Word, has warned and admonished them against it.
improvement:
1. Since mankind are so extremely apt to harbour and cherish expectation of the long continuance of life, there is reason to think that they generally die unexpectedly to themselves.
2. It appears from what has been said that death commonly comes to men in an evil time. To die is the great and last act to be done on the stage of life, and extremely solemn and interesting to the dying and to the living; and a sudden and unexpected time is certainly a very evil time to make the solemn and important transition out of this into the invisible and eternal world.
3. It appears from mens undue expectation of living why bereavements are often so heavy and grievous to be borne. Those who habitually expect to live long in the world themselves are almost equally prone to expect that their relatives and friends will be long-lived; and therefore their sudden and unexpected death brings with it a sudden and unexpected bereavement, which often gives a treble and sometimes a tenfold weight to it.
4. Since death so generally comes suddenly and unexpectedly to the living, we learn the wisdom and importance of early piety.
5. We learn from what has been said why God does cause so many sudden and unexpected deaths to take place in the world. It is undoubtedly designed more for the benefit of the living than for the dying. (N. Emmons, D. D.)
The uncertainty of human life
It is an ancient aphorism that every man thinks all men mortal but himself. Rather than encounter a realizing view of death, and engage in a serious preparation to meet it, men will hazard all consequences. They are like soldiers marching up to the battery of an enemy with their eyes and ears closed, and dreaming of safety because they neither see nor hear the motions of the foe. Death will come, however much a stranger it may be to our thoughts; and it will come with double ruin for having been kept out of view so long. It may come suddenly, like the convulsions of an earthquake which at dead of night buries whole cities in ruins. Man also knoweth not his time; that is, he is ignorant of the time of his death and the time when overwhelming calamities may come upon him. He may be stripped naked in one day like Job; or in the midst of his dreams of earthly happiness he may open his astonished eyes in the world of spirits. As the fishes that are taken in an evil net–while they are wandering securely, or sporting among pearls, or rushing together for food, little thinking of being suddenly drawn up in the concealed net. And as the birds that are caught in the snare, while they are skipping sportively without apprehension, or are eager to pick up the grain which is spread to decoy them to death. So are the sons of men snared in an evil time–while they are sporting and feeding themselves, secure in conscious health, ignorant of the shaft that is festering in their breast. When it falleth suddenly upon them. While they are most secure the arrow of the Almighty reaches their heart. While they are saying, Soul, take thine ease, eat, drink, and be merry, the word comes, Thou fool, this night thy soul shall be required of thee. Where are now the ancient empires of Assyria, and Babylon, and Persia, and Greece, and Rome? Where are the emperors, statesmen, philosophers, and bards of antiquity? Where is now the immense army of Xerxes, which seemed to darken Asia, and to sink with its weight the land of Greece? Where are now the many millions who have filled the world with noise and contention, with fame and folly for a hundred generations? Kingdom has trodden on the heel of kingdom, and nation has followed nation down to the land of forgetfulness. You hang over the grave by a thread on which the flame has seized, and you may look every moment to fall to rise not again till the heavens be no more. Could the veil be drawn from eternity and discover to your astonished eyes the infinitely glorious or dreadful consequences depending on the present life; could then the veil be drawn from the many agents which are constantly striving within you to keep in order your complicated machine, and discover to you the many critical junctures which are daily occurring, which, without making you sensible of it, bring you within a baits breadth of death; could the veil be also drawn from the course of nature around you, and disclose the dangers among which you walk by day and sleep by night; could you thus have a view of your hourly exposures and of the eternal interests at stake, you would start from your dream like a man awoke in a burning house, and flee for your life–ah, whither? whither but to the arms of Christ? (E. D. Griffin, D. D.)
So are the sons of men ensnared.—
Snares in the path of the young
The sad truth here declared has been experienced thousands of times, not only by those who are now alive, but by others who have passed away to their great account. No one likes to be deceived in any matter; and yet how sin is constantly deceiving us! No man is willing to be ensnared by an enemy; and yet how Satan leads us captive at his will! and what a disclosure will the judgment-day present, of fraud and subtlety on the side of sin and Satan–of weakness and compliance on the part of sinners! From among the many sources of danger now presenting themselves to my mind I must select several of the most prominent and powerful.
1. There is the danger of speculativeness in matters of religion. Remember, speeulativeness proves nothing–faith proves all things: speculativeness deceives–faith cannot; speculativeness enfeebles the mind–faith strengthens it; speculativeness receives nothing truly–faith grasps and retains that which is revealed to faith; speculativeness is the false light of a carnal state–faith is the beacon-blaze of God set up in the soul; and this the apostle knew full well, when he said–We walk by faith, not by sight.
2. Another source of danger is indecision with regard to personal religion. Multitudes of young men, we believe, who neither speculate upon the Bible, nor deny or even question its authority, but yield a full respect to religion itself and to the religion of religious friends, are in this sad state of personal indecision. No step of a positive kind has been taken. They wish to be religious–we give them credit for that; but then they are not. They hope to be so by and by–we believe they do; but where is the sustained effort that evidences the reality both of wishes and of hope? Indecision, long persevered in, may at length–and it is a solemn thought–acquire the force of decision, but acting in a wrong direction. It may be decision on the side of ruin, simply because the young man, knowing in a truth, may not have firmness to act on what he knows, nor grace enough, sought in persevering prayer, to decide at once for life, salvation and a glorious immortality, accessible to him at any moment, through faith in Christ Jesus by the Spirit.
3. I have next to set before you the danger of worldly conformity, even when you have been enabled to overcome your natural indecision, and have east in your let with the true people of God. Before this occurs, you are of necessity conformed to the world; it cannot be otherwise; you have no motive for separation from the world till then. In whatever degree a Christian conforms to the habits and principles which govern the world around him, in the same degree is his spirituality in danger of deterioration. And yet how many Christian professors live as like the rest of the world, as if they had never professed to come to a decision on the side of Christi The truth is, that the world makes concessions to religion; and the religion of these modern days is too liberal to withhold compliance to the demands which the world makes in return for its concession. Contact with the world is unavoidable; it is one thing, however, for us to submit to that which must be, but quite another to conform to that which should not be, just because it invites and pleases, or because it threatens. I know it is difficult to maintain your ground when the intercourse between Christians and the world is so familiar; but are you to give way when a difficulty crosses you in the path, and looks you in the face? Are you accustomed to do so in the ordinary pursuits of life? Is there not difficulty in the way of everything that is worth doing? Does not difficulty generally stimulate perseverance? To be aware of difficulty arising from the character of worldly society, with which you cannot perhaps at all times avoid mingling, is, if you will have it so, to be partly armed against it. If you fail in this, the worldly spirit around you will soon cast a successful snare; and you may find by bitter and humbling experience that, as the fishes are taken in an evil net, and as the birds are caught in the snare, so are the sons of men snared in an evil time, when it falleth suddenly upon them. (G. Fisk, LL. B.)
Fuente: Biblical Illustrator Edited by Joseph S. Exell
Verse 12. As the birds that are caught] Man acts so heedlessly, notwithstanding all his wisdom, and all his warnings, that he is often taken, as a fish is, by the baited hook; and the bird by the baited snare. And thus, an evil time, like the snare, gin, trap, hook, falleth suddenly upon them; and they are taken in a moment, and have no means of escaping. How frequently do we see these comparisons illustrated!
Fuente: Adam Clarke’s Commentary and Critical Notes on the Bible
His time, to wit, the time of his death, or of some other sore distress which God is bringing upon him; which is opposed to the time of success mentioned in the foregoing verse, and man is said to be ignorant both of the one and of the other.
That are taken in an evil net; that whilst they are sporting and feeding themselves, are suddenly and unexpectedly ensnared to their ruin.
When it falleth suddenly upon them; when they are most careless and secure.
Fuente: English Annotations on the Holy Bible by Matthew Poole
12. his timenamely, of death(Ecc 7:15; Isa 13:22).Hence the danger of delay in doing the work of God, as one knows notwhen his opportunity will end (Ec9:10).
evil netfatal to them.The unexpected suddenness of the capture is the point of comparison.So the second coming of Jesus Christ, “as a snare” (Lu21:35).
evil timeas an “evilnet,” fatal to them.
Fuente: Jamieson, Fausset and Brown’s Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible
For man also knoweth not his time,…. Though it is fixed and settled by the Lord, yet times and seasons are kept in his own power, and not known by men; not the time of his death, nor of any calamity and distress coming upon him, nor the proper season and opportunity of doing himself good, and avoiding evil;
as the fishes that are taken in an evil net, and as the birds that are caught in the snare; as fishes are suddenly taken in a net, unhappy for them, which is at once east over them, while they are sporting and playing in the water, and catching at the bait; and as birds, being decoyed, are unawares taken in a snare; that is, both of them know not the time of their being caught;
so [are] the sons of men snared in an evil time, when it falleth suddenly upon them; they are no more able to guard against a time of adversity and calamity, and the evil of it, which comes at once upon them, than the poor fishes or silly birds are to avoid the net and snare; and are, like them, at such a time, in the utmost security, indulging themselves in ease and pleasure: so the day of death, and of judgment, will come like a thief in the night; or like a snare upon men, when they think nothing of it, but are giving up themselves to their lusts and pleasures; see 1Th 5:2; for pleasure, as Plato says, is the bait of evils, with which men are caught, as fishes with the hook g.
g Apud Ciceronem de Senectute, c. 12. “Hic ubi saepe occultum visus decurrere piscis ad hamum”, Horat. Epist. l. 1. Ep. 8. v. 73, 74.
Fuente: John Gill’s Exposition of the Entire Bible
“For man also knoweth not his time: like the fishes which are caught in an evil net, and like the birds which are caught in the snare – like them are the sons of men snared in an evil time, when it suddenly breaks in upon them.” The particles are here not so clearly connected as at Ecc 8:12; Ecc 4:14, where, more correctly, the pointing should be ( ki with the conjunct. accent); ki rules the sentence; and gam, as to its meaning, belongs to eth’itto . The particular has its reason from the general: man is not master of his own time, his own person, and his own life, and thus not of the fruits of his capabilities and his actions, in spite of the previously favourable conditions which appear to place the result beyond a doubt; for ere the result is reached of which he appears to be able to entertain a certainty, suddenly his time may expire, and his term of life be exhausted. Jerome translate ‘itto (cf. Ecc 7:17) rightly by finem suum ; , with the gen. following, frequently ( vid., under Job 24:1) means the point of time when the fate of any one is decided, – the terminus where a reckoning is made; here, directly, the terminus ad quem . The suddenness with which men are frequently overtaken with the catastrophe which puts an end to their life, is seen by comparison with the fishes which are suddenly caught in the net, and the birds which are suddenly caught in the snare. With (that are caught) there is interchanged, in two variations of expression, , which is incorrectly written, by v. d. Hooght, Norzi, and others, .
(Note: Vid., Ed. Knig, Gedanke, Laut u. Accent (1874), p. 72.)
, a net, – of which the plur. form Ecc 7:26 is used, – goes back, as does the similar designation of a bulwark ( Ecc 9:14), to the root-conception of searching (hunting), and receives here the epithet “evil.” Birds, (from a ground-form with a short terminal vowel; cf. Assyr. itstsur , from itspur ), are, on account of their weakness, as at Isa 31:5, as a figure of tender love, represented in the fem.
The second half of the verse, in conformity with its structure, begins with (which more frequently occurs as ). .) is part. Pu. for (Ewald, 170d); the particip. is rejected, and is treated altogether as a guttural, the impracticable doubling of which is compensated for by the lengthening of the vowel. The use of the part. is here stranger than e.g., at Pro 11:13; Pro 15:32; the fact repeating itself is here treated as a property. Like the fish and the birds are they, such as are caught, etc. Otherwise Hitz.: Like these are they caught, during the continuance of their life in the evil time … ; but the being snared does not, however, according to the double figure, precede the catastrophe, but is its consequence. Rightly, Ginsb.: “Like these are the sons of men ensnared in the time of misfortune.” might be adj., as at Amo 5:13; Mic 2:3; but since it lies nearer to refer to ra’ah than to ‘eth , thus ra’ah , like the frequently occurring yom ra’ah (Ecc 7:14; cf. Jer 17:17 with Jer 15:11), may be thought of as genit. An example of that which is here said is found in the fatal wounding of Ahab by means of an arrow which was not aimed at him, so that he died “at the time of the going down of the sun,” 2Ch 18:33-34.
Fuente: Keil & Delitzsch Commentary on the Old Testament
(12) Pro. 7:23; Eze. 12:13; Hos. 7:12.
Fuente: Ellicott’s Commentary for English Readers (Old and New Testaments)
12. Man knoweth not his time “His time” of danger and trial. The most notable illustration in modern times is that of Napoleon, who, at the height of his fortune, made the invasion of Russia, and, losing the finest army the world had ever seen, began his swift and utter downfall.
Also Better, Even.
His time Means the “time” of calamity just named. The shrewdest speculator has often made one investment too many.
Birds This word, without any qualification, means the sparrow, the most familiar bird of Palestine, just as “the flower” means the lily.
Fuente: Whedon’s Commentary on the Old and New Testaments
Ecc 9:12. When it falleth suddenly upon them By sudden accidents. The third proof, in support of the third proposition, is taken from those wrong judgments which are known to be such only by the event; but which must have appeared very probable before. These are brought under two heads. I. In Ecc 9:11-12 it is highly probable that the end will be attained by using such means as are the best adapted to it. Yet experience testifies that this is not always the case: success generally depends upon a certain concourse of circumstances, which it is not in the power of man to procure, or upon seizing an opportunity, which he is so far from knowing, that, like the fishes and birds, he is apt to mistake that for a favourable one which proves most dangerous to him. Thus he often runs to his utter destruction, at the very time when he imagines himself in a successful and most infallible pursuit of happiness.
Fuente: Commentary on the Holy Bible by Thomas Coke
Ecc 9:12 For man also knoweth not his time: as the fishes that are taken in an evil net, and as the birds that are caught in the snare; so [are] the sons of men snared in an evil time, when it falleth suddenly upon them.
Ver. 12. For man also knoweth not his time. ] His end, say the Septuagint and Vulgate; what may befall him in after time, say others.
“ Flebile principium melior fortuna sequatur,
Accidit in puncto quod non speratur in anno. ”
So are the sons of men snared in an evil time.
a Josephus.
Fuente: John Trapp’s Complete Commentary (Old and New Testaments)
For man, &c. Connect this sentence with Ecc 9:11.
man . . . men. Hebrew. ‘adam (with Art.) App-14.
Fuente: Companion Bible Notes, Appendices and Graphics
man: Ecc 8:5-7, Ecc 8:11, Luk 19:42-44, 2Co 6:2, 1Pe 2:12
as the fishes: Pro 7:22, Pro 7:23, Hab 1:14-17, 2Ti 2:26
the sons: Job 18:8-10, Psa 11:6, Psa 73:18-20, Pro 6:15, Pro 29:6, Isa 30:13, Luk 12:20, Luk 12:39, Luk 17:26-31, Luk 21:34-36, 1Th 5:3, 2Pe 2:12
Reciprocal: Jos 8:6 – They flee Jos 8:14 – he wist not Jdg 16:30 – and the house Jdg 20:34 – knew not 1Sa 17:44 – Come to me 2Sa 11:25 – for the sword 2Ch 23:13 – Then Athaliah Job 1:13 – when Job 24:1 – seeing Psa 18:5 – snares Psa 37:19 – in the evil Psa 49:12 – beasts Psa 91:3 – snare Ecc 3:22 – who Ecc 8:7 – he knoweth Jer 50:24 – snare Eze 17:20 – I will spread Eze 32:3 – General Dan 11:11 – the multitude Hos 7:12 – I will bring Amo 3:5 – General Amo 5:13 – an evil Luk 21:35 – as
Fuente: The Treasury of Scripture Knowledge
Ecc 9:12. For man also knoweth not his time Namely, the time of his death, or of some other sore distress, which God is bringing upon him; as fishes are taken in an evil net While they are sporting and feeding themselves, are suddenly and unexpectedly ensnared to their ruin; so are the sons of men snared When they are most careless and secure.
Fuente: Joseph Bensons Commentary on the Old and New Testaments
9:12 For man also knoweth not his {g} time: as the fishes that are taken in an evil net, and as the birds that are caught in the snare; so [are] the sons of men snared in an evil time, when it falleth suddenly upon them.
(g) That is, he does not foresee what will come.