Exegetical and Hermeneutical Commentary of Isaiah 59:5
They hatch cockatrice’ eggs, and weave the spider’s web: he that eateth of their eggs dieth, and that which is crushed breaketh out into a viper.
5. cockatrice’ eggs ] or basilisks ’ eggs. See on ch. Isa 11:8. The figure is expanded in the latter part of the verse, and the meaning seems to be that the persons spoken of brood over and bring to maturity projects of wickedness, whose effects are almost equally fatal to those who acquiesce in them and to those who oppose them.
he that eateth of their eggs ] (cf. Deu 32:33) i.e. either he who enters into their schemes, or he who is their victim.
that which is crushed viper ] Should one try to stamp out one of their diabolical plots, its deadly nature will only be the more clearly manifested.
Fuente: The Cambridge Bible for Schools and Colleges
5 8. These verses differ somewhat in character from Isa 59:3 f., and are regarded by Duhm and Cheyne as a quotation from some Psalm or collection of proverbs. In point of fact the first part of Isa 59:7 appears in Pro 1:16, but probably as an interpolation, since the verse is wanting in the LXX. On the other hand, Isa 59:7-8 are partly reproduced in the LXX. recension of Psa 14:3, as in Rom 3:10 ff. These facts do not by themselves raise any presumption against the genuineness of the passage in this discourse; and the first image of Isa 59:5 connects itself naturally enough with the conclusion of Isa 59:4. It must be admitted, however, that the description can only apply to a limited class of utter reprobates, and there is some difficulty in conceiving that it can be the continuation of Isa 59:3-4, which contain perfectly definite and intelligible accusations against a whole community.
Fuente: The Cambridge Bible for Schools and Colleges
They hatch cockatrice eggs – Margin, Adders. On the meaning of the word rendered here cockatrice, see the notes at Isa 11:8. Some poisonous serpent is intended, probably the adder, or the serpent known among the Greeks as the basilisk, or cerastes. This figurative expression is designed to show the evil nature and tendency of their works. They were as if they should carefully nourish the eggs of a venomous serpent. Instead of crushing them with the foot and destroying them, they took pains to hatch them, and produce a venomous race of reptiles. Nothing can more forcibly describe the wicked character and plans of sinners than the language used here – plans that are as pernicious, loathsome, and hateful as the poisonous serpents that spread death and ruin and alarm everywhere.
And weave the spiders web – This phrase, in itself, may denote, as some have understood it, that they formed plans designed to seize upon and destroy others, as spiders weave their web for the purpose of catching and destroying insects. But the following verse shows that the language is used rather with reference to the tenuity and gossamer character of the web, than with any such designs. Their works were like the web of the spider. They bore the same relation to true piety which the web of the spider did to substantial and comfortable raiment. They were vain and useless. The word rendered here web properly denotes the cross-threads in weaving, the woof or filling; and is probably derived from a word signify ing a cross-beam (see Rosenmuller in loc; also Bochart, Hieroz. ii. 4. 23).
He that eateth of their eggs dieth – That is, he who partakes of their counsels, or of the plans which they form, shall perish. Calvin says that the meaning is, that whosoever had anything to do with them would find them destructive and pestiferous. Similar phrases, comparing the plans of the wicked with the eggs and the brood of the serpent, are common in the East. It is said, says Roberts, speaking of India, of the plans of a decidedly wicked and talented man, That wretch! he hatches serpents eggs. Beware of the fellow, his eggs are nearly hatched. Ah, my friend, touch not that affair, meddle not with that matter; there is a serpent in the shell.
And that which is crushed breaketh out into a viper – On the meaning of the word rendered here viper, see the notes at Isa 30:6. Margin, Sprinkled, is as if there brake out a viper. Jerome renders it, Which if pierced, breaks out into a basilisk. The Septuagint renders it, And he who was about to eat of their eggs having broken one that was putrid ( suntripsas ourion), found in it a basilisk ( basiliskon). The difference of translation in the text and the margin of the common version has arisen from the fact that the translators supposed that the word used here ( zurah) might be derived from zarah, to sprinkle, or to scatter. But it is formed from the word zur, to squeeze, to press, to crush; and in Job 39:15, is applied to the fact that the ostrich might crush her eggs with her foot. The sense here is, that when their plans were developed, they would be found to be evil and pernacious – as when an egg should be broken open, a venomous setpent would come forth. The viper, it is true, brings forth its young alive, or is a viviparous animal. But Bochart has remarked, that though it produces its young in this manner, yet that during the period of gestation the young are included in eggs which are broken at the birth. This is a very impressive illustration of the character and plans of the wicked. The serpents here referred to are among the most venomous and destructive that are known. And the comparison here includes two points –
1. That their plans resembled the egg of the serpent. The nature of the egg cannot be easily known by an inspection. It may have a strong resemblance to those which would produce some inoffensive and even useful animals. It is only when it is hatched that its true nature is fully developed. So it is with the plans of the wicked. When forming, their true nature may not be certainly known, and it may not be easy to determine their real character.
2. Their plans, when developed, are like the poisonous and destructive production of the serpents egg. The true nature is then seen; and it is ruinous, pernicious, and evil.
Fuente: Albert Barnes’ Notes on the Bible
Isa 59:5-6
They hatch cockatrice eggs
Wicked devices
I.
THE DEVICES OF THY. WICKED.
1. Like eggs–productive.
2. Like cockatrice eggs–injurious.
3. Like spiders webs–frail, useless.
II. THEIR EFFECT.
1. Upon others–mischief, death.
2. Upon themselves–disappointment, retribution. (J. Lyth, D. D.)
The schemes of the ungodly
The meaning seems to be that the persons spoken of brood over and bring to maturity projects of wickedness, whose effects are almost equally fatal to those who acquiesce in them and to those who oppose them. He that eateth of their eggs, i.e either he who enters into their schemes or he who is their victim. That which is crushed breaketh out into a viper. Should one try to stamp out one of their diabolical plans, its deadly nature will only be the more clearly manifested. Verse 6 is the development of the second image of Isa 59:5, the point of comparison being the uselessness for any good social end of the schemes devised by the ungodly. (Prof. J. Skinner, D. D.)
And weave the spiders web:–
Hypocritical religion
See the spiders web and behold in it a most suggestive picture of the hypocrites religion.
1. It is meant to catch his prey; the spider fattens himself on flies. Foolish persons are easily entrapped by the loud professions of pretenders, and even the more judicious cannot always escape.
2. A spiders web is a marvel of skill; look at it and admire the cunning hunters wiles. Is not a deceivers religion equally wonderful? How does he make so barefaced a lie appear to be a truth.
3. A spiders web comes all from the creatures own bowels. Even so hypocrites find their hope and trust within themselves.
4. But a spiders web is very frail. Hypocritical cobwebs will soon come down when the broom of destruction begins its purifying work.
5. Which reminds us of one more thought, viz that such cobwebs are not to be endured in the Lords house. (C. H. Spurgeon.)
Spiders webs
As the spider weaveth her web to catch the smaller flies, so do they lay their plots to take the poorer sort of people, and them which are most destitute of friends. (W. Day, M. A.)
Fuente: Biblical Illustrator Edited by Joseph S. Exell
They hatch cockatrice eggs; or adder, or basilisk; one kind put for any venomous creature; a proverbial speech, signifying by these eggs mischievous designs, and by hatching them their putting them in practice: this is to show that mischief is natural to them, and they can do no otherwise, poison is natural to these eggs.
Weave the spiders web; another proverbial speech, whereby is taught, both how by their plots they weave nets, lay snares industriously, with great pains and artifice, whereby they may entangle and involve their poor neighbours in intricacies and perplexities, and so devour them, as the spider weaves her web to catch flies, and then to feed on them; and also how that they contrive nothing but what will tend to their own ruin, as the issue of the viper is the death of the mother, and they and their designs will come to nothing, and not answer their end, as the spiders web is soon swept away, and is seen no more, which doth well agree with what follows.
He that eateth of their eggs dieth: here is a catachrestical allusion, noting that he who hath commerce with them, and approves their counsels, which are the eggs which they hatch, will be poisoned with them.
And that which is crushed breaketh out into a viper: if and be copulative here, then the sense is either, If any seek to crush and disappoint their plots, or if they be sprinkled or dispersed abroad, (as the margin seems to favour,) they will seek his ruin, will be as a viper to him. But if and be causal, as it often is, and may be here, then the sense is, q.d. He dieth, because the eggs being crushed, a poisonous viper proceeds from it; the more you partake of their counsels, the more you are infected, there lies such a dreadful poison embodied in them.
Fuente: English Annotations on the Holy Bible by Matthew Poole
5. cockatriceprobably thebasilisk serpent, cerastes. Instead of crushing evil in theegg, they foster it.
spider’s webThisrefers not to the spider’s web being made to entrap, but toits thinness, as contrasted with substantial “garments,”as Isa 59:6 shows. Their worksare vain and transitory (Job 8:14;Pro 11:18).
eateth . . . their eggshewho partakes in their plans, or has anything to do withthem, finds them pestiferous.
that which is crushedTheegg, when it is broken, breaketh out as a viper; their plans,however specious in their undeveloped form like the egg, whendeveloped, are found pernicious. Though the viper is viviparous (fromwhich “vi-per” is derived), yet during gestation, the youngare included in eggs, which break at the birth [BOCHART];however, metaphors often combine things without representingeverything to the life.
Fuente: Jamieson, Fausset and Brown’s Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible
They hatch cockatrice eggs, and weave the spider’s web,…. Invent false doctrines according to their own fancies, which may seem fair and plausible, but are poisonous and pernicious; as the “eggs [of the] cockatrice”, which may look like, and may be taken for, the eggs of creatures fit to eat; and spin out of their brains a fine scheme of things, but which are as thin, and as useless, and unprofitable, as “the spider’s web”; and serve only to ensnare and entangle the minds of men, and will not stand before the word of God which sweeps them away at once; particularly of this kind is the doctrine of justification by the works of men, which are like the spider’s web, spun out of its own bowels; so these are from themselves, as the doctrine of them is a device of man, and is not of God:
he that eateth of their eggs dieth: as a man that eats of cockatrice eggs dies immediately, being rank poison; so he that approves of false doctrines, receives them, and feeds upon them, dies spiritually and eternally; these are damnable doctrines, which bring upon men swift destruction; they are poisonous, and eat as do a canker, and destroy the souls of men:
and that which is crushed breaketh out into a viper; or “cockatrice”; so Kimchi and Ben Melech take it to be the same creature as before, which goes by different names; and the words seem to require this sense; however, it cannot be the creature we call the viper, since that is not oviparous, but viviparous, lays not eggs, but brings forth its young; though both Aristotle w and Pliny x, at the same time they say it is viviparous, yet observe that it breeds eggs within itself, which are of one colour, and soft like fishes. The Targum renders it “flying serpents”: the sense is, that if a man is cautious, and does not eat of the cockatrice eggs, but sets his foot on them, and crushes them, out comes the venomous creature, and he is in danger of being hurt by it; so a man that does not embrace false doctrines, and escapes eternal death by them, but tramples upon them, opposes them, and endeavours to crush and destroy them, yet he is exposed to and brings upon himself calumnies, reproach, and persecution.
w Hist. Animal. l. 5. c. 34. x Nat. Hist. I. 10. c. 62.
Fuente: John Gill’s Exposition of the Entire Bible
5. They hatch the eggs of the basilisk. The Prophet proceeds farther, comparing the Jews not only to women, but to venomous beasts; so as to make it more evident that everything that proceeds from them is destructive and deadly. First, then, he says, that “they hatch the eggs of the basilisk;“ because, as a viper cannot lay an egg that is not venomous, so they are so inured to wickedness, and so full of it, that they can throw out nothing but poison. (133)
And weave the webs of spiders. By “the webs of spiders” he means that they are so barren and destitute of anything good, that even by the appearance of virtues they deceive. By two marks he describes wicked men; first, that the works which they perform manifest their corrupt nature; secondly, that they are of no value whatever, and. contribute nothing towards making them kind, amiable, charitable, and faithful to those with whom they have intercourse. I am aware that it is explained ill a different manner by other commentators; namely, that the wicked, while they are contriving the destruction of others, ruin themselves, and, while they think that they are industrious, labor fruitlessly and to no purpose; that “they are snared in their own nets,” (Psa 9:15) and “fall into the pit which they had digged.” (Psa 7:15) But I am of opinion that the Prophet meant what I have now said; namely, that the wicked do mischief in all places, at all times, and in all transactions, and that they never do anything good; and that every person who has anything to do with them will find them to be venomous and destructive. Such is the import of what he says, that in their eggs there lurks a deadly venom, and that, if they are broken, a serpent will come out of them.
(133) “These are ( παροιμιώδη) proverbial expressions, and mean that bad men have taken destructive counsels, as if the eggs of serpents, which ought to be crushed by those who meet with them, were purposely hatched by some person, in order that poisonous animals might, in due time, be produced by them for the destruction of men.” — Rosenmuller
Fuente: Calvin’s Complete Commentary
(5) They hatch cockatrice eggs.Better, basilisks, as in Isa. 14:29. The schemes of the evil-doers are displayed in their power for evil and their impotence for good. To eat of the eggs, which are assumed to be poisonous, is to fall in with their schemes, and so be ruined: to crush them is to oppose and so to rouse a more venomous opposition. Men break the egg, and the living viper darts forth to attack them.
Fuente: Ellicott’s Commentary for English Readers (Old and New Testaments)
5, 6. Cockatrice’s eggs Hatched into basilisks, (see Isa 11:8😉 a fabulous reptile its gaze supposed to be fatal, its eggs, as food, certainly poisonous. The reference is to a popular, not a scientific, conception of a certain not well-known reptile, and is employed to characterize strongly the people’s evil works. So of the next figure.
The spider’s web An emblem of the people’s acts of enticing and ruining others. The further point of the figure is, that the “spider’s web” is too gauzy as a covering to conceal wicked plans against others. Flimsy sophistry cannot hide pretended righteousness.
Fuente: Whedon’s Commentary on the Old and New Testaments
Isa 59:5 They hatch cockatrice’ eggs, and weave the spider’s web: he that eateth of their eggs dieth, and that which is crushed breaketh out into a viper.
Ver. 5. They hatch cockatrice’ eggs,] i.e., Poisonous and pernicious designs; there are that interpret it of false doctrines, as destruetive to men’s souls, as cockatrice’ eggs eaten, or but broken, would be to their bodies. As the bird that sitteth on the serpent’s eggs, by breaking and hatching them, bringeth forth a perilous brood to her own destruction, so here.
And weave the spider’s web.] Good for nothing but to catch flies. The natural man is ever either weaving spider’s webs, which are futiles and fragiles, or hatching cockatrice’ eggs. Vanity or villany is his whole study and practice.
Fuente: John Trapp’s Complete Commentary (Old and New Testaments)
cockatrice = adders’, or vipers’. See note on Isa 11:8.
eggs . . . web. Note the Alternation in verses: Isa 5:6.
weave. See note on Isa 19:9.
viper. Occurs in Isaiah only here, and in the “former” portion (Isa 30:6). See App-79.
Fuente: Companion Bible Notes, Appendices and Graphics
cockatrice’: or, adder’s, Isa 14:29, Pro 23:32, *marg.
crushed breaketh out into a viper: or, sprinkled is as if there brake out a viper, Mat 3:7, Mat 12:34
Reciprocal: Job 8:14 – web Job 15:35 – conceive Psa 7:14 – General Psa 144:8 – mouth Pro 11:18 – wicked Isa 11:8 – cockatrice’ Isa 28:20 – the bed Luk 3:7 – O generation Act 28:3 – came
Fuente: The Treasury of Scripture Knowledge
Isa 59:5-6. They hatch cockatrice eggs They contrive and execute wicked purposes and practices, whereby sure and sudden destruction is brought upon themselves and others. Of the cockatrice, or basilisk, as it should rather be rendered, see on Isa 14:29. One kind is put for any venomous creature. The speech is proverbial, signifying, by these eggs, mischievous designs, and by hatching them their putting them in practice. And weave the spiders web Another proverbial speech, whereby is signified, both how by their plots they weaved nets, laid snares industriously with great pains and artifice, to entrap or entangle others; and also how their designs would come to nothing, as the spiders web is soon swept away. He that eateth of their eggs That converses and joins with them in their mischievous designs, and partakes of the fruits thereof; dieth Is seduced into destructive errors and vices, or involved in ruin. And that which is crushed In order that it may be eaten; breaketh out into a viper A poisonous viper proceeds from it. The more any one partakes of their counsels, the more he is infected, such a deadly poison lies imbodied in them. Their webs shall not become garments Though they are finely wrought, yet they are too thin and weak to be of any use; that is, their contrivances and deep designs shall not advantage them. Neither shall they cover themselves, &c. Their works shall neither cover nor defend the actors. Their works are works of iniquity Of injustice, whereby they grieve, vex, and injure their brethren. And the act of violence is in their hands They exercise themselves in all acts of violence and oppression.
Fuente: Joseph Bensons Commentary on the Old and New Testaments
59:5 They hatch {d} eggs of an adder, and weave the spider’s {e} web: he that eateth of their eggs dieth, and that which is crushed breaketh out into a viper.
(d) Whatever comes from them is poison, and brings death.
(e) They are profitable to no purpose.
Fuente: Geneva Bible Notes
The results of such a society are serpents’ eggs and spider webs. Instead of receiving nourishment from the eggs, the eggs either poison or, if hatched, fatally attack the eater. Instead of receiving warmth from the beautifully woven web, the web fails to clothe and instead entangles its wearer. This was because the work the people expended to secure food and clothing was self-centered. People even resorted to physical violence to get what they wanted for themselves. Such a society promises much but delivers little, and what it does deliver turns around and kills it.