Exegetical and Hermeneutical Commentary of Malachi 1:4
Whereas Edom saith, We are impoverished, but we will return and build the desolate places; thus saith the LORD of hosts, They shall build, but I will throw down; and they shall call them, The border of wickedness, and, The people against whom the LORD hath indignation forever.
4. impoverished ] Rather (with R.V. text, and so in Jer 5:17), beaten down. “So Ephraim said of old ‘in the pride and stoutness of heart, The bricks are fallen down, but we will build with hewn stones: the sycomores are cut down, but we will change them into cedars.’ Isa 9:9-10.” Pusey.
return and build ] This rendering is retained in R.V., but as there is no evidence that Edom was carried away captive ‘return and build’ is, probably, according to a well-known Heb. idiom =‘rebuild.’ (Comp. Eze 26:8; Eze 26:12-14.) This Israel ‘loved’ of God had done, but Esau ‘hated’ of Him should not do.
border ] i.e. land, or territory, as in Mal 1:5 below. It is frequently rendered coasts, in A.V., e.g. 1Sa 11:3; 1Sa 11:7.
for ever ] For the subsequent history of Edom, as fulfilling this prediction, see reference to Obadiah in note on Mal 1:3 above.
Fuente: The Cambridge Bible for Schools and Colleges
Whereas Edom saith – o.
We are impoverished – o, .), or, more probably, we were crushed. Either gives an adequate sense. Human self-confidence will admit anything, as to the past; nay, will even exaggerate past evil to itself, Crush us how they may, we will arise and repair our losses. So Ephraim said of old Isa 9:9-10, in the pride and stoutness of heart, The bricks are fallen down, but we will build with hewn-stones: the sycamores are cut down, but we will change them into cedars. It is the one language of what calls itself, indomitable; in other words, untameable, conquerors or every other gambler; we will repair our losses. All is again staked and lost.
They shall call them the border of wickedness. Formerly, it had its own proper name, the border of Edom, as other countries Exo 10:14, Exo 10:19, all the border of Egypt Deu 2:18, the border of Moab 1Sa 11:3, 1Sa 11:7; 1Sa 27:1; 1Ch 21:12, the whole border of Israel 2Ch 11:13, the border of Israel Jdg 11:22, the whole border of the Amorite. Henceforth, it should be known no more by its own name; but as the border of wickedness, where wickedness formerly dwelt, and, hence, the judgment of God and desolation from Him came upon it, an accursed land. In a similar manner, Jeremiah says somewhat of Jerusalem (Jer 22:8-9. Compare Deu 29:23-28.) Many nations shall pass by this city, and they shall say, every man to his neighbor, Wherfore hath the Lord done this unto this great city? Then they shall answer, Because they have forsaken the covenant of the Lord their God, and worshiped other gods and served them. Only Israel would retain its name, as it has; Edom should be blotted out wholly and forever.
Fuente: Albert Barnes’ Notes on the Bible
Mal 1:4
They shall build, but I will throw down.
Foolish builders
To separate our lives from God is folly; to live in opposition to Him is madness. Many not only disregard Him, but also oppose Him.
I. Who are these foolish builders?
1. Those who seek to build up a reputation with deceits.
2. Those who build up the fortunes of their houses with unrighteousness.
3. Those who build up a religious life without faith in Christ, the only foundation.
4. Those who build up their characters with evil principles and deeds.
5. Those who build up high positions by treachery and tyranny.
II. Consider the certainty of their overthrow. Woe be to the work that has God against it. It cannot stand. Think of His power, knowledge, and absolute control of all things. Everything that He does not smile upon must perish. History confirms this. Kingdoms created with great magnificence and might, but built in defiance of His laws, have, like Edom, fallen. Theological systems, and ecclesiastical despotisms that have been built up in opposition to Him, have been overthrown. Biography also confirms this. No life that has been spent in opposition to Him, however apparently influential, but has crumbled away like a falling tower. When God says, I will throw down, none can save. Experience also confirms it. Learn not to lay a stone in life without God. We should enter upon no work without first securing His aid and blessing. We can only erect a structure that will stand for ever, as we build in Gods way, and under the influence of the Spirit of Jesus. ( W. Osborne Lilley.)
Fuente: Biblical Illustrator Edited by Joseph S. Exell
Verse 4. They shall build, but I will throw down] We have already seen enough of the wickedness of the Edomites to justify the utmost severity of Divine justice against them. The pulling down predicted here was by Judas Maccabeus; see 1Mac 5:65; and by John Hyrcanus; see Joseph. Antiq., lib. xiii. c. 9. s. 1.
They shall call them, The border of wickedness] A wicked land. Among this people scarcely any trace of good could ever be noted.
Fuente: Adam Clarke’s Commentary and Critical Notes on the Bible
We are impoverished: here the prophet introduceth Edom reflecting on its present low condition, and taking up resolutions of bettering their condition: We are now, as the Jews were five years before, exceedingly spoiled by Nebuchadnezzar, who hath rifled our houses, burnt our cities, and captivated our citizens.
We will return; this speaks their insolence: or shall; this speaks their hopes of such a return as Jacobs posterity had after seventy years.
Build the desolate places; repair their cities, as Jerusalem was repaired by the returned captivity. They may do so for a while, but, saith God, I will throw it down; as he did in the times of the Maccabees.
They shall call them, The border of wickedness; they will be by their flagitious lives, after they a little recover themselves, a most wicked people, and so notorious that all their neighbours shall brand them for it, and presage a curse will follow them.
The people against whom the Lord hath indignation for ever; they will so highly provoke God, that his indignation will be kindled against them, and will burn for ever.
Fuente: English Annotations on the Holy Bible by Matthew Poole
4. Whereas“But if“Edom say [MAURER]. Edommay strive as she may to recover herself, but it shall be in vain,for I doom her to perpetual desolation, whereas I restore Israel.This Jehovah states, to illustrate His gratuitous love to Israel,rather than to Edom.
border of wickednessaregion given over to the curse of reprobation [CALVIN].For a time Judea seemed as desolate as Idumea; but though the latterwas once the highway of Eastern commerce, now the lonely rock-housesof Petra attest the fulfilment of the prophecy. It is still “theborder of wickedness,” being the resort of the marauding tribesof the desert. Judea’s restoration, though delayed, is yet certain.
the Lord hathindignation“the people of My curse” (Isa34:5).
Fuente: Jamieson, Fausset and Brown’s Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible
Whereas Edom saith, We are impoverished,…. Or the Idumeans, as the Targum; the posterity of Esau, who acknowledge themselves greatly reduced by the desolations made in their country, cities, towns, and houses, being plundered of all their valuable things. Kimchi interprets it, if the congregation of Edom should say, though we are become poor and low, and our land is laid waste:
but we will return; being now become rich, as the Targum adds; that is, as Jarchi explains it, with the spoils of Jerusalem:
and build the desolate places: as Israel did, as Kimchi observes, when they returned from their captivity; and so the Edomites hoped to do the same:
thus saith the Lord of hosts, They shall build, but I will throw down; they attempted to build again their cities and towns, but could not succeed, God was against them:
and they shall call them; or, “they shall be called” u; this shall be the name they, shall go by among men, by way of proverb and reproach:
The border of wickedness; a wicked kingdom and nation, from one end to the other; this shall be said of them, as the reason of their utter and perpetual desolation:
and, The people against whom the Lord hath indignation for ever; not for seventy years only, as against the Jews, Zec 1:12, but forever; and these are now no more a people; they are utterly extinct; their name and nation are lost; there is not the least appearance of them; when the Jews, though they are scattered about in the world, yet they are still a people, and distinct from all others.
u “et vocabuntur”, V. L. Junius & Tremellius, Piscator, Drusius, Grotius.
Fuente: John Gill’s Exposition of the Entire Bible
And to the same purpose he adds, If Edom shall say, We have been diminished, but we shall return and build houses; but if they build, I will pull down, saith God. He confirms what I have stated, that the posterity of Edom had no hope of restoration, for however they might gather courage and diligently labor in rebuilding their cities, they were not yet to succeed, for God would pull down all their buildings. This difference then was like a living representation, by which the Jews might see the love of God towards Jacob, and his hatred towards Esau. For since both people were overthrown by the same enemy, how was it that liberty was given to the Jews and no permission was given to the Idumeans to return to their own country? There was, as it has been said, a greater ill-will to the Jews, and yet the Chaldeans dealt with them more kindly. It then follows, that all this was owing to the wonderful purpose of God, and that hence it also appeared, that the adoption, which seemed to have been abolished when the Jews were driven into exile, was not in vain.
Thus then saith Jehovah of hosts, They shall build, that is, though they may build, I will overthrow; and it shall be said to them, Border of ungodliness, and a people with whom Jehovah is angry for ever. By the border of ungodliness he means an accursed border; as though he had said, “It will openly appear that you are reprobate, so that the whole world can form a judgment by the event itself.” By adding, A people with whom Jehovah is angry or displeased, he again confirms what I have said of love and hatred. God might indeed have been equally angry with the Jews as with the Edomites, but when God became pacified towards the Jews, while he continued inexorable to the posterity of Esau, the difference between the two people was hence quite manifest.
Noticed also must be the words, עד-עולם, od-oulam, for ever: for God seemed for a time to have rejected the Jews, and the Prophets adopt the same word זעם, som, angry, when they deplore the condition of the people, who found in various ways that God was angry with them. But the wrath of God towards the Jews was only for a time, for he did not wholly forget his covenant; but he became angry with the Edomites for ever, because their father had been rejected: and we know that this difference between the elect and the reprobate is ever pointed out, that when God visits sins in common, he ever moderates his wrath towards his elect, and sets limits to his severity, according to what he says, “If his posterity keep not my covenant, but profane my law, I will chastise them with the rod of man; but my mercy will I not take away from him.” (Psa 89:31 2Sa 7:14.) But with regard to the reprobate, God’s vengeance ever pursues them, is ever suspended over their heads, and ever fixed as it were in their bones and marrow. For this reason it is that our Prophet says, that God would be angry with the posterity of Esau.
Fuente: Calvin’s Complete Commentary
CRITICAL NOTES.
Mal. 1:4. Edom] cannot recover herself. Her perpetual ruins illustrate love to Israel rather than to her. Border] still the resort of marauding tribes of the desert. Indignation] Curse (cf. Isa. 34:5).
Mal. 1:5. See] the ineffectual attempts of Edom, and then acknowledge the greatness of Jehovah in and beyond the land of Israel.
Mal. 1:6.] Expostulation to priests, who should love Jehovah as sons, and fear] him as servants (Exo. 20:12). Say] Instead of confessing guilt, deny the charge and demand proofs.
Mal. 1:7. Polluted] i.e. any sacrifices the bread or food of God (Lev. 21:6; Lev. 21:8; Lev. 22:25; Num. 28:2). Blind and lame were polluted bread.
Mal. 1:8. Governor] If customary to offer heathen rulers presents proportionate to the dignity of the receiver the circumstances of the giver, and the value of the favour sought, should God be insulted by offering things which they would reject?
Mal. 1:9. Pray] An earnest call to repentance say some; others, that it is ironical. Think you that God will be persuaded by polluted gifts? No; amend your ways. This] Contemptible offerings your doing. Means] Lit. from your hand. Will God regard] you?
Mal. 1:10. Nought] So avaricious were they that the meanest things were not done without payment. Some say this frees the priests from excuse for carelessness, for the least service, such as shutting the door, was paid for. Others regard the words as a wish: Oh that some among you would not open my sanctuary to such profane intruders (close the doors against such worshippers and sacrifices), and would not kindle the fire on mine altar to no purpose! Better without worship than such as this [cf. Keil and Words.].
HOMILETICS
BUILDING UP WITHOUT GOD.Mal. 1:4
Edoms temporal desolation and her resolve to repair it may be taken as a figure of our moral condition and the efforts of men to improve it.
I. Mans moral condition is a ruin. We are impoverished; lit. ruined. Sin creates distance from God, and brings poverty and ruin. There is no misery like that which sin brings, and no misfortune so disastrous as that in which it ends. Sin brought death and all our woe into the world; and death is passed upon all men, for all have sinned.
II. Men try to repair their moral condition by wrong means. They are sensible of their misery,we are impoverished,feel their distance,we will return,and resolve to build up their broken fortunes,we will build the desolate places.
1. Mens efforts are directed to a wrong end. We will return. Return to what? Return to our kingdom and associations. Thus men cling to creeds, societies, and institutions, and not to God. If thou wilt return, O Israel, saith the Lord, return unto me.
2. Mens efforts are put forth in a wrong spirit. But we will return and build. Here we have pride, presumption, and opposition to God. Men resolve, but God will hinder. At Babel men were frustrated in purpose, confused in tongues, and scattered over the earth.
3. Mens efforts are built on a wrong foundation. They shall call them the border of wickedness. If the foundation be bad, the higher it is run up the more labour is lost, and the more tremendous the fall. Empires, houses, and fortunes built on selfish principles will never stand. Woe unto him that buildeth his house by unrighteousness, and his chambers by wrong (Jer. 22:13).
III. When men try to repair their moral condition by wrong means God will overthrow their efforts. They shall build, but I will throw down. Providence pulls down as well as builds up (Ecc. 3:3). God can crush every effort and break down every edifice of man. I will work, and who shall let? (hinder, turn it back, Isa. 14:27) (Isa. 43:13). He overturns our bodies by disease and death; our families by discord and bereavement; business by failure and loss; nations by famine and sword.
1. This overthrow is terrible. Places were desolate, buildings thrown down, broken into fragments. The firmest foundation, the most fortified walls of sin, will not avail before God. The Lord hath stretched out a line (not to build, but destroy, 2Ki. 21:13; Isa. 34:11), he hath not withdrawn his hand from destroying: therefore he made the wall and the rampart to lament (Lam. 2:8).
2. This overthrow is irrevocable. The indignation is for ever. The destruction can never be repaired. This seen in the tower of Babel and the cities of the plain. Joshuas curse fell upon the rebuilding of Jericho (cf. Jos. 6:26; 1Ki. 16:34). The apostate Julian could not contravene the word of God concerning Jerusalem. When he had gathered materials and commenced the work the tempest from heaven filled him with dismay, and forced him to confess the hand of God. He breaketh down, and (so that) it cannot be built again (Job. 12:14). But is there no way of building that we may be secure and happy? Must our efforts to recover ourselves perpetually fail, and our hopes be for ever disappointed? Build on Christ, the true foundation, for no other foundation can any man lay; build by the aid of the Spirit, and in humble confidence in the promise of God, then your work shall abide. Building up yourselves on your most holy faith. I commend you to God, and to the word of his grace, which is able to build you up, and to give you an inheritance among all them which are sanctified.
TITLES WITHOUT HONOURS.Mal. 1:6
Upon the fact that respect is shown by inferiors to superiors Jehovah founds his right to honour and reverence due to him as Creator and Ruler. But God condemns the contempt priests and people displayed in offering blemished sacrifices.
I. God is our Father, and should be honoured. The prophet does not appeal to the law, but lays down the truth, which none will dispute, that Jehovah is the Father of Israel. If God, therefore, is a father, the honour of sons is due to him. Heathen philosophers taught that parents were household gods, and were to have all possible respect. To God and our parents, said Aristotle, we can never make recompense.
1. God claims honour from us. Honour thy father and thy mother (Exo. 20:12). Doubtless thou art our father (Isa. 63:16; Mal. 2:10).
2. Men withhold the honour due to him. Where is mine honour? They do not honour him with their substance, but despise him in heart and act. Do ye thus requite the Lord?
II. God is our Master, and should be served. If I be a master, where is my fear? God is acknowledged to be our Lord. He should be served in filial not in slavish fear. We are not to find fault with his employment, or engage in it by force and constraint. They say and do not. Our service must be earnest and constant. In all fear should we obey and submit to him (1Pe. 2:18). Fidelity to our conscience will ever be rewarded. He that waiteth on his master shall be honoured; here by the promise and presence of God, at length by the approval of God. Well done, &c. If any man serve me him will my Father honour.
Bad servants wound their masters fame [Gay].
THE SINS OF THE PRIESTS.Mal. 1:6-10
Turning from the people, the prophet addresses the priests, who should be leaders in holiness, but are foremost in bringing the service of God into contempt. They were under special obligations to sanctify him, but they profaned his name and caused Israel to sin.
I. Their services were a violation of all law. A son should honour his father, and a servant obey his master (Mal. 1:6); but they withheld from God what they-demanded from the people, and slighted him more than any creature.
1. The law of nature was dishonoured. Fair words and grand titles require consistent life. Nature teaches honour to parents and respect to masters, reproves want of reverence to God, and testifies against those who honour in word and dishonour in life. Why call ye me Lord, Lord, and do not the things which I say?
2. The law of God was violated. God expressly forbade the offering of the blind, the lame, or any evil-favoured sacrifice. Whatsoever hath a blemish, that shall ye not offer: for it shall not be acceptable for you. Ye shall not offer unto the Lord that which is bruised, or crushed, or broken, or cut (Lev. 22:20; Lev. 22:24). If it be lame, or blind, or have any ill blemish, thou shalt not sacrifice it unto the Lord thy God (Deu. 15:21; Neh. 5:14-15).
3. The law of common civility was disregarded. Offer it now unto thy governor; will he be pleased with thee? (Mal. 1:8). What insult to offer God what a mortal would disdain! Yet what a contrast between Gods table and that of our princes! If an earthly monarch would neither accept our gift nor espouse our cause with such approach, can we expect God to bless? Will he be pleased with thee or accept thy person?
II. Their services were offensive to God. They despised his name and offered polluted bread upon his altar.
1. Their offerings were mean in substance. Ye offer the blind for sacrifice; is it not evil? They put God off with what was worth nothing. Darius probably supplied them plentifully with victims for sacrifice, but they offered the worst. God despises not the widows mite, but he does despise the misers mite, says Moore.
2. Their offerings were mercenary in spirit. They would neither kindle a fire nor shut the door without pay (Mal. 1:10). What will ye give me, and I will deliver him unto you? How niggardly we are in Gods service! Ever crying, What profit shall we have? Thinking more of gain than duty. The meanest service for God will not be unrewarded. The servants of the temple had their tithes, cups of cold water have their benediction, and God is not unjust to forget labours of love. But if we become covetous and unfaithful, every one for his gain, from his quarter (Isa. 56:11), then we pollute the altar and bring the service of God into contempt.
TRUE SPIRITUAL SERVICE.Mal. 1:7-8
In the condemnation of what was evil in the spirit and substance of ancient sacrifice we learn the right method of approaching God, the true nature of spiritual service.
I. It should be intelligent. We should never offer the blind or ignorant service, and worship we know not what. For he hath no pleasure in fools.
II. It should be earnest and hearty. Not lame and half-hearted, but upright and sincere; not sick and feeble, but vigorous and cheerful. The homage and communion of the highest part of man; for God is a spirit, and can only hold communion with spirit. If my soul is not engaged in my worship, it is even as though I worshipped not [Confucius].
III. It should be reverential. If heathens were careful to offer sacrifices without blemish, how reverential should we be in the sanctuary of God. Never enter without due preparation; never utter hasty and ill-arranged thoughts, nor offer slovenly prayers and praise. Be as anxious to worship God as to discharge secular functions. God deserves our best, let us not dishonour him with unsound and grudged gifts. Neither will I offer burnt offerings unto the Lord my God of that which doth cost me nothing.
HOMILETIC HINTS AND OUTLINES
Mal. 1:6. It becomes us to do what God enjoins. First, because he has a right to command us. He is Sovereign, we are subjects; Master, we are servants; Father, we are children. Secondly, because all his commandments are reasonable. None arbitrary or tyrannical. Thirdly, because his commands are beneficial. All enjoined has special regard to our welfare. In keeping his commandments there is great reward. Fourthly, because Gods commands are practicable. All imply power to obey. If not possessed, yet attainable; if not in nature, yet in grace; if not in ourselves, yet in him whose authority we recognize, and who is always accessible [Jay]. God is the Father of the faithful
(1) By creation;
(2) by preservation and governance;
(3) by alimony;
(4) by fatherly care and providence;
(5) by faith and grace, whereby he justifies and adopts us sons and heirs of his kingdom [Pusey].
Mal. 1:7. Is it not evil? If we worship God ignorantly and without understanding we bring the blind for sacrifice; if we do it carelessly and without consideration, if we are cold, and dull, and dead in it, we bring the sick; if we rest in the bodily exercise, and do not make heart work of it, we bring the lame; and if we suffer vain thoughts and distractions to lodge within us, we bring the torn [Matt. Henry].
Polluted bread. Because
1. It does not correspond with the requirements of Gods law.
2. It is offered with impure mind and life. If temple purifications were necessary of old, how much holiness is needful now! Contemptible table. In what way can we now pollute the table of the Lord?
(1) In the Sacrament, when we ourselves partake of it unworthily, or do not enough arouse the consciences of others.
(2) In life, when we allow in ourselves, or in others committed to us, a half-way devotedness to the Lord [Lange].
Mal. 1:9-10. These words are difficult, but may contain
1. A charge against the priests. You begun, and continued to insult God, by worthless sacrifices, and brought all the consequences upon the people. Not from aliens, not from the custom of your fathers, but from your hand hath this been.
2. An ironical appeal, covering an implied menace. Bring your maimed sacrifices, press God with your prayers, will he regard your persons, in the spirit in which you serve him? Some say
3. A call to repentance and prayer for the mercy of God. I pray you, beseech God, that he will be gracious unto you.
4. A rejection of priestly intercession. An indignant appeal is made to their own consciences. If you have brought this evil upon the worship of God, if your hands are tainted with sinful offerings; are you fit to pray for the rest? Try it on, you will not succeed. God will reject you! He sums up with an entire rejection of them, present and future: I have no pleasure in you; it is a term of repudiation (cf. 1Sa. 18:25), sometimes of disgust (Jer. 22:28; Jer. 48:38; Hos. 8:8), neither will I accept an offering at your hands [Pusey].
5. To silence excuse. You have nothing to say for such careless offerings. You know what is right, and you are paid for the smallest service you perform.
6. A wish to close the doors against such proceedings. Who among you will shut the doors, and keep such worshippers out of the temple? Better close the sanctuary than open it to subserve selfish and hypocritical purposesbetter have no offerings at all than vain offerings which God will not accept (Isa. 1:11-15). Away with your vain oblations! What purpose is the multitude of your sacrifices to me!
ILLUSTRATIONS TO CHAPTER 1
Mal. 1:2-5. Loved you. Ingratitude is too base to return a kindness, and too proud to regard it; much like the tops of mountains, barren indeed but yet lofty; they produce nothing, they feed nobody, they clothe nobody, yet are high and stately, and look down upon all the world about them [Dr. South].
Mal. 1:6. Honoureth. One of the best elements of character as well in a child as in a man, is reverence. This is the feeling due to parents and to God, our Father in heaven. It is more than respect; it is respect blended with awe. One void of reverence unconsecrates all the mysteries and sanctities of life [Dulce Domum].
Mal. 1:7-8; Mal. 1:12-13. Accept person.
When once thy foot enters the Church, be bare:
God is more there than thou, for thou art there
Only by his permission. Then beware;
And make thyself all reverence and fear. [G. Herbert.]
Mal. 1:10. Nought. His money perish with him, said the pious marquis of Vico, who prefers not one hours communion with Christ before all the riches and pleasures of the world. Covetousness debaseth a mans spirit [Tillotson].
Fuente: The Preacher’s Complete Homiletical Commentary Edited by Joseph S. Exell
(4) Whereas . . . saith.Better, If Edom say.
We are impoverished.Better, we are broken to pieces. Edoms ineffectual attempts to restore itself will be looked on as proofs of Gods wrath against the nation on account of its wickedness, and will acquire for it the titles border of wickedness, the people against whom the Lord hath indignation for ever. Border means confines, territory; Latin, fines.
Keith, Evidence of Prophecy, pp. 309, 310, in reference to the literal fulfilment of this prophecy, writes as follows:In recording the invasion of Demetrius, about three hundred years before the Christian era, into the land of Edom, Diodorus describes the country as a desert, and the inhabitants as living without houses; nor does he mention any city in that region but Petra alone. Yet the names of some of the cities of Arabia Petra, enumerated by Josephus, as existing at the time when the Romans invaded Palestinethe names of eighteen cities of Palestina Tertia, of which Petra was the capital, and the metropolitan see, in the times of the Lower Empireand the towns laid down in DAnvilles map, together with the subsisting ruins of towns in Edom, specified by Burckhardt, and also by Laborde, give proof that Edom, after having been impoverished, did return, and build the desolate places, even as the ruined towns and places, still visible and named, show that though the desolate places were built again according to the prophecy, they have, as likewise foretold, been thrown down, and are ruined places lying in utter desolation.
Fuente: Ellicott’s Commentary for English Readers (Old and New Testaments)
Mal 1:4. They shall build, &c. “The Edomites may rebuild their cities, but the Lord will raise against them the Maccabees, who shall subject them, and constrain them to receive circumcision, and the other laws and customs of the Jews.” See 1Ma 5:3. 2Ma 10:16-17 and Joseph. Antiq. lib. 13: cap. 17.
Fuente: Commentary on the Holy Bible by Thomas Coke
Mal 1:4 Whereas Edom saith, We are impoverished, but we will return and build the desolate places; thus saith the LORD of hosts, They shall build, but I will throw down; and they shall call them, The border of wickedness, and, The people against whom the LORD hath indignation for ever.
Ver. 4. Whereas Edom saith, We are impoverished ] Or, thrust out of house and home, and reduced to extreme indigence; yet we will return, and build the desolate places. We will do it all, despite di Deo (as that profane pope said), if it be but to cross God’s prediction, and to withstand his power and providence. Thus these earthen pots will be dashing themselves against the rocks, against those mountains of brass (so God’s immutable decrees are called, Zec 6:1 ). Thus Lamech will have the odds of God seventy to seven (so Junius interprets it), Gen 4:24 . Thus, when God had threatened to root out Ahab and his posterity, he would try that; and to prevent it, took more wives, and so followed the work of generation, that he left seventy sons behind him, 2Ki 10:1 . Thus Pharaoh (that sturdy rebel) holds out against God to the utmost, and sends away his servant Moses, threatening death to him, even then when he was compassed on all hands with that palpable darkness. Thus the Philistine princes (while sore plagued) gather themselves together again against the humbling Israelites at Mizpeh; and so run to meet their bane, 1Sa 7:10 . Thus the proud Ephraimites, Isa 9:10 . The bricks indeed, say they, are fallen down, but we will build it again with hewn stones. The wild fig trees are cut down, but we will change them into cedars. Thus the Pharisees and lawyers rejected the counsel of God against themselves, Luk 7:30 , yea, would needs be found fighters against God, as Gamaliel truly told them, Act 5:39 . Thus those primitive persecutors would needs attempt to root our Christian religion; the Jews, by the leave and help of Julian, to despite the Christians, would rebuild their city and temple, but were hindered from heaven. Otho, the Emperor, would make the city of Rome his imperial seat (which was long before pointed and painted out for the nest of antichrist), but could not effect it. The Jesuits would fain heal the beast’s wounded head, and re-establish their kingdom of idolatry, but this they must never look for. Christ shall reign, and all his foes shall be his footstool: the Romish Edomites shall come to ruin.
Thus saith the Lord, They shall build, but I will throw down
They shall build, but I will destroy
And they shall call them, The border of wickedness
And, The people against whom the Lord hath indignation
Fuente: John Trapp’s Complete Commentary (Old and New Testaments)
impoverished: or, beaten down.
saith hath said.
the LORD of hosts. This expression occurs twenty four times in this prophecy, and gives its character to the whole, as in Zechariah.
border: or, territory.
wickedness = lawlessness. Hebrew. rasha`. App-44.
Fuente: Companion Bible Notes, Appendices and Graphics
Edom
i.e. Esau’s descendants. See Gen 25:30.
Fuente: Scofield Reference Bible Notes
but: Isa 9:9, Isa 9:10, Jam 4:13-16
They shall build: Job 9:4, Job 12:14, Job 34:29, Psa 127:1, Pro 21:30, Isa 10:4, Isa 10:15, Isa 10:16, Lam 3:37, Mat 12:30
The border: Jer 31:17, Eze 11:10, Amo 6:2
The people: Mal 1:3, Psa 137:7, Isa 11:14, Isa 34:5, Isa 34:10, Isa 63:1-6, Lam 4:21, Lam 4:22, Eze 25:14, Eze 35:9
Reciprocal: Jos 6:26 – Cursed Jdg 6:6 – impoverished Isa 34:11 – stretch Isa 64:9 – remember Jer 22:14 – I will Jer 49:7 – Edom Jer 49:10 – I have made Jer 49:13 – a desolation Jer 49:20 – make Lam 2:2 – he hath thrown Eze 25:13 – I will also Eze 26:14 – be built Eze 32:29 – Edom Eze 35:4 – lay Hos 2:9 – will I Joe 3:19 – Edom Amo 1:11 – Edom Amo 9:12 – Edom Oba 1:1 – concerning Oba 1:3 – pride Oba 1:10 – and Oba 1:19 – the south Hab 2:13 – is it Mal 3:18 – shall
Fuente: The Treasury of Scripture Knowledge
Mal 1:4. Esau was the founder of the Edomites who thought they could resist the work of God that was meant for their punishment. Yet they failed, for the Lord was determined to through doing their work. All of this was evidence that Israel had fared better than his brother and hence was beloved by the Lord.
Fuente: Combined Bible Commentary
Mal 1:4-5. Edom saith, We are empoverished, [or, brought low,] but we will return and build the desolate places This they accordingly did, as we learn from the history of those times; and undoubtedly thought to become a flourishing people again, and to continue so. But God had determined otherwise, as is here declared. Thus saith the Lord, They shall build, but I will throw down This was accordingly done by Gods giving success, first to the arms of Judas Maccabus, and afterward to those of Hyrcanus, by whom Edom was spoiled and laid waste again. And they shall call them, The border of wickedness They shall be called, or accounted by others, a wicked nation, or a country of wicked men, and therefore deservedly laid waste. And ye shall say, The Lord will be magnified Or, rather, Let the Lord be magnified; from the border of Israel Namely, from that border which extended even to Idumea.
Fuente: Joseph Bensons Commentary on the Old and New Testaments
Even though the Edomites, Esau’s descendants, determined to rebuild their nation after it had suffered destruction by the Babylonians, they would not be able to do so. They could not because almighty Yahweh would not permit it. He would tear down whatever they rebuilt, so much so that other people would view them as a wicked land (cf. the holy land, Zec 2:12) and the objects of Yahweh’s perpetual indignation. The "holy" land was holy, sanctified, because God set it apart for special blessing, as He had the nation of Israel. Edom, on the other hand, was wicked because God had not set it apart for special blessing.
"Israel needed to consider what her lot would have been if she, like Edom, had not been elected to a covenant relationship with Yahweh. Both Israel and Edom received judgment from God at the hands of the Babylonians in the sixth century (Jer 27:2-8). Yet God repeatedly promised to restore Israel (because of His covenant promises, Deu 4:29-31; Deu 30:1-10), but He condemned Edom to complete destruction, never to be restored (Jer 49:7-22; Ezekiel 35)." [Note: Blaising, p. 1576.]
"The Judeans had Persian permission and support in their rebuilding campaign (Ezr 1:1-11; Ezr 4:3; Ezr 6:1-15; Ezr 7:11-28; Neh 2:7-9; Neh 13:6). That was God’s doing. The Edomites had no such help, which was also God’s doing and which sealed Edom’s fate as a people forever." [Note: Stuart, p. 1289.]