Exegetical and Hermeneutical Commentary of Galatians 3:24

Wherefore the law was our schoolmaster [to bring us] unto Christ, that we might be justified by faith.

24. Translate, so that the law has proved to us a tutor unto Christ.

our schoolmaster ] The Greek word, ‘paidagogos’ (from which Engl. pedagogue) does not mean a teacher, but a confidential slave, who had the general charge of boys, watching over their conduct and exercising discipline sometimes, though not always, attending them to school. The sense is, that the legal dispensation, with its requirements and restrictions, was a preparation for the liberty of the Gospel. But while rejecting the narrow interpretation which would limit the office of the law to the functions of a schoolmaster or teacher, we must not (with some commentators) regard Christ as the Schoolmaster to Whose school the law conducted us. The contrast is not between the ‘tutor’ and the teacher, but between the state of tutelage and that of freedom see Gal 3:25.

Fuente: The Cambridge Bible for Schools and Colleges

Wherefore the law was our schoolmaster – The word rendered schoolmaster ( paidagogos, whence the word pedagogue), referred originally to a slave or freedman, to whose care boys were committed, and who accompanied them to the public schools. The idea here is not that of instructor, but there is reference to the office and duty of the paedagogus among the ancients. The office was usually intrusted to slaves or freedmen. It is true, that when the paedagogus was properly qualified, he assisted the children committed to his care in preparing their lessons. But still his main duty was not instruction, but it was to watch over the boys; to restrain them from evil and temptation; and to conduct them to the schools, where they might receive instruction. See, for illustrations of this, Wetstein, Bloomfield, etc. In the passage before us, the proper notion of pedagogue is retained. In our sense of the word schoolmaster, Christ is the schoolmaster, and not the Law. The Law performs the office of the ancient pedagogue, to lead us to the teacher or the instructor. That teacher or instructor is Christ. The ways in which the Law does this may be the following:

(1) It restrains us and rebukes us, and keeps us as the ancient pedagogue did his boys.

(2) The whole law was designed to be introductory to Christ. The sacrifices and offerings were designed to shadow forth the Messiah, and to introduce him to the world.

(3) The moral law – the Law of God – shows people their sin and danger, and thus leads them to the Saviour. It condemns them, and thus prepares them to welcome the offer of pardon through a Redeemer.

(4) It still does this. The whole economy of the Jews was designed to do this and under the preaching of the gospel it is still done. People see that they are condemned; they are convinced by the Law that they cannot save themselves, and thus they are led to the Redeemer. The effect of the preached gospel is to show people their sins, and thus to be preparatory to the embracing of the offer of pardon. Hence, the importance of preaching the Law still; and hence, it is needful that people should be made to feel that they are sinners, in order that they may be prepared to embrace the offers of mercy; compare the note at Rom 10:4.

Fuente: Albert Barnes’ Notes on the Bible

Gal 3:24

Wherefore the law was our schoolmaster.

The law was our schoolmaster

I. The condition of humanity and the ultimate purpose of God respecting it. The Jews a type of mankind. Humanity is the Son of God, legally disinherited by apostasy, and gross and sensual. The heart of the Father is set upon its restoration, by pure favour, by means of faith. The Divine purpose was spiritual, and man must be conducted to it gradually. So God put man to school that, by a course of preparatory discipline, he might have his senses exercised.

II. The heir as long as he was a child was at school. The methods adopted were such as befitted his condition and age. The young mind is first made familiar with visible symbols, which for a time it mistakes for substance, but eventually learns the inner meaning. These methods were–

1. Prophetic intimations which must be put together like a dissected map.

2. A large picture-book was put before the scholars in the Levitical institute.

3. In addition to this pupils were required to do something, which constituted another process of emblematical teaching; ceremonies for purification, e.g.

III. These lessons of the schoolmaster became a preparation for the gospel. Christ was the end or scope of the law. The process of learning, however, was similar to what occurs in ordinary teaching. The mind of the scholar opens very gradually to that of the teacher.

1. The map which the young pupil had to study, the earthly land secured to Abraham, and his seed, is found to expand into a higher region, and to associate itself with another race (Rom 4:13; Heb 11:8; Heb 11:13-16).

2. The pieces of prophecy are put together, and compose the majestic figure of the Messiah.

3. With new views of the centre figure the whole of the Levitical system assumes its Divine significance.

(1) Its sacrifices become symbols of the better sacrifice.

(2) Its purification of the fountain opened for sin and uncleanness.

(3) Its feasts superseded by the spiritual privileges symbolized.

(4) With all this comes a new and ennobling sentiment of obedience. The law is not now heard in thunder and as a terrible shalt not, but a privilege and a joy. (T. Binney, D. D.)

There was a time of the worlds minority, and a time when it came of age. These times were marked–

1. By two stages–bondage and liberty.

2. By two principles of action–law and faith. Moses was the worlds schoolmaster, Christ became the worlds higher teacher. This state of things obtains in natural life, and in the single hearts life. Observe–

I. The uses of restraint in the hearts education. The law to the Jews was a system of checks.

1. To restrain from violence. The law is a schoolmaster to rule those who cannot rule themselves. In this stage it would be madness to relax from restraint.

2. To show the inward force of evil. Evil is unsuspected until opposed.

3. To form habits of obedience. Would you have your child happy, decided, manly? Teach him to obey.

4. To nourish the temper of faith. The use of all education is to form faith. The child does not know the reason of his teachers command; he has to trust.

II. The time when restraint may be safely laid aside.

1. When self-command is obtained. To be brought to Christ is to have learned to deny self.

2. When the state of justification by faith has been attained. Justification is acceptance with God, not because a man is perfect, but because he does all in a large and generous spirit. In such a state a man acts on principle, and gets beyond enactments. Apply to parents and teachers. How is it that children of religious parents turn out ill?

1. Because there has been no restraint during the time of discipline.

2. Because restraint has been applied when there should have been an appeal to principle and faith. (F. W. Robertson, M. A.)

The law is a schoolmaster

I. As giving precepts in which principles are involved but not expressly taught. Every wise teacher begins so, and the first duty of the pupil is a blind obedience. At length when the pupil discovers the principle he may dispense with the rule or not, as he pleases.

II. As prescribing inadequate duties–a part instead of the whole, which was to develop into the whole.

1. The institution of temple worship, by means of which the Jews were to be led into the truth that God is here, and therefore to be worshipped. But God is everywhere, and His true temples infinite space and the soul of man.

2. The institution of the Sabbath. But just as a right of way is often secured to the proprietor by shutting up a road one day in the year, not to declare it his only on that day, or more on that day than others, but simply to vindicate his right in it for every day; so did God shut up one-seventh part of time, that it might be understood that all belonged to Him.

3. The third commandment, which is not simply a prohibition of blasphemy, but was equivalent to thou shalt not forswear thyself, but perform thy oaths.

Learn:

1. That revelation is education. What education is for the individual, revelation is for the race.

2. That revelation is progressive.

3. That the training of character in Gods revelation has always preceded illumination of the intellect. (F. W. Robertson, M. A.)

The stern pedagogue

I. The office of the law. Our guardian, ruler, tutor, governor.

1. To teach us our obligations.

2. To show us our sinfulness.

3. To sweep away our excuses.

4. To chasten our delinquencies.

5. To watch us everywhere

II. The design of this office.

1. Not to conduct any man to despair, except of himself and it.

2. Not to urge us to make an amalgam of works and faith.

3. But to make us accept salvation as a free gift of God.

III. The termination of this office. When we come to believe in Jesus, the pedagogue troubles us no more. We become, then, of age. The office of the law ends.

1. When we ascertain that Christ has fulfilled it.

2. When it comes to be written on the heart. The man can be trusted, the boy must be watched.

3. When we take up our heirship in Christ. (C. H. Spurgeon.)

The law a guide to Christ

I. The method of this guiding power is exercised–

1. By completely shutting us out from every other hope.

2. By showing us the character and qualifications which we must find in the Saviour on whom we can entirely rely.

(1) He must be one competent to fulfil all the provisions of the holy law.

(2) But no creaturely being has ever accomplished this.

(3) The Saviour, therefore, must be Divine as well as human.

(4) These conditions meet in Christ.

3. By revealing the way in which we must be partakers of the Saviours mercy, and be interested in His redemption.

(1) It must be all of grace;

(2) by faith;

(3) issuing in justification.

4. By proclaiming its entire satisfaction with the provided Saviour.

(1) All its demands are honoured;

(2) its penalties borne;

(3) its acquital secured.

II. The object for which this guiding power is exercised.

1. Justification before God is the great want of the rebel under the condemnation of the law. He must gain this blessing or perish.

2. This cannot be obtained by the works of the law, which involve the discharge of its obligations and the endurance of its penalty.

3. It must, and therefore is, to be obtained by faith in Christ.

4. This faith working by love manifests itself in righteousness. (S. H. Tyng, D. D.)

The pedagogue

The pedagogue was a slave who had charge of his owners children, And who led them to the porch of the one who was really to give them lessons. But his office was not merely to keep the children in the right path and out of danger; he was a sort of private tutor, who prepared them for the instruction they were to receive from the philosopher or the professor. These higher lessons were quite beyond the power of the tutor himself; but he could do something to remove the difficulties which prevented young people from understanding, but above all he could undertake that they should be punctually in their place when the professor began his work. (Canon Liddon.)

Christ our schoolmaster

You send your little child in the care of some one to school. The ward takes the little creature, and says, Come, I will take you to school, and away they go to the place of instruction. Now the law was our care-taker, our companion, to take us to our schoolmaster Christ; Christ keeps a school, Christ calls those who go to His school His disciples, His scholars; Christ says, Learn of Me. (J. Parker, D. D.)

Life a school

Men are brought into this world, just as children are taken to school, to learn their lessons. We are born into this world to be schooled for heaven. There are vacancies in heaven for a certain number of us, and all who pass a good examination when the time comes will have their cards of admission given them into the place marked which they are to take. This life the public school that prepares for the university which we call heaven; and the Bible the code by which our lives will be tested when we present ourselves as candidates for admission: this is all, literally, that our present existence was contrived for, or the Bible given. (E. S. Ffoulkes, B. D.)

Love in the schooling of the law

A written law of God being given to man, what is its further office? The fulfulling of that law is in one word, love; for God is its Author, and God is love. Can the will of man, by itself and unaided, fulfil that law? And hero observe two things. First, this is not a question of much or little–can mans will half fulfil the law, or nearly fulfil it, or quite fulfil it?–but it is an absolute question, which must be answered, yea or nay, from the very nature of mans will and of the law. It is not, Can mans will fulfil this or that part of it? but Can it ever fulfil it at all, any single command of it? What is mans will? A will diverted, in the fall, from its central object; a selfish will; a will which recognizes not, follows not, the law of love as its guide; and in this wandering away from love and from God, leads with it mans whole nature. Now you see our question is this, Can such a will again renew itself into love? Manifestly not. It is powerless to give itself a new direction. What we want, then, is not a law to obey, but a Redeemer to set us free. Next, we may remark, that this question of the ability of man by his own will to keep Gods law, must not be confused, by being mixed up with the entirely distinct question of the relation of Gods absolute foreknowledge and foreordination to the free will of man. That relation did not begin with the fall of man at all; it would have subsisted just as much if he had never fallen: it subsists with regard to the holy angels in heaven, who have never sinned; it is an universal law of all created being. The incapacity of mans will of which we here speak, is not in consequence of any fettering of it by Gods sovereign decrees, but in consequence of its own act and deed, by which it left God and the law of love in our first parent, and became subject to those lower desires and faculties which it was created to rule and guide. Now let me not be mistaken as to my present position. In saying that the will of fallen man is incapable of fulfilling Gods law, let me be thoroughly understood. I am drawing no wild, exaggerated picture of depravity, but wish to keep to the strict letter of fact, and to build on it important consequences. There is much that the human will can do. It can choose between the outward objects which are presented to us in life–the objects of thought, of speech, of action. Nay, more; over all mere outward obedience to Gods law the will has power. But the will has not power over the desires and affections; in other words, over the superior faculties, of which it is a servant. It can produce good deeds to a certain extent, but it cannot produce good tendencies. And so by the law it has been proved, that redemption is necessary for man. And more; it has been brought about that man should be receptive of redemption, prepared to welcome it, eager to avail himself of it. His very demonstrated helplessness has shown that he must be helped from above. The law was Gods great instrument to prepare man for redemption by Christ. He used it in this way on a large scale in the history of the world. The Jewish people, who were placed under it, were by it not rendered a people acceptable to God, but proved incapable of pleasing Him. Its lower requirements became to them a substitute for its first and great commandment; and no restoration to the law of love was effected by it in them. In the course of history its threatenings were executed on them, its promises, and more than its promises, fulfilled to them as a people; and when the Redeemer came, they were for the most part a nation of hardened hypocrites. All its power was power to convict and find guilty–not power to save even by that conviction:–for mans depraved conscience might quench and annul the conviction. And He has ever made the same use of His law in the hearts of individuals. And now I would ask you to mark the wonderful course and progress of Divine love towards us. In mankind at large, as in individual men, there must be produced this knowledge and feeling of their own unworthiness and incapacity to save themselves; not indeed so as to make them universally cry out for the gospel, but so as to make them, when the gospel has come, on looking over the page of history, confess that God has manifested beyond a doubt the sinfulness of man. For the first many ages after the fall, the unwritten law took its course. The conscience became darkened–the earth full of violence–till the vengeance of God was drawn down upon it in the Flood. Again, the true knowledge and fear of him, in the family of Noah, was assumed as a starting-point for the new world; again, even from this more definite covenant did the nations of the world go astray as widely as ever. Out of them God selected Abraham, and entered into special covenant with him and his seed. And while in them was proved the powerlessness of His revealed law to renew or to save, among the Gentile nations a lesson not less remarkable was being taught to mankind. Of them God suffered some to advance to the very highest pitch of art, and science, and acuteness of the human intellect. Their philosophy has set the pattern for the world; their oratory, their poetry, have been since unrivalled. And that nothing might be wanting to the full trial of man, another people found its employment and pride in civil arts; in taming the nations, in sparing and consolidating by exquisite polity the states subjected to its sway; in laying the foundation of public right and justice for the latest age of mankind. And thus both by these, and in other parts of the inhabited world by other nations, the powers of man for good were fully and maturely tried. Every facility was given him which belonged to his fallen state. And the result of all was this: that neither by wisdom, nor by imagination, nor by individual or social power for good, nor by the revelation of Gods will in the law, could man put himself back again into the path of love which he had left. O you who read ancient history, whether sacred or profane, read it to trace it in this design of God, to prepare the world for Christ; for this is the master-key to its secrets. (Dean Alford.)

The use of the law

A minister says, When I was a boy I ploughed a field with a team of spirited horses. I ploughed it very quickly, Once in a while I passed over some of the sod without turning it, but I did not jerk back the plough with its rattling devices. I thought it made no difference. After awhile, my father came along, and said: Why, this will never do; this isnt ploughed deep enough; there, you have missed this and you have missed that. And he ploughed it over again. The difficulty with a great many people is that they are only scratched with conviction when the subsoil plough of Gods truth ought to be put in up to the beam.

The law and the gospel

You never saw a woman sewing without a needle. She would come but poor speed if she only sewed wi the thread. So, I think, when were dealing with sinners, we maun aye put in the needle of the law first; for the fact is, they are sleepin sound, and they need to be awakened up wi something sharp. But, when weve got the needle o the law fairly in, we may draw as long a thread as you like o gospel consolation after it. (Lockhart.)

The law a schoolmaster

The method devised by Dr. Arnold at Rugby School, was to eventually raise the moral tone of the whole school by first raising the tone of a certain part. Is it irreverent to call the Israelites the Sixth Form of the school of the human race, an elect nation for the sake of the non-elect, chosen neither for their own merits, nor principally for their own blessing (though their privileges were inestimable), but to hasten the coming of Christ, and thus in the end to open the kingdom of heaven to all believers? (C. R. Lloyd Engstrom, M. A.)

The law leading men to Christ

The law! It is one of a group of words round which the thought of St. Paul constantly moves; and he uses it in more senses than one. Here he means by it generally the five Books of Moses to which the Jews commonly gave the name; and more particularly he means those parts of Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers, and Deuteronomy, in which are contained the various rules which God gave to Moses for the moral, social, political, and religious, or ceremonial conduct of the people of Israel. This was the law in which, as St. Paul said, the Jew of his day made his boast; he was proud to belong to the race which had received it. This was the law, the possession of which made Israel a peculiar people, marking it off by a deep-cut line of separation from all the other nations of the world. This was the law which it was the business of every Israelite to obey. Now St. Paul says bluntly, that the main purpose of this law was not present, but prospective; it was not to be so much prized on its own account, as for the sake of that to which it was to lead. It was really like those slaves who were kept in well-to-do households in the ancient world, first to teach the children of their masters roughly, or as well as they could, and then to lead them down day by day to the school of some neighbouring philosopher, at whose hands they would receive real instruction. This, then, was the business of the law; it did the little it could do for the Jewish people as an elementary instructor, and then it had to take them by the hand and lead them to the school of Jesus Christ. This it did:

I. By foreshadowing him. This was especially true of its ceremonies. All the Jewish ritual, in its minutest details, was a shadow of good things to come. Each ceremony was felt to have some meaning beyond the time then present, and so it fostered an expectant habit of mind; and as the ages passed, these expectations converged more and more towards a coming Messiah; and so, in a subordinate but real way, the ceremonial law did its part in leading the nation to the school of Christ.

II. By creating in mans conscience a sense of want, which Christ alone could relieve. This was the work of the moral law. Exact obedience to strict precepts was commanded; but who could render it? So the law, universally disobeyed, became like a torch carried into the dark cellars and crevices of human nature that it might reveal the foul shapes lurking there, and might rouse man to long for a righteousness which it could not confer. And this could only be found in Christ.

III. By putting them under a discipline which trained them for Christ. God begins with rule, and ends with principle; begins with law, and ends with faith; begins with Moses and ends with Christ. In the earlier revelation God only said Do this, do not do that. In the later or Christian revelation He has done much more; He has said, Join yourselves by an act of adhesion of your whole moral nature to the perfect moral Being–in other words, Believe on the Lord Jesus Christ, This is justification by faith. So far from being moral anarchy, it is the absorption of rule into the higher realm of principle. In the experience of the soul, faith corresponds to the empire of principle in the growth of individual character and in the development of national life; while the law answers to that elementary stage in which outward rules are not yet absorbed into principle. (Canon Liddon.)

The schooling of the law

There were three systems of law delivered to the Jews, each leading, like a highway of the Lord, to Christ.

I. The judicial law. This involved their civil policy as a state or nation, governed their conduct as between man and man, and determined their offences and penalties as citizens and subjects.

II. The ceremonial law, determining their ecclesiastical polity.

III. The moral law. Resolved by Christ into two commandments, and by St. Paul into one word–love. This law brings us to Christ

(1) By convicting of sin;

(2) by revealing our peril;

(3) by its weakness through the flesh to save from death. (J. B. Owen, M. A.)

Pedagogic character of the law

A schoolmaster nowadays is not at all like the personage Paul intended. He speaks of a pedagogue, an official seldom if ever now seen among men. This was not a person who actually officiated as master in the school, and gave instruction in the school itself; but one–a slave generally–who was set to take the boys to school, and to watch over them, and to be a sort of general supervisor of them, both in school and Out of school, and at all times. A pedagogue was very generally employed in the training of the young; indeed, it was a common and customary thing for the sons of the Greek and Roman nobility to have appointed over them some trustworthy servant who took them in charge. The boys were entirely under these servants; and thus had their spirits broken in, and their vivacity restrained. As a rule these pedagogues were very stern and strict–they used the rod freely, not to say cruelly, and the condition of the boys was sometimes no better than slavery. The boys (as it was supposed to be for their good) were kept in perpetual fear. Their recreations were restricted; even their walks were under the surveillance of the grim pedagogue. They were sternly held in check in all points, and were thus disciplined for the battle of life. Now Paul, taking up this thought, says the law was our pedagogue, our guardian, our custodian, ruler, tutor, governor, until Christ came. (C. H. Spurgeon.)

The Church to be governed by principle, not rigid law

A Christian Church, from the necessity of the case, is based on faith–that is, on principle; it represents by its existence the definitive triumph of believing principle over mere outward Jewish rule; it does not discard rule, far from it, but it provides for the good that is to be achieved by rule, by insisting always on the higher influence of principle; and thus the true direction of the Churchs life would seem to be adherence to principle, combined with freedom as to all that touches mere outward rule. In modern language, Holy Scripture, the three great Creeds which guard it, the essential conditions of the means of grace–that is, the governing and informing principles of the Churchs life,–should all of them be defended to the very last extremity; but as to matters of mere ceremonial and the like, there should be as much freedom as is compatible with the very elementary requirements of order. Where the faith is held sincerely, the rules of outward observance should be largely left to take care of themselves; the margin of liberty within which devotional feeling at very different stages of its growth finds its congenial expression, should be as wide as possible. (Canon Liddon.)

The gentleness of Christs dominion

Moses and the law is a rigid and severe schoolmaster, who by whips and threats requires a hard lesson of his scholars, whether able to learn it or not; but Christ and the gospel is a mild and gentle teacher, who by sweet promises and good rewards, invite their scholars to duty, and guide and help them to do what of themselves they cannot do; by which means they love both their Master and their lessons, and rejoice when it is nearest to them to direct them in their studies. (W. Burkitt.)

Relation of the law to the gospel

I. The whole law of god is one. Gods law is the declaration of His will; and Gods perfect will never changes, and, therefore, Gods law is like Himself–the same yesterday, to-day, and for ever. It is essentially impossible that one part of Gods law should ever contradict any other part; from beginning to end it is one. But this law may develop itself by successive stages, and manifest itself in different ways in these different stages. Under ground, among the rocks, among the subterranean springs, the tree develops in the form of roots. Above ground, we find the tree developing in the form of trunk. We go higher, and our tree is branches, and then leaves, and blossoms, and fruit. The tree is one. Fruit and root are the extremes of one perfect organism; yet what a difference between them. So Gods law is one, whether we see it in its lower or higher stage.

II. We are to distinguish between the substance and the form of the law. The Divine thought is the essential thing; not the mere formal precept or symbol by which it was conveyed. So, while the former must ever be retained, the latter may drop off; just as the tree drops off in the branches the mould which clings about the roots, and drops off in the blossom and fruit the bark of the trunk and branches, while root and trunk and branch and blossom yet continue to be one tree. (Marvin R. Vincent, D. D.)

Rule yields to principle

Here is a boy who begins to study mathematics. The teacher gives him specific rules. Do thus, and you will add numbers. Do so, and you will subtract or multiply. It is not a matter of principles or laws at all. The boy has, and can have, no conception of the great fundamental laws of numbers and of their relations. He takes his arithmetic and studies the rule for decimals or long division, and does his sums by the process laid down in the rule. But one day, the boy comes to the teacher with his sum worked out by a process not laid down in his arithmetic. He has thought it out by a process of his own. The rules he has been practising have led him unconsciously up to certain great mathematical principles which are not confined in their working out to the one little rule of the arithmetic, but are capable of a variety of expressions. Is the teacher angry because the sum was not done by the rule? Is he not rather delighted? He sees, in the lads overstepping the rule, the very result at which he has been aiming. All the rules were directed to bring about this grasp of principles which he has obtained. Henceforth he will not be bound by the rules, but will he therefore violate the great laws of mathematics? Will he not be as much under law as ever, yea, under the same law, when he measures the orbits of planets or weighs suns, as when he repeated the multiplication table, or cast up the little columns in simple addition? So it is in moral development. You want to teach a child the great principle of order. You begin with specific rules. You must put your books in such a place, and your hat in such a place. You must study such and such hours. You may amuse yourself at such times. The time finally comes when all thess rules drop off of themselves. They are no longer needed. He has got hold of the great truth of order, and its obligation has its grip upon him, and that was all that the rules were intended for. That being reached, he may be orderly and systematic in his own way. The great point is that, however his way may differ from that prescribed by his old rules, he is still under law, and under the same law–the law of order. So then, when Gods law, the pedagogue, the law of commandments, precepts, prohibitions, hands a man over to Christ, it introduces him to a life which is just as much under the power of law and of the same law as ever. Law is not abolished, but whereas formerly the law was applied to the man from without, it now begins to work from within the man. In other words, he lives by the law of God written upon his conscience and wrought into his life. He is a law unto himself. He is no longer a moral schoolboy, but a man in Christ Jesus. The law of precepts has been silently preparing the man to be kindled and quickened into life by contact with Christs life. You know how, at the sacred season in Rome, the workmen are engaged for clays in arranging the lines of lamps over the dome and portico of St. Peters; and when at last the hour strikes, on a sudden the whole gigantic structure bursts into flame. Just so law draws the line of obedience and duty; but these, however symmetrical and sharp, are dead and cold until they feel Christs touch; then the life kindles and glows. The lines of law are all irradiated. (Marvin R. Vincent, D. D.)

Christ supersedes the law

If the law is done away, we are never henceforth under its tyranny, but are under Christ, and live in all security and joy, through Him who now reigns in us mildly and graciously by His spirit. Therefore, if we could rightly apprehend Christ, the dear Saviour, this severe and wrathful schoolmaster would not dare to touch a hair of our heads. From this it follows that believers, as concerns the conscience, are by all means free from the law; on this account the schoolmaster should not rule therein, i.e., he should not affright, threaten, or take the conscience captive, and though he should undertake it, the conscience should not care for it, but should behold Christ on the cross, who through His death had freed us from the law and all its terrors. Nevertheless there is sin still remaining in the saints, whereby their conscience is accused and plagued. Yet Christ helps it up again through His daily, yea, continual drawing near. (Luther.)

The law a schoolmaster

The law taught, as a schoolmaster teaches, the elements of true religion and right morals. It therefore prepared men for Christianity, or was the introduction to Christianity, which supposes and embraces those elements, though it carries them forward into further and higher developments, and surrounds them with more mature and heavenly sanctions than were before revealed; just as the schoolmaster prepares a pupil by the studies of the school-room, for the studies and pursuits of life, and furnishes the knowledge which is absolutely necessary for the attainment of the superior knowledge of future years, and which can never be entirely dispensed with. The pupil is not required to remain in the school-room, amenable to all the minor regulations of the school-room, and indeed would not be justified in doing so, when the time has come for his entrance upon the advanced discipline and broader duties and prospects of maturity and the world; and yet he must never slight or forget the real knowledge and true habits which have been instilled and formed within those humbler precincts, for these are always available and useful, and are indeed indispensable to his progress. The law was our schoolmaster to bring us unto Christ. It could not have brought us unto Christ, unless it had taught us much that is intrinsically and permanently true and good, and of Divine authority. Such aa introduction could have been made by no unworthy or unauthorized hand. Holiness unto the Lord must have been engraved upon the forehead of that instructor, who performed the high office of leading us into the presence of the Son of God. Let us see how this truth may be confirmed. Let us refer to what may be gathered of the mind of Jesus on this subject. First and chiefly, he always speaks of the God by whose commission Moses gave the law to the Israelites, aa his own God and Father, by whom he was sanctified and sent into the world. It is impossible for any man of common-sense and a clear and unprejudiced head, who shall read the Old Testament and then proceed to read the New, to entertain any other idea than that the Supreme Being and Almighty God of the one is the Supreme Being and Almighty God of the other, though more chiefly revealed and brought nearer to us in the second than in the first. Jesus refers also to the patriarchs and prophets of the former dispensation not as strangers, or belonging to a hostile order or communion, but as His own predecessors and forerunners, who had seen His day and intimated His coming, and He often repeats and applies their sayings and predictions. The proposition is further confirmed by a view of those characters of the law which are evidently intrinsic and unchangeable. The primary truth of the Unity of God is declared in it with a distinctness and a grandeur which no words and no imagination can surpass. The Hear, O Israel! the Lord our God is one Lord, is a proclamation which sounds, as with trumpet voice, from one dispensation to the other, from the Tabernacle and the Temple to the Church, and from the Church into the depths of time. Those infinite attributes of God, which, when proposed to the mind, are in perfect conformity with the best exercises of our reason, and are yet so high that our highest reason cannot reach or measure them, are revealed in the law with all the clearness which human language can command, and with an original sublimity which is to be found nowhere else. As in the doctrinal, so in the ethical part of the law, there is a height and a purity which might fitly introduce the moral system of the gospel, and be blended and incorporated with it, because it is in unison with it, and speaks of a common origin. The ten commandments, which are the condensation of this part of the law, are unquestionably permanent and irreversible. Finally, two important inferences must be kept in mind.

1. That we should never take one part of the conclusion, when the apostle is pressing it upon our attention with all his innate zeal, without a reference to the other part, which, under different circumstances, he would have pressed as warmly, and which was never really absent from his mind. He must be interpreted by himself; what he says at one time compared with what he says at another.

2. We ourselves are bound to pay becoming reverence to that ancient law, whose office it was to introduce men to the knowledge and enjoyment of gospel privileges and blessings. There is little danger at present of our falling back under the yoke against which St. Paul warns his converts; but there is some danger of our erring on the opposite side, and treating the law, and the books which contain it, with an undeserved and unbecoming irreverence. Let us remember that the law was a schoolmaster to bring us to Christ, and that, as such, its instructions were necessary and are still to be revered. Having entered a higher institution, we do not go back to school; but having been well taught in those elements which prepared us for that institution, we will remember the teacher with respect and gratitude. While the Saviour of men appears before us in all his transfigured glory, though we shall give to His person our longest and intensest regards, we shall not shut our eyes to the venerable forms of Moses, and Elias, who appear with Him and talk with Him. (F. W. P. Greenwood, D. D.)

After that faith is come, Christian freedom and sonship

I. To prove to ourselves that we have faith we must prove that we need not the law;

II. To prove that emancipation and liberty we must prove that we are the sons of God.

III. To prove that engrafting and adoption we must prove that we have put on Christ.

IV. To prove that apparelling our proof is that we are baptized into Him. (Doune.)

The superiority of Christianity to Judaism

It was the happiness of the Jews to have had the law, but it is ours not to need it; they had the benefit of a guide to direct them, but we are at our journeys end; they had a schoolmaster to lead them to Christ, but we have proceeded so far as that we are in possession of Christ. The law of Moses binds us not at all as it is His law; whatsoever binds a Christian in that law would have bound Him though there had been no law given to Moses. (John Donne, D. D.)

The law our schoolmaster

I. The Holy Ghost employs the law as a servant. Salvation never came by the law, never could have come by the law, never can come by the law, through any obedience that fallen man can render either felts letter or its spirit. The law is the map; it is not the country. The law is the model; it is not the substance. The law is the picture; it is not the person. The law prophesies, prefigures, presents the fulness of the salvation which is wrought by Jesus Christ as the ground of the believers security and the warrant of his faith. But under the ministry of the Holy Ghost another illustration is introduced, and the apostle says the law is the schoolmaster, or, to Anglicise the Greek word, is the pedagogue, to bring us unto Christ. And the parts of the figure are easily comprehended. The Holy Ghost is the parent of the soul; the law is the tutor to whose instruction it is committed until the time of majority, when all the tutors and governors of minority disappear, and the privileges of heirship in Christ become the possession and the enjoyment of those who have passed from the tutors care. Now, the Spirit of God presents to us the law of God under this simile. Go where the sinner will, before he has come to the full age of faith, the law of God is his shadow. Oh I that men would remember this. They do not in darkness escape Gods ever present detection; they do not by double dealing evade the inspection of Him who has established the law for their discipline to bring them unto Christ. Wherever the man goes before he has learned the fulness of his salvation in Jesus, he must be looking about him for the presence of the schoolmaster. When the law of God takes hold of a man, and he realizes his obligation under its commandment and his subjection to its penalty, then, of course, pleasures cease for him, for the presence of the schoolmaster destroys every circumstance of peace and enjoyment. Does he go to a place of frivolous amusement? The law of God whispers to his conscience, What if you should die here? Does he go to his pillow and seek relief from remorse? He lays his head upon it without possible quietness, while the law of God recounts to him the condemnation he has justly deserved for every impurity of thought and defection in act. Does he go to church, and is the minister of God expounding the gospel of Gods grace? Next to him in the pew sits the law of God, his inseparable companion, who tells him, in the midst of promises, These are not for you. In the midst of all the descriptions of the pleasures of the saint, You have no part in these. And when the dark cloud of Divine indignation which brings out in relief the grace of Jesus Christ rises before him, the awful menace of the law tells him, The storm will burst upon you, the condemnation of God will catch you, hell is yawning to receive you. Oh! the horrors of this pedagogue-companion under whose discipline men are so ready to live. Now let us, having looked at their inseparable companionship, overtake them in their walk and listen to some of their conversation. The refrain of all that the law says is, Do. Do this and thou shalt live. And to this constant exhortation, which stirs up all the bitterness of the heart, there is a succession of apologies and pleas presented, which, for the time, will silence the voice of conscience, but which the law brushes away with ridicule as of offering chaff for wheat, brass for gold, currency for coin. Do this and thou shalt live. I want to do it. It is not wanting to do; it is doing, saith the law. I will try to obey. That will not suffice. It is not trying; it is obeying. I have obeyed a great many of the commandments. I am reputed to be obedient. I think I have almost reached it. Almost is not enough, child; altogether thou must do it. Not a single defect must there be in either spirit or letter of prohibition or command. Oh, what a multitude of apologies does the pedagogue have to hear! I am quite as good as those about me. Thou hast nothing to do with another; Cursed is every one that continueth not in all things which are written in the book of the law to do them. Yes, but I am ready to believe in Christ after I have done all I can. Christ cannot help thee; as long as thou art under age thou must be under the law and thou must do all. When thou hast become of majority, then my office is at an end, and is passed away. Well, I am praying for help to obey the commandment. There will no help come to thee until thou dost come of age, child, and dost trust completely in Him who is the Saviour of the world. Thou canst never compound and commingle and amalgamate the law and the gospel. The illustration might be indefinitely continued to cover all the possible pretexts of sinners before the law of God. But the whole story is told in this one statement, that the law of God never smiles upon a sinner. This schoolmaster always frowns. There is no pity in the law; there is no mercy under its ministration. The one office of the pedagogue was to drag the boy down. The one office of Gods law, as the spirit employs it, is to humble every proud thought, every high look, every personal ambition and determination, until the man is willing to be a beggar and be saved by the blood of the Crucified One.

II. The errand which is entrusted to this pedagogue. The law was our schoolmaster to bring us to Christ. The original reads, The law is our schoolmaster unto Christ. When we reach Christ, then is the vocation of the schoolmaster at an end. It convinces men that they need Christ–that they need a free salvation. Christ has fulfilled the law. His obedience was perfect. Now we want to be justified by faith through His righteousness.

III. The sign that the law has discharged his commission. Our boys come of age at twenty-one years. Under the Greek code, the child came of age at thirteen and a half years. And I know some boys in our congregation that it would greatly delight if that were the rule in America. We have very few children nowadays. They are all men and women. Under the Roman law, majority was not attained until twenty-five years, but when the day was reached at which the child, by the custom of the land and the constitution of the Government, was pronounced a man, he could laugh at the school-master, and his office had passed away. Up to that hour he was imperious. Now he was impertinent. Up to that day his sharpness of examination was only the fulfilment of the duty he had assumed. After that day, to assume any such relation to the man, was to bring himself under the law which would condemn him utterly. So, saith the apostle, when faith is come, when the child has passed up toward full majority by trusting in Jesus Christ, then the schoolmaster has gone, the believer is freed from the law as a discipline. Oh I dear friend, this is the mountain top from which we view the land of promise. This is the place of privilege to which every child of God is permitted to attain. We are not under the law, says the apostle, we are under grace. But the sign that this majority has been reached is the transference of the soul from the discipline of precepts to that of principles, which the apostle calls the law written on the fleshly tables of the heart. We are not free from this law. It never passes away; but now we delight in the law of God. There is no fear now as we remember the old commandments. (S. H. Tyng.)

Fuente: Biblical Illustrator Edited by Joseph S. Exell

Verse 24. The law was our schoolmaster] The law was our pedagogue unto Christ. The , pedagogue, is not the schoolmaster, but the servant who had the care of the children to lead them to and bring them back from school, and had the care of them out of school hours. Thus the law did not teach us the living, saving knowledge; but, by its rites and ceremonies, and especially by its sacrifices, it directed us to Christ, that we might be justified by faith. This is a beautiful metaphor, and highly illustrative of the apostle’s doctrine. See Clarke on Ro 10:4, where this figure is farther explained.

Fuente: Adam Clarke’s Commentary and Critical Notes on the Bible

The law, both the law contained in ordinances and the moral law,

was our schoolmaster; serving us in the same stead that a schoolmaster in a school doth, who only fitteth children for higher degrees of learning at universities.

To bring us unto Christ: the ceremonial law showed us Christ in all his types and sacrifices; the moral law showed us the absolute need of a Mediator, as it showed us sin, accused and condemned us for it; and it showed us no help either for the guilt of sin contracted, or against the power of it.

That we might be justified by faith; so that Gods end in giving us the law was, that we might be fitted for Christ, and obtain justification by believing in him.

Fuente: English Annotations on the Holy Bible by Matthew Poole

24. “So that the lawhath been (that is, hath turned out to be) ourschoolmaster (or “tutor,” literally, “pedagogue”:this term, among the Greeks, meant a faithful servant entrusted withthe care of the boy from childhood to puberty, to keep him from evil,physical and moral, and accompany him to his amusements and studies)to guide us unto Christ,” with whom we are no longer “shutup” in bondage, but are freemen. “Children”(literally, infants) need such tutoring (Ga4:3).

might berather, “thatwe may be justified by faith”; which we could not be tillChrist, the object of faith, had come. Meanwhile the law, byoutwardly checking the sinful propensity which was constantly givingfresh proof of its refractorinessas thus the consciousness of thepower of the sinful principle became more vivid, and hence the senseof need both of forgiveness of sin and freedom from its bondage wasawakenedthe law became a “schoolmaster to guide us untoChrist” [NEANDER].The moral law shows us what we ought to do, and so we learnour inability to do it. In the ceremonial law we seek, byanimal sacrifices, to answer for our not having done it, but finddead victims no satisfaction for the sins of living men, and thatoutward purifying will not cleanse the soul; and that therefore weneed an infinitely better Sacrifice, the antitype of all the legalsacrifices. Thus delivered up to the judicial law, we see howawful is the doom we deserve: thus the law at last leads us toChrist, with whom we find righteousness and peace. “Sin, sin!is the word heard again and again in the Old Testament. Had it notthere for centuries rung in the ear, and fastened on the conscience,the joyful sound, “grace for grace,” would not have beenthe watchword of the New Testament. This was the end of the wholesystem of sacrifices” [THOLUCK].

Fuente: Jamieson, Fausset and Brown’s Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible

Wherefore the law was our schoolmaster unto Christ,…. So the words should be read, as they are by the Syriac and Ethiopic versions; for the words “to bring us” are a supplement of our translators, and have nothing to answer to them in the original; and the sense of the passage is, that the law performed this office of a schoolmaster until the coming of Christ; which shows that till that time the church was in its minority, that the Jews were but children in knowledge and understanding, and therefore stood in need, and were under the care of a schoolmaster, the law, by which the whole Mosaic administration is designed. They were taught by the moral law, the letter, the writing on the two tables, with other statutes and judgments, their duty to God and men, what is to be done and to be avoided, what is righteousness and what is not, the nature of sin, its demerit and consequences; but these gave them no instructions about a Saviour, and life and righteousness by him. The ceremonial law gave them some hints of the Gospel scheme, and the way of salvation by Christ, but in a manner suited to their estate of childhood; by sights and shows, by types and figures, by rites and ceremonies, by shadows and sacrifices; it taught them by divers washings the pollution of their nature, their need of the blood of Christ to cleanse from all sin; by circumcision, the necessity of regeneration, and the internal circumcision of the heart; by the passover, the daily sacrifice and other offerings, the doctrines of redemption, satisfaction, and atonement; and by the brazen serpent, the necessity of looking to Christ for life and salvation, and by various other things in that branch of the legal economy: but besides the instruction the law gave, it made use of discipline as a schoolmaster does; it kept a strict eye and hand over them, and them close to the performance of their duty; and restrained them from many things their inclinations led them to, threatening them with death in case of disobedience, and inflicting its penalties on delinquents; hence they that were under its discipline, were through fear of death it threatened them with, all their time subject to bondage: even the ceremonial law had something awful and tremendous in it; every beast that was slain in sacrifice was not only an instruction to them that they deserved to die as that creature did; but carried in it a tacit acknowledgment and confession of their own guilt; and the whole was an handwriting of ordinances against them. Moreover, the law being called a schoolmaster, shows that the use of it was but temporary, and its duration but for a time; children are not always to be under, nor designed to be always under a schoolmaster, no longer than till they are come to a proper age for greater business and higher exercises of life; so the law was to continue, and did continue, to be of this use and service to the Jewish church during its minority, until Christ came, the substance of all it taught and directed to: both the Jerusalem Targum and that of Jonathan ben Uzziel, on Nu 11:12 use the very Greek word the apostle does here, concerning Moses, rendering the words, as a “pedagogue” or “schoolmaster” bears a sucking child into the land, c.

That we might be justified by faith by Christ the object of faith, by his righteousness, which faith looks unto and receives, and not by the law and the works of it; the people of the Jews were in such a state under the law, and the law of that use unto them before the coming of Christ, as above represented, that it might be made manifest, be a clear point, and out of all dispute, that there is no such thing as justification by the law; for how could ever such a blessing be expected from it, when men were kept under it as under a military guard; when they were shut up in it as in a prison, and were treated by it as malefactors, convicted and condemned; and when they were under the discipline of it, as a rigid and severe schoolmaster? this being their case till Christ came, when it ceased to be all this to them, he being the end of it for righteousness, it became a thing self-evident, that justification is only by him and his righteousness, and so the end here mentioned was answered.

Fuente: John Gill’s Exposition of the Entire Bible

Our tutor unto Christ ( ). See 1Co 4:15 for the only other N.T. example of this old and common word for the slave employed in Greek and Roman families of the better class in charge of the boy from about six to sixteen. The paedagogue watched his behaviour at home and attended him when he went away from home as to school. Christ is our Schoolmaster and the law as paedagogue kept watch over us till we came to Christ.

That we might be justified by faith ( ). This is the ultimate purpose of the law as paedagogue.

Now that faith is come ( ). Genitive absolute, “the faith (the time of the faith spoken of in verse 23) having come.”

Under a tutor ( ). The pedagogue is dismissed. We are in the school of the Master.

Fuente: Robertson’s Word Pictures in the New Testament

Wherefore [] . Better, so that. Theological consequence of the previous statements.

Our schoolmaster [ ] . Our. Paul speaks as a Jew of Jews especially. Schoolmaster [ ] is an error. The word means an overseer or guardian. See on 1Co 9:15. Tutor (Rev.) is defensible on the ground of etymology, tueri to look upon, thence to guard. In civil law a tutor is a person legally appointed for the care of the person and property ===Gal4

CHAPTER IV

The last words of chapter iii, “heirs according to the promise,” are now further discussed. It is shown that the capability of heirship, which was first conferred through Christ, could not enter earlier into the history of mankind, because mankind was still in its minority; and its majority, its sonship, was first entered upon through Christ. The way of the law was not, as the Jews supposed, a direct way to the fulfillment of the divine promise. At the same time, it did not utterly lead away from the true goal. It was a roundabout way to it. Sabatier (l’ Apotre Paul) observes : “The law is neither absolutely identical with the promise, nor absolutely opposed to it. It is not the negation of the promise, but is distinct from it and subordinate to it. Its final purpose lies in the promise itself. It is an essential but transitional element in the historical development of humanity. It must disappear on attaining its goal. ‘Christ is the end of the law. ‘” But why was this way necessary? Why did not God open the way of faith leading to the inheritance of the promise immediately after the promise was given? The answer to this was indicated in Gal 3:24 – 26. It is now given more fully.

Fuente: Vincent’s Word Studies in the New Testament

1) “Wherefore the law was our schoolmaster to bring us,” (hoste ho nomos paidagogos hemon gegonen) “So as a trainer of us the law has become,” as a school director, master, pedagogue, one that leads, chastens, prods, and instructs the immature, as giving direction to the young child, Heb 9:9-10; Heb 9:13-14.

2) “Unto Christ,” (eis Christon) “up to, unto, to point us unto, in the direction of and up to Jesus Christ,” as the promised Redeemer, Act 2:16; Rom 10:4; Col 2:17.

3) “That we might be justified by faith,” (hina ek pisteos dikaiothomen) “in order that we might be justified out of faith,” the source of faith, not out of the deeds of the law, Act 13:38-39; Rom 4:5; Rom 5:1. This justification was not by media of rites and ceremonies of the law, nor is it obtained or retained by media of or thru ceremonies of baptism and the Lord’s Super thru the church, but by faith in Jesus Christ, Gal 3:26; Eph 2:8-9; 1Jn 5:1.

RELATION 0F LAW AND THE GOSPEL

You never saw a woman sewing without a needle. She would come but poor speed if she only sewed with the thread. So, I think, when we’re dealing with sinners, we maun aye put in the needle of the law first; for the fact is they are sleepin’ sound, and they need to be awakened up wi’ something sharp. But when we’ve got the needle o’ the law fairly in, we may draw as lang a thread as you like o’ Gospel consolation after it.

-Flockhart

Fuente: Garner-Howes Baptist Commentary

24. Wherefore the law was our schoolmaster This is the second comparison, which still more clearly expresses Paul’s design. A schoolmaster is not appointed for the whole life, but only for childhood, as the etymology of the Greek word παιδαγωγός implies. (63) Besides, in training a child, the object is to prepare him, by the instructions of childhood, for maturer years. The comparison applies in both respects to the law, for its authority was limited to a particular age, and its whole object was to prepare its scholars in such a manner, that, when its elementary instructions were closed, they might make progress worthy of manhood. And so he adds, that it was our schoolmaster ( εἰς Χριστὸν) unto Christ. The grammarian, when he has trained a boy, delivers him into the hands of another, who conducts him through the higher branches of a finished education. In like manner, the law was the grammar of theology, which, after carrying its scholars a short way, handed them over to faith to be completed. Thus, Paul compares the Jews to children, and us to advanced youth.

But a question arises, what was the instruction or education of this schoolmaster? First, the law, by displaying the justice of God, convinced them that in themselves they were unrighteous; for in the commandments of God, as in a mirror, they might see how far they were distant from true righteousness. They were thus reminded that righteousness must be sought in some other quarter. The promises of the law served the same purpose, and might lead to such reflections as these: “If you cannot obtain life by works but by fulfilling the law, some new and different method must be sought. Your weakness will never allow you to ascend so high; nay, though you desire and strive ever so much, you will fall far short of the object.” The threatenings, on the other hand, pressed and entreated them to seek refuge from the wrath and curse of God, and gave them no rest till they were constrained to seek the grace of Christ.

Such too, was the tendency of all the ceremonies; for what end did sacrifices and washings serve but to keep the mind continually fixed on pollution and condemnation? When a man’s uncleanness is placed before his eyes, when the unoffending animal is held forth as the image of his own death, how can he indulge in sleep? How can he but be roused to the earnest cry for deliverance? Beyond all doubt, ceremonies accomplished their object, not merely by alarming and humbling the conscience, but by exciting them to the faith of the coming Redeemer. In the imposing services of the Mosaic ritual, every thing that was presented to the eye bore an impress of Christ. The law, in short, was nothing else than an immense variety of exercises, in which the worshippers were led by the hand to Christ.

That we might be justified by faith. He has already said that the law is not perfect, when he compared it to the training of childhood; but it would make men perfect if it bestowed upon them righteousness. What remains but that faith shall take its place? And so it does, when we, who are destitute of a righteousness of our own, are clothed by it with the righteousness of Christ. Thus is the saying accomplished, “he hath filled the hungry with good things.” (Luk 1:53.)

(63) “As the law was before compared to a jailer, so it is here likened to a παιδαγωγός, by which term is not to be understood a schoolmaster, (for that would have been διδάσκαλος,) but the paedagous or person (usually a freedman or slave) who conducted children to and from school, attended them out of school hours, formed their manners, superintended their moral conduct, and in various respects prepared them for the διδάσκαλος.” — Bloomfield. Our author’s observations on παιδαγωγός, in another passage, have brought out the full meaning of this word, and the classical authorities for the use of it, in the translator’s notes. — Calvin on the Corinthians, vol. 1, p. 169. — Ed

Fuente: Calvin’s Complete Commentary

(24) The law was our schoolmaster.Not quite a satisfactory translation; yet it is difficult to suggest a better. The Greek word is that from which is derived the English pedagogue. Originally it meant the slave who was placed in charge of a child, and whose duty it was to conduct it to school. The idea is that of moral rather than of intellectual discipline. The care of the pedagogue ceased where that of the school-master began, but it was he who had more especially to form the character of the child. Horace notes as a peculiar advantage of his own that his father himself had taken the place of pedagogue to him (Sat. i. 6, 81, 82).

To bring us unto Christ.The words to bring us, it will be seen, are supplied. They may be retained, provided that the metaphor is not pressed to the extent of supposing that Christ represents the schoolmaster proper to whom the child is led by the pedagogue slave. The work of Christ as a Teacher is not what the Apostle has in mind. It is rather a higher kind of guardianship, which is to succeed that of the Law, and to which the Law hands over its pupil. Once brought within the guardianship of Christ, and so made a member of the Messianic kingdom, the Christian is justified by faith, he receives an amnesty for his past sins, and is accounted righteous before God. (See Epistle to the Romans, Excursus E: On the Doctrine of Justification by Faith and Imputed Righteousness.)

Fuente: Ellicott’s Commentary for English Readers (Old and New Testaments)

24. Wherefore Rather, so that. In strict accordance with the above image of a fortress is the image next to be introduced a tutor.

Our schoolmaster Rather, our private tutor or monitor. A boy was anciently placed under care of an elder person, perhaps a cultured slave, to attend him, and guard his manners and morals.

Unto Christ As the monitor brings the boy to a well-mannered manhood, so the law brings us to justification by faith through Christ. The monitor is not represented as bringing us to Christ’s school, but into full emancipation, as of adulthood and freedom.

Fuente: Whedon’s Commentary on the Old and New Testaments

Gal 3:24. Our school-master The original does not signify a school-master, but “one who heads or conducts children to school.”The ancients generally employed a person for this purpose; and if the Apostle be supposed to allude to this custom, his reasoning will appear exceedingly plain and conclusive. See the next verse, and on Rom 10:4 and the Introduction to my Commentary on the Old Testament.

Fuente: Commentary on the Holy Bible by Thomas Coke

Gal 3:24 . Accordingly the law has become our paedagogue unto Christ . As a paedagogue (see on 1Co 4:15 ) has his wards in guidance and training for the aim of their future majority, so the law has taken us into a guidance and training, of which Christ was the aim, that is, of which the aim was that we in due time should no longer be under the law, but should belong to Christ. This munus paedagogicum , however, resulting from Gal 3:23 , did not consist in the restriction of sin , [168] or in the circumstance that the law “ ab inhonestis minarum asperitate deterreret ” (Winer, and most expositors, including de Wette, Baur, Hofmann, Reithmayr, but not Usteri, Hilgenfeld, Wieseler), views decidedly inconsistent with the aim expressed in Gal 3:19 , and with the tenor of Gal 3:23 , which by no means expresses the idea of preparatory improvement; but it consisted in this, that the law prepared those belonging to it for the future reception of Christian salvation (justification by faith) in such a manner that, by virtue of the principle of sin which it excited, it continually brought about and promoted transgressions (Gal 3:19 ; Rom 7:5 ff.), thereby held the people in moral bondage (in the , Gal 3:23 ), and by producing at the same time the acknowledgment of sin (Rom 3:20 ) powerfully brought home to the heart (Rom 7:24 ) the sense of guilt and of the need of redemption from the divine wrath (Rom 4:15 ), a redemption which, with our natural moral impotence, was not possible by means of the law itself (Rom 3:19 f., Rom 8:3 ). Luther appropriately remarks: “Lex enim ad gratiam praeparat, dum peccatum revelat et auget, humilians superbos ad auxilium Christi desiderandum.” See also Weiss, bibl. Theol . p. 287 f.; Holsten, z. Evang. d. Paul. u. Petr . p. 315 f. Under this paedagogal discipline man finally cries out: , Rom 7:24 .

] not usque ad Christum (Castalio, J. Cappellus, Morus, Rosenmller, Rckert, Matthias), but designating the end aimed at, as is shown by . .; comp. Gal 3:23 . Chrysostom and his successors (see Suicer, Thes . II. pp. 421, 544), Erasmus, Zeger, Elsner, and others, refer to the idea that the law , , , just as the paedagogi had to conduct the boys to the schools and gymnasia (Plat. Lys . p. 208 C; Dem. 313. 12; Ael V. H . iii. 21). But this introduces the idea of Christ as a teacher , which is foreign to the passage; He is conceived of as reconciler ( . .).

.] is the divine destination , which the paedagogic function of the law was to fulfil in those who were subject to it. The emphatic ( by faith , not by the law) shows how erroneously the paedagogic efficacy of the law is referred to the restriction of sin.

[168] Comp. Liban. D . xxv. p. 576 C: , . Comp. also Simplic. Epict . 10, p. 116, ed. Schweigh.; and see Grotius on our passage.

Fuente: Heinrich August Wilhelm Meyer’s New Testament Commentary

24 Wherefore the law was our schoolmaster to bring us unto Christ, that we might be justified by faith.

Ver. 24. The law was our schoolmaster ] Such a one as that Livy and Florus speak of in Italy, who brought forth his scholars to Hannibal; and if he had not been more merciful than otherwise, they had all perished.

Fuente: John Trapp’s Complete Commentary (Old and New Testaments)

24 .] So that (taking up the condition in which the last verse left us, and adding to it the fact that we are the SONS of God, cf. , Gal 3:26 ) the Law has become (has turned out to be) our tutor (pedagogue, see below) unto (ethically; for ) Christ (the was a faithful slave, entrusted with the care of the boy from his tender years till puberty, to keep him from evil physical and moral, and accompany him to his amusements and studies. See Dict. of Gr. and Rom. Antt. sub voce. The E. V. ‘ schoolmaster ’ does not express the meaning fully: but it disturbs the sense less than those have done, who have selected one portion only of the pedagogue’s duty, and understood by it, ‘ the slave who leads a child to the house of the schoolmaster ’ ( , Thdrt.: so also Thl.: see Suicer, , b), thus making Christ the schoolmaster, which is inconsistent with the imagery. On the contrary, the whole schoolmaster’s work is included in the , and Christ represents the of the grown-up son, in which he is no longer guarded or shut up, but justified by faith, the act of a free man; and to Christ as a Teacher there is here no allusion), in order that by faith we might be justified (which could only be done when Christ had come): but (adversative) now that the faith (see above) has come, we are no longer under a tutor (pedagogue).

Fuente: Henry Alford’s Greek Testament

was = has become.

schoolmaster. Greek. paidagogos. This was a trust-worthy slave who had the guardianship of the boys of it family. See Cor. Gal 4:15.

Fuente: Companion Bible Notes, Appendices and Graphics

24.] So that (taking up the condition in which the last verse left us, and adding to it the fact that we are the SONS of God, cf. , Gal 3:26) the Law has become (has turned out to be) our tutor (pedagogue, see below) unto (ethically; for) Christ (the was a faithful slave, entrusted with the care of the boy from his tender years till puberty, to keep him from evil physical and moral, and accompany him to his amusements and studies. See Dict. of Gr. and Rom. Antt. sub voce. The E. V. schoolmaster does not express the meaning fully: but it disturbs the sense less than those have done, who have selected one portion only of the pedagogues duty, and understood by it, the slave who leads a child to the house of the schoolmaster ( , Thdrt.: so also Thl.: see Suicer, , b), thus making Christ the schoolmaster, which is inconsistent with the imagery. On the contrary, the whole schoolmasters work is included in the , and Christ represents the of the grown-up son, in which he is no longer guarded or shut up, but justified by faith, the act of a free man; and to Christ as a Teacher there is here no allusion), in order that by faith we might be justified (which could only be done when Christ had come): but (adversative) now that the faith (see above) has come, we are no longer under a tutor (pedagogue).

Fuente: The Greek Testament

Gal 3:24. , a schoolmaster) who has kept us under discipline, lest we should slip from his hands.-, infants [children], need such discipline, Gal 4:3. There is again a personification of the law.

Fuente: Gnomon of the New Testament

Gal 3:24

Gal 3:24

So that the law is become our tutor to bring us unto Christ, that we might be justified by faith.-So the law served as a tutor to train the Jews for Christ, that coming to him they might be justified, by faith in Jesus, and conform the life to the law of faith, given through Christ.

Fuente: Old and New Testaments Restoration Commentary

law

I. The law of Moses, Summary:

(1) The Mosaic Covenant was given to Israel in three parts: the commandments, expressing the righteous will of God Exo 20:1-26, the “judgments,” governing the social life of Israel Exo 21:1 to Exo 24:11, and the “ordinances,” governing the religious life of Israel; Exo 24:12; Exo 31:18.

(2) The commandments and ordinances were one complete and inseparable whole. When an Israelite sinned, he was held “blameless” if he brought the required offering Luk 1:6; Php 3:6.

(3) Law, as a method of the divine dealing with man, characterized the dispensation extending from the giving of the law to the death of Jesus Christ Gal 3:13; Gal 3:14; Gal 3:23; Gal 3:24.

(4) The attempt of legalistic teachers (e.g.) Act 15:1-31; Gal 2:1-5, to mingle law with grace as the divine method for this present dispensation of grace, brought out the true relation of the law to the Christian, viz.

II. The Christian doctrine of the law:

(1) Law is in contrast with grace. Under the latter God bestows the righteousness which, under law, He demanded Exo 19:5; Joh 1:17. (See Scofield “Rom 3:21”).; Rom 10:3-10; 1Co 1:30.

(2) The law is, in itself, holy, just, good, and spiritual Rom 7:12-14.

(3) Before the law the whole world is guilty, and the law is therefore of necessity a ministry of condemnation, death, and the divine curse Rom 3:19; 2Co 3:7-9; Gal 3:10.

For Another Point of View: See Topic 301242

Other Factors to Consider: See Topic 301187

(4) Christ bore the curse of the law, and redeemed the believer both from the curse and from the dominion of the law Gal 3:13; Gal 4:5-7.

(5) Law neither justifies a sinner nor sanctifies a believer Gal 2:16; Gal 3:2; Gal 3:3; Gal 3:11; Gal 3:12.

(6) The believer is both dead to the law and redeemed from it, so that he is “not under the law, but under grace” Rom 6:14; Rom 7:4; Gal 2:19; Gal 4:4-7; 1Ti 1:8; 1Ti 1:9.

(7) Under the new covenant of grace the principle of obedience to the divine will is inwrought Heb 10:6. So far is the life of the believer from the anarchy of self-will that he is “inlawed to Christ” 1Co 9:21 and the new “law of Christ”; Gal 6:2; 2Jn 1:5 is his delight; while, through the indwelling Spirit, the righteousness of the law is fulfilled in him; Rom 8:2-4; Gal 5:16-18. The commandments are used in the distinctively Christian Scriptures as an instruction in righteousness; 2Ti 3:16; Rom 13:8-10; Eph 6:1-3; 1Co 9:8; 1Co 9:9.

to bring us Omit “to bring us.”

unto up to, or until.

Fuente: Scofield Reference Bible Notes

the law: Gal 3:25, Gal 2:19, Gal 4:2, Gal 4:3, Mat 5:17, Mat 5:18, Act 13:38, Act 13:39, Rom 3:20-22, Rom 7:7-9, Rom 7:24, Rom 7:25, Rom 10:4, Col 2:17, Heb 7:18, Heb 7:19, Heb 9:8-16, Heb 10:1-14

justified: Gal 2:16, Act 13:39

Reciprocal: Mat 19:20 – All Joh 5:46 – had Joh 8:17 – also Rom 3:28 – General 1Co 6:11 – but ye are justified 2Co 3:13 – to the Gal 3:23 – faith came Gal 4:21 – ye that

Fuente: The Treasury of Scripture Knowledge

Gal 3:24. -So that the law has become our tutor (paedagogue) for Christ. Wycliffe has under-maister; schoolmaster is in Tyndale, Cranmer, and the Genevan; the Rheims has pedagogue; and the interpolated words to bring us are taken from the Genevan, Tyndale rendering unto the time of Christ. marks the conclusion from the preceding statements, and especially from . We are the children of God; and the law prior to the coming of faith acted toward us as our paedagogue, with all his vigorous discipline and vigilant superintendence. The paedagogue was not the or ,-non magister et pater (Jerome). The term, as its composition implies, is one qui puerum manu prehensum ducit . . . ad magistrum. The paedagogue was usually a slave selected for his fidelity, to whom was entrusted the complete supervision of the children of a family from their sixth or seventh year till they arrived at puberty. Under his charge they went to and from school-gymnasia; he accompanied them in their walks and recreations, as responsible for their personal safety; and he guarded them against evil society and immoral influences. Horace, Sat. lib. i. 6:81, 4. A paedagogue is accused of the opposite, Athenaeus, 7.279, Opera, vol. iii. p. 16, ed. Schweighaser. He was therefore obliged to maintain the rigid discipline which was commonly associated with the name. Not only were paedagogues called assidui and custodes, but their functions came to be associated with moroseness and imperious severity. Their countenance became proverbial for its sourness. It represents in the Jerusalem Targum the Hebrew , nursing father, of Num 11:12; and the Syriac renders it by , monitor. The apostle in 1Co 4:15 puts paedagogue in contrast with father. In the later days of Rome the young slave paedagogue was delicately trained, his office in the palace degenerated into that of a mere ornamental attendant on his imperial master, and naturally paedagogue was shortened into the modern page. The Rabbins took the word into their language, making it , and associated with it the additional idea of a closer superintendence, as in food, etc.

Thus the surveillance of a paedagogue carried with it the idea of a strictness bordering on severity, and of an inferior but responsible position. The law was in the place of a paedagogue to the Jews-hard, severe, unbending in its guardianship of them when they were in their minority,-it being implied in the illustration, however, that all the while they were children. The paedagogic function of the law was not in the repression of sins (De Wette, Baur); it was given for the sake of transgressions, to produce such convictions of guilt and helplessness as prepared for faith in Christ. Its types and ceremonial services conduced to the same result. The phrase is very naturally understood as meaning to Christ,-the paedagogue bringing the child to the Teacher. So the Greek fathers, with Erasmus, Elsner, etc. But this idea does not suit the imagery, for Christ is here not regarded at all as a Teacher, but rather as a Redeemer, as the following clause distinctly implies, as well as the commencing imagery of the next chapter. Nor is the temporal, usque ad (Morus, Rosenmller, Rckert, Bagge), but telic; it expresses the spiritual design of the previous paedagogy: it was for Christ, as its ultimate purpose. Winer, 49, a. The statement is therefore a virtual reply to the objection, Is the law against the promises of God? No, it is a paedagogue with a view to Christ, and to Christ the Seed were the promises made. The next clause explains the , or shows in what sense we ought to regard it-in order that we might be justified by or out of faith; , as in contrast to , having the emphasis. See under Gal 2:16, Gal 3:6. See Suicer on .

Fuente: Commentary on the Greek Text of Galatians, Ephesians, Colossians and Phillipians

Gal 3:24. Wherefore means the apostle is drawing a conclusion from the facts of the preceding verse, and it is stated in the form of an illustration. Schoolmaster is from PAIDAGOGOS, which occurs only three times in the Greek New Testament; twice in Paul’s present argument and once in 1Co 4:15, where it is rendered “instructors.” But neither of these English words is used in the same sense as they are today. The original word is defined by Thayer as, “a tutor,” and Robinson defines it, “a pedagogue.” Thayer furnishes some historical information on the subject that will be useful as follows: “A guide and guardian of boys. Among the Greeks and Romans the name was applied to trustworthy slaves who were charged with the duty of supervising the life and morals of boys belonging to the better class. The boys were not allowed so much as to step out of the house without them [were “shut up”–E. M. Z.] before arriving at the age of manhood.” The apostle likens the law of Moses to this guardian of the child, because it was given charge of the “children of the Abrahamic promise” until such time as the fully-empowered Schoolmaster (Christ) should come, who would take charge of the pupils and administer spiritual education under the curriculum of the faith.

Fuente: Combined Bible Commentary

Gal 3:24. So then the law has been our tutor unto Christ. This sentence expresses in a few words the true philosophy of the law in its relation to ChristTutor, literally pdagogue (leader of boys), one intrusted with the moral supervision and instruction of minors. In Greek and Roman families of rank the office of tutor was intrusted to a reliable slave who had to watch the children of his master in their plays, to keep them from excess and folly, to lead them to school, or instruct them himself in the elementary branches, and thus to train them for the freedom of youth and manhood. This pdagogic mission attaches not only to the law of Moses, but we may say to all laws, also to the moral law of nature written in the conscience of man. The discipline of law and authority is still the school of moral freedom, and reaches its proper end in self-government which is true freedom. The Greek fathers called philosophy the pdagogue of the Gentiles, which prepared them theoretically for Christianity, as the Mosaic law prepared the Jews practically.

The schoolmaster of the E. V. expresses only one element in the office of the law. Luthers version: Zuchtmeister, is better, because more comprehensive. It is still wider of the mark and inconsistent with the imagery of the context to make Christ the schoolmaster (the tutor to conduct us to the school of Christ). On the contrary the whole work of preparatory training belongs to the pdagogue, and Christ represents here the result of the educational process, i.e., the state of evangelical freedom and independent, self-governing manhood. Comp. Eph 4:13.

Fuente: A Popular Commentary on the New Testament

Gal 3:24-26. Wherefore the law was our schoolmaster That is, the instructer of the childhood of us Jews, or of the church of God, in its state of minority; see on Gal 4:3; to bring us unto Christ To train us up for him. And this it did, both by its precepts, which showed us the need we had of his atonement, and by its sacrifices, oblations, purifications, and other ceremonies, which all pointed us to him; that we might be justified by faith In him, and so might obtain the benefit of the promise. But after that faith is come The gospel dispensation being fully revealed, and the law of faith promulgated; we are no longer under that schoolmaster

The Mosaic law, but pass over into a more liberal and happy state. For ye Who have believed on Christ, with a faith working by love; are all Not merely the subjects and servants of God, your Lord and Master, but his children, by faith in Christ Jesus The sons and daughters of the Lord Almighty; yea, his heirs, and joint heirs with his beloved Son: and to you his commandments are not grievous.

Fuente: Joseph Bensons Commentary on the Old and New Testaments

So that the law is become our tutor to bring us unto Christ, that we might be justified by faith. [In the first of these two verses, Paul enlarges the thought of verse 22, fully describing those subjects of the law as prisoners incarcerated in a fortress, and awaiting the coming of a deliverer. The next image is distinct from that of a fortress, yet very similar to it; for the pedagogue or tutor was usually a slave, whose duty it was to take charge of a boy from his childhood to his majority, shield him from physical and moral evil, accompany him in all his amusement, and, as it were, keep him as a prisoner at large, lest he should in any way injure himself. Now, the law was such a tutor to bring those under his care to a state of development fit for the society and fellowship of Christ, the spiritual father.]

Fuente: McGarvey and Pendleton Commentaries (New Testament)

Verse 24

The law was our schoolmaster; that is, the law was only the means of preparatory training, by which the Jewish nation was led on to salvation by Christ.

Fuente: Abbott’s Illustrated New Testament

Wherefore the law was our schoolmaster [to bring us] unto Christ, that we might be justified by faith.

This term schoolmaster is also translated instructor in the Bible. It really just pictures the fact that anyone attempting to obey the law found how inadequate to the task they were – in short they knew they needed another way for they could not do it. The law informs them that Christ is needed.

The term is used of Roman slaves that were entrusted with the bringing up of boys in that culture. The boy was taught and mentored in all sorts of ways to bring him to manhood. The boy could not leave the house without his schoolmaster.

Again, Paul emphasizes the fact that it is not the law that can justify, but rather Christ by faith.

There are some today, mostly in the independent Baptist circles from my observation that are saying you can’t properly teach the gospel until you teach the law. This passage is partial basis for this teaching. I would agree to the fact that we need to get them lost – help them understand their position before God – but I don’t think we are required to teach the law. If you want to show the law (how impossible it is to keep) yes, go ahead, this will show them their lostness as well, but I personally feel that they only need to know they are lost and that Christ is the only answer available now or in the future.

The law was our schoolmaster or our teacher to bring us to Christ.

Fuente: Mr. D’s Notes on Selected New Testament Books by Stanley Derickson