Exegetical and Hermeneutical Commentary of Judges 8:23
And Gideon said unto them, I will not rule over you, neither shall my son rule over you: the LORD shall rule over you.
23. I will not rule over you ] But ch. 9 implies that Gideon did exercise some kind of supremacy, at any rate in his own district, and his sons claimed to inherit his position, Jdg 9:2. These words, then, either mean that Gideon seized the power, but rejected the title, of king; or they represent the view, which apparently came to the front in the closing years of the Northern Kingdom, that earthly kingship was inconsistent with the sovereignty of Jehovah; cf. 1Sa 8:7; 1Sa 10:19 ; 1Sa 12:12; 1Sa 12:17; 1Sa 12:19 (E source), Hos 13:10 f. The latter is the explanation most generally accepted.
Fuente: The Cambridge Bible for Schools and Colleges
Verse 23. The Lord shall rule over you] Few with such power at their command would have acted as Gideon. His speech calls them back to their first principles, and should have excited in them both shame and contrition. How different is this speech from that of Oliver Cromwell when the commons offered him the crown of England!
Fuente: Adam Clarke’s Commentary and Critical Notes on the Bible
I will not rule over you, to wit, as a king, which you desire.
The Lord shall rule over you, in a special manner, as he hath hitherto done, by judges, whom God did particularly appoint and direct, even by Urim and Thummim, and assist upon all occasions; whereas kings had a greater power, and only a general dependence upon God, as other kings had. Compare 1Sa 8:6,7.
Fuente: English Annotations on the Holy Bible by Matthew Poole
And Gideon said unto them, I will not rule over you,…. Not that he declined the government of them as a judge, to which he was raised of God, but as a king, for which he had no authority and call from God; the choice of a king belonging to him, and not to the people:
neither shall my son rule over you; which Abarbinel thinks he spake as a prophet, and under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit; for after his death neither Jether his eldest son, nor any of the rest of his legitimate sons, ruled over them; for they were all slain by Abimelech, the son of his concubine, who was made king:
the Lord shall rule over you; as he did; their government was a theocracy, which they would have changed, but Gideon would not agree to it.
Fuente: John Gill’s Exposition of the Entire Bible
(23) The Lord shall rule over you.Num. 23:21; Deu. 33:5; 1Sa. 6:12. Gideon refused the splendid temptation of an hereditary crown, though, in strict accordance with Divine guidance, he was willing to be their judge ( Shaphat, as in Jdg. 10:2-3; Jdg. 12:7, &c.). Cassel compares the remark of Washington when he accepted the Presidency, because he would obey the voice of the people. saying that no people could be more bound to acknowledge and adore the invisible hand which conducts the affairs of men than the people of the United States (Marshalls Life of Washington, 2:146). The day anticipated in Deu. 17:14-20 had not yet come. Up to this point we feel all the goodness of Gideon. There is a sweetness and nobleness mingled with his courage, something of the past greatness of Joshua, something of the future grace of David. He reminds us in some respects of Henry Y. of England, and Henry IV. of France.
Fuente: Ellicott’s Commentary for English Readers (Old and New Testaments)
23. The Lord shall rule over you Your king shall still be Jehovah, not Gideon. By choosing a Gideon or a Saul the nation would be choosing a human instead of a divine sovereign. The people were ever in danger of forgetting the Divine Author of all civil government, and especially so in times of popular excitement and enthusiasm, when the masses either seem, or assume to be, sovereign. At such times all should be reminded that there is a power higher than the civil ruler. It does not appear that Gideon, during the forty years of peace (Jdg 8:28) that followed this victory over Midian, performed any of the ordinary duties of a civil ruler. It is not said that he judged Israel at all, though the silence of the history must not be construed into evidence that he never did. He was raised up to deliver the nation from the yoke of Midian, and, having nobly accomplished that work, he retired to his native city and dwelt there till his death.
But whatever the form of a government whether it be a nation miraculously led and instructed, like Israel under Moses, Joshua, or the Judges, or a monarchy like that erected in the days of Saul, or modern empires or republics the Lord is still the Ruler. All civil governments must have their officers, and these may differ widely in their character and powers; but “the powers that be are ordained of God,” and the civil ruler is “the minister of God.” Rom 13:1-6. This is a doctrine of the Old Testament as well as of the New, and it is therefore the duty of all civil governments to know and acknowledge their dependence on the Supreme Ruler.
Fuente: Whedon’s Commentary on the Old and New Testaments
‘ And Gideon said to them, I will not rule over you, neither shall my son rule over you. Yahweh shall rule over you.’
There are good grounds for thinking that in fact this was a speech of acceptance couched in pious terms. He certainly proceeded to behave like a ruling prince (Jdg 8:27; Jdg 8:30) and the people expected his sons to succeed him (Jdg 9:2). But his stress was on the fact that their real ruler was Yahweh Who ruled over the whole covenant people. (In Canaan the word ‘king’ (melech) denoted a petty king over a city. It was thus not suitable to describe Yahweh). He did not want to replace the tribal covenant, and wanted the people to recognise that Yahweh was their King. But he was prepared to rule as Yahweh’s hereditary prince over this particular area.
Fuente: Commentary Series on the Bible by Peter Pett
By Gideon ‘ s answer, it evidently appears, that there was a spirit of idolatry in Israel: they desired, like the nations around, a king, thereby denying the government of God. If you consult these scriptures, they will serve to throw a light upon the subject: 1Sa 8:4-7 and 1Sa 12 .
Fuente: Hawker’s Poor Man’s Commentary (Old and New Testaments)
Jdg 8:23 And Gideon said unto them, I will not rule over you, neither shall my son rule over you: the LORD shall rule over you.
Ver. 23. I will not rule over you. ] Since I cannot without manifest wrong done to God. This modesty of his in refusing such an offer was very commendable; as it was afterwards in Alphonsus, King of Arragon, and Frederick, the Elector of Saxony, who might have been chosen emperors of Germany, but would not. Rodolphus, Duke of Suevia, was too forward to accept of the empire offered him by Pope Hildebrand; and all too late repented it. So was Silvester II, who for seven years’ enjoyment of the popedom, gave his soul to the devil.
Fuente: John Trapp’s Complete Commentary (Old and New Testaments)
I will: Jdg 2:18, Jdg 10:18, Jdg 11:9-11, Luk 22:24-27, 2Co 1:24, 1Pe 5:3
the Lord: 1Sa 8:6, 1Sa 8:7, 1Sa 10:19, 1Sa 12:12, Isa 33:22, Isa 63:19
Reciprocal: Jdg 9:8 – Reign 1Sa 8:1 – made his
Fuente: The Treasury of Scripture Knowledge
Jdg 8:23. I will not rule over you As a king. He rejected their offer, because he looked upon God as their king, who appointed what deputy he pleased to govern them; and because he considered this proposal as an effort, or at least as tending to alter that form of government which God had instituted and had given them no authority to change. The Lord shall rule over you In a special manner, as he hath hitherto done by judges. These God particularly appointed and directed in all the more important concerns of their office, even by Urim and Thummim, and, in a special manner, assisted upon all occasions: whereas kings had only a general dependance on God. That God was their supreme Ruler and King, was the foundation of their whole state. Hence the judgment which was administered among them is called Gods judgment, Deu 1:17. And Solomon is said to sit upon the throne of the Lord, (1Ch 29:23,) and the kingdom of his posterity is called the kingdom of the Lord, (2Ch 13:8,) because before kings were settled in Israel, the Lord was their king; from whom the government was derived to the house of David by a special act of God.