Exegetical and Hermeneutical Commentary of 1 Samuel 17:41
And the Philistine came on and drew near unto David; and the man that bore the shield [went] before him.
41 54. The victory of faith. The flight of the Philistines
41. This verse is not found in the Sept. (B).
Fuente: The Cambridge Bible for Schools and Colleges
1Sa 17:41
And the Philistine came on and drew near unto David.
Combat and consequences
The inward preparation through outward trial may have been hidden from David. We are not permitted to know the why of many an hour of discipline; God lets when wait on why! David urges his suit; he wishes to go. Every warrior called of God has weapons for use that no Saul can give. Dependence alone upon God gives wonderful independence of men. Behind the outer world record, there is always the inner and spiritual. From the outward view, Abraham leaving country and kindred was only in consonance with the restlessness of a nomadic life. From the inward we know it was the call of God. David was being trained for triumph, trained for his future as king. This panel is the closing one in the story of his shepherd days. The old peaceful, songful, careless days end. They end with a conflict and a victory. Do not the epochs of our lives close with combat? We close the days of our boyhood really when we enter our first contest, when we close with some temptation that never came as a temptation in the old days. The doors are open, the steps are hidden he who would enter must climb.
I. The apparent inequality of the combatants. To the eye of sense the conflict between the Church of God and that armed Goliath of the world appears as if it could only end in the Churchs defeat! It does really sound like presumption and folly to sing of victory when we present only ruddy and unarmoured Davids. There is a quantity the worlds eye never sees!–chariots whose wheels, horses whose hoofs move noiselessly, such as Elishas servant once saw. There is a quality the world knows not and has no more power to recognise than had Herod to recognise the kingliness of purity, when Christ stood before him.
II. The real inequality of the combatants. Things ere not what they seem. There is more than eye can see. David tells him of dependence upon Divine power (1Sa 17:46). How calm one can be when dependent wholly and alone on the Lord! How strangely at variance with appearances a mans words may then be! This day. So Elijah could stand before Ahab, or the priests of Baal or Carmel, or Bunyan before the judges at Bedford. Do not mistake presumption for dependence; they differ eternally. Dependence upon God never opposes commonsense, but sanctifies it, Davids heart is resting in his God, his head and hand fulfilling the Divine command. How often at fault is the judgment of sense! Yet this old-world scene occurs every day. We may still see aggregations of mere material strength–walking mountains of brass, to quote Matthew Henry. It is no dream, no fancy, to remind you that before the enthusiasm of faith, and by Divine direction, these shall fall. The Church has yet to learn the deep meaning of the words, The weapons of our warfare are not carnal but spiritual. Who can successfully cope with evil licensed by Government, the fearful monopolies of vice, prostitution under British rule in India, gambling beneath the very eye of the legislative assembly? This victory was fraught with momentous consequences for David. From that moment he became acquainted with life in quite another aspect than that of his Bethlehem home. As Dr. MacLaren beautifully says, He began to learn its hate and effort, hollow fame, whispering calumnies, and political intrigues. Until then he had not heard the hollow tone of courtiers nor the frenzied laugh of disappointment. The door of victory was for David, as it is for all Gods warriors, the door of trial. It was needful for David to know sorrow, to become acquainted with grief. He must learn the meaning of hate and deceit; not to practise, but avoid; must come into touch with natures he will afterwards have to rule. He must gain a mastery over himself. The metal must be annealed. (H. E. Stone.)
David and Goliath
Sauls simple blessing, Go, and the Lord shall be with thee, ought to have been allowed to stand as the veterans farewell charge to the new recruit. It would have been as sufficient as the mothers parting kiss add God bless you when her boy leaves his home of poverty to make his way in the great city with all his goods tied up in a handkerchief and his Bible in his pocket. When we have done a good thing, especially a spiritual one, it is difficult to be persuaded to leave the single impression without some private brand of our own. Hunters use in the pursuit of wild game an expanding bullet, which enlarges as it enters the side of its victim. When one has uttered a gracious truth it can often be left to itself to work its way to the heart. Saul could not quite keep his hands off the new enterprise. The latent jealousy of the old commander would rise at any scheme conducted entirely by an underling. The veteran could not be content to see the stripling champion of the Lords cause without some of the traditional military costume. We remark as in contrast to this:–
I. The wisdom of following the Spirits suggestions as to the method of a work of faith. And Saul clad David with his apparel, and he put an helmet of brass upon his head, and he clad him with a coat of mail. For the moment Saul was allowed to array David in the heavy war suit of the day. A sense of the ridiculous may have come first to the relief of the lad. He was not so large a man as the king, and the clanking plates of metal would impede the free movement of the volunteer. There are times when an appreciation of the humorous elements of a situation will prevent serious folly. If good people who overwork prophecy on every possible occasion had only a slight intuition of the appearance of their performances, they would be aware that something must be wrong in their outfit. Scripture does not lend itself to grotesque interpretations without exacting penalties from its manipulators. There are fads of false science which are so silly that they cannot be meant to be incorporated into the great body of the worlds dignified truth. The boy in his grandfathers coat is not counted a serious actor on the stage of life. But beyond this feeling of unfitness there was this reason, I have not proved them. The youth felt the seriousness of the crisis, notwithstanding his bravery. He knew the long practice required to get an unerring aim with the sling. Beyond all these motives which influenced David would be the assurance that God, who gave him a work to do, would show the method of it. The Lord who called to the bold undertaking would give the plan.
II. The range of gifts which the spirit can use and bless in an enterprise of faith. And he took his staff in his hand, and chose him five smooth stones out of the brook, and put them in the shepherds bag which he had, even his scrip; and his sling was in his hand. This was not the first experience of the Lords consecration of the youths gifts. Thy servant smote both the lion and the bear. The Lord often makes use of mens gifts to get them to a position of vantage from which they can do more efficient service. Sir Hope Grant when a youth was selected because of his skill in playing the flute for the staff of Lord Saltoun, who was going out to take command of the British forces in China. The long voyage of months around the Cape of Good Hope to their destination was thus to be made more tolerable for the officers. Grant soon became the foremost Christian in the English army in the East and one of its most successful generals. Davids reputation for music got him a place at the court of Saul, and perhaps the story of his rugged valour among the shepherds secured him a hearing as a champion of Israel. Guizots gifts as a diplomat made him necessary to his Catholic sovereigns and gave him a position from which he could exert a beneficent influence for an oppressed church in France. John Wycliffes parliamentary skill and zeal for liberty mede him an important ally of the House of Lancaster and gained him the protection which he needed to spread the doctrines of the Gospel. Many accomplishments of the Christian may be of service in gaining an entrance to doors and hearts closed to direct religious appeal. Dr. Asa Gray, the botanist, records of his long and singularly successful career as a Christian and a man of science that when he was ready for any forward movement he almost always found that things were prepared for him. Let one have himself in training for a useful life and he will find a place and opportunity awaiting the employment of his gifts.
III. A consecrated youth early begins to bear his countrys burdens as a work of faith. But I come to thee in the name of the Lord of hosts, the God of the armies of Israel, which thou hast defied. David belongs to a legion of those out of every nation who have consecrated their youth to their countrys freedom and to God. They are a nobler band than Sons of the Revolution. They have been the sires of States. The war song that has made all Germans merge their local differences in one great purpose–the common fatherland–that united Bavarians, Prussians, Saxons, end Wurtembergers in 1870, and the Imperial Crown to the House of Hohenzollern–that song is Die Wacht am Rheim. It was written at the age of twenty-one by a poor German roused against the French aggressions upon his native land. Not all such heroic souls have been permitted to take up arms. Their stanzas, their speeches, their deeds of mercy have made them members of this patriotic and Christian fraternity. Every nation has contributed its quota for this ancient peerage to which David belonged. It is older than all orders, chapters, and lodges. The people who are to be preserved in their inheritance and liberties must still be able to call forth the devotion of these volunteer champions of law, institutions, faith, and native land. (W. R. Campbell.)
Fuente: Biblical Illustrator Edited by Joseph S. Exell
Verse 41. The man that bare the shield] See on 1Sa 17:7.
Fuente: Adam Clarke’s Commentary and Critical Notes on the Bible
And the Philistine came on, and drew near unto David,…. By slow paces, because of the weight of his armour, and bulk of his body, yet with a haughty air, and a proud gait:
and the man that bare the shield [went] before him;
[See comments on 1Sa 17:7].
Fuente: John Gill’s Exposition of the Entire Bible
1Sa 17:41 And the Philistine came on and drew near unto David; and the man that bare the shield [went] before him.
Ver. 41. And the Philistine came on and drew near. ] When he saw David, that , presuming to make his approach: he considered not that
“ A cane non magno saepe tenetur aper. ”
Fuente: John Trapp’s Complete Commentary (Old and New Testaments)
He Wins the Lords Battle
1Sa 17:41-54
David did not wait until his enemy had crossed the valley, but hastened to the streamlet to select the pebbles needed for his sling. Goliath scouted such a champion and cursed him. To this boasting and blaspheming, David opposed the name of Jehovah of Hosts-the unseen hosts of heaven, the twelve legions of angels, of which our Lord spoke. That God-the God of Israel-would assuredly take up the challenge, and vindicate His servants faith. Thus all Gentile nations would see that the God of Israel was a living reality, while Israel also would learn the too-long-forgotten lesson that Jehovah saveth not by sword nor spear.
So confident was the Philistine that he did not trouble to draw his sword nor let down the visor of his helmet. One thrust of his heavy spear, he reckoned, was all that would be required. But in a moment more Goliath was lying helpless on the ground. It is thus that Gods champions, in every age, have gone out against giant wrongs, as Luther against Tetzel, or Garrison against slavery; and it is thus that we may confidently over-throw the inbred sins that claim supremacy over our lives.
Fuente: F.B. Meyer’s Through the Bible Commentary
Reciprocal: Jos 8:18 – the spear 1Sa 17:31 – sent for him
Fuente: The Treasury of Scripture Knowledge
David’s victory by faith 17:41-49
Goliath disdained David because the lad had no battle scars; he was not a warrior at all but simply a fresh-faced boy (1Sa 17:42). Goliath assumed that he would win because his physical power and armaments were superior. As often happens, pride preceded a fall (Pro 16:18).
1Sa 17:45-47 give the clearest expression to David’s faith in Yahweh. He viewed Yahweh as the commander of Israel’s armies, a view of God that Saul never accepted but which made the difference between Saul’s failure and David’s success as the Lord’s anointed (1Sa 17:45). He also saw God as the real deliverer of Israel (1Sa 17:46). Furthermore, David was jealous for the reputation of God (1Sa 17:47), not his own glory, which so preoccupied Saul. His faith must have rested on God’s promises concerning victory against the enemies of God’s people for their confidence in Him and their obedience to His word (Gen 12:3; Deu 31:1-8; Jos 1:1-9).
"Intimidation. That’s our MAJOR battle when we face giants. When they intimidate us, we get tongue-tied. Our thoughts get confused. We forget how to pray. We focus on the odds against us. We forget whom we represent, and we stand there with our knees knocking. I wonder what God must think, when all the while He has promised us, ’My power is available. There’s no one on this earth greater. You trust Me.’ . . .
"David lived by a very simple principle: nothing to prove, nothing to lose. He didn’t try to impress anybody in the army of Israel. He didn’t try to impress his brothers. He didn’t even try to impress God. He just ran to meet Goliath." [Note: Swindoll, p. 46.]