Exegetical and Hermeneutical Commentary of 1 John 3:22
And whatsoever we ask, we receive of him, because we keep his commandments, and do those things that are pleasing in his sight.
22. This verse is so closely connected with the preceding one, that not more than a comma or semicolon should be placed between them. When a good conscience gives us boldness towards God our prayers are granted, for children in such relations to their heavenly Father cannot ask anything which He will refuse.
And whatsoever we ask ] The ‘and’ is probably epexegetic, as in 1Jn 3:20, and explains the special character of our boldness. See on 1Jn 3:15.
we receive of him ] The present is to be taken quite literally; not as the present for the future. It may be a long time before we see the results of our prayer; but it is granted at once. As S. Augustine says, ‘He who gave us love cannot close His ears against the groans and prayers of love’.
because we keep his commandment ] This should certainly be plural, commandments: previous English Versions have the plural, and there seems to be no trace of a various reading, so that one suspects a misprint in the edition of 1611. ‘Because’ depends upon ‘receive’, not upon ‘have boldness’: we receive because we are loyal. This is in harmony with the Gospel and with Scripture generally: ‘We know that God heareth not sinners: but if any man be a worshipper of God, and do His will, him He heareth ’ (Joh 9:31); ‘The Lord is far from the wicked, but He heareth the prayer of the righteous’ (Pro 15:29; comp. Psa 66:18-19; Job 27:8-9; Isa 1:11-15). For ‘keep His commandments’ see on 1Jn 2:3.
do those things which are pleasing in his sight ] Not the same as ‘keeping His commandments’: the one is obedience, which may be slavish, the other is love. We seem here to have another reminiscence of the Gospel (Joh 8:29): ‘Because the things pleasing to Him I always do’. Excepting Act 6:2; Act 12:3, the word for ‘pleasing’ occurs nowhere else in N. T. Comp. Heb 13:21; 1Ti 2:3.
Fuente: The Cambridge Bible for Schools and Colleges
And whatsoever we ask, we receive of him – If we are truly his children, and ask in a proper manner. See the notes at Mat 7:7. Compare Mar 11:24; Luk 11:9; Luk 18:1 ff; Joh 14:13; Joh 15:7; 1Jo 5:14. The declaration here made must be understood with these limitations:
(1)That we ask in a proper manner, Jam 4:3; and,
(2)That the thing asked shall be such as will be consistent for God to give; that is, such as he shall see to be best for us, 1Jo 5:14. See the notes at this latter passage.
Because we keep his commandments – Not that this is the meritorious ground of our being heard, but that it furnishes evidence that we are his children, and he hears his children as such.
And do those things that are pleasing in his sight – As a parent is disposed to bestow favors on obedient, affectionate, and dutiful children, so God is on those who please him by their obedience and submission to his will. We can have no hope that he will hear us unless we do so live as to please him.
Fuente: Albert Barnes’ Notes on the Bible
1Jn 3:22-24
And whatsoever we ask, we receive of Him, because we keep His commandments
The conditions of power in prayer
I.
The essentials of power is prayer. We must make a few distinctions at the outset. I take it there is a great difference between the prayer of a soul that is seeking mercy and the prayer of a man who is saved. I would say to every person present, whatever his character, if you sincerely seek mercy of God through Jesus Christ you shall have it. Qualifications for the sinners first prayer I know of none except sincerity; but we must speak in a different way to those of you who are saved. You have now become the people of God, and while you shall be heard just as the sinner would be heard, and shall daily find the needful grace which every seeker receives in answer to prayer, yet you are under a special discipline peculiar to the regenerated family. There is something for a believer to enjoy over and above bare salvation; there are mercies, and blessings, and comforts, which render his present life useful, happy, and honourable, and these he shall not have irrespective of character. To give a common illustration: If a hungry person were at your door, and asked for bread, you would give it him, whatever might be his character; you will also give your child food, whatever may be his behaviour; you will never proceed in any course of discipline against him, so as to deny him his needful food, or a garment to shield him from the cold; but there are many other things which your child may desire, which you will give him if he be obedient, but which you will not give if he be rebellious to you. I take it that this illustrates how far the paternal government of God will push this matter, and where it will not go. Understand also, that the text refers not so much to Gods hearing a prayer of His servants now and then, for that He will do, even when His servants are out of course with Him; but the power in prayer here intended is continuous and absolute power with God; so that, to quote the words of the text, whatsoever we ask of Him we receive. For this prayer there are certain prerequisites.
1. The first is child-like obedience: Whatsoever we ask, we receive of Him, because we keep His commandments.
2. Next to this is another essential to victorious prayer, viz., child-like reverence. We receive what we ask, because we keep His commandments, and do those things that are pleasing in His sight. Suppose any of us should be self-willed, and say, I shall not do what pleases God, I shall do what pleases myself. Then observe what would be the nature of our prayers? Our prayers might then be summed up in the request, Let me have my own way. And can we expect God to consent to that?
3. In the third place, the text suggests the necessity of child-like trust: And this is His commandment, that we should believe on the name of His Son Jesus Christ. Let us come back to our family similitudes again. Suppose a child in the house does not believe his fathers word; suppose, indeed, that he tells his brothers and sisters that his faith in his father is very weak. He mentions that wretched fact, but is not at all shocked that he should say such a thing, but he rather feels that he ought to be pitied, as if it were an infirmity which he could not avoid. I think a father so basely distrusted would not be in a very great hurry to grant such a sons requests; indeed, it is very probable that the petitions of the mistrustful son would be such as could not be complied with, even if his father were willing to do so, since they would amount to a gratification of his own unbelief and a dishonour to his parent. Expect not, therefore, to be heard when your prayer is suggested by an unbelieving heart: Commit thy way unto the Lord; trust also in Him, and He shall bring it to pass.
4. The next essential to continued success in prayer is child-like love: That we should believe on the name of His Son, Jesus Christ, and love one another as He gave us commandment. We should abound in love to God, love to Christ, love to the Church, love to sinners, and love to men everywhere. You must get rid of selfishness before God can trust you with the keys of heaven; but when self is dead, then He will enable you to unlock His treasuries, and, as a prince, shall you have power with God and prevail.
5. Next to this, we must have child-like ways as well. He that keepeth His commandments, dwelleth in Him, and He in him. It is one of a childs ways to love its home. Suppose one of you had a boy, who said, Father, I do not like my home, I do not care for you; and I will not endure the restraints of family rule; I am going to live with strangers. But mark, father, I shall come to you every week, and I shall require many things of you; and I shall expect that you will give me whatever I ask from you. Why, if you are at all fit to be at the head of the house, you will say, My son, how can you speak to me in such a manner? If you are so self-willed as to leave my house, can you expect that I will do your bidding? If you utterly disregard me, can you expect me to support you in your cruel unkindness and wicked insubordination. No, my son; if you will not remain with me and own me as a father, I cannot promise you anything. And so it is with God.
6. One thing more: it appears from the text that we must have a child-like spirit, for hereby we know that He abideth in us, by the Spirit which He hath given us. What is this but the Spirit of adoption–the Spirit which rules in all the children of God? The Holy Spirit if He rules in us, will subordinate our nature to His own sway, and then the prayers which spring out of our renewed hearts will be in keeping with the will of God, and such prayers will naturally be heard.
II. The prevalence of these essential things. If they be in us and abound, our prayers cannot be barren or unprofitable.
1. First, if we have faith in God, there is no question about Gods hearing our prayer. If we can plead in faith the name and blood of Jesus, we must obtain answers of peace. But a thousand cavils are suggested. Suppose these prayers concern the laws of nature, then the scientific men are against us, What of that? The Lord has ways of answering our prayers irrespective of the working of miracles or suspending laws. Perhaps there are other forces and laws which He has arranged to bring into action just at times when prayer also acts, laws just as fixed and forces just as natural as those which our learned theorisers have been able to discover. The wisest men know not all the laws which govern the universe, nay, nor a tithe of them. If there be but faith in God, God must either cease to be, or cease to be true, or else He must hear prayer. The verse before the text says, If our heart condemn us not, then have we confidence toward God; and whatsoever we ask, we receive of Him. He who has a clear conscience comes to God with confidence, and that confidence of faith ensures to him the answer of his prayer.
2. But next, love must succeed too, since we have already seen that the man who loves in the Christian sense is in accord with God. God always hears the prayers of a loving man, because those prayers are the shadows of His own decrees.
3. Again, the man of obedience is the man whom God will hear, because his obedient heart leads him to pray humbly and with submission, for he feels it to be his highest desire that the Lords will should be done.
4. Again, the man who lives in fellowship with God will assuredly speed in prayer, because if he dwells in God and God dwells in him, he will desire what God desires.
5. And here, again let us say, our text speaks of the Christian man as being filled with Gods Spirit: We know that He abideth in us, by the Spirit which He hath given us. Who knows the mind of a man but the spirit of a man? So, who knows the things of God but the Spirit of God? And if the Spirit of God dwells in us, then He tells us what Gods mind is; He makes intercession in the saints according to the will of God.
Practical improvement:
1. The first is, we want to pray for a great blessing as a church. Very well. Have we the essentials for success? Are we believing in the name of Jesus Christ? Are we full of love to God and one another?
2. Next, are we doing that which is pleasing in Gods sight?
3. The next question is, do we dwell in God?
4. Lastly, does the Spirit of God actuate us, or is it another spirit? (C. H. Spurgeon.)
Righteousness essential to our pleasing God and to His hearing us
I. We keep His commandments, and do those things that are pleasing in His sight. So John writes; and so also Jesus speaks (Joh 8:29). The language is the very same; the sense and spirit in which it is used must be the very same also. Jesus uttered the words for our sakes; and as expressing a human feeling which we may understand, and with which He would have us to sympathise. That human feeling in the bosom of Jesus must have been very simple and intensely filial; realising intensely His filial relation to the Father and His filial oneness with the Father. There is, if I may venture so to speak, a child-like simplicity, a sort of artless straightforwardness, in His saying so confidingly, so lovingly, so naturally, I do always those things that please Him. He has the Cross in view. Men, displeased with Him, are to lift Him up, and leave Him to die in His agony alone. Not so the Father. He leaves me not alone; He is with me; for I do always those things that please Him. Somewhat similar are the circumstances in which John would have us to say; we do those things that are pleasing in His sight. Oh! to be converted, and become as little children! First, to be made willing as little children, that all this misunderstanding should be ended, and this breach thoroughly healed at once, and once for all, as the Father would have it to be, in the Son. And then, as little children, to know something of a little childs touching and artless simplicity, as we look with loving eye into the loving eye of the Father, and lovingly lisp out the touching words: We keep His commandments and do those things that are pleasing in His sight.
II. And whatsoever we ask, we receive of Him. In this saying also we have the countenance of Jesus (Joh 11:41-42). Thou hearest me always! It is a blessed assurance. And the blessedness of it really lies, not so much in the good he gets from the Fathers hearing him, as in the Fathers hearing him itself; not so much in what he receives, as in his receiving it from the Father. For this is the charm, the joy, the consolation, of that access to the Father and that influence with the Father which you now have in common with the Son. It is not that you may enrich and gratify yourselves with what you win by asking from Him. But it is literally that whatever you ask you receive of Him, as His gift; the proof that He is ever with you and heareth you always. Ah! how then shall I ask anything at all? If such is my position, in and with Christ, how shall I have the heart or the hardihood to ask anything at all of the Father, except only that He may deal with me according to His good pleasure? If I am really on such a footing with the Father that He heareth me always, and whatsoever I ask I receive of Him; if I have such influence with Him; if, as His dear child, pleasing Him, and doing what pleases Him, I can so prevail with Him that He can refuse me nothing; what can I say? What can I do? I can but cast myself into His arms and cry, Thou knowest better than I, oh my Father! Father, Thy will be done. (R. S. Candlish, D. D.)
Answers to prayer
We must make a wide distinction between a cause and a condition. The cause of anything is the actual reason why it is–the source from which it flows. The condition is something which comes in afterwards–super added–to limit and to guide the actings of the first cause. Just, for example, as the rain is not caused by the particular state of the atmosphere, but it depends upon it; and there must be a certain rarity in the air, without which the rain would not fall. This is its condition. In like manner, keeping the commandments is not the cause of our prayers being answered, but it is the condition. Your prayers will not be answered unless yon keep the commandments. If we ask, what is the reason why any prayer prevails with God? the explanation lies very deep. You will find it among the grandnesses of the Holy Trinity. It is because God is a Father, and therefore of Himself loves to listen to His childrens petitions, and to give them everything they ask. It is because every believer praying, prays in Christ–he presents Christ–he is in Christ. Hence the almost omnipotence of prayer. It is because whatever true prayer goes up to the throne of God, it is the Holy Ghost who prays it. Thus the whole Trinity meets to make the prayer of the weakest Christian, and this is the cause why prayer gets answered. Who has not asked of God a great many things? Who does not believe that many, at least, of the things which he asks are the legitimate, nay, the covenanted subjects of prayer? Who has not the evidence of his own heart that for many of these things, at all events, he has prayed, and is praying very earnestly. And yet, who has not to feel My prayers are not answered; I do not obtain what I ask? And who has not wondered why it is thus with his prayers? Now what is the reason? Certainly the cause cannot be in God; it must be in you. But where in you? I answer deliberately–in your life, in your heart. In some way or other, you are not keeping some commandment, you are not doing those things that are pleasing in His sight. Let us now pause upon the thought that the life rules the prayer–that according as you are holy, so wilt you receive answers to your prayers–that the condition of prayer is obedience, and without obedience prayer loses its prerogative. If a man is leading a religious life–not grieving his conscience–a man of pure thoughts and holy pleasures–that man grows into such a state of mind that he will only wish such things as God has promised to give him, he will not desire many temporal things; but his tastes will be spiritual, therefore his prayers are always keeping within the bounds of the promises. He will not ask nor long for anything which is not after the will of God to give. The Spirit which is in him will take care of that for him.
1. And here is the first grand secret of the success of a good mans prayer, which arises out of a conformity of his mind to the mind of God, and that conformity of his mind to the mind of God arises out of his daily habits of life.
2. Secondly, blessings may be ready to come down, and they may pour, but unless your heart be in a right state to receive them, they will pour in vain. The heart is hard, and they cannot come in; or it is so crowded that there is no room; or it is so weak that there is no holding. Now any state of wilful sin puts the heart in that state. Hence, prayer cannot be answered–for even should the answer come, it will not find entrance.
3. Thirdly, remember this; that when God says that a man must keep His commandments if he will have his prayers answered, part of the commandments is faith in Jesus Christ; and therefore the passage runs thus in very emphatic order–Whatsoever we ask, we receive of Him, because we keep His commandments, and do those things that are pleasing in His sight. And this is His commandment, That we should believe on the name of His Son Jesus Christ.
4. And then fourthly, it is quite evident that what God gives to those who are leading a godly and devoted life, He gives to the promotion of His own glory; because, either directly or indirectly, they will use the gift for the extension of His kingdom, and this gives a plain reason why their prayer should be granted. For shall God give to a man whose life has two faces–one face in practice, and another face in prayer? Shall He give to a sheer hypocrite?
5. And once more, why should not our heavenly Father do what all fathers do, love to give His good things to the child who tries to please Him most, and who delights in His society? (J. Vaughan, M. A.)
And this is His commandment, That we should believe on the name of His Son Jesus Christ, and love one another–
On the importance of faith in Christ and love to Christians
I. The gospel, wherever it comes, requires a firm trust in the merits and grace of the Lord Jesus Christ.
1. It is necessary to obtain pardon of sin.
2. It is necessary to produce purity of heart.
3. It is necessary to promote vital union with God, the fountain of life and felicity.
II. The gospel requires brotherly love, as a primary and most important duty.
1. Let us consider the nature and extent of that brotherly love which the gospel inculcates and demands. It is esteem, complacence, compassion, benevolence.
(1) Love is evinced by sincerely sympathising with our Christian brethren in their sufferings.
(2) Love is evinced by cheerfully communicating of our substance to relieve the wants of our Christian brethren.
2. The grounds and obligations of brotherly love.
(1) Faith in Christ, and love to Christians are represented as closely and inseparably connected.
(2) There is an express and very particular command of Christ, enjoining brotherly love upon His followers.
(3) The basis of our obligation is the cause of God.
There are two cases to which this subject may be applied.
1. Let it serve as a test or touchstone of our personal piety.
2. Let this subject rouse us to more seriousness, activity, and zeal. (Essex Remembrancer.)
The warrant of faith
The true believer has learned to look away from the killing ordinances of the old law. He turns with loathing from all trust in his own obedience and lays hold with joy upon the hope set before him in the one commandment contained in my text.
I. The matter of believing, or what is it that a man is to believe in order to eternal life? That faith which saves the soul is believing on a person, depending upon Jesus for eternal life. We must believe Him to be Gods Son–so the text puts it–His Son. We must grasp with strong confidence the great fact that He is God: for nothing short of a Divine Saviour can ever deliver us from the infinite wrath of God. Furthermore, we must accept this Son of God as Jesus, the Saviour. We must believe that Jesus Christ, the Son of God, became man out of infinite love to man, that He might save His people from their sins. We must look upon Jesus as Christ, the anointed of the Father, sent into this world on salvations errand, not that sinners might save themselves, but that He, being mighty to save, might bring many sons Unto glory. Moreover, we should rejoice that as Jesus Christ, by His dying, put away forever the sin of His people, so by His living He gave unto those who trust in Him a perfect righteousness, in which, despite their own sins, they are accepted in the Beloved. We are also taught that if we heartily trust our soul with Christ, our sins, through His blood, are forgiven, and His righteousness is imputed to us. The mere knowledge of these facts will not, however, save us, unless we really trust our souls in the Redeemers hands.
II. The warrant of believing. This is the commandment, that ye believe on His Son Jesus Christ.
1. First, negatively.
(1) That any other way of preaching the gospel warrant is absurd. Are we to go running up and down the world proclaiming life to the living, casting bread to those who are fed already, and holding up Christ on the pole of the gospel to those who are already healed?
(2) To tell the sinner that he is to believe on Christ because of some warrant in himself, is legal. If I lean on Christ because I feel this and that, then I am leaning on my feelings and not on Christ alone, and this is legal indeed.
(3) Again, any other way of preaching than that of bidding the sinner believe because God commands him to believe, is a boasting way of faith. When we tell a sinner that filthy as he is, without any preparation or qualification, he is to take Jesus Christ to be his all in all, finding in Him all that he can ever need, we leave no room for self-glorification, all must be of grace. Law and boasting are twin brothers, but free grace and gratitude always go together.
(4) Any other warrant for believing on Jesus than that which is presented in the gospel is changeable. Since everything within changes more frequently than ever does an English sky, if my warrant to believe in Christ be based within, it must change every hour; consequently I am lost and saved alternately. Can these things be so?
(5) Again, any other warrant is utterly incomprehensible. Multitudes preach an impossible salvation. Personally, I do not remember to have been told from the pulpit to believe in Jesus as a sinner. I heard much of feelings which I thought I could never get, and frames after which I longed; but I found no peace until a true, free grace message came to me, Look unto Me and be ye saved, all the ends of the earth.
(6) Yet again, I believe that the preaching of alarms of conscience and repentance as qualifications for Christ is unacceptable to the awakened sinner. Oh, I am ashamed of myself when I think of the way in which I have sometimes talked to awakened sinners. I am persuaded that the only true remedy for a broken heart is Jesus Christs most precious blood.
(7) Any other warrant for the sinners faith than the gospel itself, is false and dangerous. It is as false as God is true, that anything in a sinner can be his warrant for believing in Jesus. There cannot be a true and real hatred of sin where there is not faith in Jesus. All the sinner knows and feels before faith is only an addition to his other sins, and how can sin which deserves wrath be a warrant for an act which is the work of the Holy Spirit. How dangerous is the sentiment I am opposing. Take care of resting in your own experience. All that is of natures spinning must be unravelled, and everything that getteth into Christs place, however dear to thee, and however precious in itself, must he broken in pieces. Sinners, Jesus wants nothing of you, nothing whatsoever, nothing done, nothing felt; He gives both work and feeling. Ragged, penniless, just as ye are, lost, forsaken, desolate, with no good feelings and no good hopes, still Jesus comes to you, and in these words of pity He addresses you, Him that cometh to Me I will in no wise cast out.
2. But now, positively, and as the negative part has been positive enough, we will be brief here. This is the commandment. Do you want any warrant for doing a thing better than Gods command to do it? The command to believe in Christ must be the sinners warrant, if you consider the nature of our commission. How runs it? Go ye into all the world, and preach the gospel to every creature. It ought to run, according to the other plan, preach the gospel to every regenerate person, to every convinced sinner, to every sensible soul. But it is not so; it is to every creature. Then how is it put?–He that believeth and is baptised shall be saved; he that believeth not shall be damned. Where is there a word about the prerequisites for believing.
(1) I shall only add, that the blessings which flow from preaching Christ to sinners as sinners, are of such a character as prove it to be right. Do you not see that this levels us all? We have the same warrant for believing, and no one can exalt himself above his fellow.
(2) Then how it inspires men with hope and confidence; it forbids despair. No man can despair if this be true; or if he do, it is a wicked, unreasonable despair, because if he has been never so bad, yet God commands him to believe.
(3) Again, how it makes a man live close to Christ! If I am to come to Christ as a sinner every day, and I must do so, for the Word saith, As ye have received Christ Jesus the Lord, so walk ye in Him; if every day I am to come to Christ as a sinner, why then, how paltry all my doings look! what utter contempt it east upon all my fine virtues, my preachings, my prayings, and all that comes of my flesh I and though it leads me to seek after purity and holiness, yet it teaches me to live on Christ and not on them, and so it keeps me at the fountain head. (C. H. Spurgeon.)
Gods one commandment
Every thoughtful reader of the Word of God must have been struck with the very great importance that the sacred writers attach to names. In the opening chapter of the Sacred Volume we read of God giving their names to the works of His hands: God called the light Day, and the darkness He called Night. The very first thing that Adam, the first man, does, is by Gods direction to give names to all Gods creatures. Then, when God entered into covenant with Abram, He changed his name from Abram to Abraham. When God wrestled with Jacob, He changed his name from Jacob to Israel. But we must pass on to the New Testament. It also begins with God giving a name. On its very title page we have God sending an angel to give a name to One not yet born–that Second Adam–that Beginning of the New Creation of God, whom He sent into the world. In the very first chapter of the New Testament we have two names assigned to the Saviour. First, the angels say, Thou shalt call His name Jesus, for He shall save His people from their sins. Then the name of Emmanuel, given to Him in the spirit by Isaiah, the prophet, is also claimed as His by the Evangelist. These two names, given to the Second Adam in the first chapter of the book of the New Covenant, answer to the two names by which God made Himself known to the children of Israel. Emmanuel signifies what the Saviour is in Himself–God with us; God in our nature. Jesus rather signifies what He is to His people–their Saviour from sin. It means literally, The Lord is salvation, or The Lord Our salvation.
I. What is meant by believing in the name of Jesus Christ? It must mean more than believing that some years ago a person came into this world who had such a name given to him. It is believing that Jesus Christ is to us what His name means. Now let us take the best known name of our Saviour–Jesus Christ, His only Son our Lord. We know Him as the only Son of God–as Jesus–as Christ. Take the first of these–the Son of God. See how our Lord insists upon our believing in this, as His name, in His discourse with Nicodemus (Joh 3:18). Now a man who believes this respecting the Person who was then speaking to Nicodemus, and who was afterwards crucified and raised again, believes in the greatest possible instance of Gods love. It is quite clear, also, that any interpretation which attaches to the term Son of God a lower meaning than that of only-begotten Son, really destroys all the testimony which such a text as God so loved the world that He gave His only-begotten Son bears to the exceeding love of God. Now let us proceed to the human name by which we know the Son of God–Jesus Christ. The name Jesus signifies the Lord our salvation. He has saved us from the guilt of sin by His sacrifice on the Cross. Again, He saves us from the power of sin by His indwelling Spirit making us partakers of His nature, so that His risen life is in us our spiritual life. And so with that title of Messiah, or Christ, or Anointed One, to which is joined His name of Jesus. It is implied in the very fact of His being called Christ that He has been anointed by the Holy Ghost to be the Prophet, Priest, and King of His people. Believing in the name of Gods Son, Jesus, then, is believing that Gods Son is that very Lord, our Saviour, which His name implies. This is Gods commandment. No, no; it is only part of Gods commandment: for the one commandment of God, which God inspired the beloved disciple to give to His people, is made up of two things. This is His commandment, that we believe on the name of His Son Jesus Christ, and love one another, as He–i.e. as Christ Himself–gave us commandment. Anyone who knows anything of the history of the Church, or about religious society, knows well that a man may have, or at least may express, not only belief in the name, but the sincerest trust in the finished work of Christ, and yet be bitter to those who differ from him, uncharitable to those who oppose him, and churlish to those who are at all in his way. St. Paul writes his Epistle to the Ephesians to men who realised the gospel far better than any Christians now do; and instead of leaving the gospel to itself, and simply insisting on believing in Christ crucified, the apostle actually bids those who are supposed to believe the gospel not to lie, nor to steal, nor to use bad language, nor to grieve the Holy Spirit, but to walk in love, and put away all bitterness, wrath, anger, clamour, and evil speaking. Similarly with St. Peter. If there is any place in which he declares the precious truths of the gospel in terms full of consolation and good hope, it is in the first chapter of his Epistle; but, so far from thinking that all this would do its own work, he tells them at the beginning of the very next chapter to lay aside all malice, and all guile, and hypocrisies, and envies, and all evil speakings. But what is loving one another? Why, according to St. Paul, the apostle of justification, it is keeping the last six commandments (Rom 13:8). And in the next chapter he reckons working ill to our neighbours soul, as well as to his body, as a breach of love. But what, according to St. John, is loving one another? This is His commandment, that ye believe in all the power and grace that is contained in the name of His Son Jesus Christ, and seek out, visit, relieve, and comfort your sick and needy fellow Christians. This is His commandment, that ye believe in the name of the only begotten Son of God, and be kindly affectioned one to another, in honour preferring one another. This is His commandment, that ye believe in the name of Him who saves His people from their sins, and put away from you all bitterness, and wrath, and anger, and clamour, and evil speaking, and all malice. This is His commandment, that ye believe in the name of Him who was anointed by God to be a Prince and a Saviour, and covet earnestly that best gift of a charity that suffereth long, is kind, etc. (M. F. Sadler, M. A.)
Faith a work
I. The word believe, which enters this Epistle for the first time at this point, is one of the royal words of the New Testament. It contains three ideas.
1. First there is knowledge. That which you believe must first announce itself as a fact to your intellect. It must enter the crystal chamber of consciousness.
2. Then follows assent. That is the answer of your mind to the claims made upon it by the fact.
3. Then comes the last and most important of all, viz., trust. You say to yourself, This is truth–this will bear, and you put your whole weight upon it.
II. But what is to be dons with it? To what shall a man attach himself by means of this threefold cord? The object around which we are bid throw our faith is no series of propositions–not any Church–not even the Bible as a whole, but the full name of Jesus Christ. The full title of Christ, as given here, gathers up into itself every ray of spiritual truth diffused through the whole Bible. His Son Jesus Christ. Say that seriously, simply, honestly, without qualification or reserve, and you have repeated the full Christian creed. That name is the gospel.
III. This is Gods commandment. Note that well. Faith is set before us as a duty, as a work. Now, if God commands us to believe, then surely belief is something that is possible to us all. We cannot imagine God commanding the impossible. Then, too, unbelief is a sin. It is positive disobedience. And further, St. John says that belief in Christ is not simply a commandment, but that it is the commandment. Faith working by love is the spiritual unity of all commandments, and unbelief is therefore the root of all sins.
IV. Now, how far have we the power to believe in Christ? To what extent is faith subject to our will? It is worth while finding this out, for the measure of our power to believe will be the measure of our sin and of our punishment if we disbelieve.
1. If we look into the Bible we shall find two sets of texts. One set ascribes the whole work of redemption to God–faith, repentance, love, holiness, are all declared to be gifts of God. Another whole class of texts describes repentance, faith, purification, and love as acts which each man ought to, and therefore can perform himself.
2. Again, in the teaching of the Church we have two opposite camps of opinion on this matter. Augustine held very strong views on this point. He taught that when Adam fell he lost his freedom of will; the will sank into a state of infirmity, in which it had no power of choice at all between good and evil–only the power of always choosing the wrong; and through his sin all his successors fell into the same state of bondage. In fact, as one said, he taught that in the fall of man one whole piece of human nature had fallen out! But out of this mass of mutilated humanity God has elected a number to be saved. These must be saved. Gods grace overpowers them, and they are saved by a fiat of the Almighty Will. As to the others, they must be lost–they are reprobate. Pelagius held very strong views on the subject of our text. All men, he said, are as free to choose as Adam was. The will is not impaired, and can of itself, at any moment, free itself from sin. Man stands at the parting of the ways, and he has full power to choose either. Man–mans own power, is the note that is heard sounding all through his teaching. Grace scarcely appears at all. Thus, while the one almost did away with the free will of man, the other almost did away with the grace of God. And these two men divided the Christian world into opposing factions. The majority followed Augustine, though many too followed Pelagius. And so from age to age the pendulum of opinion swung from extreme to extreme.
3. Neither of these views is right. The first libels both God and man. It represents God as partial and arbitrary. It reduces man to a poor puppet of destiny. It robs religion of morality and deprives heaven of holiness. It takes away the guilt of sin, and lifts the blame of hell from the souls of men and lays it at the feet of God. Equally distant from the New Testament truth is the other view. It renders the best half of Scripture meaningless, and the whole mediatorial work of Christ needless. It peoples the earth with an imaginary race of moral giants, each of whom is sufficient in himself, and fills heaven with a multitude of self-saved souls.
4. But while the many thus swung from one extreme to another, there have always been in the Church of Christ a party of common sense men, able, like Melancthon, to combine the two sets of texts, and to see that they are not contradictions–only the two opposite poles of one great truth. Salvation, they teach, is a work of Gods grace, in which each man is required and enabled to take an active part. Mankind is a fallen race, but not an abandoned race. Man cannot save himself, yet Gods preparing grace has kept alive in each man enough of moral life to respond to the offer of Christ, a something living in each man to which the Christ can make His appeal. So men are utterly unable to save themselves. But they are not literally lifeless like a stone or stick. Faith is preeminently a matter of will. The text does not say, Believe this doctrine or that, but Trust yourselves in Christs hands–trust Christ as your Saviour. (J. M. Gibbon.)
Fuente: Biblical Illustrator Edited by Joseph S. Exell
Verse 22. Whatsoever we ask] In such a spirit, we receive of him, for he delights to bless the humble, upright, and sincere soul.
Because we keep his commandments] Viz., by loving him and loving our neighbour. These are the great commandments both of the old covenant and the new. And whoever is filled with this love to God and man will do those things which are pleasing to him; for love is the very soul and principle of obedience.
The word heart is used in the preceding verses for conscience; and so the Greek fathers interpret it, particularly Origen, Nicephorus, and OEcumenius; but this is not an unfrequent meaning of the word in the sacred writings.
Fuente: Adam Clarke’s Commentary and Critical Notes on the Bible
It is supposed, where there is that accord with God, that what was last, and is next after, said implies, there will be no disposition to ask any thing disagreeable to his will, or otherwise than as he hath expressed his will about the matter of prayer. And then,
whatsoever we ask, we receive, i.e. are as sure to receive it, in the kind or in equivalence, as if we had it, 1Jo 5:14.
Because we keep his commandments; i.e. this is the cause of our certainty, being the evidence of our state God-ward, Psa 66:18,19; not of our receiving the things prayed for, which we only owe to his free promised mercy in Christ.
Fuente: English Annotations on the Holy Bible by Matthew Poole
22. we receiveas a matter offact, according to His promise. Believers, as such, ask only what isin accordance with God’s will; or if they ask what God wills not,they bow their will to God’s will, and so God grants them eithertheir request, or something better than it.
because we keep hiscommandmentsCompare Psa 66:18;Psa 34:15; Psa 145:18;Psa 145:19. Not as though ourmerits earned a hearing for our prayers, but when we are believers inChrist, all our works of faith being the fruit of His Spiritin us, are “pleasing in God’s sight”; and our prayers beingthe voice of the same Spirit of God in us, naturally and necessarilyare answered by Him.
Fuente: Jamieson, Fausset and Brown’s Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible
And whatsoever we ask we receive of him,…. According to his promise, Mt 7:7; that is, whatever is asked according to the will of God, in the name of Christ, and for his sake, and in faith, nothing wavering, but believing in God, in his covenant and promises, for these are provisos in the case; and such as ask in this way may exercise an holy confidence that they shall receive; and indeed they do receive what they ask for; see 1Jo 5:14;
because we keep his commandments; not that keeping the commands of God is the meritorious cause of receiving anything from him; for when men have done all they can, or are assisted to do, they are but unprofitable servants in point of merit: whatever is received from God, as it is in consequence of asking, so it is entirely owing to his own grace and favour, and for the sake of Christ; but keeping the commands of God is a necessary adjunct, or, as Calvin on the text calls it, an inseparable accident, or what necessarily belongs unto, and enters into the character of such, who are heard and answered by God, and receive at his hands; for there is a great deal of truth in what the Jews say to the blind man, Joh 9:31; and which may serve as a comment on these words:
and do those things that are pleasing in his sight; as keeping of his commandments is; not that these things ingratiate into the love and favour of God, or are the causes and conditions of it, for the love of God is prior to anything of this kind; nor are they the causes of men’s acceptance with God, for the acceptance both of persons and services is only in Christ the beloved; but these things are what God approves of, when done in faith, from a principle of love, and with a view to his glory: and since he hears such persons that are worshippers of him, and do his will, and has promised good things to them; this is therefore a reason strengthening their confidence in him, that what they ask they shall receive.
Fuente: John Gill’s Exposition of the Entire Bible
Whatsoever we ask ( ). Indefinite relative clause with modal and the present active subjunctive, like in verse 20. In form no limitations are placed here save that of complete fellowship with God, which means complete surrender of our will to that of God our Father. See the clear teaching of Jesus on this subject in Mark 11:24; Luke 11:9; John 14:12; John 16:23 and his example (Mark 14:36; Matt 26:39; Luke 22:42). The answer may not always be in the form that we expect, but it will be better.
We receive of him ( ‘ ). See 1:5 for ‘ (from him).
Because (). Twofold reason why we receive regularly () the answer to our prayers (1) “we keep” (, for which see 2:3) his commandments and (2) “we do” (, we practise regularly) “the things that are pleasing” ( , old verbal adjective from , to please, with dative in Joh 8:29 with same phrase; Ac 12:3 and infinitive in Ac 6:2, only other N.T. examples) “in his sight” ( , common late vernacular preposition in papyri, LXX, and in N.T., except Matthew and Mark, chiefly by Luke and in the Apocalypse), in God’s eye, as in Heb 13:21.
Fuente: Robertson’s Word Pictures in the New Testament
We ask [] . See on Luk 11:9.
We receive of Him [ ] On the form of expression, see on 1 5. For the thought, compare Joh 14:7.
We keep [] . See on 1Pe 1:5. Note the combination of keep and do. Watchful discernment and habitual practice. Compare Psa 123:2. The same combination occurs 1Jo 5:2, 3, where instead of the first thrwmen keep, read poiwmen do.
Pleasing [] . See Joh 8:29.
In His sight [ ] . Compare emprosqen aujtou before Him, or in His presence (ver. 19). In His sight “accentuates the thought of the divine regard. Compare Joh 7:37 and Joh 20:30” (Westcott).
Fuente: Vincent’s Word Studies in the New Testament
1) “And whatsoever we ask, we receive of him.” Based on the pre-condition that our hearts condemn us not, and that we have confidence or boldness to approach God, we are assured, by John and our Lord, that we shall have or receive whatever we earnestly ask in His name, Joh 15:7.
2) “Because we keep his commandments,” keeping or (teroumen) – guarding His commandments, is another ground for assurance of answered prayer; Joh 14:15.
3) “And do those things that are pleasing in his sight. God delights in blessing His children in their ways of obedience, and answering their petitions. 1Ch 7:12-15; Jas 5:14-18.
HOW BRAINERD PRAYED
No sublimer story has been recorded in earthly annals than that of David Brainerd. No miracle attests, with diviner force, the truth of Christianity than the life and work of this godly man. Alone in the savage wilds of America, struggling day and night with a mortal disease, unschooled in the care of souls, having access to the Indians for a large portion of time only through the bungling medium of a pagan interpreter, with the Word of God in his heart and in his hand, his soul fired with the divine flame, a place and time to pour out his heart and soul to God in prayer, he fully established the worship of God and secured great results. After spending a whole week in prayer he spoke with such power that countless numbers of the Indians were led to yield their lives to God. The Indians were changed from the lowest besotments of heathenism, to pure, devout, intelligent Christians.
Brainerd lived a life of holiness and prayer: by day and by night he prayed. Before preaching and after preaching he prayed. Riding through the interminable solitudes of the forest he prayed. On his bed of straw he prayed. Morning noon and night he communed with God. Little wonder he had such power -God was with him mightily because he lived in the presence of God.
– Gospel Herald
Fuente: Garner-Howes Baptist Commentary
22 And whatsoever we ask These two things are connected, confidence and prayer. As before he shewed that an evil conscience is inconsistent with confidence, so now he declares that none can really pray to God but those who with a pure heart, fear and rightly worship him. The latter follows from the former. It is a general truth taught in Scripture, that the ungodly are not heard by God, but that on the contrary, their sacrifices and prayers are an abomination to him. Hence the door is here closed up against hypocrites, lest they should in contempt of him rush into his presence.
He does not yet mean that a good conscience must be brought, as though it obtained favor to our prayers. Woe to us if we look on works, which have nothing in them but what is a cause of fear and trembling. The faithful, then, cannot otherwise come to God’s tribunal than by relying on Christ the Mediator. But as the love of God is ever connected with faith, the Apostle, in order that he might the more severely reprove hypocrites, deprives them of that singular privilege with which God favors his own children; that is, lest they should think that their prayers have an access to God.
By saying, because we keep his commandments, he means not that confidence in prayer is founded on our works; but he teaches this only, that true religion and the sincere worship of God cannot be separated from faith. Nor ought it to appear strange that he uses a causal particle, though he does not speak of a cause; for an inseparable addition is sometimes mentioned as a cause as when one says, Because the sun shines over us at midday, there is more heat; but it does not follow that heat comes from light.
Fuente: Calvin’s Complete Commentary
22. And We feel full access in prayer.
Whatsoever In this frame of sweet accord with God we ask, we receive. That spirit of accord will, indeed, circumscribe our ask within the limits of God’s will that we should have. And the Spirit grants delightful contentment and resignation to our lot within that blessed sphere.
Keep his commandments For without this objective test no subjective assurance is genuine. Our apostle gives no comfort to a mere emotional self-gratulation which is not confirmed by the volitional and active keeping and doing the positive commandments, that is, doing in all respects what is conscientious and right. The old Mosaic decalogue is not repealed in our behalf. The emotionalism that repeals the commandments is antinomianism.
Fuente: Whedon’s Commentary on the Old and New Testaments
1Jn 3:22. Whatsoever we ask, we receive of him, There are four conditions on which men may expect to have their prayers heard: First, If they pray for things agreeable to the will of God; that is, for things in themselves truly good and proper. See ch. 1Jn 5:14-15. Secondly, If they pray in a right manner, or with a right temper and disposition of mind; that is, with faith in the atoning Blood, and in the wisdom, goodness, power, and over-ruling providence of God; with humility and resignation to the Divine will, with importunity, patience, and perseverance: Thirdly, If they pray for a good end, or with a design to make a right use of mercies when bestowed: Fourthly, and above all, If they be real Christians, and of course keep the commandments of God, and do those things which are pleasing in his sight. In this verse, St. John assigns another reason forcultivating universal righteousness, and particularly mutual love; namely, that then their prayers would be heard, and God would grant them all proper blessings.
Fuente: Commentary on the Holy Bible by Thomas Coke
1Jn 3:22 . By the following is closely connected with the preceding, inasmuch as it states what further happens when, in consequence of non-condemnation on the part of the heart, the exists; it is not merely the consciousness of the hearing of our prayers, but it is this hearing itself.
] is to be taken quite generally, and must not be spoiled by arbitrary limitations; the necessary limitation lies, on the one hand, in the subject itself: the child of God asks for nothing which is contrary to his Father’s will, comp. 1Jn 5:14 ; and, on the other hand, in the with which he prays; comp. Mat 21:22 ; the contrary in Jas 1:6-7 .
] i.e. . The present is not used instead of the future (Grotius); the subject is here not something future, but what constantly occurs in the life of believers. Augustine suitably says: Charitas ipsa gemit, charitas ipsa orat, contra hanc aures claudere non novit, qui illam dedit.
. . .] is connected with the immediately preceding , and states the ground of God’s manifestation of love in the hearing of prayer; this ground, which, however, is not to be regarded as the causa meritoria, is the childlike obedience of him who prays, wherein God recognises him as His child; the idea of obedience is expressed in two mutually co-ordinate sentences (similar to the Hebrew parallelism): and are synonymous; [248] by the obedience is specified as active; the second clause indicates that it consists, not in a slavish subjection to the commandment , but in a childlike fulfilment of that which is pleasing to God. In Joh 8:29 , is construed with the dative; only in Act 6:2 ; Act 12:3 is the word besides found; similar is the expression: (1Ti 5:4 ).
[248] Meyer actually thinks that by are meant the so-called consilia evangelica, by which ordinary Christians are not bound, but which are voluntarily undertaken by Christians who are specially holy!
Fuente: Heinrich August Wilhelm Meyer’s New Testament Commentary
22 And whatsoever we ask, we receive of him, because we keep his commandments, and do those things that are pleasing in his sight.
Ver. 22. And whatsoever we ask ] sc. According to his will. Fiat voluntas mea, quia tua, said Luther. I can have what I will of God, said one; for my will shall be concentric with his will.
Because we keep ] The obedience of faith emboldens us; yet may no man say as the prodigal, “Give me the portion that belongeth to me.” It was a proud speech of that emperor (Antonin. Philo.) that said, Non sic Deum coluimus, aut sic viximus, ut ille nos vinceret, We have not so served God, that the enemy should overcome us. It was much worse in that arrogant Papist that said, God forbid that we should enjoy heaven as of alms to us; no, we have it by purchase or conquest.
Fuente: John Trapp’s Complete Commentary (Old and New Testaments)
ask. App-134.
of. App-104., but the texts read apo (App-104.)
keep. See Mat 19:17.
pleasing. Greek. arestos. See Act 6:2 (reason).
Fuente: Companion Bible Notes, Appendices and Graphics
whatsoever: 1Jo 5:14, Psa 10:17, Psa 34:4, Psa 34:15-17, Psa 50:15, Psa 66:18, Psa 66:19, Psa 145:18, Psa 145:19, Pro 15:29, Pro 28:9, Isa 1:15, Isa 55:6, Isa 55:7, Jer 29:12, Jer 29:13, Jer 33:3, Mat 7:7, Mat 7:8, Mat 21:22, Mar 11:24, Luk 11:9-13, Joh 9:31, Joh 14:13, Joh 15:7, Joh 16:23, Joh 16:24, Jam 1:5, Jam 5:16
because: 1Jo 3:23, 1Jo 3:24, Mat 7:24, Mat 7:25, Mat 17:5, Joh 15:10, Act 17:30, Act 20:21
do: Joh 6:29, Joh 8:29, Joh 9:31, Phi 4:18, Col 1:10, Heb 13:21
Reciprocal: Lev 19:37 – General 2Ki 20:3 – in truth Psa 78:7 – keep Psa 99:7 – kept Pro 16:7 – please Pro 19:16 – keepeth the Isa 38:3 – I have Isa 58:9 – shalt thou Eze 18:11 – that Mat 18:19 – That if Mar 3:35 – do Luk 8:21 – which Rom 8:8 – please Rom 8:27 – according 1Co 7:19 – but Phi 4:9 – do 1Th 4:1 – to please Heb 10:22 – in full Heb 11:5 – that he Jam 4:3 – and 1Jo 2:3 – if we 1Jo 5:2 – General
Fuente: The Treasury of Scripture Knowledge
1Jn 3:22. Because we keep his commandments is the condition on which we will receive what we ask. Keeping the commandments includes the obligation of consulting the scriptures to learn what would be right for us to receive. It also includes our doing the things that please Him.
Fuente: Combined Bible Commentary
Observe here, 1. An extraordinary favour and privilege insured, Whatsoever we ask, we receive of him; that is, whatsoever we ask according to his will, we are sure to receive, either in kind or in equivalency. It shall either be given in mercy, or denied in love; for verily God is as kind in denying some of our requests, as in answering others; we often cry for that which it would be cruelty for God to give; we know not what is best to beg, but an infinitely wise God knoweth what is fittest to give. Dat pre jocundis aptissima.
Observe, 2. The qualification of the persons to whom this precious privilege does belong. They keep God’s commandments, and do the things that please him. According to our hearing God’s commandments, so he hears and answers our prayers; with what measure we mete to God, God will measure to us again. If God’s commands be trod under our feet, no wonder that all our prayers fall to the ground. God hears not us, if we hear not him. If we keep his commandments, whatsoever we ask, we receive of him.
Fuente: Expository Notes with Practical Observations on the New Testament
3:22 {22} And whatsoever we ask, we receive of him, because we keep his commandments, and do those things that are pleasing in his sight.
(22) The conclusion, that faith in Christ and love one towards another are things joined together, and therefore the outward testimonies of sanctification must and do answer that inward testimony of the Spirit given to us.