Exegetical and Hermeneutical Commentary of 2 Kings 5:26

And he said unto him, Went not mine heart [with thee], when the man turned again from his chariot to meet thee? [Is it] a time to receive money, and to receive garments, and oliveyards, and vineyards, and sheep, and oxen, and menservants, and maidservants?

26. Went not mine heart with thee] The Hebrew has nothing to represent the last two words, as will be seen from the italics both of A.V. and R.V. But the rendering is that of the LXX., and is probably correct. The verb takes up that which Gehazi had used, ‘Thy servant went no whither’. On a former occasion Elisha in Gehazi’s presence (2Ki 4:27) had said of some event ‘the Lord hath not told me’, but now he finds that in spirit his master had been with him, and was aware of all that had occurred.

Is it a time to receive money ] The opportunity of Naaman’s visit had been used by Elisha to direct the thoughts of the heathen officer to Jehovah alone as the healer of his disease. Hence he had never shewn himself to Naaman till the cure was complete, and had steadily refused any present lest it should be thought that he deemed himself in any way instrumental in the recovery. Such conduct must have impressed Naaman greatly, and now Gehazi has done his best to obliterate the impression. In the enumeration of all the grand possessions which the ill-gotten talents were to purchase Elisha shews Gehazi that he has been reading all his thoughts.

Fuente: The Cambridge Bible for Schools and Colleges

Went not mine heart with thee? – i. e. Was I not with thee in spirit – did I not see the whole transaction, as if I had been present at it? He uses the verb went, because Gehazi has just denied his going.

Is it a time … – i. e. Was this a proper occasion to indulge greed, when a Gentile was to be favorably impressed, and made to feel that the faith of the Israelites was the only true religion? Was it not, on the contrary, an occasion for the exhibition of the greatest unselfishness, that so a pagan might be won to the truth?

And oliveyards and vineyards … – Gehazis thoughts had probably run on to the disposition which he would make of his wealth, and the prophet here follows them, enumerating his servants intended purchases.

Fuente: Albert Barnes’ Notes on the Bible

Verse 26. Went not mine heart with thee] The Chaldee gives this a good turn: By the prophetic spirit it was shown unto me, when the man returned from his chariot to meet thee.

Is it a time to receive money] He gave him farther proof of this all-discerning prophetic spirit in telling him what he designed to do with the money; he intended to set up a splendid establishment, to have men-servants and maid-servants, to have oliveyards and vineyards, and sheep and oxen, This, as the Chaldee says, he had thought in his heart to do.

Fuente: Adam Clarke’s Commentary and Critical Notes on the Bible

Went not mine heart with thee? did not my mind. being enlightened by Gods Spirit, discern what thou saidst and didst?

Is it a time? was this a fit season for this action? I had but newly and obstinately refused his gifts, for great reasons; of which See Poole “2Ki 5:16“; and now thou hast given him cause to think that I was a cursed and wicked impostor, who vain-gloriously refused in public what I inwardly and greedily desired, and sought only a fitter place and opportunity to take; and that all our religion is but an imposture; and that the God who owns such a vile wretch for his prophet, as thou hast represented me to him, is not so holy and righteous as we pretend.

Garments, and oliveyards, & c.; which Gehazi intended to purchase with this money; and therefore the prophet names them, to inform him that he exactly knew by Divine inspiration, not only Gehazis outward actions, but even his most secret intentions.

Fuente: English Annotations on the Holy Bible by Matthew Poole

And he said unto him, went not mine heart with thee?…. Did my heart or knowledge go from me, that what thou hast done should be hid from me? so Ben Gersom and others; or my heart did not go with thee, it was contrary to my mind and will what thou didst; so Abendana; or rather, as the Targum, by a spirit of prophecy it was shown unto me, c. I knew full well what thou wentest for, and hast done and so Maimonides y; was not I employed in my thoughts? or, did I not think that so it was as thou hast done? I did:

when the man turned again from chariot to meet thee? meaning Naaman the Syrian:

is it a time to receive money, and to receive garments: as Gehazi had now done:

and oliveyards, and vineyards, and sheep and oxen, and menservants, and maidservants? that is, to purchase those with the two talents of silver he had received, as he thought in his heart, or intended to do, as the Targum; or had given orders to purchase such for him to the persons to whom he had committed the care of them in the tower; this was not a proper time, when the honour of the prophet, and the credit of religion, and the good of this man, as a new proselyte, were in danger thereby.

y Moreh Nevochim, par. 1. c. 39.

Fuente: John Gill’s Exposition of the Entire Bible

(26) Went not mine heart . . . meet thee?Rather, Nor did my heart (i.e., consciousness) go away, when a man turned (and alighted) from his chariot to meet thee. The prophet, in severe irony, adopts Gehazis own phrase: Maurer, Non abierat animus meus; I was there in spirit, and witnessed everything. The sentence has given the commentators much trouble. (See the elaborate Note in Thenius. We might have expected wl, and w may have been omitted, owing to the preceding w; but it is not absolutely necessary.) The Authorised Version follows the LXX. (Vat.), which supplies the expression with thee ( ), wanting in the Hebrew text. The Targum paraphrases: By the spirit of prophecy I was informed when the man turned, &c. The Syriac follows with, My heart informed me when the man turned, &c.

Is it a time to receive.Comp. Ecc. 3:2, seq. The LXX., pointing the Hebrew differently, reads: . (And now thou receivedst the money, &c.). So also the Vulg. and Arabic, but not the Targum and Syriac. Bttcher, retaining the interrogative particle of the Hebrew, adopts this: Didst thou then take the money? &c. But the Masoretic pointing appears to be much more suitable. The prophets question comes to this: Was that above all others a proper occasion for yielding to your desire of gain, when you were dealing with a heathen? Ought you not to have been studiously disinterested in your behaviour to such an one, that he might learn not to confound the prophets of Jehovah with the mercenary diviners and soothsayers of the false gods? The prophets disciple is bound, like his master, to seek, not worldly power, but spiritual; for the time is one of ardent struggle against the encroachments of paganism.

And oliveyards . . . maidservants?The prophet develops Gehazis object in asking for the money: he wished to purchase lands, and live stock, and slaveswhatever constituted the material wealth of the time. The Targum inserts the explanatory: And thou thoughtest in thy heart to purchase oliveyards, &c. So Vulg.: ut emas oliveta.

Fuente: Ellicott’s Commentary for English Readers (Old and New Testaments)

26. Went not mine heart with thee Elisha, by Divine revelation, was enabled to see all Gehazi’s actions and read the wickedness of his heart. So Peter, in the case of Ananias and Sapphira. Act 5:1-11.

Is it a time to receive money Shall we, by covetousness, identify ourselves with the corrupt and lying priests and prophets who bring dishonour on Jehovah’s name, and on the holy office, by receiving, with avaricious grasp, money and garments and cattle and servants? However right and proper in itself it might be for priests or prophets to receive such gifts under ordinary circumstances, the times then forbade. Such gifts had in Israel become so associated with priestly covetousness and venality that it behooved the true prophet to decline them.

Fuente: Whedon’s Commentary on the Old and New Testaments

2Ki 5:26. Went not mine heart with thee, &c.? Was not I present with thee in mind, when the man, &c.?Thou hast indeed taken money, with which thou mayest buy gardens, and olive-yards, &c. Houbigant.

Fuente: Commentary on the Holy Bible by Thomas Coke

2Ki 5:26 And he said unto him, Went not mine heart [with thee], when the man turned again from his chariot to meet thee? [Is it] a time to receive money, and to receive garments, and oliveyards, and vineyards, and sheep, and oxen, and menservants, and maidservants?

Ver. 26. Went not mine heart with thee? ] Was not all the transaction revealed as really and clearly unto me, as if I had been there bodily present?

Is it a time to receive money? ] Giving is kind, and taking is courteous: and both may at some times and in some cases be done without sin. There is much use of godly discretion, doubtless, in directing us when to open, when to shut our hands.

And oliveyards and vineyards? ] The purchase of all which Gehazi was now busily meditating with his two talents.

Fuente: John Trapp’s Complete Commentary (Old and New Testaments)

Went not . . . ? Figure of speech Erotesis. = Did not my heart beat?

Fuente: Companion Bible Notes, Appendices and Graphics

he said: Psa 63:11, Pro 12:19, Pro 12:22, Act 5:9

Went: 2Ki 6:12, 1Co 5:3, Col 2:5

Is it a time: 2Ki 5:16, Gen 14:23, Ecc 3:1-8, Mat 10:8, Act 20:33, Act 20:35, 1Co 9:11, 1Co 9:12, 2Co 11:8-12, 2Th 3:8, 2Th 3:9

Reciprocal: Jos 7:11 – dissembled 1Ki 13:8 – go 1Ki 21:17 – General 2Ki 6:32 – ere the messenger 2Ki 7:9 – some mischief will come upon us 2Ki 20:14 – What said Psa 101:7 – He that worketh Pro 10:22 – he Ecc 3:6 – time to get Jer 35:9 – General Jer 45:5 – seekest Dan 5:17 – Let Mat 24:48 – say Mar 14:11 – and promised Joh 4:19 – I perceive Act 8:20 – Thy Act 8:31 – And he 1Th 2:17 – in presence

Fuente: The Treasury of Scripture Knowledge

2Ki 5:26. Went not my heart with thee? &c. Was not I present with thee in mind, when the man, &c. Is it a time to receive money? &c. Was this a fit season for this action? I had but just refused his gifts, and that obstinately, for important reasons; and now thou hast given him cause to think that this was done in mere vain-glory, and that I inwardly desired, and sought only a fitter place and opportunity, to take secretly in private what I refused in public; thus bringing reproach on our religion, and on the God we worship. And olive-yards, &c. Which Gehazi intended to purchase with this money; and therefore the prophet names them, to inform him that he exactly knew, not only his outward actions, but even his most secret intentions. What a folly is it to presume upon sin in hopes of secrecy! When thou goest aside into any by-path, doth not thy own conscience go with thee? Nay, doth not the eye of God go with thee? What then avails the absence of human witnesses?

Fuente: Joseph Bensons Commentary on the Old and New Testaments

5:26 And he said unto him, {n} Went not mine heart [with thee], when the man turned again from his chariot to meet thee? [Is it] a time to receive money, and to receive garments, and {o} oliveyards, and vineyards, and sheep, and oxen, and menservants, and maidservants?

(n) Was I not present with you in spirit?

(o) That is, money to buy possessions with: meaning that it is detestable in the servants of God to have covetous minds.

Fuente: Geneva Bible Notes