Exegetical and Hermeneutical Commentary of Amos 4:8

So two [or] three cities wandered unto one city, to drink water; but they were not satisfied: yet have ye not returned unto me, saith the LORD.

8. wandered &c.] would totter but would not be satisfied: the frequentative tenses are continued. Eastern cities are dependent largely for their water upon underground cisterns in which the rain is collected and stored; but the quantity thus supplied in the more fortunate city would not suffice for the wants of so many more than its normal inhabitants. The word rendered wander means properly to move with an unsteady, uncertain gait, to totter; it is thus used of one drunken (Isa 24:20; Isa 29:9, Psa 107:27 [R.V. stagger ]), or blind (Lam 4:14), or, as Psa 59:15 and here, of one exhausted for want of food (cf. of beggars, Psa 109:10). Cf. ch. Amo 8:12. For droughts in Palestine, cf. Deu 11:17; Deu 28:22 ; 1Ki 8:35; 1Ki 17:1 ff.; Jer 3:3; Jer 14:2-6; Hag 1:10 f.

Fuente: The Cambridge Bible for Schools and Colleges

Two or three cities wandered into one city – Those then who were punished, were more than those who were reprieved. The word wandered literally, trembled, expresses the unsteady reeling gate of those exhausted, in quest of food . They staggered through weakness, and uncertain, amid the general drought, whither to betake themselves. This was done, not in punishment but to heal. God paused, in order to give them opportunity to repent; in deed, His long-suffering only showed to themselves and to others, that they would not; and ye returned not not Me; saith the Lord.

Fuente: Albert Barnes’ Notes on the Bible

Two or three, a certain for an uncertain number,

cities, the places for the inhabitants, by a usual metonymy,

wandered unto one city to drink water: it seems to imply that they travelled at some uncertainty, as they do who wander and rove about. It is not unlikely but that in the prophets times the story might be well known and fresh in memory, though here no mention is made of these cities.

But they were not satisfied; either that city they went to had not enough for them, or durst not part with it; or, though they quenched their thirst, yet because they must return back to their own dry and waterless cities, or because God withdrew his blessing, they were never the better, or else not much or long the better.

Yet have ye not returned unto me: see Amo 4:6.

Fuente: English Annotations on the Holy Bible by Matthew Poole

8. three cities wanderedthatis, the inhabitants of three cities (compare Jer14:1-6). GROTIUSexplains this verse and Am 4:7,”The rain fell on neighboring countries, but not on Israel,which marked the drought to be, not accidental, but the specialjudgment of God.” The Israelites were obliged to leave theircities and homes to seek water at a distance [CALVIN].

Fuente: Jamieson, Fausset and Brown’s Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible

So two [or] three cities wandered unto one city, to drink water,…. Two or three cities, that is, the inhabitants of them, being without water, went up and down in quest of any city or place where they could find water for themselves and cattle to drink:

but they were not satisfied; could not get enough for their present use and much less to carry back with them to supply them for any length of time; such a scarcity there was of it in other parts; see 1Ki 18:5;

yet have ye not returned unto me, saith the Lord; this had no more effect upon them than the other to relinquish their former courses, and return unto the Lord by humiliation and repentance.

Fuente: John Gill’s Exposition of the Entire Bible

Marking the difference, the Prophet relates, that two or three cities had come to one, to seek drink, and that they were not satisfied, because the waters failed on account of so large a number: for though the fountains could have supplied the inhabitants, yet when such a multitude flowed from every quarter, the very fountains became exhausted. The Prophet thus aggravates the punishment brought by God on the Israelites; for so great was the thirst, that whole cities had recourse to fountains, where they heard that there was any water. It was indeed an unusual thing for inhabitants to leave their own city and to run to another to seek water, like wild beasts who, when satiated with prey, run far for water: but it is an unwonted thing for men to undertake a long journey for the sake of finding drink: for they dig wells for themselves, and seek water by their own industry, when rivers do not flow, or when fountains do not supply them with drink. When therefore men are forced to leave their own homes and to seek water at a distance, and when they exhaust the fountains, it is a portend which ought to be observed.

But how was it that the Israelites took no notice of God’s hand, which was then as it were visible? Hence then, as they repented not, their obstinate blindness became quite evident. They were no doubt terrified with fear and harassed by grief; but all this produced no effect, for they continued in their sins, took delight in their own superstitions, and pursued the same life as before. Since then they divested not themselves of their own character, nor ceased to provoke continually the wrath of God, their hopeless and incorrigible obstinacy is here manifestly proved. This was the Prophet’s design. It follows —

Fuente: Calvin’s Complete Commentary

Amo 4:8 So two [or] three cities wandered unto one city, to drink water; but they were not satisfied: yet have ye not returned unto me, saith the LORD.

Ver. 8. So two or three cities wandered ] Necessity is a hard weapon: and want of water will make men wander far and part with anything for it; as Lysimachus did with his kingdom, sacrificing his estate to the service of his life. Oh that we were as solicitous for our souls! Those good souls, Psa 84:7 , went “from strength to strength,” travelled many a mile to see God’s face, though but in that dark glass of the ceremonies. The good Shunammite went every sabbath and new moon to the prophet. Our forefathers were unweariable in making out after the means, which we vilipend, and make no reckoning of.

To drink water ] Rain water; for in those countries (as Jerome testifieth, who lived there many years, and therefore knew the situation and nature thereof) they have but few springs, and no considerable rivers, but only Jordan; and are therefore glad to keep rain water in cisterns for all uses; being much afflicted with thirst and drought, if it rain not.

But they were not satisfied ] Either because there was not enough to be had; or by a singular curse of unsatisfiableness, see Hag 1:6 . See Trapp on “ Hag 1:6 “

Yet have ye not returned unto me ] Usque ad me, so far as me. You have made some faint overtures and essays of returning, but they have not reached out unto me; they have not amounted to the full measure of a sound conversion. Plectimur, may you well say, nec tamen flectimur: corripimur, sed non corrigimur (Salvian). God rained not upon us that we might return unto him, and learn righteousness, Isa 26:10 , that we might pour out a prayer when his chastening was upon us, Isa 26:16 ; Isa 26:18 . But we, alas, have done nothing less; “we have turned every one to his own way”; and done what in us lies to defeat God and undo ourselves by our incorrigibleness and uncurableness.

Fuente: John Trapp’s Complete Commentary (Old and New Testaments)

two: 1Ki 18:5, Isa 41:17, Isa 41:18, Jer 14:3

but: Eze 4:16, Mic 6:14, Hag 1:6

yet: Amo 4:6, Amo 4:9-11, Jer 23:14, Hos 7:10

Reciprocal: Lev 26:4 – Then I Psa 107:33 – watersprings Isa 30:23 – shall he Hos 11:5 – because Amo 1:2 – the habitations Hag 2:17 – yet Zec 14:17 – even

Fuente: The Treasury of Scripture Knowledge

Amo 4:8. The scarcity of drinking water is indicated by the fact that the citizens of several cities would consume all the supply in one of the more favored ones, and even then their thirst was not satisfied. What made the condition more deplorable was the fact that none of these chastisements brought the rebellious people to re-pentance.

Fuente: Combined Bible Commentary

4:8 So two [or] three cities wandered unto one city, to drink water; but they were {k} not satisfied: yet have ye not returned unto me, saith the LORD.

(k) They could not find enough water where they had heard that it had rained.

Fuente: Geneva Bible Notes