Exegetical and Hermeneutical Commentary of Daniel 11:35
And [some] of them of understanding shall fall, to try them, and to purge, and to make [them] white, [even] to the time of the end: because [it is] yet for a time appointed.
35. And some of them that be wise ( Dan 11:33) shall fall, to refine among them (among the people at large), and to cleanse, and to make white ] The martyrdom of some of the godly leaders in the struggle would have the effect of testing the faith of the people at large, and of confirming and perfecting the character of those who were loyal. Cf. Dan 12:10.
to refine ] the word means properly to smelt gold or silver ore (or alloy), so as to free the noble metal from impurities; it is then often used figuratively, sometimes of testing, sometimes of purifying, by severe discipline: cf. Isa 1:25, ‘and smelt away as with lye thy dross’; Jer 6:29, ‘in vain the smelter smelteth, for the evil are not separated’; Dan 9:6 ‘Behold, I will smelt them, and try them’; Zec 13:9.
1. Silver Tetradrachm. Head of Antiochus, with diadem (in other coins of this type a star is seen distinctly on the forehead: Babelon, Les Rois de Syrie, xii. 3, 4).
Reverse: Apollo, seated on omphalos, holding arrow and bow. Inscription: (‘Of King Antiochus’).
2. Silver Drachm. Head of Antiochus, radiate.
Reverse: Eagle, with closed wings, standing on thunderbolt. Inscription: (‘Of King Anthichus, God Manifest’).
3. Silver Tetradrachm. Head of Anthiochus, as Zeus, with laurels.
Reverse: Zeus, wearing himation over shoulder, seated on throne: holds Nike (Victory), who crowns Inscription; and rests on sceptre. Inscription: (‘Of King Antiochus, God Manifest, Victory-bearer’).
4. Copper Pentechalcon. Head of Zeus-Serapis, wearing laurel-wreath, ending above in cap of Osiris.
Reverse: Eagle, with closed wings, standing on thunderbolt. Inscription: (‘Of King Antiochus, God Manifest’). This coin was struck in Egypt, and illustrates Antiochus’ conquest of that country (cf. Babelon, p. c).
(From casts taken from coins in the British Museum. The descriptions from Gardner’s Coins of the Seleucid Kings of Syria, xi. 2, xii. 13, xi. 9, xii. 11.)
until the time of the end ] the fall of the masklm will continue till the final end of the present order of things (Dan 8:17), which the author pictures as coinciding with the close of Antiochus’ reign ( Dan 11:40).
for (it is) yet for the time appointed ] the end has not come yet; it has still to wait for the moment fixed in the counsels of God: cf. Dan 11:27 end.
Fuente: The Cambridge Bible for Schools and Colleges
And some of them understanding shall fall – Some of those who have a correct understanding of religion, and who have joined the army from pure motives. The idea seems to be that on some occasion they would meet with a temporary defeat, in order that the sincerity of the others might be tested, or that it might be seen who adhered to the cause from principle, and who from selfish purposes. If they should not always be successful; if they should be temporarily defeated; if some of the most eminent among them should fall among the slain; and if the cause should at any time look dark, this would serve to try the sin cerity of the remainder of the army, and would be likely to thin it off of those who had joined it only from mercenary motives.
To try them – Margin, or, by them. So the Hebrew – bahem. The meaning perhaps is, that it would be by them, as it were, that the army would be tried. As they would fall in battle, and as the cause would seem to be doubtful, this would test the fidelity of others. The word try here ( tsaraph) means, properly, to melt, to smelt – as metals; then to prove anyone; and then to purify.
And to purge – To purify; to test the army and to make it pure.
And to make them white – To wit, by thus allowing those who had joined the army from mercenary motives to withdraw. Compare 2 Macc. 12:39-41.
Even to the time of the end – The end of the war or the conflict. There would be an end of these persecutions and trials, and this process had reference to that, or tended to bring it about. The act of freeing the army from false friends – from those who had joined it from mercenary motives, would have a tendency to accomplish the result in the best way possible, and in the speediest manner.
Because it is yet for a time appointed – See the notes at Dan 11:27. This seems to be designed for an assurance that the calamity would come to an end, or that there was a limit beyond which it could not pass. Thus it would be an encouragement to those who were engaged in the struggle, for they would see that success must ultimately crown their labors.
Fuente: Albert Barnes’ Notes on the Bible
Verse 35. And some of them of understanding] Disputes on certain points of religion soon agitated the Christian Church; and now, having no outward persecution, they began to persecute each other. And many excellent men, men of understanding, fell victims because they would not embrace erroneous doctrines, when professed by the state. But this was permitted,-
To try them, and to purge, and to make them white] To bring all to the pure profession, possession, and practice of Christianity.
To the time of the end] To the time that God shall cause pure and undefiled religion every where to prevail. But when is the time appointed for this?
Fuente: Adam Clarke’s Commentary and Critical Notes on the Bible
To try them: we see hereby that the best of men have some dross, which makes afflictions, yea, fiery trials, necessary for them, for the word signifies all kind of examination and trials, either as founders try metals to purge them, or as corn is winnowed to cleanse it from chaff, or as fullers that wash and scour to take out spots, Mal 3:1-3.
Even to the time of the end: now mark here the Spirit of God seems to slide into the Roman monarchy, for this began in the reign of Antiochus, so that he did begin that which the Romans afterward in process of time acted more highly against the Jews and Christians too. For Antiochus is made by all a type of antichrist; as Maldonate confesseth. And thus you find the prophets, and our Saviour too. David brings in Christ; Psa 72:8, when the rest is spoken of Solomon. So Psa 16; Isa 49; Isa 44; Isa 60. So our Saviour, speaking of the temple, speaks with it of the end of the word. And thus the end of this chapter is clearly of antichrist, and this prophecy of Daniel cads with the worlds end. Therefore Antiochus is a type of antichrist, in his pride, covetousness, craft, and cruelty against the people of God, and blasphemies and idolatries to the reproach of Christ. Therefore it is here added,
because it is yet for a time appointed.
Fuente: English Annotations on the Holy Bible by Matthew Poole
35. to try themthe design ofaffliction. Image from metals tried with fire.
to purgeEven in theelect there are dregs which need to be purged out (1Pe1:7). Hence they are allowed to fall for a time; not finally(2Ch 32:31; Luk 22:31).Image from wheat cleared of its chaff by the wind.
make . . . whiteimagefrom cloth (Re 7:9).
to . . . time of . . .endGod will not suffer His people to be persecuted withoutlimitation (1Co 10:13). Thegodly are to wait patiently for “the end” of “thetime” of trial; “for it is (to last) yet for a timeappointed” by God.
Fuente: Jamieson, Fausset and Brown’s Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible
And some of them of understanding shall fall,…. Not into sin, or from the religion they profess; and the doctrines they have an understanding of, and have instructed others in; but into distresses and calamities for their steadfast adherence to the word, worship, and ordinances of God:
to try them, and purge and make them white; to try their faith, patience, and other graces, and whether they would hold fast their profession, and persevere in the good ways of God; and to purge and separate them from others, that were like chaff, hypocrites, that so they might be manifest, both the one and the other; and these good men appear to be sincere and upright: moreover, the best of men have their dross, and chaff, and spots, to be removed from them; and this is one way of doing it, even by afflictions: the allusion, in the first word, is to the melting, purifying, and refining of metals, gold and silver; the second to the winnowing of a grain floor, and separating the chaff from the wheat; and the third to the cleansing and whitening of cloths, and taking the spots out of them by the fuller. Afflictions are the furnace in which the Lord refines and purifies his people; the fan with which he purges his floor; and the fuller’s soap with which he makes his people white; by all this the iniquity of Jacob is purged, and the fruit of it is to take away sin, Isa 27:9, so that afflictions are not hurtful, but beneficial to the saints, even those more violent ones, severe persecutions.
Even to the time of the end; because it is yet for a time appointed; these distresses, calamities, and persecutions, would have an end, and the time for it was appointed of God; as yet it was not come, but quickly would, and then an end would be put to the third or Grecian monarchy; a hint of the Roman power over that being given, Da 11:30, hence we have no further account of Antiochus or his sons. Very remarkable are the words of Aemilius Sara m,
“the Assyrians first were possessors of monarchy; then the Medes; afterwards the Persians; then the Macedonians; from that time the kings, Philip and Antiochus, who sprung from the Macedonians, being conquered, not long after Carthage was subdued, the supreme power of empire came to the Roman people;”
of whom, under one character or another, the following part of the prophecy is chiefly to be understood. So another historian says n, Antiochus being drove out of Asia, the Romans first set footing there; and another o observes, that Antiochus being defeated by L. Cornelius Scipio, he took the name of Asiaticus, because he had conquered Asia; as his brother was called Africanus, from his subduing Africa: wherefore Asia and Africa being now in the hands of the Romans, the supreme power might well be said to be with them; and therefore, henceforward, are only spoken of, and particularly the Roman antichrist.
m De annis populi Romani apud Velleii Paterculi Hist. Roman. l. 1. c. 6. n “Festi Breviarium, prope initium”. o Eutropii Hist. Rom. l. 4. So Plutarch. in Vita Scipionis Africani.
Fuente: John Gill’s Exposition of the Entire Bible
The angel pursues the same sentiment as before shewing us how the children of God, in their eagerness to defend the cause of piety, should be subject to many grievous persecutions. Some of the learned shall fall; meaning, that calamity shall not be for a single moment only; for those who earnestly desired to defend the true worship of God should perish by the sword, and by fire, and by other methods of destruction, and their successors, too, should suffer the same calamities. The phrase, the learned should fall, implies the perishing of the very flower of the Church. There will always be much refuse among a people, and the greater part of it flies off and revolts when their religion requires of them the sacrifice of their life. A few remain, here called intelligent, who, as we stated yesterday, are not wise after the flesh. Making provision for the flesh, implies taking care of themselves, and of their own interests, running no risks, and avoiding all troubles; while those are called intelligent, who, forgetful of their own lives, offer themselves in sacrifice to God. They do not hesitate to incur universal hatred, and are prepared to meet death with fortitude. The angel, therefore, predicts the perishing of the flower of the Church. For who could have expected the name of God to have existed upon earth when all His sincere worshippers were thus murdered with impunity? The severity of the despotism of Antiochus is notorious, no one dared to utter a word, all the sacred books were burnt, and he thought the worship of God entirely abolished. Women with their children were promiscuously seized for burning, and the satellites of this tyrant did not spare the mothers with infants hanging on their breasts. (1Ma 1:0.) During the progress of such atrocious cruelty, who would not have thought the whole seed of God to have been extinct? But the angel here shews the true result to have been different, namely, that the sons of God should be purged, cleansed, and whitened He signifies that all events should not prove so destructive, but should rather promote their salvation. This passage unfolds to us the nature of true prudence in the sight of God; for we ought to be prepared for death, rather than be turned aside from the free and ingenuous profession of the heavenly doctrine, and from the true worship of God. For this necessity is imposed on the sons of God — to fall either by the sword or by fire, and to suffer the spoiling of their goods, and banishment from their homes. The angel points out from the result how persecutions which seem to issue in the destruction of the Church, are yet profitable and salutary to the sons of God, as This is the method of their being purified, and cleansed, and whitened But we must always remember how some defiling dregs, which require clearing out, remain in the elect, nay, even among the holy Martyrs. The angel does not here treat of hypocrites, or of ordinary believers, but of whatever is most conspicuous and most perfect in the Church, and yet asserts their need of purification. None, therefore, he concludes, possess such sanctity and purity as to prevent the remnant of some pollution which requires to be removed. Hence it becomes necessary for them to pass through the furnace, and to be purified like gold and silver. This is extended to all God’s martyrs.
This reminds us of the great folly of the Papists, in imagining the merits of saints to be transferred to us, as if they had more than they required for themselves. Indulgences, as they call them, depend upon this error, according to the following reasoning, — had Peter lived to the ordinary period of human life, he would have proved faithful to the end, and then would have merited the crown of the heavenly kingdom; but when he went beyond this, and poured out his blood in martyrdom, some merits were superabundant; these ought not to be lost, and hence the blood of Peter and Paul profit us at this day for the remission of sins. This is the Papal theology, and these miserable sophists are not ashamed of these gross blasphemies, while they vomit forth such foul sacrilege. But the angel’s teaching is far different; — the martyrs themselves are benefited by meeting death for their adherence to the truth, because God purges, and cleanses, and refines, and whitens them. The angel would not have said this except some admixture of dross still defiled the purity of the saints. But this doctrine ought to be more than enough to animate us to undergo all dangers, when we see ourselves stained and polluted with hidden dross; besides this, we ought certainly to determine that death would be profitable in this sense, as God will then purge us from those vices by which we are both infected and defiled. Whence the value of the repetition here; the angel does not simply say to purge them, but adds, to cleanse and whiten them. Whatever holiness may shine forth in the best of men, yet many stains and much defilement he concealed within them; and thus in consequence of their many failings, persecution was always useful to them.
The angel mitigates whatever might seem exceedingly bitter, by saying, until the time of an end, meaning, a fixed and definite time. These words imply the merciful character of God, in not urging his people beyond their strength, as Paul also states his faithfulness in granting them a happy issue out of their trials, and in not pressing’ us beyond the measure of that strength and fortitude which he has conferred upon us. (1Co 10:13.) The angel predicts an end to these evils, and confirms this opinion by saying, even to a determined time In the last clause he signified the temporary nature of the persecutions of which he had spoken; for they should not cease directly, nor yet for two or three years. By the words, as yet even to a time determined, he urges the sons of God to prepare themselves for new contests, as they should not reach the goal for the space of a year. But if God wished to humble them for three, or ten, or a hundred years, they should not despond, but wait for the time divinely predetermined, without depending on their own will. This is the substance of the instruction conveyed. It now follows:
Fuente: Calvin’s Complete Commentary
(35) Some of them.The reason of this persecution is revealed. Whilst in Dan. 11:33 it appears that the sufferings of those that understand would instruct others, it appears that they would themselves profit by their sufferings. These gradations are mentioned (1) to try i.e., to refine, as a precious metal is refined by fire; (2) to purge i.e., to separate the bad from the good; (3) to make whitei.e., to cause them to become completely purified. (Comp. Psa. 51:7; Isa. 1:18). In this way the dissemblers are made known. The patient example of the sufferers is followed by others who are faithful, while the flatterers become open apostates.
Fuente: Ellicott’s Commentary for English Readers (Old and New Testaments)
35. R.V., “And some of them that be wise shall fall, to refine them, and to purify, and to make them white, even to the time of the end: because it is yet for the time appointed.” Suffering and martyrdom are not proofs of God’s forgetfulness. This is the refining fire which comes “to test and purify” the saints. Blessed is he that shall endure to the end which end God knows and the time of which He has fixed.
Fuente: Whedon’s Commentary on the Old and New Testaments
Dan 11:35 And [some] of them of understanding shall fall, to try them, and to purge, and to make [them] white, [even] to the time of the end: because [it is] yet for a time appointed.
Ver. 35. And some of them of understanding shall fall. ] Depth of divine knowledge, and height of holiness, is no target against persecution; the best fall under it soonest. None out of hell have ever suffered more than saints.
To try them.
And to purge, and to make them white.
a Acts and Mon.
b A beetle or wooden ‘bat’ used in washing, also (when made cylindrical) for smoothing out or ‘mangling’ linen clothes; hence also applied to similarly shaped instruments, e.g. the paddle of a canoe, a utensil for inserting loaves into an oven, or glassware into the kiln, etc. D
c Acts and Mon., 1743.
d Dr Goodwin.
Fuente: John Trapp’s Complete Commentary (Old and New Testaments)
try = refine. Expulsion of dross.
purge = purify. Separation from dross.
the time of the end. Now near at hand.
Fuente: Companion Bible Notes, Appendices and Graphics
Dan 11:35
Dan 11:35 And some ofH4480 them of understandingH7919 shall fall,H3782 to tryH6884 them, and to purge,H1305 and to make them white,H3835 even toH5704 the timeH6256 of the end:H7093 becauseH3588 it is yetH5750 for a time appointed.H4150
Dan 11:35
And some of them of understanding shall fall, to try them, and to purge, and to make them white, even to the time of the end: because it is yet for a time appointed.
The forces against the faithful Jews appeared to be insurmountable. Many among them who had initially been faithful were persuaded by the promises of Antiochus IV to turn traitor. It must have been discouraging to see one’s relatives and friends being tortured and killed in the full scale war that had been launched against them by the Syrians. But there is another effect which takes place when one sees the staunch and deliberate resolve of faithful people who are willing to go to their deaths for their faith. One cannot behold the suffering and staunch faith of one’s family and countrymen without having feelings of guilt and remorse over their deaths. When we see here is the arousing of the national pride of apostate Jews who after witnessing the faith of their countrymen and their willingness to endure torture and death against all odds repented of their traitorous defection and rallied in support of the Jewish cause.
“even to the time of the end”
The Maccabees re-conquered Jerusalem in 165 BC and by December 164 BC, the temple had been purified and re-dedicated. Antiochus forces were now routed and defeated. He now was forced to make concessions to the now well-organized Jewish national resistance. Antiochus later died and was succeeded by six others to the time of Antiochus VII Sidetes (138-129 BC) and by this time following additional battles, the Jews became an independent state.
“because it is yet for a time appointed”
God is not going to allow this suffering to continue indefinitely. Keeping in mind that this is his faithful children who are suffering as a result of all this persecution. The purpose here being stated in the previous statement, the apostate Jews are either returning to the faith or being purged from their ranks. This vision by no means constitutes the first time Daniel has witnessed God’s workings in this manner. Daniel was a faithful Israelite caught up in a similar instance when he was imprisoned by Nebuchadnezzar during the overthrow and destruction of Judea in his lifetime. Daniel knew first hand that when God cleaned house, there could be grim and terrible consequences. Daniel, like everybody else had no choice but to remain faithful. Those who remain faithful will emerge triumphant in the end.
Fuente: Old and New Testaments Restoration Commentary
the time of the end
Here the prophetic foreview, having traced the history of the two parts of Alexander’s empire which had to do with Palestine and the Jews, viz. Syria and Egypt, to the time of Antiochus Epiphanes, and having described his career, overleaps the centuries to “the time of the end,” when he of whom Antiochus Epiphanes was a type, the “little horn” of Dan 7:8 the “Beast out of the sea” of Rev 13:4-10 shall appear (cf) (See Scofield “Dan 7:8”). Prophecy does not concern itself with history as such, but only with history as it affects Israel and the Holy Land. Antiochus Epiphanes was insignificant as compared with historical personages whom the Bible does not mention, but he scourged the covenant people and defiled God’s altar, thus coming into prophetic light. From Dan 11:36 the “little horn” of Dan 7:8; Dan 7:24-26 fills the scene. His prosperity lasts until “the indignation” (the “time of trouble” of; Dan 12:1; Mat 24:21 is accomplished (Dan 11:36). This is parallel with; Rev 17:10-14; Rev 19:19-21. Dan 11:37-45 supply details not mentioned in the N.T. The expression “God of his fathers” (Dan 11:37) has been held to indicate that the “king” is an apostate Jew, but this does not accord with Dan 9:26 which was fulfilled by the Gentile armies of Rome. The “little horn” is an apostate, but from Christianity, not Judaism (cf) 1Jn 2:18; 1Jn 2:19. Dan 11:38-45 describe his career. Substituting “the god of forces” (i.e. forces of nature) for the true God (Dan 11:38; Dan 11:39), he soon presents himself as that god (cf) 2Th 2:3; 2Th 2:4. While his career lasts he is an irresistible conqueror Dan 11:40-44). He established his palace in Jerusalem, probably at the time of his supreme act of blasphemous impiety; Dan 9:27; Dan 12:11; Mat 24:15; 2Th 2:4. From this time begins the great tribulation; Dan 12:1; Mat 24:21 which runs its course during the last half of Daniel’s seventieth week, viz. three and one half years; Dan 7:25; Dan 12:7; Dan 12:11; Rev 13:5. Scofield “Rev 19:20”.
Fuente: Scofield Reference Bible Notes
some: Dan 11:33, Dan 8:10, Mat 16:17, Mat 26:56, Mat 26:69-75, Joh 20:25, Act 13:13, Act 15:37-39
to try: Dan 12:10, Deu 8:2, Deu 8:3, Deu 8:16, 2Ch 32:31, Pro 17:3, Zec 13:9, Mal 3:2-4, Mal 4:1-3, Jam 1:2, 1Pe 1:6, 1Pe 1:7, Rev 2:10
them: or, by them
even: Dan 11:29, Dan 11:40, Dan 8:17, Dan 8:19, Dan 9:27, Dan 10:1, Dan 12:4, Dan 12:11, Hab 2:3, Rev 14:15, Rev 17:17
Reciprocal: Isa 27:9 – this therefore Isa 40:2 – warfare Dan 11:27 – yet Dan 12:3 – they that be Act 17:26 – hath determined 1Ti 4:1 – depart Heb 11:17 – when 1Pe 4:12 – the fiery
Fuente: The Treasury of Scripture Knowledge
Dan 11:35. There is not much new in this verse as it 1b still speaking of the hardships that the Maccabees endured in their struggles for the restoration of the worship In Jerusalem. Make them white refers to the purification that results to the righteous when they are “persecuted for righteousness sake.
Fuente: Combined Bible Commentary
Dan 11:35. Some of them of understanding shall fall Some of the principal men for piety and knowledge shall fall under this persecution, and suffer grievous miseries and torments: see Dan 11:33. To try them, and to purge, &c. For the trial of their faith and patience, and to purge them from those corruptions which are the usual effects of prosperity: compare 1Pe 1:7 : and to make it the more evident how sincere they were in their profession, and that no temptations or sufferings could induce them to violate Gods law, and act contrary to their duty. The persecutions which were to befall the church under antichrist were and are designed for the same purpose, as appears by comparing Dan 12:10 with the words here; Antiochuss persecution being a type and figure of that under antichrist. Even to the time of the end Namely, the time appointed by God for the ending of these calamities. Because it is yet for a time appointed It will be still some time before a deliverance will be granted: or, these calamities are appointed to last for some time. Mr. Mede refers the latter part of this sentence to the following verse, and so connects the following prophecy with what went before, thus: This persecution shall last to the time of the end; for as yet, for a time appointed, a king shall do according to his will.
Fuente: Joseph Bensons Commentary on the Old and New Testaments
Dan 11:35. some of them: i.e. some of the leaders would suffer martyrdom, but the effect would be to refine and purify the rest of the people.
Fuente: Peake’s Commentary on the Bible
11:35 And [some] of them {r} of understanding shall fall, to try them, and to purge, and to make [them] white, [even] to the time of the end: because [it is] yet for a time appointed.
(r) That is, of those that fear God and will lose their life for the defence of true religion. Signifying also that the Church must continually be tried and purged, and ought to look for one persecution after another: for God has appointed the time, and therefore we must obey.
Fuente: Geneva Bible Notes
Even though many godly Jews died, the struggle against the Syrians (Greeks) purified the Jews. John Hyrcanus, the son of Simon Maccabeus, eventually founded a strong Jewish kingdom. His son, Alexander Jannaeus, enlarged it to its fullest extent in the last part of the first century B.C. [Note: See Anthony J. Tomasino, Judaism Before Jesus, for more detail of this "second temple period."]
Daniel received assurance that the predicted persecution would run its course and end. The purification of his people came eventually, though not completely, through the turmoil just described. There would be a final end later.
Mention of "the end time" (Dan 11:35) prepares for the revelation to follow, which concerns events not yet fulfilled in history. "The appointed time" (Dan 11:27; Dan 11:29; Dan 11:35; Dan 12:7) reminds the reader that all these predicted events would be the outworking of divine control and purpose, even though they would involve suffering for the Israelites.
"The amazingly detailed prophecies of the first thirty-five verses of this chapter, containing as they do approximately one hundred and thirty-five prophetic statements, all now fulfilled, constitute an impressive introduction to the events that are yet future, beginning in Dan 11:36. . . . The fact is that there is no supported evidence which can contradict any statement made in these thirty-five verses. . . . From the divine viewpoint, the accuracy of this prophetic word is supporting evidence that prophecy yet unfulfilled will have the same precise fulfillment in the future." [Note: Walvoord, Daniel . . ., pp. 269-70.]
We can understand why critics who deny the possibility of predictive prophecy believe these verses must have been written after they occurred.