Exegetical and Hermeneutical Commentary of Ezekiel 18:24
But when the righteous turneth away from his righteousness, and committeth iniquity, [and] doeth according to all the abominations that the wicked [man] doeth, shall he live? All his righteousness that he hath done shall not be mentioned: in his trespass that he hath trespassed, and in his sin that he hath sinned, in them shall he die.
24. Although it would have sufficed for the prophet’s purpose to assure the repentant sinner of God’s forgiveness, he has a certain theoretical interest in the principle which he is insisting on which makes him develop it on the other side also.
Fuente: The Cambridge Bible for Schools and Colleges
Eze 18:24
When the righteous turneth away from his righteousness.
The evil of apostasy
1. There is a righteousness which men may turn from. There is an opinionative righteousness (Luk 18:9; Mat 23:28); many think themselves righteous, and appear so to others: there is also a duty, a moral, or legal righteousness, such as Paul had (Php 3:6); and from these righteousnesses men may and do turn daily. Many attain to a duty righteousness under the Gospel, but yet fall off again (Mat 13:20-22; 1Ti 5:15; Joh 6:66; 2Pe 2:2; 1Ti 4:1). Take heed, therefore, of trusting in or to any righteousness of your own.
2. It is not sufficient to begin well unless we proceed: fair beginnings without progress come to nothing. Consider the arguments which lie here in the text, to keep you from falling off, and encourage you to persevere in God.
(1) If you do turn back you will fall into iniquity; you will commit iniquity, the frame, bent, and set of the heart will be that way; the thoughts, studies, counsels, motions, endeavours will be towards and in iniquity, you will be an evil-doer, a worker of iniquity.
(2) He lies obvious to all manner of sin; what will not the man do that turns from his holy profession?
(3) Whatever good he hath formerly done shall be all forgotten: if he have done much good to his family or friends, it shall be all laid aside, buried in the dark, and not once be mentioned unto him.
(4) He shall die, and that eternally, in his apostasy, and the guilt, not of one sin, but all his sins, shall be upon him. (W. Greenhill, M. A.)
The danger of relapse
Presumption and desperation are two dangerous maladies, not more opposite one to the other, than to the health of the soul; presumption overprizeth Gods mercy, and undervalueth our sins; and on the contrary, desperation overprizeth our sins, and undervalueth Gods mercy. Both are most injurious to God; the one derogateth from His mercy, the other from His justice, both band against hearty and speedy repentance; the one opposing it as needless, the other as bootless Presumption saith, thou mayest repent at leisure, gather the buds of sinful pleasures before they wither, repentance is not yet seasonable; desperation saith, the root of faith is withered, it is now too late to repent. The life of a Christian is not unfitly compared to a long and dangerous sea voyage; the sea is this present world, the barques are our bodies, the sailors our souls, the pilot our faith, the card Gods Word, the rudder constancy, the anchor hope, the mainmast the cross of Christ, the strong cables our violent affections, the sails our desires, and the Holy Spirit the good wind which filleth the sails and driveth the barque and mariners to the fair haven which is heaven. Now, in our way which lieth through many temptations and tribulations, there are two dangerous rocks, the one on the right hand, the other on the left; the rock on the right hand to be avoided is presumption, the rock on the left threatening shipwreck is despair; between which we are to steer our ship by fear on the one side and hope on the other. To hold us in a solicitous fear that we touch not upon presumption, let us have always in the eye of our mind–
1. The glorious and most omnipotent majesty of God.
2. His all-seeing providence.
3. His impartial justice.
4. His severe threatenings against sin.
5. The dreadful punishments He inflicteth upon sinners.
6. The heinousness of the sin of presumption, which turneth Gods grace into wantonness.
7. The difficulty of recovery after relapses.
8. The uncertainty of Gods offer of grace after the frequent refusal thereof.
To keep us in hope, that we dash not upon the rock of despair on the contrary side, let us set before our troubled and affrighted consciences these grounds of comfort–
1. The infiniteness of Gods mercy.
2. The price and value of Christs blood.
3. The efficacy of His intercession.
4. The virtue of the Sacraments.
5. The universality and certainty of Gods promises to the penitent.
6. The joy of God and angels for the conversion of a sinner.
7. The communion of saints, who all pray for the comfort of afflicted consciences, and the ease of all that are heavy laden with their sins.
8. The examples of mercy showed to most grievous sinners.
But to confine my meditations to the letter of my text. The words divide themselves into (first) a supposition, when, or, if the righteous forsake; secondly, an inference, his former righteousness shall not be remembered, etc. The supposition is dangerous, the inference is pernicious.
1. Of the supposition, when the righteous turneth away from his righteousness. No man ever made question but that a truly regenerate man may depart from his actual righteousness, and commit iniquity, and do according to all the abominations that the wicked doth; and that if he should die without repentance, that his former righteousness should stand him in no stead, but that he should suffer the pain of eternal death, which is all that the letter of this text enforceth our assent unto. Our motions to God-ward, and proceedings in a sanctified course of life, are like the rowing of a small boat against a strong wind and tide (the blasts of the evil spirit, and the propension of our corrupt nature), much labour and sweat is required, and very little is done with much ado; and if we slack our hands, and miss but one stroke, we are carried down with the stream, and cast farther back than we can fetch again with many strokes. What a foul and shameful thing is it with the dog to return to your vomit of luxury, and with the swine to your wallowing in the mire of sensual pleasures. As in the diseases of the body, so also much more of the soul, all relapses are dangerous, and in some diseases altogether incurable; the reason whereof alleged by some learned physicians is this, that when we first take our bed the malignity of the disease worketh upon corrupt humours in the body, which when they are purged, and we restored to health, if after by any distemper we fall into the same malady, the malignity of the disease worketh upon our vital spirits; in like manner the malignity of sin before our conversion worketh but upon our corrupt nature, but after upon the graces of Gods Spirit. We find in Scripture many desperately sick, yet cured the first time by our Saviour; but where do we read in all the Gospel of any blind mans eyes twice enlightened? of any deaf ears twice opened? of any tied tongue twice loosened? of any possessed with devils twice dispossessed? of any dead twice raised? No doubt Christ could have done it, but we read not that ever He did it, that we should be most careful to avoid relapses into our former sins, the recovery whereof is always most difficult, and in some cases (as the Apostle teacheth us) impossible (Heb 6:4-8). (D. Featly, D. D.)
Fuente: Biblical Illustrator Edited by Joseph S. Exell
Verse 24. When the righteous turneth away from his righteousness] Here is the second case. Can a man who was once holy and pure, fall away so as to perish everlastingly? YES. For God says, “If he turn away from his righteousness;” not his self-righteousness, the gloss of theologians: for God never speaks of turning away from that, for, in his eyes, that is a nonentity. There is no righteousness or holiness but what himself infuses into the soul of man, and as to self-righteousness, i.e., a man’s supposing himself to be righteous when he has not the life of God in his soul, it is the delusion of a dark and hardened heart; therefore it is the real righteous principle and righteous practice that God speaks of here. And he tells us, that a man may so “turn away from this,” and so “commit iniquity,” and “act as the wicked man,” that his righteousness shall be no more mentioned to his account, than the sins of the penitent backslider should be mentioned to his condemnation; and “in the sin that he,” this once righteous man, “hath sinned, and in the trespass that he hath trespassed, in them shall he die.” O, how awful a termination of a life once distinguished for righteousness and true holiness! So then, God himself informs us that a righteous man may not only fall foully, but fall finally. But to such righteous persons the devil will ever preach, “Ye shall not surely die; ye shall be as God.” Touch, taste, and handle; ye cannot ultimately fall. Thus we find, by the manner of treating these two cases, that God’s way is equal, Eze 18:25; just, merciful, and impartial. And to prove this, he sums up his conduct in the above cases, in the following verses, 26-29. Eze 18:26-29 And then, that the “wicked may not die in his sins,” and that the “backslider may return and find mercy,” he thus exhorts: –
Fuente: Adam Clarke’s Commentary and Critical Notes on the Bible
After the stating the equity of Gods ways in his dealings with parents and children, and his mercy in dealing with sinners that return according to his own promise, he proceeds to vindicate the equity of his ways in another case.
When, or if; should it so happen at any time. The righteous; one who really had observed the commands of the law, not done the abominations the wicked do, but done the good which the righteous doth, and in the sight of man appears as righteous, and as good as any one; whose apostacy is first full proof of his unsoundness and hypocrisy.
Turneth; changeth his course into sinful practices, like the wicked.
His righteousness; there is a righteousness which is of God, and there is a righteousness which is a mans own, such as does arise from a mans own reason and will, improved by common grace, or education, or awed by fears, or swayed by interest, or maintained by some failing spring which may easily dry up; these righteous ones easily fall away, and of such the prophet speaks.
Committeth iniquity; makes sin his work and business, Joh 8:31; 1Jo 3:8,9.
Doeth according to all the abominations; forgets all better rules, derides his own former preciseness, and shakes off all restraints, that he may run to the excess of sin.
Abominations; recounted Eze 18:10-13.
That the wicked man doeth: see Eze 18:21.
Shall he live? do you think I will be so partial as to acquit him from real wickedness, committed with his whole heart, from his last works, which are abominable? Do you think his first heartless, partial, temporary righteousness will counterbalance his last and final apostacy? I tell you nay, but he shall die in it.
All his righteousness that he hath done; though he could produce his own righteousnesses, (as the Hebrew,) and these multiplied to many, all, and that they were really done, yet these should not avail before a just judge; who by a law that requires man should ever be and do what he was and did at best, is to determine his rewards or punishments according to what the man is at last, not according to what he was or seemed to be at first.
Shall not be mentioned; the parable tells us, Mat 25:44,45, some will plead that they did what they had opportunity of doing, and others, Mat 7:22, will mention what they have done. But though they may mention these, the just judge will not, nor the law by which they are to be judged will not, allow it for a good and sufficient plea: see the phrase Eze 18:22.
In his trespass that he hath trespassed: this expression shows that this mans heart was on his sin; in his transgression he transgressed with full bent of mind, with delight and consent he did what he did, and could not say, I do what I would not; or, So then it is no more I that do it, but sin that dwelleth in me, as Rom 7:17. Lest any stumble at sight of infirmities in all, or needlessly disquiet themselves with fears of wrath at last, because they cannot be sinless, yet they do not fall under the character of such as are here threatened.
In them; in these great, wilful, continued, and multiplied sins.
Shall he die; every such obdurate and final apostate shall be condemned and punished temporally and eternally, and therefore look to it, ye wicked Jews, and consider, ye sinful Christians.
Fuente: English Annotations on the Holy Bible by Matthew Poole
24. righteousone apparentlysuch; as in Mt 9:13, “Icame not to call the righteous,” c., that is, those who fancythemselves righteous. Those alone are true saints who by the grace ofGod persevere (Mat 24:13 1Co 10:12;Joh 10:28; Joh 10:29).
turneth away from . . .righteousnessan utter apostasy; not like the exceptionaloffenses of the godly through infirmity or heedlessness, which theyafterwards mourn over and repent of.
not be mentionednot betaken into account so as to save them.
his trespassutterapostasy.
Fuente: Jamieson, Fausset and Brown’s Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible
But when the righteous turneth away from his righteousness,…. This is to be understood, not of a truly righteous man; for no man can be so denominated from his own righteousness; but from the righteousness and obedience of Christ; and such a man cannot turn from his righteousness; for that is the righteousness of God, and can never be lost; and is an everlasting one, and will always endure; and with which eternal life is inseparably connected: but this is to be interpreted of one that is reckoned so from his own righteousness, what he himself has done, and not from another, from the righteousness of Christ, which he has wrought out; he is one that is righteous in his own esteem, and in the account of others; who is outwardly righteous before men; who trusts in himself that he is righteous, and trusts to his own righteousness; see Eze 33:13; whose righteousness is not an evangelical one, but either a ceremonial righteousness, or at most a mere moral one, consisting of some negative holiness, and a few moral performances, as appears from Eze 18:5; and from such a righteousness as this a man may turn, commit iniquity, sin and die; see 2Pe 2:20; and is no proof or instance of the apostasy of real saints, true believers, or truly righteous men; besides, this man is represented as a transgressor, or “prevaricator”, as the word signifies; a hypocrite, a man destitute of the truth of grace, and of true righteousness:
and committeth iniquity; makes a trade of sinning; goes into a vicious course of life, and continues in it; which a truly gracious man, one that is born again, and has true faith in Christ’s righteousness, by which he is justified, can never do, 1Jo 3:8;
[and] doeth according to all the abominations that the wicked [man] doeth; such as theft, murder, adultery, idolatry, oppression of the poor, and giving upon usury, Eze 18:10;
shall he live? in his own land, in peace and prosperity, enjoying all manner of good things? he shall not; much less shall he live an eternal life, so living and dying:
all his righteousness that he hath done shall not be mentioned: or, “all his righteousnesses” k; all the good works which he has done will never come into any account, or be of any avail; as they merited nothing, they will meet with no reward; they will not preserve him from present calamity, which his now sinful life exposes him to, nor secure him from eternal ruin; these may be mentioned and pleaded by himself, but to no purpose; God will not mention them, nor take any notice of them, nor the Judge at the great day of account, Mt 7:22;
in his trespass that he hath trespassed, and in his sin that he hath sinned, in them shall he die; or, for his hypocrisy, “prevarication” l, and vicious course of life he now lives in, a death of affliction shall come upon him; great calamities and distresses in this world; and, if grace prevent not, eternal death in the other; if he dies in his trespasses and sins, he will die the second death.
k “omnes justitiae ejus”, V. L. Pagninus, Montanus, Cocceius.
l “propter prvevaricationem ipsius, [vel] suam”, Junius & Tremellius, Piscator, Polanus.
Fuente: John Gill’s Exposition of the Entire Bible
As in the last lecture the Prophet offered to sinners a sure hope of pardon if they heartily repented, and promised that God would be propitious to them as soon as they shall seek reconciliation with him: so now, on the other hand, he pronounces, if the just shall decline from his justice, whatever he has hitherto done, shall not come into the account before God. He urged sinners to repentance when he assured them that God was prepared to pardon them: but he now frightens those who profess for the occasion to be pure and sincere worshipers of God, if they fall back in the midst of their course: as Paul says, Let him who stands take heed lest he fall. (1Co 10:12.) Besides, we gather from this passage, as Christ teaches, that those only are happy who persevere, (Mat 24:13😉 since a temporary righteousness will never profit those apostates who afterwards turn aside from God. We see, then, how these two clauses unite together, namely, that God invites all who are in danger of perdition with extended arms, and promises them salvation if they heartily return to him. Again, that he may restrain within the bounds of duty those who have made some progress, and correct their sloth and stir up their anxiety, he threatens, that unless they pursue the course of a holy and pious life to the end, their former righteousness will not profit them. But here a question arises, Can a truly just person deflect from the right way? for he who is begotten of God is so free from the tyranny of sin that he devotes himself wholly to righteousness: and then if any do turn aside, they prove that they were always strangers to God. If they had been of us, says John, they would never have gone out from us. (1Jo 2:19.) And regeneration is an incorruptible seed: so we must determine that the faithful who are truly regenerate never fall away from righteousness, but are retained by God’s unconquered power: for God’s calling in the elect is without repentance. (Rom 11:29.) Hence he continues the course of his grace even to the end. Nor are they to be listened to, who, in contradiction to Scripture, teach that faith is extinct in the elect, when, through its barrenness, they bring forth no fruit. In what sense, then, does Ezekiel mean that the just fall away? That question is easily answered, since he is not here treating of the living root of justice, but of the outward form or appearance, as we commonly say. Paul reminds us that God knows us, but adds, that this seal remains. (2Ti 2:19.) God therefore claims to himself alone the difference between the elect and the reprobate, since many seem to be members of his Church who are only outwardly such. And that passage of Augustine is true, that there are many wolves within, and many sheep without. (227) For before God demonstrates his election, the sheep wander, and seem altogether strangers to the hope of salvation. Meanwhile many hypocrites make use of the name of God, and openly boast themselves pre-eminent in the Church, but inwardly they are wolves. But because it often happens that some make the greatest show of piety and justice, the Prophet very properly says, that if such fall away, they cannot boast of their former righteousness before God, since its remembrance will be bloated out.
In fine, we see that the word righteousness is referred to our senses, and not to God’s hidden judgment; so that the Prophet does not teach anything but what we perceive daily: for those who seem to excel others desert their calling, shake off every yoke, and cast away the fear of God, and sometimes rush on with diabolical fury. When this result occurs we hear what the Spirit pronounces by the mouth of the Prophet, that none of their righteousness shall be taken into account. But weight is added to his words when he says, if you have turned aside from righteousness, and done according to all the abominations of the impious, (or wicked,) shall he live? For the Prophet separates those who desert God and rush into every wickedness from those who fall through infirmity or want of thought, and from those also who would fall headlong into ruin, unless God preserved them, yet do not utterly cast off his fear, and the desire of living piously and righteously. For example: every one is occasionally off his guard; and hence, in numberless ways, we offend God through error: and hence David exclaims, Who can understand his faults? (Psa 19:12.) We fall of our own accord, since we are often conquered by temptations, even when our consciences accuse us; so that, although sanctified, we decline from the path of uprightness through ignorance, and depart from duty through infirmity. But what is far worse, the saints sometimes rush headlong, as though utterly desperate. For the example of David shows that the elect, although regenerated by God’s Spirit, not only sin to a small extent, but, as I have said, plunge into the very lowest abyss. David became a perfidious homicide, and a traitor to the army of God; then that wretched king fell into a series of crimes: yet he failed in only one thing, and showed that God’s grace was only suffocated within him, and not altogether extinguished. For as soon as Nathan reproves him, he confesses that he had sinned, and is prepared to undergo any punishment which God may inflict. Since, therefore, the saints sometimes fall, the Prophet here stretches forth his hand, lest they should despair, and bears witness that God does not reject them unless they turn aside from their righteousness and commit all the abominations which the impious do. By these words, as we see, he expresses a complete revolt, and he so mitigates the severity of the sentence, lest the minds of those who had only partially relapsed should despond. Now we see the meaning of this language: If he has done according to all the abominations of the wicked, shall he live? says he; all the righteousness which he has done shall not be remembered, because he shall perish. Here the Prophet shows that: a mere temporary righteousness will not profit us unless we persevere unto the end in the fear of God.
Here again the contrast is worthy of notice, because it enables us to refute a fiction which is current in the schools of the papacy. They say that guilt is remitted by God, but the punishment is retained. Now what says our Prophet? If the impious turn away from his impiety, I will no longer remember any of his iniquities. Here the papists thrust for-ward the foolish distinction, that God does not remember them as to their guilt, but he does as to their punishment. But what follows a little afterwards? If the just turn away from his justice, his justice shall not be taken into account. But if they do not come into the account as to merit, and yet do as to reward, what is the meaning of the passage? how will the Prophet’s meaning stand? But it is necessary thus to receive what the Prophet says; because, if the distinction of guilt and punishment avails, that of merit and reward will avail also. Hence it will follow, that as to merit God forgets all acts of righteousness; but as far as reward is concerned, they are remembered since they are not abolished. Since, then, it is sufficiently clear that the righteousness of the backslider is not taken into account, so as to lead him to hope for reward, it follows, on the other hand, that his sins are abolished not only as to guilt, but also as to punishment. It now follows —
(227) Augustine. Comment, in Joh 10:16.
Fuente: Calvin’s Complete Commentary
24. When the righteous turneth away Having emphasized the new relations to Jehovah attained by the repentant sinner, he has a word of warning for any one who, having once felt the certainty of God’s approving grace, may think himself safe forever. The righteous man, if he be not watchful, may lose his righteousness and thus lose God’s favor. (Compare 1Co 9:27.)
Fuente: Whedon’s Commentary on the Old and New Testaments
“But when the righteous turns away from his righteousness, and commits iniquity, and does according to all the abominations which the wicked man does. Shall he live? None of his righteous deeds which he has done will be remembered. In his trespass that he has trespassed and in his sin that he has sinned, in them will he die.”
God has no pleasure in the death of anyone. But if a righteous man turns away from his righteous living and takes up the way of wickedness, following in the abomination of flagrant disobedience of God’s laws, as illustrated in Eze 18:10-12, his past righteousness will not save him. Thus once for all is done away the theory that a man will be measured in scales, the good against the bad. His righteous deeds will not be remembered. There will be nothing to put in the scales. He will be condemned for his current life. Present submission to God’s covenant and obedience to His requirements alone can make a man right with God. There is no room for presumption.
Note the differing words used for sin. Here ‘iniquity’ is ‘wl speaking of behaving unjustly, doing wrong. ‘Trespass’ is m‘l signifying acting counter to one’s duty to God. ‘Sin’ is chata’ meaning to miss the way or the goal, or the mark aimed at. To fall short. (See Jdg 20:16 where it means to aim and not miss).
Fuente: Commentary Series on the Bible by Peter Pett
Eze 18:24 But when the righteous turneth away from his righteousness, and committeth iniquity, [and] doeth according to all the abominations that the wicked [man] doeth, shall he live? All his righteousness that he hath done shall not be mentioned: in his trespass that he hath trespassed, and in his sin that he hath sinned, in them shall he die.
Ver. 24. But when the righteous. ] He that is good in his own eyes, and passeth for good in the esteem of others, but yet is not really righteous, if such a one do utterly fall away, and lose that little that he seemed to have, what wonder? Comman grace can never hold out, or stretch to eternity. Bellarmine saith well, That which is true grace, veritate essentiae, only may be lost: not that that is true veritate firma soliditatis, with the truth of firm solidity; which latter, being rightly understood, may be called special, as the other common grace.
Fuente: John Trapp’s Complete Commentary (Old and New Testaments)
NASB (UPDATED) TEXT: Eze 18:24-29
24But when a righteous man turns away from his righteousness, commits iniquity and does according to all the abominations that a wicked man does, will he live? All his righteous deeds which he has done will not be remembered for his treachery which he has committed and his sin which he has committed; for them he will die. 25Yet you say, ‘The way of the Lord is not right.’ Hear now, O house of Israel! Is My way not right? Is it not your ways that are not right? 26When a righteous man turns away from his righteousness, commits iniquity and dies because of it, for his iniquity which he has committed he will die. 27Again, when a wicked man turns away from his wickedness which he has committed and practices justice and righteousness, he will save his life. 28Because he considered and turned away from all his transgressions which he had committed, he shall surely live; he shall not die. 29But the house of Israel says, ‘The way of the Lord is not right.’ Are My ways not right, O house of Israel? Is it not your ways that are not right?
Eze 18:24 This verse demonstrates that an OT covenant person could
1. be righteous, Eze 18:24
2. become wicked, Eze 18:24
3. become righteous again, Eze 18:27-28
The OT is a performance-based, conditional covenant! The question remains, is the NT a conditional covenant? It is not performance-based, but the goal of both the OT and NT is a righteous people who reflect God’s character to a lost world! The problem of easy believism is the issue. The NT is a conditional covenant, which requires
1. repentance
2. faith, trust, belief
3. obedience
4. perseverance
SPECIAL TOPIC: APOSTASY (APHISTMI)
Notice the phrases used to describe one who turns from righteousness.
1. commits iniquity (lit. injustice, BDB 732, cf. Eze 3:20; Eze 18:24; Eze 18:26 [twice]; Eze 33:13 [twice],15,18; Lev 19:15; Lev 19:35; Deu 25:16
2. does according to all the abominations (BDB 1072, see Special Topic at Eze 5:11)
3. wicked man does (lit. wicked, BDB 957, cf. Eze 3:18 [twice]; Eze 7:21; Eze 21:30; Eze 33:8 [twice])
4. treachery which he has committed (lit. act unfaithfully, BDB 591, cf. Eze 14:13; Eze 15:8; Eze 17:20; Eze 20:27; Eze 39:23; Eze 39:26)
5. sin which he has committed (BDB 308, cf. Eze 16:51; Eze 18:14; Eze 21:29; Eze 33:10; Eze 33:16)
All of these phrases refer to covenant people. Their genealogy in the family of Abraham did not protect them (note Joh 8:31-59) from the consequences of evil acts (cf. Isa 65:7; Jer 31:29-30; Lam 5:7).
Eze 18:25
NASBnot right
NKJVnot fair
NRSV, JPSOAunfair
TEVisn’t right
NJBunjust
REBacts without principle
This VERB (BDB 1067, KB 1733, Niphal IMPERFECT) refers to a standard of weight or measurement (cf. Eze 18:29; Eze 33:17; Eze 33:20). YHWH judges precisely because He weighs the human heart and knows the actions of all (cf. Pro 16:2; Pro 16:11).
This verse shows the purpose of the chapter (cf. Eze 18:2). The Judeans in Jerusalem are trying to explain God’s judgment by blaming
1. their ancestors
2. their parents
3. God (He is unjust in His actions, cf. Eze 18:29; Eze 33:17; Eze 33:20)
They were attempting to deflect spiritual responsibility. This whole chapter must contextually be seen in this light!
Hear now is a Qal IMPERATIVE (BDB 1033, KB 1570). YHWH is still dealing with His covenant people. He wants them to repent and return to Him (cf. Eze 18:30-32).
Eze 18:28 because he considered This is literally see (BDB 906, KB 1157, Qal IMPERFECT), but used in the sense of mental enlightentment (TEV realizes). It is similar to came to himself of Luk 15:17. Spiritual choices all begin in the mind! The new thoughts resulted in modified behavior!
The phrase he shall surely live is a repeated divine affirmation (see Eze 18:9; Eze 18:17; Eze 18:19; Eze 18:21).
Eze 18:29 The VERB is not right (BDB 1067, KB 1733, Niphal IMPERFECT) is used three times; once as an accusation against God, but twice of the Judeans’ sinful actions.
Fuente: You Can Understand the Bible: Study Guide Commentary Series by Bob Utley
righteousness. So Hebrew text; but margin, with scone codices and one early printed edition, read plural = “none of his righteous acts The Hebrew verb is plural
trespass. trespassed. Hebrew. ma’ al. App-44.
Fuente: Companion Bible Notes, Appendices and Graphics
when: Eze 18:26, Eze 3:20, Eze 3:21, Eze 33:12, Eze 33:13, Eze 33:18, 1Sa 15:11, 2Ch 24:2, 2Ch 24:17-22, Psa 36:3, Psa 36:4, Psa 125:5, Zep 1:6, Mat 13:20, Mat 13:21, Joh 6:66-70, Gal 5:7, Heb 10:38, Heb 10:39, 2Pe 2:18-22, 1Jo 2:19, 1Jo 5:16-18, Jud 1:12
and doeth: Eze 18:10-13, Mat 12:43-45, Rom 1:28-31, 2Co 12:20, 2Co 12:21, 2Ti 3:1-5
All his: Eze 18:22, Mar 13:13, Gal 3:4, Heb 6:4-6, Heb 10:26-31, 2Jo 1:8, Rev 2:10, Rev 3:11
in his: Eze 18:18, Pro 14:32, Pro 21:16, Mat 7:22, Mat 7:23, Joh 8:21, Joh 8:24
Reciprocal: Num 6:12 – but the Deu 27:26 – confirmeth Jos 23:12 – go back Jos 24:20 – he will turn Psa 94:23 – cut them Jer 18:10 – do Jer 27:13 – Why Jer 34:16 – ye turned Eze 18:13 – shall he Eze 33:6 – he is Hos 4:10 – left Amo 5:7 – leave Rom 11:22 – otherwise 1Pe 4:18 – if 2Pe 2:21 – to turn
Fuente: The Treasury of Scripture Knowledge
Eze 18:24. This verse is akin to verse 22 at one very important point. When a wicked man repents and is forgiven, one of his former sins are mentioned against him. Likewise, if a righteous man backslides and deserts his life of righteousness, he will he dealt with according to his sins just the same as if he had never been a righteous man. It is one of the weaknesses of mankind to overlook the evil doing of a person for the sake of his previous record. It will be heard say, “We know he is not doing just right now. but we still remember the good he has done.” Such persons are pretending to have a better memory or know better how to deal with a sinner than does the Lord. He declares he will not consider the former good deeds of the backslider after he takes up a life of sin but that he shall die in his sins.
Fuente: Combined Bible Commentary
Eze 18:24. But when the righteous turneth away from his righteousness, &c. The question here, say some commentators, is not whether truly righteous men ever do thus apostatize. No? Surely it is the question, and the sole question: for if the truly righteous (of whom alone the prophet is speaking, and not of the hypocritically righteous, or mere professors of righteousness) do never apostatize, why does the prophet suppose that they do? Nay, why does he expressly affirm it, saying, When the righteous turneth away from his righteousness, and committeth iniquity? &c. Which is repeated Eze 18:26, with the addition, And dieth in them; for the iniquity that he hath done shall he die. Surely these words are utterly irreconcilable with the notion, that the truly righteous never fall away. They who maintain this position may, on similar grounds, maintain, and, to be consistent with themselves, ought to maintain, in contradiction to the 21st and 27th verses, that the truly wicked never turn from their wickedness, never truly repent, and save their souls alive. For both events are equally supposed by the prophet frequently to take place, and it is affirmed in similar terms that both do take place. See note on Eze 3:20. Nor is this prophet singular in teaching this doctrine, or this the only passage of Scripture in which it is taught: it is abundantly and explicitly declared and attested in other parts of holy writ, and by other inspired writers, especially those of the New Testament, and even by Christ himself, as the reader may see, if he will take the trouble of consulting the passages quoted in the margin. All his righteousness that he hath done shall not be mentioned For, better had it been for him not to have known the way of righteousness, than after he hath known it, to turn aside from the holy commandment, 2Pe 2:21. Such a one sins against a clearer light, and greater convictions, and withal is guilty of the highest ingratitude in doing despite unto the Spirit of grace.
Fuente: Joseph Bensons Commentary on the Old and New Testaments
18:24 But when the righteous turneth away from his righteousness, and committeth iniquity, [and] doeth according to all the abominations that the wicked [man] doeth, shall he live? All his {g} righteousness that he hath done shall not be mentioned: in his trespass that he hath trespassed, and in his sin that he hath sinned, in them shall he die.
(g) That is, the false opinion that the hypocrites have of their righteousness.
Fuente: Geneva Bible Notes
The second objection: God’s justice 18:24-29
The Jews to whom Ezekiel ministered went beyond questioning God’s conduct. They also questioned His justice.
Fuente: Expository Notes of Dr. Constable (Old and New Testaments)
A turn in the other direction would have the same result. If a person turned from righteous conduct and pursued a life of sin, God would punish him with premature death for his sins even though he had formerly done right.
"An individual’s relationship with God when the judgment arrives determines whether he will live or die." [Note: Dyer, "Ezekiel," p. 1261. Cf. The New Scofield . . ., p. 857.]
"A generation is not predetermined for judgment or for blessing by the previous one. Even within a generation, or within an individual life, the past does not necessarily determine the present or the future." [Note: Cooper, p. 191.]
"Ezekiel has hereby repudiated the notion of a ’treasury of merit or demerit’ on two counts. First, one generation cannot build up such a treasure [sic] for another; each individual determines his or her own destiny by his or her own conduct. Second, an individual cannot build up such a treasury in one phase of his or her life and count on this to balance off a deficit later." [Note: Block, The Book . . ., p. 583.]