Exegetical and Hermeneutical Commentary of Genesis 37:18
And when they saw him afar off, even before he came near unto them, they conspired against him to slay him.
18 36 (JE). Joseph is sold into Egypt
The composite character of the narrative becomes at this point very evident. J ( Gen 37:21 ; Gen 37:25-28 b, 31 35) relates that Judah restrains his brethren from murder, and persuades them to sell Joseph to passing Ishmaelites, who sell him as a slave to an Egyptian noble. E ( Gen 37:22-25 ( bread), 28a ( pit), 28c 30, 36) relates that Reuben interposes, and saves Joseph from his brethren: by his advice Joseph is cast into a tank, where he is found by passing Midianite merchants, who draw him out, take him to Egypt, and sell him to Potiphar, “captain of the guard.” Reuben returning to the tank, after the interval for food, finds it empty.
Fuente: The Cambridge Bible for Schools and Colleges
Gen 37:18-19
They conspired against him to slay him
The conspiracy to murder Joseph
I.
AN EXAMPLE OF THE RAPIDLY DOWNWARD COURSE OF EVIL.
II. AN EXAMPLE. OF THE BOLD DARING OF SINNERS.
III. AN EXAMPLE OF GUILT INCURRED EVEN WHERE PURPOSE HAS NOT RIPENED INTO ACT.
IV. AN EXAMPLE OF DEGREES OF GUILTINESS EVEN AMONG THOSE WHO HAVE LENT THEMSELVES TO ONE DESIGN. (T. H. Leale)
Joseph with his brethren
I. MAN UNDER THE INFLUENCE OF JEALOUSY.
1. Jealousy leads a man to slander.
2. Jealousy leads to falsehood.
3. Jealousy hardens the heart.
4. Jealousy leads to crime.
II. MAN UNDER THE INFLUENCE OF MERCY.
1. The merciful are in the minority.
2. The merciful lose sight of self.
3. The merciful are always ready to assist others. (Homilist)
Lessons
1. The sight of the righteous, whom the wicked hate, is an occasion of working mischief and evil to them.
2. The looks of the wicked is for the mischief of those good souls, who look and seek for their peace.
3. Subtlety and conspiracy for death is the wickeds practice against innocent gracious souls (Gen 37:18).
4. The wicked encourage each other in evil matters to committing them.
5. Vile persons jeer and scorn the revelations of God under terms of contempt. Dreamer (Gen 37:19).
6. Sinners persecute the saints for Gods revelations to them.
7. Providence suffers sinners to breathe death and destruction to saints, when they effect it not.
8. Murderers themselves are ashamed to own blood-guiltiness, therefore seek to hide it.
9. Brothers blood is not pitied with men of sin.
10. Evil men design to frustrate the counsels and revelation of God by their crafty and cruel practices (Gen 37:20). (G. Hughes, B. D.)
Lessons
1. In evil counsels against the saints, God overpowers the heart of some to frustrate bloody designs of others.
2. God makes evil projected against His servants to come to the cognizance of those that shall defeat it.
3. Deliverance is effected sometimes for the saints by such as hate them enough.
4. Providence causeth the counsel of one evil man to prevail against others, for His saints good (Gen 37:21).
5. God puts an awe upon some to counsel others not to shed blood.
6. Pretence of a worse death providence ordereth to be made by men to save His from death wholly.
7. Fratricide is made horried to evil men by God for saving His own.
8. Respect to paternal honour may sway with men of bad resolutions, to abstain from evil and offering violence to a brother (Gen 37:21-22). (G. Hughes, B. D)
Lessons
1. Under Providence innocent souls come in their integrity into the hands of spoilers.
2. Simple, honest hearts, may think of coming to brethren when it is to cruel destroyers.
3. Unnatural treacherous dealers stick not to take a garment from a brother.
4. Garments of pleasure may expose men to envy and spoil by wicked hands (Gen 37:23).
5. Violent hands are soon layed even upon an innocent brother by envious and enraged spirits.
6. Brethren degenerate into spoilers, stick not at it to bury an innocent brother alive.
7. God emptieth the pits of water where He will not have His innocents perish.
8. Dry pits of trouble are in Gods Use, tokens of deliverance. Joseph shall come out (Gen 37:24). (G. Hughes, B. D)
Reubens attempt to save Joseph
He boarded the train which he could not arrest, but he boarded it with the purpose of ultimately controlling it and so preventing a catastrophe. The motive was good, but I am not quite so sure about the policy. It savours a little too much of worldly wisdom for me, and little good came out of it in the end. We have seen it tried here often enough in politics, and almost always with this result: that the well-meaning men who have gone into a questionable movement under the idea that they could thereby guide it into something that would be at least harmless, have been themselves outwitted and befooled. It would have been just about as easy for Reuben to have stood out against the persecution of Joseph altogether as it was for him to protest against the shedding of his blood, and it might have been equally efficacious. At any rate it would have exonerated him from the guilt which they all alike ultimately incurred. His plan was to deliver Joseph, but in a way that was itself deceptive, for he seemed to be doing one thing while he was really seeking another. His proposal was that they should put Joseph into a pit. That to them looked to be a refinement on their cruelty, for it left him to starve to death, while they had meant that he should be slain out of hand. As such, therefore, it commended itself to their acceptance. But his secret intention was to come back by himself when the others should be out of the way, and then take him out and return with him to his father. It was well meant, and not very badly planned either; but then it required that a very careful watch should be maintained, and just there the instability of Reubens character came in to mar it all; for, thinking that now the crisis was past, he wont away and took no further oversight of the matter, and in his absence it was all upset. For the moment, however, it looked as if he had succeeded, for the others accepted his suggestion, and after stripping Joseph of his hated coat, they put him into one of those cisterns which were so common in Palestine, and which, when dry, were sometimes, as in the case of Jeremiah, used as a prison. Lieutenant Anderson, of the Palestine Exploration Enterprise, thus writes regarding them: The numerous rock-hewn cisterns that are found everywhere would furnish a suitable pit in which they might have thrust him; and as these cisterns are shaped like a bottle, with a narrow mouth, it would be impossible for any one imprisoned within it to extricate himself without assistance. These cisterns are now all cracked and useless; they are, however, the most undoubted evidences that exist of handiwork of the inhabitants in ancient times. (W. M. Taylor, D. D.)
Evil for good
Joseph put himself to so much trouble to find out his brethren that he might inform himself and his father of their welfare; but they took advantage from his love to wreak their hatred upon him, as if they had been devils in flesh and blood, rather than patriarchs in the Church. It is too common with discontented men to say that none were even so ill-used as themselves. But let us consider how Joseph was used, how David was used, how Christ Himself was used, by those men from whom they had most reason to expect kindness. (G. Lawson.)
Josephs brethren conspire against him
I. The Scriptures expressly prohibit envy (Pro 3:31; Pro 23:17). God prohibits envy, then, because it is rebellion against His just authority, an insult to His honour, and a denial of His attributes of wisdom and justice and truth. It is also a passion which is infinitely removed from His own pure nature. God prohibits it also because it cannot exist with peace and happiness. Where envy enters happiness departs. Like the buckets of a well, they cannot both descend into the depths of the human heart together. The absence of envy is spoken of in Scripture as a mark of a renewed mind, the characteristic of a soul born of God (Tit 3:3).
II. The Lord has, however, given us something more than precepts against envy in His word. To prohibit it ought to be enough, and it will be enough with the child of God to make him loathe and abhor a thing so detestable in the sight of his heavenly Father. The Lord has added to these precepts many most instructive illustrations of the pernicious effects of this base passion. He points us to the fugitive Cain, as he rushes from His presence, his brow stamped with the brand of infamy, and his hand steeped in the life-blood of his righteous brother, and He says, Behold the effects of envy. He points us to the distracted family of Jacob in their rival tents, Rachel envying Leah her children, and Leah envying Rachel the first place in their husbands affections, and He says, Behold the misery and torment produced by envy. To what a fiend does envy reduce the man! These unnatural children appear to have had no more compassion for their father than for Joseph; perhaps they even secretly enjoyed the thought of disappointing and grieving him by dashing to the ground all his hopes of his favorite sons advancement. Let us kill him, say they, and then he cannot rule over us. And is there nothing, in this conspiracy of his brethren against Joseph, to remind us of a similar conspiracy against Gods beloved Son? Joseph was here in the strictest sense a type of Christ. Envy endangered His life at its first commencement, and the slaughter of the innocents at Bethlehem may teach us how a man may become envious at the predicted royalties of an infant, as well as at the actual prosperity of those of riper years. His own brethren after the flesh in his after life conspired against Him, and why? Envy was at the root of all their conspiracies. They treated His claim to the Messiahship as a dream. And in their treatment of Jesus they discovered as strong a hatred of His Father, whom they also called their Father, as did Josephs brethren towards their father. So evident was this that Jesus Himself says of them, Now have they both seen and hated both Me and My Father (Joh 15:24). There is one more point which makes the type perfect. The steps the brethren of Joseph took to prevent his exaltation over them, actually helped forward the very thing they wished to prevent; so inscrutable are the ways of God in His providence, He maketh the wrath of man to praise Him. The same was the ease with Jesus. God permitted His enemies to go just far enough to accomplish His purposes and to defeat their own. By crucifying Jesus the Jews effectually fulfilled His most ardent wishes, and promoted the benefit and advancement of believers which they meant to hinder. (E. Dalton.)
This dreamer
The worlds treatment of dreamers
To-day we do not like the dreamers who have seen visions which involve us more or less in decay and inferiority. It is not easy to forgive a man who has dreamed an unpleasant dream concerning us. We cannot easily forgive a man who has founded an obnoxious institution. If a man has written a book which is distasteful to us, it is no matter, though he should do ten thousand acts which ought to excite our admiration and confirm our confidence, we will go back and back upon the obnoxious publication, and whensoever that mans name is mentioned, that book will always come up in association with it. Is this right? Ought we to be confined in our view of human character to single points, and those points always of a kind to excite unpleasant, indignant, perhaps vindictive feelings? The worlds dreamers have never had an easy lot of it. Dont let us imagine that Joseph was called to a very easy and comfortable position when he was called to see the visions of Providence in the time of his slumber. God speaks to man by dream and by vision, by strange scene and unexpected sight; and we who are prosaic groundlings are apt to imagine that those men who live in transcendental regions, who are privileged occasionally to see the invisible, have all the good fortune of life, and we ourselves are but servants of dust and hirelings of an-ill-paid day. No; the poets have their own pains, and the dreamers have their own peculiar sorrows. Men of double sight often have double difficulties in life. Dont let us suppose that we are all true of inspiration. It is not because a man has had a dream that he is to be hearkened unto. It is because the dream is a parable of heaven that we ought to ask him to speak freely and fully to us concerning his wondrous vision, that we may see further into the truth and beauty of Gods way concerning man. (J. Parker, D. D.)
God in dreams
They insulted the Sovereign of the world, while they persecuted their poor brother. They intended to frustrate the Word of the Lord, and hoped they would bring to nothing the counsels of the Most High. Presumptuous creatures! did they think they were stronger than the Almighty? If they had cut Joseph into a thousand pieces, the Word of the Lord would have stood firm and sure. It would be far easier to arrest the sun in his course, than to hinder the performance of any promise that God has made to His people. His counsel shall stand for ever; the thoughts of His heart to all generations. They might, no doubt, imagine that they were fighting, not against God, but against a presumptuous boy, who fondly dreamed of rising into honours above his equals or superiors, and that Josephs arrogance well deserved to be humbled. They did not perhaps think that Josephs dreams were from God; but why, then, were they so much piqued with his dreams? Might they not have suffered them to pass from their memories like other vanities, which pass away the moment in which they make their appearance? Must a man be hunted day after day, till he is chased out of the world, for a silly dream? But if their spirits had not been blinded by envy, they might have either seen that there was something more than ordinary in Josephs dream, or at least have seen good reason to suspend their judgment. It was not a good excuse that they did not know the dreams to be from God. They ought to have known with certainty that they did not come from God, before they ventured to turn them into derision. (G. Lawson, D. D.)
A remarkable dream
In a sketch of my life-work, which appears in the Christmas number of the Methodist, Gee. Smith, of Coalville, says:–One night, in the summer of 1868, I had a remarkable dream, which, strange to say, was repeated three nights in succession. Thousands of poor little children clustered round me, with looks and cries which pierced my soul. I was toiling to drag them to the top of a mountain. Just as I was giving up the struggle, Mr. Gladstone joined in my effort, and just as we both were giving up, our good and noble Queen come to the rescue, and we landed them all at the top. A similar dream occurred during the early part of my canal crusade.
Dreams but not dreams
Carnal men hear of the beauty of holiness, of the excellency of Christ, of the preciousness of the covenant, of the rich treasures of grace, as if they were in a dream. They look upon such things as mere fancies, like to foolish dreams of golden mountains, or showers of pearls. This their way is their folly. When scientific men describe to us their curious experiments and their singular discoveries, we know them to be persons of credit, and therefore accept their testimony: why do not men of the world do us the like justice and believe what we tell them? We are as sane as they, and as observant of the law of truth: why, then, do they not believe us when we declare what the Lord has done for our souls? Why is our experience, in the spiritual world, to be treated as a fiction, any more than their discoveries in chemistry or geography? There is no justice in the treatment with which our witness is received. Yet the Christian man need not complain, for in the nature of things he may expect it to be so, and the fact that it is so is a confirmation of his own beliefs. In a world of blind men, an elect race to whom eyes had been given, would be sure to be regarded ae either mad or false. How could the sightless majority be expected to accept the witness of the seeing few? Would it not touch their dignity to admit that others possessed faculties of which they were destitute? And would it not be highly probable that the blind would conspire to regard the men of eyes as fanatical dreamers or deluded fools? Unrenewed men know not the things which are of the Spirit of God, and it is by no means a strange thing that they should deride what they cannot understand. It is sad that those who are dreamers, in the worst sense, should think others so, but it is by no means so extraordinary as to cause surprise. Oh, my Lord, whatever others may think of me, let me be more and more sensible of Thy presence, and of the glorious privileges and hopes which are created in the heart by Thy grace. If men should even say of me as of Joseph, behold this dreamer cometh, it will not grieve me so long as Thou art with me, and Thy favour makes me blest. (C. H.Spurgeon.)
Fuente: Biblical Illustrator Edited by Joseph S. Exell
18. when they saw him afar offonthe level grass field, where they were watching their cattle. Theycould perceive him approaching in the distance from the side ofShechem, or rather, Samaria.
Fuente: Jamieson, Fausset and Brown’s Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible
And when they saw him afar off,…. They knew him as soon as they saw him, by his stature, his gesture or manner of walking, and especially by his coat of various colours he now had on, Ge 37:23;
even before he came near unto them; the distance he was from them when they first spied him is particularly remarked and repeated, not to show the quickness of their sight, but for the sake of what follows; to observe how soon their passions were raised, how intense and prepense their malice, and which put them upon devising ways and means to destroy him, for it follows:
they conspired against him, to slay him; they entered into a consultation, and devised the most crafty methods they could think of to take away his life, and yet conceal the murder.
Fuente: John Gill’s Exposition of the Entire Bible
18. And when they saw him afar off. Here again Moses, so far from sparing the fame of his own family by adulation, brands its chiefs with a mark of eternal infamy, and exposes them to the hatred and execration of all nations. If, at any time, among heathens, a brother murdered his brother, such impiety was treated with the utmost severity in tragedies, that it might not pass into an example for imitation. But in profane history no such thing is found, as that nine brethren should conspire together for the destruction of an innocent youth, and, like wild beasts, should pounce upon him with bloody hands. Therefore a horrible, and even diabolical fury, took possession of the sons of Jacob, when, having cast aside the sense of nature, they were thus prepared cruelly to rage against their own blood.
But, in addition to this wickedness, Moses condemns their impious contempt of God, Behold this master of dreams. For why do they insult the unhappy youth, except because he had been called by the celestial oracle to an unexpected dignity? Besides, in this manner, they themselves proclaim their own baseness more publicly than any one could do, who should purposely undertake severely to chastise them. They confess that the cause why they persecuted their brother was his having dreamed; as if truly this ass an inexpiable offense; but if they are indignant at his dreams, why do they not rather wage war with God? For Joseph deemed it necessary to receive, as a precious deposit, what had been divinely revealed unto him. But because they did not dare directly to assail God, they wrap themselves in clouds, that, losing sight of God, they may vent their fury against their brother. If such blindness seized upon the patriarchs, what shall become of the reprobates, whom obstinate malice drives along, so that they do not hesitate to resist God even to the last? And we see that they willingly disturb and excite themselves, as often as they are offended with the threatenings and chastisements of God, and rise up against his ministers for the sake of taking vengeance. The same thing, indeed, would at times happen to us all, unless God should put on his bridle to render us submissive. With respect to Joseph, the special favor of God was manifested to him, and he was raised to the highest dignity; but only in a dream, which is ridiculed by the wicked scorn of his brethren. To this is also added a conspiracy, so that he narrowly escaped death. Thus the promise of God, which had exalted him to honor, almost plunges him into the grave. We, also, who have received the gratuitous adoption of God amidst many sorrows, experience the same thing. For, from the time that Christ gathers us into his flock, God permits us to be cast down in various ways, so that we seem nearer hell than heaven. Therefore, let the example of Joseph be fixed in our minds, that we be not disquieted when many crosses spring forth to us from the root of God’s favor. For I have before showed, and the thing itself clearly testifies, that in Joseph was adumbrated, what was afterwards more fully exhibited in Christ, the Head of the Church, in order that each member may form itself to the imitation of his example.
Fuente: Calvin’s Complete Commentary
CRITICAL NOTES.
Gen. 37:18. Conspired.] Heb. Cunningly plotted.
Gen. 37:19. This dreamer.] Heb. Lord, or master of dreams; using the title in bitter scorn.
Gen. 37:23. They stript Joseph of his coat.] According to Eastern habits, it would be his only garment. He entered Egypt naked, as was the custom with slaves and captives (Isa. 20:4), in strange contrast to his subsequent array of pomp. (Gen. 41:42.) (Alford.)
Gen. 37:25. Ishmaelites.] In Gen. 37:28 and in Gen. 39:1, they are called Midianites. The caravan consisted, probably, of both of these. The general meaning is. Arabian Merchants. Gilead. Celebrated for a precious balm. (Jer. 8:22; Jer. 46:11.) Spicery. This is a species of gum called tragacanth. Balm. It was a very precious gum obtained from the balsam tree, almost peculiar to Palestine. (Alford.)Myrrh. Gum, laudanum.
Gen. 37:28. Twenty pieces of silver.] The price of a lad under twenty years of age. (Lev. 27:5.) The full price of a slave was thirty shekels. (Exo. 21:32.)
MAIN HOMILETICS OF THE PARAGRAPH.Gen. 37:18-28
THE CONSPIRACY TO MURDER JOSEPH
The brethren of Joseph conspired against him to slay him. (Gen. 37:18.) This foul crime furnishes
I. An example of the rapidly downward course of evil. Josephs brethren at first envied him, then envy passed into animosity, animosity into fixed hatred, and fixed hatred rapidly grew into a scheme of murder. So steep is the descent from the evil things within the heart of man to the lowest depths of crime.
II. An example of the bold daring of sinners. Josephs brethren are prepared to brave all the consequences. They are ready with a deceitful story to account to their father for the loss of his favourite son. (Gen. 37:20.) They trust to artifice, falsehood, cunning, and deceit. They are daring enough to cover up their crime with a lie.
III. An example of guilt incurred even where purpose has not ripened into act. Josephs brethren were guilty of murder though they stopped short of the deed. Thought and act are the same in the sight of God. (Mat. 5:28.) It was not for killing his brother (for that might have been accidental), but for killing him through hatred, that Cain was branded a murderer. (1Jn. 3:15.) Murder is the goal or limit to which hatred tends when not repressed. But these men were prevented from carrying out their purpose, not by unforeseen circumstances, not by fear at a sudden realization of the magnitude of their crime, but by the love of gain,stronger in them than even their hatred and purpose of murder. It was not the voice of conscience, or the effect of grace, but the power of another passion that comes in here to stay the hand of crime. It was the triumph of avarice over malice. (Gen. 37:27-28.) One sin is sometimes cast out by another. Devils may be cast out by Beelzebub, the prince of the devils.
IV. An example of degrees of guiltiness even among those who have lent themselves to one design. The brethren of Joseph were not all equally guilty. Simeon, Levi, and others wished to slay him, but Judah proposed his being sold into captivity. (Gen. 37:26-27.) Reuben proposed to cast him into a pit, intending, probably, to fetch him out when the others were not by. He wanted to save Joseph, but secretly, for he had not courage enough to save him openly. All this shows that the brethren were not equally guilty, though the motive of the least culpable among them was not superior virtue, but some softness of character, or the influence of a stronger temptation.
SUGGESTIVE COMMENTS ON THE VERSES
Gen. 37:18. In an honest and obedient simplicity, Joseph comes to inquire of his brethrens health, and now may not return to carry news of his own misery: whilst he thinks of their welfare, they are plotting his destruction. Who would have expected this cruelty in them, which should be the fathers of Gods church?(Bp. Hall.)
Cain has left a name of infamy to all generations of mankind. But where shall we find nine men conspiring at once to kill a brothera brother whose amiable qualities deserved their warmest lovewho tenderly loved them, and was in the very act of showing his love to them at the time when their fury broke loose upon him. Joseph had too good reason, as David afterwards had to say in the person of Christ, For my love they are mine adversaries.(Bush.)
Gen. 37:19-20. Who will say that the workers of iniquity have no knowledge? They have all the cunning as well as the cruelty of the old serpent. But what do they mean by that sarcastic saying, we shall see what will become of his dreams? If they had considered them as feigned through ambition, they would not have felt half the resentment. They considered these dreams as the intimations of heaven, and their language included nothing less than a challenge to the Almighty. But is it possible that they could think of thwarting the Divine counsels? It is possible. Witness Pharaohs pursuit of Israel, after all that he had seen and felt of the Divine judgments; Sauls attempts on Davids life; Herods murder of the children of Bethlehem; and the conspiracy of the Jews against Christ, who, as many of them knew had raised Lazarus from the dead, and done many miracles. Yes, we will kill him, say they, and then let God advance him to honour if He can! But they shall see what will become of his dreams. They shall see them accomplished by the very means they are concerting to overthrow them. Thus, though the kings of the earth take counsel together against the Lord and against His Anointed, He that sitteth in the heavens shall laugh at them, the Lord shall have them in derision. Josephs brethren, like the sheaves in the dream, should make obeisance to him; and at the name of Jesus every knee shall bow.(Fuller.)
Gen. 37:21-22. Reuben, though he had been very wicked (Gen. 35:22), shows now a tender heart.(Jacobus.)
As the murderous scheme was prevented by Reubens plan of deliverance, and modified by Judahs proposal, so, in the life of our Lord, the scheme of the Sanhedrin was changed more than once by arresting circumstances. Thus Providence turned the destructive plots to a beneficent end. It was the chief tendency of these schemes to promote the highest glory of the hated one, whose glory they aimed to destroy.(Lange.)
He was not cruel, simply because he was guilty of a different class of sin. It is well for us, before we take credit to ourselves for being free from this or that sin, to inquire whether it be banished by grace or only by another sin. You are not censorious, but then pause and ask whether you are not too lax to be censorious. You are not a tale-bearer or a busybody, but are you certain that you have in you sufficient love for others to make you at all interested in these matters?(Robertson.)
That weakness of character for which Reuben was remarkable, had also its good side. It rendered him incapable of committing some sins.
Gen. 37:23-24. It was not enough to injure him, they must also insult him. Thus Jesus was stripped and degraded before He suffered. Now it was, as they afterwards confessed one to another in the Egyptian prison, that they saw the anguish of his soul, when he besought them, and they would not hear. (Gen. 42:21.)(Fuller.)
How dearly did he purchase this honour bestowed upon him by his father! They no doubt considered it as an insult to themselves that he came to them decked with this trophy of his superior standing in the patriarchs regard. His robe, the evidence of Jacobs tender regard, might have reminded them that to murder Joseph was in effect to murder their father. It would deprive him of the comfort of life and fill up all the rest of his days with bitterness and sorrow.(Bush.)
The Lord delivers His people from the pit of their sins and sorrows.(Zec. 9:11.)
All the spite of his brethren cannot make Joseph cast off the livery of his fathers love. What need we care for the censures of men, if our hearts can tell us we are in favour with God?(Bp. Hall.)
Gen. 37:25. To weep for their wickedness, they should have sat down rather. But the devil had drawn a hard hoof over their hearts, that either they felt no remorse of what they had done, for the present; or else they sought to ease themselves of it by eating and merrymaking. They drank wine in bowls, but no man was sorry for the affliction of Joseph. (Amo. 6:6).(Trapp.)
Observe the calmness of these men after their crime. We often think respecting the tyrants of whom we read in history, that they must have been haunted by the furies. It is not so, there is a worse doom for sin than this; it is that it makes the heart callous and forgetful of its presence. If there were but the sting it would be well, for it would lead to reformation.(Robertson.)
Egypt was their market. This agrees with the testimony of classic historians, as Homer and Herodotus, who tells us that Egypt was a storehouse for drugs, and a seat of physicians.(Jacobus.)
Gen. 37:26. It were to be wished, that whenever we are tempted to sin, we would ask ourselves this question, What profit is it?(Trapp.)
Gen. 37:27-28. Judahs proposal contains words of mercy, but it was mercy mixed with covetousness. It is not unusual for covetous men to urge their objects under a show of generosity and kindness. But if he did, it was the profit that wrought upon the company. The love of money induced them to sell their brother for a slave. A goodly price at which they valued him! But let not Joseph complain, seeing a greater than he was sold by Judas Iscariot for but a little more.(Fuller.)
Reuben and Judah remind us of Joseph of Arimatha and Nicodemus, who did not consent to the sentence of the Sanhedrin; but they were less inclined to the right, and their, half measures remind us of Pilates attempt to save, though they had not, like him, the power in their hands; since being implicated by their former animosity towards Joseph, they could only weakly oppose their angry brethren.(Lange.)
Little did the Ishmeelitish merchants know what a treasure they bought, carried, and sold; more precious than all their balms and myrrhs. Little did they think that they had in their hands the lord of Egypt, the jewel of the world. Why should we contemn any mans meanness, when we know not his destiny?(Bp. Hall.)
The saints of God are His princes, His portion, His heirs; but they are in a strange country; they are unknown in the world.
These merchantmen testify to the outward increase and spiritual decrease of the descendants of Ishmael. They are witnesses to a heartrending scene, but coolly pay their twenty pieces of silver, reminding us of the thirty paid by Judas, then go their way with the poor lad, who passes his home without hope of deliverance, and is for a long time, like Moses, David, and Christ, reckoned among the lost.(Lange.)
Fuente: The Preacher’s Complete Homiletical Commentary Edited by Joseph S. Exell
Luk 20:14
See Gen 42:22 .-Observe how the LORD interposes by his instruments in the hour of need!
Fuente: Hawker’s Poor Man’s Commentary (Old and New Testaments)
Gen 37:18 And when they saw him afar off, even before he came near unto them, they conspired against him to slay him.
Ver. 18. They conspired against him. ] So did the husbandmen against Christ: “This is the heir,” say they, &c. Luk 20:14 The word is by one rendered, They craftily conspired. The Greek hath it, malignantly: craft and cruelty go usually together in the Church’s adversaries. The devil lends them his seven heads to plot, and his ten horns to push poor Joseph, that dreads no danger.
Fuente: John Trapp’s Complete Commentary (Old and New Testaments)
NASB (UPDATED) TEXT: Gen 37:18-24
18When they saw him from a distance and before he came close to them, they plotted against him to put him to death. 19They said to one another, “Here comes this dreamer! 20Now then, come and let us kill him and throw him into one of the pits; and we will say, ‘A wild beast devoured him.’ Then let us see what will become of his dreams!” 21But Reuben heard this and rescued him out of their hands and said, “Let us not take his life.” 22Reuben further said to them, “Shed no blood. Throw him into this pit that is in the wilderness, but do not lay hands on him” – that he might rescue him out of their hands, to restore him to his father. 23So it came about, when Joseph reached his brothers, that they stripped Joseph of his tunic, the varicolored tunic that was on him; 24and they took him and threw him into the pit. Now the pit was empty, without any water in it.
Gen 37:18 “they saw him from a distance” This possibly refers to the ostentatious coat given to him by his father, which he probably always wore.
“they plotted against him to put him to death” The rare VERB (BDB 647, KB 699, Hithpael IMPERFECT) is parallel to hate in Psa 105:25. This VERB in the Piel stem is used by YHWH of the Midianites in Num 25:18. The Qal PARTICIPLE is translated “swindler” in Mal 1:14.
The murderous sin of Cain against Abel (Genesis 4) is confirmed again in fallen humanity. Self interest is the deciding factor!
Gen 37:20 “we will say” See Gen 37:32. They premeditatively planned how to kill him, how to deal with his corpse, and how to cover their actions with their father.
“Then let us see what will become of his dreams” This may be an allusion to their own personal desire for inheritance, which they were afraid Joseph might usurp.
Gen 37:21-22 “Reuben” We cannot be certain about the exact motivation of Reuben, but from what is recorded at the end of Gen 37:22, it seems to show that he felt a responsibility as the eldest son to protect his younger brother. It may have been that he hoped this would help to reinstate him with Jacob, in light of Gen 35:22. I think that he really wanted to save Joseph, which can be seen by his reaction in Gen 37:29-30. This event clearly shows he has lost his influence and leadership among the brothers.
Notice Reuben’s words.
1. “Let us not take his life,” Gen 37:21, BDB 645, KB 697, Hiphil IMPERFECT used in a COHORTATIVE sense
2. “Shed no blood,” Gen 37:22, BDB 1049, KB 1629, Qal IMPERFECT used in a JUSSIVE sense
3. “Throw him into this pit,” Gen 37:22, BDB 1020, KB 1527, Hiphil IMPERATIVE
4. “But do not lay hands on him,” Gen 37:22, BDB 1018, KB 1511, Qal IMPERFECT used in a JUSSIVE sense
Notice that Reuben’s ulterior motive is stated.
1. that he might rescue him, BDB 664, KB 717, Hiphil INFINITIVE CONSTRUCT
2. to restore him to his father, BDB 996, KB 1427, Hiphil INFINITIVE CONSTRUCT
Gen 37:24 “they took him and threw him into a pit” We can understand something of the trauma this teenage boy experienced from what is recorded in Gen 42:21, which describes his plea for help.
“without any water in it” This is obviously a dry cistern (not a well, but a water collector), which was so common in this area of Palestine. The rabbis say that they were full of snakes and scorpions, but this is only an assumption.
Fuente: You Can Understand the Bible: Study Guide Commentary Series by Bob Utley
conspired. Compare Mat 27:1.
Fuente: Companion Bible Notes, Appendices and Graphics
conspired: 1Sa 19:1, Psa 31:13, Psa 37:12, Psa 37:32, Psa 94:21, Psa 105:25, Psa 109:4, Mat 21:38, Mat 27:1, Mar 12:7, Mar 14:1, Luk 20:14, Luk 20:15, Joh 11:53, Act 23:12
Reciprocal: Gen 27:42 – comfort himself Gen 37:4 – hated him Gen 44:7 – General Gen 44:16 – God hath Gen 49:23 – General Gen 50:20 – ye thought Psa 76:10 – Surely Pro 18:19 – brother Mat 27:23 – Why Act 7:9 – sold
Fuente: The Treasury of Scripture Knowledge
UNBROTHERLY BROTHERS
They conspired against (Joseph).
Gen 37:18
The scene changes. Dothan was, and is, on the line of traffic between the East and Egypt; it was quite natural, therefore, that a company of merchants, camels and servants should pass along. A happy (?) thought now struck the brethren, as this picture rose to view, and, on the suggestion of Judah, they at once sold their young brother for twenty pieces of silverabout 3, as he was only a boy.
There is curious irony in this transaction, as the Midianites were the descendants of Abraham through his union with Keturah. Thus do these men oppress the children of promise.
I. A striking feature in the narrative is the discomfiture of Reuben on returning to the pit.Joseph is gone! Could you not imagine such a possibility, Reuben? Feeble, wicked compromises will avail no more than the rending of your garments!
Is there no balm in Gilead? asked the prophet, and the question is proverbial. These Midianites (or Ishmaelites) were carrying sweet spices from Gilead to Egypt; but we may be sure that they had no balm sweet enough to heal poor Josephs breaking heart, as he is thus torn away from the past.
II. How hard and terrible is sin!Some would have us believe that sin is only weakness, imperfection, and ignorance. How fearfully selfish it is! The offended vanitythe amour propreof these men cares nothing about the state of Josephs feelings. He may go to Egypt, or elsewhere. He may die a cruel death. Anything! Nor do they care about their fathers feelings either. He had sent Joseph after their welfare. They send him Josephs coat dipped in blood.
Jacob naturally inferredas he was meant to dothat Joseph was rent in pieces by some wild beast. And many, many days he mourned for the bright and interesting dreamer who was gone. And when, with strange perversity, these murderers would have comforted him, Jacobwith the olden determinationresolves to mourn on until he enters the graveSheol: not the tomb so much as the abode of the departed. Thus he had his ideas of future life. The words most certainly warrant the interpretation that his mourning would end, not in extinction, but in re-union.
III. Let us notice again, how awful is the indifference of the sinners brought before us.For many a long year they never felt their guilt. They could eat, and drink, and sleep, and workand even comfort their father. They felt secure. But they were startled at length (Gen 42:21). Moreover,
Two people look at a boy. One can see only a butt for ridicule, a good object for missiles, cuffs and blows, or of cruel indifference. The other person sees not only a human being, but future greatnessJoseph, Adam Clark, Walter Scott, etc., etc. What makes the difference between those people? Which type do you belong to?
IV. Lastly, suffering souls rejoice!We know that Joseph suffered. Long after it came to his brothers, and they described to one another the anguish of his soul as he vainly cried for mercy (Gen 42:21). Perhaps to-day you think that your cry is neither heard by God nor man. Fear not. God shall lift up thy head. And just as only we can be soothed by the thought of our suffering being fellowship with Christ, so also can we alone truly love one another through Him. It is Jesus only. Native amiability, ordinary good-nature, is about as reliable as Reuben of old. The best of people need a Saviour.
Illustration
(1) Was Jacob reproved for his own weakness? The coat now so stained with blood had played a fatal part in this tragedy, and he was responsible for it.
Did he remember? There, in yonder tent, a pale, colourless old man of 168 years, his own father, is quietly fading out of life. How had he treated him when, long ago, he seemed on the verge of the grave? Yes, someone else had played a trick with a kid of the goats, and that someone was Rebekah, his mother, lying to her feeble husband for the sake of her favourite son. What a Nemesis there is in history (Gen 27:9).
(2) Both the despair of Jacob and the despair of Joseph were mistakes, for had they seen what God was providing for them, they would have rested calmly in peaceful hope, knowing that God would do all things well.
Let us remember that amidst all the sin and wickedness, and misery of the world, God is reigning, and He will bring all things that seem dark and sad to some issue which will repay all the pain by which it has been reached.
Fuente: Church Pulpit Commentary
Gen 37:18-19. When they saw him they conspired against him It was not in a heat, or upon a sudden provocation, that they thought to slay him, but from malice prepense, and in cold blood. Behold this dreamer cometh Hebrew, this master of dreams; that covers his own ambitious desires and designs, with pretences and fictions of dreams. See the progress of vice! From envy and malice they proceeded to conspire against the life of their brother, and then contrived a lie to impose upon their own father!
Fuente: Joseph Bensons Commentary on the Old and New Testaments
Gen 37:18-30. To J we may assign Gen 37:18 b (and before, etc.), Gen 37:21 (substituting Judah for Reuben), Gen 37:23; Gen 37:25; Gen 37:27-28 (and sold to silver), to E Gen 37:18 a, Gen 37:19 f., Gen 37:22; Gen 37:24; Gen 37:28 (And there . . . pit, And they . . . Egypt), Gen 37:29 f. According to J the brothers, seeing Joseph coming, conspire to murder him. Judah dissuades them from actual murder. When Joseph arrives, they strip off his hated coat. While at food, they see approaching an Ishmaelite caravan, travelling to Egypt with gums (used for embalming). Judah urges the tie of brotherhood and the more profitable course of selling him for a slave than killing him, and then covering the blood to stifle its cry for vengeance (Gen 4:10*). So they sell Joseph to the Ishmaelites for twenty shekels, and the Ishmaelites take him to Egypt. According to E, the brothers, seeing Joseph in the distance, plot to murder him and cast him into a pit, and ascribe his death to a wild beast, then they will see what will become of his dreams. Reuben proposes that they should put him in a pit and leave him to die, to avoid the risk they will incur by shedding blood, intending to return when his brothers had left, and to rescue him. So Joseph was put into the pit [and the brothers abandoned him to his fate. After their departure] Midianite merchants pass by, discover Joseph, lift him out of the pit and take him to Egypt, where they sell him to Potiphar, (Gen 37:36). Reuben returns that he may rescue Joseph, only to find him gone, and then goes back to his brothers with a despairing cry. Observe that this representation of Joseph as kid- napped rather than sold by his brothers is confirmed by Gen 40:15, I was stolen away out of the land of the Hebrews.
Gen 37:31-36. The analysis is uncertain. According to one narrative, the brothers seem to have sent Josephs coat to Jacob, after dipping it in goats blood, according to the other to have brought the coat to him as it was; but possibly, according to one, they brought the stained coat, according to the other sent the unstained. On Gen 37:34 see p. 110. vv. Gen 37:36 concludes Es narrative; the Midianites sold Joseph into Egypt to Potiphar. If the text were a unity the Midianites would have been the Ishmaelites (Gen 37:28). The Ishmaelites are mentioned as selling him in Gen 39:1. Potiphar probably represents the Egyptian Pedephr, He whom the sun-god gives. He was a eunuch (not officer as RV), and chief of the court cooks or butchers. They seem to have become the royal bodyguard.
Fuente: Peake’s Commentary on the Bible
37:18 And when they saw him afar off, even before he came near unto them, they
(g) conspired against him to slay him.
(g) The Holy Spirit does not cover the faults of men, as vain writers do, who make virtues out of vices.
Fuente: Geneva Bible Notes
The extreme measures Joseph’s brothers considered to silence him have led some commentators to conclude that it was not just personal hatred springing from jealousy that motivated them (cf. Cain, Gen 4:9). They may have wanted to alter the will of God as revealed in Joseph’s dreams as well.
"The brothers’ hate is therefore a rebellion against the matter contained in the dreams, against the divine power itself, standing behind them, who had given the dreams. The expression usually translated by ’the dreamer’ [Gen 37:19] means much more than our English word, namely, the one empowered to prophetic dreams." [Note: von Rad, p. 353.]
Reuben, as the first-born, looked after his father’s interests and, knowing what sorrow Joseph’s death would bring to Jacob, sought to spare Joseph’s life and release him from the pit later. Perhaps Reuben wanted to get back in the good graces of his father (cf. Gen 35:22). Joseph’s place of confinement was evidently a dry well or cistern.