Exegetical and Hermeneutical Commentary of Isaiah 1:9
Except the LORD of hosts had left unto us a very small remnant, we should have been as Sodom, [and] we should have been like unto Gomorrah.
9. the Lord of hosts ] In Hebr. Yahveh Tsbth, a peculiarly solemn title of the God of Israel, specially common in the prophetic writings. On the different theories as to the origin of the expression, see the Note in Cheyne, Comm. i. pp. 11 ff. The simplest explanation of its origin is that which regards it as equivalent to “Jehovah (the God) of the armies of Israel” (1Sa 17:45; cf. Exo 7:4). It is true that this cannot be the precise sense in which the phrase is used by the prophets, since it is a fundamental conception with them that Jehovah is no longer on the side of the hosts of Israel. But just as Amos took the phrase “day of Jehovah” from the lips of the people (see below on Isa 2:12), and gave it an interpretation diametrically opposed to the popular one, so he may have done also with this expression. If this be the correct view, “God of battles” may approximately reproduce the sense in which it is used by the prophets: Jehovah is still the Lord of Hosts, although He has disowned those of Israel. Or, if a vaguer idea be preferred, we may adopt the (All-sovereign Lord) of the LXX. as sufficiently expressive.
a very small remnant ] The adverbial phrase “very small” might (disregarding the accents) be taken with the following clause, which, would then read “we might readily have been as Sodom, &c.” (as in Gen 26:10; Psa 94:17; Psa 119:87). The word for remnant ( sard) is only here used by Isaiah. He perhaps purposely avoids sh’ r, which he would have used in speaking of the ideal remnant that inherits the hope of the future.
Fuente: The Cambridge Bible for Schools and Colleges
Except … – It is owing entirely to the mercy of God, that we are not like Sodom. The prophet traces this not to the goodness of the nation, not to any power or merit of theirs, but solely to the mercy of God. This passage the apostle Paul has used in an argument to establish the doctrine of divine sovereignty in the salvation of people; see the note at Rom 9:29.
The Lord – Hebrew Yahweh. Note Isa 1:2.
Of hosts – tseba’oth – the word sometimes translated Sabaoth; Rom 9:29; Jam 5:4. The word means literally armies or military hosts. It is applied, however, to the angels which surround the throne of God; 1Ki 22:19; 2Ch 18:18; Psa 103:21; and to the stars or constellations that appear to be marshalled in the sky; Jer 33:22; Isa 40:26. This host, or the host of heaven, was frequently an object of idolatrous worship; Deu 4:19; Deu 17:3; 2Ki 17:16. God is called Yahweh of hosts because he is at the head of all these armies, as their leader and commander; he marshals and directs them – as a general does the army under his command. This, says Gesenius, is the most common name of God in Isaiah, and in Jeremiah, Zechariah, and Malachi. It represents him as the ruler of the hosts of heaven, that is, the angels and the stars. Sometimes, but less frequently, we meet with the appellation Yahweh, God of hosts. Hence, some suppose the expression Yahweh of hosts to be elliptical. But it is not a correct assertion that Yahweh, as a proper name, admits of no genitive. But such relations and adjuncts as depend upon the genitive, often depend upon proper names. So in Arabic, one is called Rebiah of the poor in reference to his liability. The name is given here, because to save any portion of a nation so wicked implied the exercise of the same power as that by which he controlled the hosts of heaven.
Remnant – A small part – that which is left. It means here, that God had spared a portion of the nation, so that they were not entirely overthrown.
We should have been as Sodom … – This does not refer to the character of the people, but to their destiny. If God had not interposed to save them they would have been overwhelmed entirely as Sodom was; compare Gen 19:24-25.
Fuente: Albert Barnes’ Notes on the Bible
Isa 1:9
Except the Lord of hosts had left unto us a very mall remnant.
The influence of good men
1. Gods greatness in the universe. The Lord of hosts, or Jehovah of hosts. Who are His hosts? Angels. Who shall count the number of these troops? He is their Creator and Sustainer.
2. Gods authority over good men. He is here represented as having left a very small remnant. whilst an existences are absolutely His, He has a special interest in the good. He keeps good men here as long as He thinks fit. He removes them at His pleasure.
I. THEIR INFLUENCE IS HIGHLY BENEFICENT. From what evil did this remnant deliver the country? The answer will come out with potency by replying to two other questions.
1. What was the moral condition of Sodom and Gomorrah? Their sin was very grievous (Gen 18:20).
2. What was their doom? (Gen 19:24-25.) Now, it was from this moral corruption and terrible doom these good people, it is said in our text, delivered others. Ye are the salt of the earth, History abounds with examples of moral declination, and all hearts are conscious of this gravitating force, What is the counteractive? The life of Christ in man. That life flashes a light upon the corrupt heart of society, and makes it blush. But few will dare to sin in the presence of living holiness. Vice cowers under the radiant eye of virtue.
II. Their influence is highly beneficent, HOWEVER FEW THEIR NUMBER. A very small remnant. A little goodness on this earth goes a great way. Even one man like Moses, Elijah, Paul, Luther, Whitefield, Wesley, may stop the flow of depravity and turn the destinies of an age. Conclusion–
1. The criminal ignorance of nations in relation to their true benefactors
2. The supreme value of Christianity. (D. Thomas, D. D.)
Beneficial influence of goodness
On a hot summers day, some years ago, I was sailing with a friend in a tiny boat on a miniature lake enclosed like a cup within a circle of steep, bare Scottish hills. On the shoulder of the brown sunburnt mountain, and full in sight, was a well with a crystal stream trickling over its lip, and making its way down towards the lake. Around the wells month and along the course of the rivulet a belt of green stood out in strong contrast with the iron surface of the rocks all around. We soon agreed as to what should be made of it. There it was, a legend clearly printed by the finger of God on the side of these silent hills, teaching the passer-by how needful a good man is, and how useful he may be in a desert world. (W. Arnot, D. D.)
The, Lord of hosts
Jehovah of hosts, or of armies, is a favourite expression of the Hebrew writers, and especially of Isaiah, Jeremiah, Zechariah and Malachi, by which they recognise Him as the universal governor of heaven and earth, who has ordained and constituted the services of men and angels in a wonderful order, and who employs His kingly and almighty power to rule the nations in righteousness, and, as now, both to punish and to save His chosen people. (Sir E. Strachey, Bart.)
Fuente: Biblical Illustrator Edited by Joseph S. Exell
Verse 9. The Lord of hosts – “JEHOVAH God of hosts”] As this title of God, Yehovah tsebaoth, “JEHOVAH of hosts, occurs here for the first time, I think it proper to note, that I translate it always, as in this place, “JEHOVAH God of hosts;” taking it as an elliptical expression for Yehovah Elohey tsebaoth. This title imports that JEHOVAH is the God or Lord of hosts or armies; as he is the Creator and Supreme Governor of all beings in heaven and earth, and disposeth and ruleth them all in their several orders and stations; the almighty, universal Lord.
We should have been as Sodom] As completely and finally ruined as that and the cities of the plain were, no vestige of which remains at this day.
Fuente: Adam Clarke’s Commentary and Critical Notes on the Bible
If God, by his infinite power and goodness, had not restrained our enemies, and reserved some of us, the whole nation and race of us had been utterly cut off, as the people of Sodom and Gomorrah were; so great was the rage and power of our enemies, and so utterly unable we were to deliver ourselves.
Fuente: English Annotations on the Holy Bible by Matthew Poole
9. Jehovah of Sabaoth, that is,God of the angelic and starry hosts (Psa 59:5;Psa 147:4; Psa 148:2).The latter were objects of idolatry, called hence Sabaism (2Ki17:16). God is above even them (1Ch16:26). “The groves” were symbols of these starryhosts; it was their worship of Sabaoth instead of the Lord ofSabaoth, which had caused the present desolation (2Ch24:18). It needed no less a power than His, to preserve even a”remnant.” Condescending grace for the elect’s sake, sinceHe has no need of us, seeing that He has countless hosts to serveHim.
Fuente: Jamieson, Fausset and Brown’s Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible
Except the Lord of hosts had left unto us a very small remnant,…. This is an instance of the super abounding goodness of the Lord of hosts, as the Targum expresses it; that he should, in those very wicked and calamitous times, leave and reserve a few from being defiled with the sins of the age, and from being involved in the general calamity of it; which was true of the Christian Jews at the time of Jerusalem’s destruction; for that this prophecy belongs to these times is clear from the application of it by the Apostle Paul, Ro 9:29 and which confirms the sense given of the above passages: “the very small remnant” are the remnant according to the election of grace, the little flock, the few that entered in at the strait gate and are saved, or the few that believed in Christ, and so were saved from that untoward generation; these were “left”, reserved, distinguished, and secured in the grace of election, being a remnant according to it, in the hands of Christ to whom they were given, and in whom they were preserved; in redemption by him, that they might be a peculiar people; in providence till called, in which the Lord watched over them to do them good, and waited to be gracious to them, and saved them to be called; and in effectual calling, in which he separated them from the rest of the world, and kept them by his power through faith unto salvation. And this was done “unto us”; for the sake of his church, that that might continue, and he might have a seed to serve him: and by “the Lord of hosts”, of the hosts of heaven, the sun, and moon, and stars, and of the angels there, and of the inhabitants of the earth; which shows great condescension in him to regard this remnant, and great grace to them; since he could not stand in need of them, having the host of heaven on his right hand and on his left; nor was there any thing in them that could deserve this of him; but it was, as Jarchi observes, in his mercy, and not for their righteousness: to which may be added, that since he is the Lord of hosts, he was able to protect and preserve this remnant, notwithstanding all the opposition of men and devils, as he did; and had he not taken such a method as this,
we should have been as Sodom, [and] we should have been like unto Gomorrah: cities that were infamous for their sins, and notorious for the punishment of them, being consumed by fire from heaven,
Ge 13:13 and not only the Jews, but any and every nation, even the whole world, would have been like these cities, both for sin and punishment, had it not been for the distinguishing grace of God, in leaving and reserving a few for his glory, and the support of his interest. All the holiness that ever was, is, or will be in the world, is owing to electing, redeeming, and efficacious grace: there had not been a holy man nor a holy woman in the world, in any age, if God had not taken such methods of grace; and it is owing to, and for the sake of, this small remnant, that temporal judgments are often averted from a nation and people, and that the conflagration of the world is not yet; this is kept back till they are gathered in; and were it not for this distinguishing grace, every individual of mankind would have been cast into hell, and must have suffered the vengeance of eternal fire, which the punishment of Sodom and Gomorrah, was an example of.
Fuente: John Gill’s Exposition of the Entire Bible
For the present, however, Jerusalem was saved from this extremity. The omnipotence of God had mercifully preserved it: “Unless Jehovah of hosts had left us a little of what had escaped, we had become like Sodom, we were like Gomorrah.” Sarid (which is rendered inaccurately in the Sept.; cf., Rom 9:29) was used, even in the early Mosaic usage of the language, to signify that which escaped the general destruction (Deu 2:34, etc.); and (which might very well be connected with the verbs which follow: “we were very nearly within a little like Sodom,” etc.) is to be taken in connection with sarid , as the pausal form clearly shows: “a remnant which was but a mere trifle” (on this use of the word, see Isa 16:14; 2Ch 12:7; Pro 10:20; Psa 105:12). Jehovah Zebaoth stands first, for the sake of emphasis. It would have been all over with Israel long ago, if it had not been for the compassion of God (vid., Hos 11:8). And because it was the omnipotence of God, which set the will of His compassion in motion, He is called Jehovah Zebaoth , Jehovah (the God) of the heavenly hosts – an expression in which Zebaoth is a dependent genitive, and not, as Luzzatto supposes, an independent name of God as the Absolute, embracing within itself all the powers of nature. The prophet says “us” and “we.” He himself was an inhabitant of Jerusalem; and even if he had not been so, he was nevertheless an Israelite. He therefore associates himself with his people, like Jeremiah in Lam 3:22. He had had to experience the anger of God along with the rest; and so, on the other hand, he also celebrates the mighty compassion of God, which he had experienced in common with them. But for this compassion, the people of God would have become like Sodom, from which only four human beings escaped: it would have resembled Gomorrah, which was absolutely annihilated. (On the prefects in the protasis and apodosis, see Ges. 126, 5.)
Fuente: Keil & Delitzsch Commentary on the Old Testament
9. Except the Lord of hosts had left unto us Here he concludes what he had formerly declared concerning God’s chastisements, that the desolation which shall take place — or rather which is present, and which they now behold — may be compared to the destruction of Sodom, were it not that the Lord snatched as it were from the burning a very small remnant. And this verse confirms what I formerly said, that the Prophet’s description of the calamities which had already taken place is interwoven with those events which were immediately at hand, as if he had said, Be not deceived by flatteries; you would be in the same condition that Sodom and Gomorrah now are, were it not that God, in compassion on you, has preserved a remnant. This agrees with the words of Jeremiah,
It is of the Lord’s mercies that we are not consumed. (Lam 3:22.)
Hence we ought to observe two things. First, the Prophet here describes utter destruction; and yet, because God had to deal with his Church and his beloved people, that judgment is mitigated by special grace, so that out of the general ruin of the whole nation God rescues his people, whom he justly compares to a very small remnant. But if God punished the crimes of the Jews by such dreadful chastisements, let us consider that we may share the same fate if we imitate their rebellion: for God had set apart that nation for himself, and had distinguished them from the ordinary lot of other men. Why then should he spare us if we shall be hardened in our ungodliness and treachery? Or rather, what is likely to be the result of that mass and sink of crimes in which men throughout the whole world give way to their passions? Unquestionably it will be the same with the fate of Sodom and Gomorrah, unless his vengeance shall be restrained by a regard to that gracious covenant in which he promised that the Church shall be eternal; and this threatening, which is truly awful and alarming, is applicable to all obstinate and incurable men, whose vices no punishments can destroy or weaken.
Again, we ought to observe that saying of Jeremiah, which I have already glanced at, that it must be attributed to the tender mercies of God that we are not altogether destroyed. (Lam 2:22.) For if We Shall Consider the vast amount Of wickedness which prevails among all classes, we shall wonder that even a single individual is left, and that all have not been removed from the land of the living; and in this way God withdraws his hand, (Eze 20:22,) that there may be some Church preserved in the world. This is the reason assigned by Paul, who is the best interpreter of this passage, when, by quoting it, he represses the haughtiness of the Jews, that they may not boast of the mere name, as if it had been enough that they were descended from the fathers; for he reminds them that God could act towards them as he had formerly done towards the fathers, but that through his tender mercies a remnant shall be saved. (Rom 9:27.) And why? That the Church may not utterly perish; for it is through the favor which he bears towards it that the Lord, though our obstinacy lays him under the necessity of trying the severest judgments, still reserves some small seed. (Rom 9:29.) This statement ought to yield us powerful consolation even in those heaviest calamities in which we are apt to think that it is all over with the Church; that, though everything should go into confusion, and the world, as we say, be turned upside down, we may persevere with unshaken fortitude, and may rest assured that God will always be mindful of his Church.
A very small remnant This clause may be connected either with what goes before or with what follows, and accordingly some render it, We would have been almost like Sodom. But I prefer connecting it with the former clause, so as to deduce that the number which God had reserved out of the destruction is small. Some think that: כ ( caph) is here used affirmatively, so as to express the matter more strongly; and I have no objection to that view, though we may take it in its natural and literal signification, as if he had said, “and that shall be a small number.” This declaration ought to be carefully observed; for if the Church does not spread far and wide, men are wont to despise her. Hence it comes that hypocrites are proud of their numbers; and weak men, terrified by the pompous display of those numbers, stagger. We also learn from it that we ought not to judge by the largeness of the number, unless we choose to prefer the chaff to the wheat, because the quantity is greater; but we ought to be satisfied with knowing that, though the number of the godly be small, still God acknowledges them as his chosen people; and we ought also to call to remembrance that consolatory saying,
Fear not, little flock; for it is your Father’s good pleasure to give you the kingdom. (Luk 12:32.)
Fuente: Calvin’s Complete Commentary
GODS RELUCTANCE TO PUNISH
Isa. 1:9. Except the Lord of hosts had left us a very small remnant, we should have been as Sodom, and we should have been like unto Gomorrah.
God had humbled His people because of their transgressions, but He had not utterly destroyed them, as He might have done in strict justice. This reminds us
1. That the punishments that befall wicked men in this world frequently fall short of their deserts.
2. That this disproportion between guilt and chastisement occurs because God is not so much concerned to punish sin as to reclaim sinners. God chastises, in the first instance, that He may correct, and it is with reluctance that He increases the severity of His strokes [234]
[234] See note (), page 18.
These facts should lead us
1. To adore the divine benignity. How worthy of our love and worship is this God who is no mere vindictive avenger of broken law, but a loving Father who chastens us, not for His pleasure, but for our profit!
2. To gratefully acknowledge the mercy that has mingled with the judgments which our sins have drawn down upon us (Lam. 3:10) [237]
3. To shrink with abhorrence from any abuse of the divine long-suffering. The fact that God is so reluctant to punish, instead of encouraging us in rebellion, should incite us to prompt and loving obedience. Nothing can be more base than to turn the grace of God into lasciviousness; and nothing could be more dangerous [240] (Pro. 29:1).
[237] If in an affliction we would pour forth to God such acceptable prayers as may obtain comfort in our crosses and deliverance from all our calamities, we must confess our sins, and humbly acknowledge that we deserve to be overwhelmed with much more heavy plagues and punishments. And so the Lord will excuse us when we accuse ourselves, remit our sins when we remember them, and absolve us from punishment when in all humility we acknowledge that we have justly deserved the fearfullest of His plagues. For if we, who have but a little of the milk of mercy, are moved with compassion when either our sons or our servants acknowledge their faults, and offer themselves of their own accord to Buffer that punishment which they have deserved, how can we doubt that God, whose love and mercy towards us are infinite and incomprehensible, will be pitiful and ready to forgive us when He sees us thus humbled?Downame, 1644.
[240] Take heed of abusing this mercy of God. Suck not poison out of the sweet flower of Gods mercy: do not think that because God is merciful you may go on in sin; this is to make mercy your enemy. None might touch the Ark but the priests, who by their office were more holy: none may touch this ark of Gods mercy but such as are resolved to be holy. He that sins because of mercy shall have judgment without mercy. Mercy abused turns to fury (Deu. 29:19-20). The mercy of the Lord is upon them that fear Him. Mercy is not for them that sin and fear not, but for them that fear and sin not Gods mercy is a holy mercy; where it pardons, it heals.Watson, 1696.
Fuente: The Preacher’s Complete Homiletical Commentary Edited by Joseph S. Exell
(9) Except the Lord of hosts . . .This name also had been stamped on the prophets mind at the time of his call (Isa. 6:3). The God of the hosts (or armies) of heaven (sun, moon and stars, angels and archangels) and of earth had not been unmindful of the people. The idea of the remnant left when the rest of the people perished is closely connected with the leading thought of Isa. 6:12-13. It had, perhaps, been impressed on the prophets mind by the remnant of Israel that had escaped from Tiglath-pileser or Sargon (2Ch. 30:6; comp. Mic. 5:7).
We should have been as Sodom . . .Here the prophet, continuing perhaps the thought of Isa. 1:7, speaks of the destruction, in the next verse of the guilt, of the cities of the plain. Both had passed into a proverb. So Ezekiel (Eze. 16:46-56) works out the parallelism; so our Lord speaks of the guilt of Sodom as being lighter than that of Capernaum (Mat. 11:23); so the tradition has condensed itself in the Arabic proverb, quoted by Cheyne, More unjust than a kadi of Sodom. (Comp. Isa. 3:9; Deu. 32:32.)
Fuente: Ellicott’s Commentary for English Readers (Old and New Testaments)
9. Lord of hosts Of the angelic hosts, and starry heavens. Worship of the latter was very early observed by the Assyrians, Phoenicians, Canaanites, etc., but the Lord of Israel is above all, and so is called “Lord” or Master “of hosts.”
Very small remnant That which is left of the people after the ravages of invasive war. With Isaiah, as often elsewhere, the word “remnant” means the righteous, in distinction from the multitude of the ungodly. Rom 9:29.
We After having reproved the sinful nation, the prophet now identifies himself with the people.
As Sodom Not in character, probably, but in destiny; that is, cut off entirely.
Gomorrah The same idea, repeated for preserving poetic parallelism.
The prophets eminently Isaiah frequently gave their instructions in symbolic terms, and in sentences metrical as well as poetical.
Fuente: Whedon’s Commentary on the Old and New Testaments
Isa 1:9 Except the LORD of hosts had left unto us a very small remnant, we should have been as Sodom, [and] we should have been like unto Gomorrah.
Ver. 9. Except the Lord. ] Jehovah, the Essentiator et Induperator, the Maker and Monarch of the universe.
Had left unto us a very small remnant.
“ Quamvis cecidere trecenti,
Non omnes Fabios abstulit una dies. ” – Ovid.
We should have been as Sodom. ] Those five cities of the plain are thrown forth for an example. Jdg 1:7 Lot was no sooner taken out of Sodom but Sodom was taken out of the world and turned into a sea of salt. Deu 29:23 So Meroz, Jdg 5:23 some city likely near the place where that battle was fought, hath the very name and memorial of it utterly extinct.
Fuente: John Trapp’s Complete Commentary (Old and New Testaments)
Except, &c. The first passage in Isaiah quoted in N.T. (Rom 9:29).
very small. Hebrew. kim’at. See note on Pro 5:14.
as Sodom. Reference to Pentateuch (Gen 19:1-29. Deu 29:23.) Compare Isa 3:9, for the reason.
Fuente: Companion Bible Notes, Appendices and Graphics
remnant Remnant. See, Isa 10:20; Rom 11:5 (See Scofield “Rom 11:5”)
Fuente: Scofield Reference Bible Notes
left: Lam 3:22, Hab 3:2, Rom 9:29
a very: Isa 6:13, Isa 10:22, Isa 17:6, Isa 24:13, Isa 37:4, Isa 37:31, Isa 37:32, 1Ki 19:18, Eze 6:8, Eze 14:22, Joe 2:32, Zec 13:8, Zec 13:9, Mat 7:14, Rom 9:27, Rom 11:4-6
we should: Gen 18:26, Gen 18:32, Gen 19:24, Deu 29:23, Lam 4:6, Amo 4:11, Zep 2:9, Luk 17:29, Luk 17:30, 2Pe 2:6
Reciprocal: Gen 13:13 – But the Gen 14:2 – Sodom Gen 18:24 – there Gen 19:5 – General Deu 28:62 – few in number Jdg 20:47 – six hundred 2Ki 19:30 – the remnant that 2Ch 30:6 – escaped Ezr 9:8 – a remnant Ezr 9:14 – no remnant Psa 12:1 – godly Isa 10:20 – the remnant Isa 46:3 – the remnant Jer 3:14 – one of a city Jer 23:14 – Sodom Jer 31:7 – remnant Jer 42:2 – left Jer 50:20 – I will pardon Jer 50:40 – General Eze 7:16 – they Eze 12:16 – I will Eze 16:46 – thy younger sister Eze 16:53 – bring Hos 11:8 – Admah Amo 5:3 – The city Amo 7:5 – for Mat 7:13 – for Mar 13:20 – for Luk 15:15 – he went Rom 2:28 – For he Jam 5:4 – Lord Rev 3:4 – even
Fuente: The Treasury of Scripture Knowledge
Isa 1:9. Except the Lord had left us a remnant If God, by his infinite power and goodness, had not restrained our enemies, and reserved some of us, we should have been as Sodom The whole nation of us had been utterly cut off, as the people of Sodom and Gomorrah were. So great was the rage and power of our enemies, and so utterly unable were we to deliver ourselves. This remnant was a type of those few converts among the Jews, who, embracing the gospel, escaped both the temporal and eternal judgments which came upon the rest of the nation for rejecting Christ and his messengers, Rom 9:2; Rom 11:5. Lowth.
Fuente: Joseph Bensons Commentary on the Old and New Testaments
1:9 Except the LORD of hosts {p} had left to us a very small remnant, we should have been {q} as Sodom, we should have been like Gomorrah.
(p) Because he will always have a Church to call on his Name.
(q) That is, all destroyed.