Exegetical and Hermeneutical Commentary of Jeremiah 50:15

Shout against her round about: she hath given her hand: her foundations are fallen, her walls are thrown down: for it [is] the vengeance of the LORD: take vengeance upon her; as she hath done, do unto her.

15. submitted herself ] lit. as mg. given her hand. Cp. Gen 24:2; Gen 47:29; 2Ki 10:15; 1Ch 29:24 (mg.); 2Ch 30:8 (mg.); Ezr 10:19; Lam 5:6. Cp. also the Latin manus dare.

Fuente: The Cambridge Bible for Schools and Colleges

Shout – i. e., spoken of the war-cry. So in Isa 42:13, where God is compared to a warrior, it is said He shall shout (the King James Version cry), i. e., raise the war-cry.

Site hath given her hand – The sign of submission (compare 1Ch 29:24 margin).

Foundations – Or, buttresses. The Septuagint: battlements.

Fuente: Albert Barnes’ Notes on the Bible

Verse 15. Shout against her round about] Encompass her with lines and with troops; let none go in with relief, none come out to escape from her ruin.

Fuente: Adam Clarke’s Commentary and Critical Notes on the Bible

Shout against her round about; either as soldiers use to shout when they fall upon their enemy, or as they use to shout and triumph when they are entered city, or whet their enemies flee.

She hath given her hand; either acknowledging themselves overcome, and yielding themselves to the power of their enemies, or, as some think, confederating with the Lydians; but the former is more probable

Her foundations are fallen, her walls are thrown down: that is, she is wholly subdued and conquered, as if her walls were thrown down, for literally her walls were not beaten down by Cyrus, for he took the city by surprise

For it is the vengeance of the Lord: God is he who brings this vengeance upon Babylon, though it be by your hands.

As she hath done, do unto her: it is very observable, that there is hardly any sins which the Lord so ordinarily punisheth in the like kind, as those which are oftener against the laws of justice and charity. The common fate of cruel and uncharitable men is to meet with others to do to them as they have done to others; unmerciful men find no mercy. See Psa 137:8,9; Jdg 1:6,7. Adonibezek acknowledged Gods justice in it.

Fuente: English Annotations on the Holy Bible by Matthew Poole

15. ShoutInspirit one anotherto the onset with the battle cry.

given . . . handanidiom for, “submitted to” the conquerors (1Ch29:24, Margin; La 5:6).

as she hath done, do untoherjust retribution in kind. She had destroyed many, so mustshe be destroyed (Ps 137:8).So as to spiritual Babylon (Re18:6). This is right because “it is the vengeance of theLord“; but this will not justify private revenge inkind (Mat 5:44; Rom 12:19-21);even the Old Testament law forbade this, though breathing a sternerspirit than the New Testament (Exo 23:4;Exo 23:5; Pro 25:21;Pro 25:22).

Fuente: Jamieson, Fausset and Brown’s Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible

Shout against her round about,…. As soldiers do when they make an assault upon a place, to encourage one another, and dismay the besieged; just as the Israelites did when they surrounded Jericho:

she hath given her hand; submitted to the conqueror, and sued for mercy. The Targum is,

“she is delivered into her hand;”

the hand of the Persians, by two princes of Babylon, who went off to Cyrus, and showed him how to take the city; or rather it was delivered by Zopyrus into the hands of Darius:

her foundations are fallen, her walls are thrown down; not at the taking of it by Cyrus, but afterwards by Darius; for this respects the conclusion of its destruction, which was progressive and gradual:

for it [is] the vengeance of the Lord: which he decreed, threatened, and took, and that on account of his people, who had been ill treated here; so the Targum,

“for it is the vengeance of the people of the Lord:”

and her enemies are called upon to

take vengeance upon her; as she hath done, do unto her; that is, to execute the Lord’s vengeance, of which the Persians were the instruments; and who were to go according to the law of retaliation, which is a just one; to do to Babylon as she had done to Jerusalem, and other places, she had utterly destroyed. These words seem to be referred to, and much the same are used of mystical Babylon, Re 18:6.

Fuente: John Gill’s Exposition of the Entire Bible

Jeremiah proceeds in exhorting the Persians and the Medes, not that he had ever spoken to them; but this mode of speaking, as it has been said, availed to confirm the minds of the godly, so that they might feel assured that what had proceeded from the mouth of Jeremiah was not vain. Here, then, he assumes the person of God himself, and with authority commands the Persians and the Medes as to what they were to do. He says again, Cry aloud against her. By crying aloud or shouting, he means the cry of triumph which soldiers send forth when a city is taken, or rather, as I think, the encouraging cries, by which soldiers rouse one another when they make an attack; for battles are never without shoutings, nor the storming of cities. God titan bids the soldiers to animate one another in their usual way to make a strenuous effort. Shout, he says, and then adds, all around.

He then says, She hath given her hand By these words he intimates that Babylon would not be able to resist. Hands are wont to be given as a token of union; but he is also said to give his hand who confesses himself to be conquered. In this sense we may take the words of Jeremiah, that Babylon had given her hand, because she could not defend herself against the Medes and Persians. But as we know flint the city was taken by treachery, in this manner also was fulfilled what Jeremiah had announced, when two Satraps, in order to revenge private wrongs, sent for Cyrus: for thus it happened that Babylon, or those within it, willingly stretched forth the hands.

It is added, her foundations have fallen, and her walls have been overthrown; not that Cyrus attacked the city with warlike engines, for he entered in by the fords; but still the soldiers readily mounted the walls. Jeremiah then speaks figuratively, as though he had said, that the Chaldeans were mistaken in thinking that they had strong fortresses, because the walls would avail them nothing, however high and wide they were. And we know what ancient historians relate of these walls and towers. The event was almost incredible; for no one could have thought it possible that a city so fortified could be taken by assault. But the Prophet derides this confidence, and declares that the walls would be overthrown, together with their foundations (60) But as it was a thing difficult to be believed, he again adds a confirmation, that it would be the vengeance of Jehovah; as though he had said, that the destruction of Babylon ought not to be estimated according to the thoughts of men, because God would there put forth his wonderful power. In the meantime, he animates again the Persians and the Medes to take vengeance, and to render to the Babylonians what they had deserved. The Prophet in short intimates that the Persians and the Medes would be armed to execute God’s vengeance on the Babylonians.

But we must notice the last clause, Do to her as she has done to others; for we hence learn, what we have also observed elsewhere, that a reward is rendered to every one, so that they who have been cruel to others, do find how dreadful is God’s judgment. God does not always execute his judgment by men; but still this is ever true,

“

Woe to thee who plunderest, for thou shalt be plundered;”

and also this,

“

Judgment without mercy shall be to him who hath showed no mercy;”

and still further,

“

With what measure any one measures, the same shall be rendered to him.”

(Isa 33:1; Jas 2:13; Mat 7:2.) This truth, then, remains fixed and unchangeable. But God in various ways renders to the ungodly their reward; for he sometimes punishes them by the hand of man, and sometimes he suspends his judgment. Here he shows that the Persians and the Medes would be the executioners of his vengeance, even as the Chaldeans themselves had been as it were his scourges when he chastised his people for their sins; for he had employed the Chaldeans in carrying on war against the Jews. But God has many ways by which he calls each one to an account. Thus at length he punished the Chaldeans, because they indulged only their avarice and ambition in oppressing the Jews; for it was not their purpose to punish the Jews as they deserved; but their own lust, as I have just said, led them to cruelty and slaughter. It was, therefore, but just that they should in their turn be chastised by God’s hand. It follows, —

(60) Rather “battlements” or ramparts, as given by the Sept.; for it is not proper to say that “ foundations ” have fallen. — Ed.

Fuente: Calvin’s Complete Commentary

(15) She hath given her hand.The words paint the attitude of one who submits and stretches forth his hand, as a sign that he gives himself into the power of the conqueror. (Comp. Ezr. 10:19; 2Ch. 30:8; Lam. 5:6.) So in Latin dare manum was a synonym for submission (Cic. de Amic. 26).

Her foundations are fallen.Better, with the LXX., bastions or bulwarks.

As she hath done, do unto her.We note an identity of thought and almost of language with Psa. 137:8. Had the Psalmist heard the prophecy, or the prophet the psalm? The former seems the more probable alternative.

Fuente: Ellicott’s Commentary for English Readers (Old and New Testaments)

Jer 50:15. She hath given her hand Giving the hand, is a token of consenting to any conditions offered. See 2Ki 10:15 and Lam 5:6. Dare manus, (to give the hand,) in Latin signifies, to yield; and most probably alludes to the act of the vanquished, who, throwing down his arms, and stretching forth his defenceless hands, acknowledges himself to be in the victor’s power.

Fuente: Commentary on the Holy Bible by Thomas Coke

Jer 50:15 Shout against her round about: she hath given her hand: her foundations are fallen, her walls are thrown down: for it [is] the vengeance of the LORD: take vengeance upon her; as she hath done, do unto her.

Ver. 15. Shout against her round about. ] As they did once at Jericho; she shall come down assuredly.

She hath given her hand, ] a i.e., She hath yielded, and cried quarter; add hereunto that two princes of Babylon, being displeased by Belshazzar, sent for Cyrus to take the city, and showed him how he might best do it. This was “giving the hands” saith Calvin.

As she hath done, do unto her. ] Neque enim lex iustior ulla est. See Jdg 1:5 . See Trapp on “ Jdg 1:5 “

a Deditionis est signum. Dare manus est fateri ae victum.

“ Victum tendere palmas

Ausanii videre. ” – Virg.

Fuente: John Trapp’s Complete Commentary (Old and New Testaments)