Exegetical and Hermeneutical Commentary of Jeremiah 5:12
They have belied the LORD, and said, [It is] not he; neither shall evil come upon us; neither shall we see sword nor famine:
12. It is not he ] lit. not he! probably corresponding to our own colloquial expression, and used as a rejoinder by those who refused to credit prophetic warnings of disaster. Cp. Zep 1:12.
Fuente: The Cambridge Bible for Schools and Colleges
It is not he – i. e., Who speaks by the prophets.
Fuente: Albert Barnes’ Notes on the Bible
Verse 12. They have belied the Lord] kichashu. They have denied or disavowed the Lord.
It is not he] lo hu, he is not; there is no such being; therefore this evil shall not come upon us. On their premises, this conclusion was just. There is no judge; therefore there shall be no judgment. Thus they denied the Lord. They were atheists at heart.
Fuente: Adam Clarke’s Commentary and Critical Notes on the Bible
They have belied the Lord: this may signify either a denying, viz. a renouncing, making little or nothing of him, as some; or a denying, i.e. not believing, that these words of the prophet were Gods words, or God did not say so; he gave not the prophet, nor any other, any such commission; and possibly their atheism might grow to so high a degree as to deny his providence, power, and justice, &c.: so it agrees with the following words,
It is not he, or, God did not speak as he meant; but he would only fright us, it shall not be thus.
Neither shall we see sword nor famine this siege or famine, or any other such dreadful judgments, as Jeremiah speaks of, shall not befall us. Seeing is used here for feeling, as it is in Job 7:7.
Fuente: English Annotations on the Holy Bible by Matthew Poole
12. belieddenied.
It is not herather,”(Jehovah) is not HE,”that is, the true and only God (Jer 14:22;Deu 32:39; Isa 43:10;Isa 43:13). By their idolatrythey virtually denied Him. Or, referring to what follows, and to Jer5:9, “(Jehovah) is not,” namely, about to be thepunisher of our sins (Jer 14:13;Isa 28:15).
Fuente: Jamieson, Fausset and Brown’s Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible
They have belied the Lord, and said, it is not he,…. Or, “denied the Lord” x, as some render the words, saying that there was no God; which, though they might not deliver in express words, yet inasmuch as they denied his providence, and disbelieved his word by his prophets, it was tacitly denying that there was a God, or that the Lord was God. The meaning of the phrase “not he” may be, he takes no notice of what is done by us; he does not concern himself with our affairs; nor has he given any such orders to our enemies, as above; nor said these things by the prophets which are pretended:
neither shall evil come upon us; they speak of:
neither shall we see sword nor famine; war and sieges, and famine, the consequence of them.
x “egaverunt Dominum”, V. L. Pagninus; “abnegant”, Piscator; “abnegarunt Jehovam”, Cocceius, Schmidt.
Fuente: John Gill’s Exposition of the Entire Bible
He expresses more clearly and fully what he had previously said. Their perfidy was, that they had denied God I do not wholly reject what others have said, that they lied to God: but as ב is here used after כחש, I cannot see that it means to lie. It ought to have been in that case, כחשו, ליהוה cacheshu La-Jeve: but as it is ביהוה, Be-Jeve, I doubt not but that he simply declares that they denied God; and the context seems to require this meaning; for he immediately adds, that they said there was no God (142) This certainly was not to lie to God, but to reject him as one who did not exist. As then the sense would be less significant, were we to say, that they lied to God, I am inclined to take the other meaning, that they denied God; that is, that they wholly disregarded him or sought to erase the remembrance of him.
The reason which follow requires special notice: They have said, He is not To render this more clear, he says, that they boasted of impunity. It seemed, no doubt, to exceed credibility, when the Prophet said that God was denied by the Jews; but that they might not evade the charge, he continued it, they have said, He is not We are further to consider why he brought against them so grievous and so atrocious a charge: it was, because they boasted that they should be free from the punishments which the prophets had threatened.
We then see what Jeremiah alleges against them, even their contempt and also their perverseness. They felt themselves safe notwithstanding the prophetic threatenings. The Prophet says, this is nothing less than wholly to deny God. Were we judges, this declaration might appear too severe: but let us pause, and acquiesce in what the Holy Spirit has pronounced.
And this is a remarkable passage, whence we may learn how abhorred by God is their indifference, who harden themselves against his threatenings, and wholly disregard his judgment. For if we acknowledge him as God, his power as a judge ought not to be taken away. What does God’s name mean? Doubtless they who imagine that God remains quiet in heaven and enjoys his leisure and his rest, though they may not in words deny God, yet treat him with mockery: there is in them at the same time no religion and no thought of a divine being. Let us then carefully notice this passage, in which the Prophet testifies that God is denied by us, except we be moved by his threatenings; for the torpidity in which we indulge ourselves, when God denounces his judgment on us, is the same as the denial of him; nor is there anything by which they can extenuate their sin who thus despise the vengeance of God. For the Holy Spirit has once for all declared, that all who trifle with the prophets do in their hearts say, that there is no God, inasmuch as they deprive him of his power and of his office, and leave him only a naked essence; nay, they make him only a creature of the imagination or a mere phantom.
We now then understand the meaning of the Prophet: he more fully explains the perfidy with which he had charged the Jews; for he says that they denied God, and said, He is not; and they proved that they did all this, for they did not believe the evil to be at hand which the prophets had announced. It afterwards follows —
(142) According to all the instances in which the verb occurs, followed by ב, its meaning is what Calvin states, though not so rendered uniformly in our version. The verb, followed by ב, occurs elsewhere five times, — Leviticus, 6:2, 3; Jos 24:27; Job 8:18; Isa 59:13; Hos 9:2. In Lev 6:3, וכחש בה, ought to be rendered, “and denieth it;” and so the verb ought to be, rendered in the previous verse, “and deny to his neighbor his deposit,” etc. It is rendered here “lied to the Lord” by the Septuagint and the Targum; and “denied the Lord” by the Vulgate and the Syriac, and so also by Piscator, Venema, and Blayney. The denial seems to have been as to the Lord speaking in his prophets. Calvin appears to have gone too far in saying that they denied his existence. The expression which follows, “Not he,“ means that he was not in the prophets. The import is correctly given in our version, “It is not he,“ that is, who speaks in the prophets. The verse might be literally given thus, —
12. And they deny Jehovah, And say, “ It is not he, And come upon us shall not evil, And the sword and the famine we shall not see.”
Then the following verse, which is a continuation of what they said, proves clearly what the meaning of this is, —
13. “And the prophets shall be wind, For the word is not in them: Thus shall it happen to them,”
or,
Thus shall it be done to them.
That is, they shall be found out to be like the wind, having spoken nothing real, such as shall be accomplished. Indeed the last line may be translated thus, —
Thus shall he do to (or, deal with) them.
The reference in this case is to God, who, they thought, would render abortive, or turn as it were into wind, what the prophets had threatened. Their blindness and presumption appear to us to have been extreme. — Ed.
Fuente: Calvin’s Complete Commentary
(12) It is not he.i.e., It is not Jehovah who speaks. They listened to the prophets warnings as if they came from himself only, and brought with them no certainty of the sword or famine which they foretold. Perhaps, however, the words refer also to the denial that Jehovah was working in the sufferings that fell upon the people, or even to a more entire denial, like that of the fool in Psa. 14:1.
Fuente: Ellicott’s Commentary for English Readers (Old and New Testaments)
GOD’S WORD BY HIS PROPHETS WILL BE FULFILLED IN PUNISHMENT, vv.11-18.
12, 13. Belied the Lord Either by stating that he does not exist, or, more probably, that it is not he who speaks by the prophets threatening these calamities. The thirteenth verse is a continuation of the same denial. The prophets who predict our ruin shall come to naught, because he that speaketh (not the word) is not in them. Some understand this as the language of God with reference to the false prophets, but that view is not to be preferred.
Fuente: Whedon’s Commentary on the Old and New Testaments
Jer 5:12. And said, It is not He lo hu. “Not He;” that is, either, he hath not spoken, or, he will not do as the prophets have threatened in his name. See Psa 94:7.
For they said, Jehovah will not see, Neither will the God of Jacob regard.
Fuente: Commentary on the Holy Bible by Thomas Coke
Jer 5:12 They have belied the LORD, and said, [It is] not he; neither shall evil come upon us; neither shall we see sword nor famine:
Ver. 12. They have belied the Lord. ] Or, They give the Lord the lie – as Montfort, Earl of Leicester, gave his sovereign, Henry III, a the lie. Every unbeliever doth as much, upon the matter; 1Jn 5:10 see the note there, Nam etiamsi non semper ore obloquitur, factis tamen obluctatur, b
And said, It is not he,
a Daniel’s Hist., 172.
b Oecolamp.
Fuente: John Trapp’s Complete Commentary (Old and New Testaments)
belied = acted deceitfully against. Compare Jos 24:27.
evil = calamity.
Fuente: Companion Bible Notes, Appendices and Graphics
have belied: Jer 5:31, Jer 4:10, Jer 14:13, Jer 14:14, Jer 23:14-17, Jer 28:15-17, Jer 43:2, Jer 43:3, Deu 29:19, 1Sa 6:9, 2Ch 36:16, Isa 28:14, Isa 28:15, Eze 12:22-28, Eze 13:6, Mic 2:11, Mic 3:11, Hab 1:5, Hab 1:6, 1Jo 5:10
neither: Jer 23:17, Jer 28:4, Psa 10:6, 1Th 5:2, 1Th 5:3
Reciprocal: Gen 19:14 – as one Deu 28:58 – fear this glorious 1Ki 13:18 – But Isa 5:19 – Let him Jer 6:14 – Peace Jer 14:15 – Sword and famine shall not Jer 18:18 – and let us not Jer 24:10 – General Eze 6:10 – General 2Pe 3:4 – where
Fuente: The Treasury of Scripture Knowledge
Jer 5:12. To belie one means to accuse him of falsehood, and the houses of the Jews had acted as if the Lord did not mean what he said. Not he was a short way of saying that if evil should come it would not be the Lord who brought it. And since the Lord would not bring evil upon his people (as they thought.) they need not fear that any will come; such was the false reasoning of the nation.
Fuente: Combined Bible Commentary
5:12 They have {k} lied about the LORD, and said, [It is] not he; neither shall evil come upon us; neither shall we see sword nor famine:
(k) Because they gave no credit to the words of his prophets, as in Isa 28:15 .