Exegetical and Hermeneutical Commentary of Job 17:10
But as for you all, do ye return, and come now: for I cannot find [one] wise [man] among you.
10. do ye return, and come ] Job bids them renew, if they please, their attempts to solve his problem or deal with his case; as often as they did so they only revealed their incapacity and foolishness.
for I cannot find one wise man ] Rather, I shall not find. Their renewed attempts would have no better success than their former ones, they would be found by Job as foolish as before.
Fuente: The Cambridge Bible for Schools and Colleges
10 16. Final repudiation by Job of the false hopes of recovery which the friends held out to him. He knows better, his hope is in the grave.
Turning with a last word to his friends Job bids them renew as often as they chose their attempts to explain his condition, they should only shew themselves ignorant and incapable ( Job 17:10). The hopes they held out were vain; his days were at an end and all the enterprises and dearest purposes of his life for ever broken off ( Job 17:11-12). His hope was in the grave, where alone he would find rest ( Job 17:13-16).
Fuente: The Cambridge Bible for Schools and Colleges
But as for you all, do you return – This may mean, either, return to the debate; or, return from your unjust and uncharitable opinion concerning me. The former seems to accord best with the scope of the passage. Tindal renders it, Get you hence. Dr. Good, Get ye hence, and begone, I pray. Wemyss, Repeat your discourses as often as you may, I do not find a wise man among you. It is doubtful, however, whether the Hebrew will bear this construction.
For I cannot find one wise man among you – Perhaps the idea here is, I have not yet found one wise man among you, and you are invited, therefore, to renew the argument. Hitherto you have said nothing that indicates wisdom. Try again, and see if you can say anything now that shall deserve attention. If this is the meaning, it shows that Job was willing to hear all that they had to say, and to give them credit for wisdom, if they ever evinced any.
Fuente: Albert Barnes’ Notes on the Bible
Job 17:10
The wise are not always wise:–All the ways of sin and error are ways of folly.
But was not Job censorious and rigid, too bold and adventurous to speak thus concerning men of such gravity, authority, and reputation for wisdom and learning, yea for holiness too, as these three were? Job did not speak this from any ill-will to his friends.
1. It is no fault to speak of men as we find them.
2. A wise man may do or speak that which is a just forfeiture of his present reputation for wisdom.
3. Wise men are rarely to be found. There are store of subtle men, and crafty men there are too many; but the wise man is a rare jewel.
4. Wise men are apt to show themselves unwise in expounding and judging the providences and dealings of God towards men. The works of the most wise God are all right, but few men are wise enough to pick out the right meaning of them. This arises–
(1) From the seeming confusions which are in the world. God doth not keep a method, nor govern Himself by precedents. No man can tell the way He will go, by looking into the way which He hath gone.
(2) From the narrowness of mans heart, who, measuring God by his own line, and comparing what God hath done by what he would do, cannot attain unto the righteousness of God in what He doth. It is excellent wisdom to know how to interpret and improve the dealings of God with ourselves or others. The grossest misinterpretation of his dealings is, to conclude from them the guilt or innocency of men, or the love and hatred of God. (Joseph Caryl.)
Fuente: Biblical Illustrator Edited by Joseph S. Exell
Verse 10. But as for you all] Ye are too proud, and too full of self-importance, to profit by what ye see. Return – enter into yourselves, consider your ways, go again to school, get back to your own houses, and endeavour to acquire humility and knowledge; for there is not one wise man among you.
Fuente: Adam Clarke’s Commentary and Critical Notes on the Bible
Return, and come now, i.e. come now again, (as this phrase is oft used,) and renew the debate, as I see you are prepared and resolved to do, and I am ready to receive you. Or, return into yourselves, and consider my cause again; peradventure your second thoughts may be wiser.
One wise man, to wit, in this matter. None of you speak like wise or good men, but like rash and heady persons; you censure me as a rotten hypocrite, and misjudge of Gods ways, and condemn the generation of Gods children upon frivolous grounds.
Fuente: English Annotations on the Holy Bible by Matthew Poole
10. returnIf you haveanything to advance really wise, though I doubt it, recommence yourspeech. For as yet I cannot find one wise man among you all.
Fuente: Jamieson, Fausset and Brown’s Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible
But as for you all, do ye return, and come now,…. This is an address to his three friends, all and everyone of them, who he perceived were nettled with his reply, and were either departing, or preparing for a rejoinder; and being conscious of his innocence, and satisfied of the goodness of his cause, and having nothing to fear from them, boldly challenges them to go on with the dispute; for though they were three to one, he was a match for them all; or else he calls upon them to turn and repent of what they had said to him, to relinquish the bad notions and ill opinion they had of him, and to retract their hard speeches and unjust censures, and return to a friendly and amicable conversation; or however, that they would come and sit down quietly, and patiently hear what he had further to say to them for their information and instruction, which they stood in great need of:
for I cannot find [one] wise [man] among you; that took his case right, was capable of judging of it, and speaking pertinently to it, and of administering comfort to him in it; they were physicians, but not skilful ones; comforters, but miserable ones; had not the tongue of the learned, to speak a word in season; disputants, but wranglers, and knew not where the pinch of the controversy lay; and their arguments were weak and worthless, and their judgment and sense of things not deserving any regard, see 1Co 6:5.
Fuente: John Gill’s Exposition of the Entire Bible
10 But only come again all of you!
I shall not find a wise man among you. –
11 My days are past, My purposes cut off,
The cherished thoughts of my heart, –
12 Ye explain night as day,
Light is near when darkness sets in.
The truly righteous man, even if in the midst of his affliction he should see destruction before him, does not however forsake God. But (nevertheless) ye – he exclaims to the friends, who promise him a long and prosperous life if he will only humble himself as a sinner who is receiving punishment – repeat again and again your hortatory words on penitence! a wise man who might be able to see into my real condition, I shall not find among you. He means that they deceive themselves concerning the actual state of the case before them; for in reality he is meeting death without being deceived, or allowing himself to be deceived, about the matter. His appeal is similar to Job 6:29. Carey translates correctly: Attack me again with another round of arguments, etc. Instead of , as it is written everywhere else (generally when the speech is drawing to a close), we find (as the form of writing , occurs also in the subst. ), perh. in order to harmonize with , which is here according to rule instead of , which corresponds more to our form of a vocative clause, just as in 1Ki 22:28; Mic 1:2 (Ewald, 327, a).
(Note: Comp. my Anekdota zur Gesch. der mittelalterlichen Scholastik unter Juden und Moslemen (1841), S. 380.)
In the jussive and imper. (for the Chethib , which occurs in some Codd. and editions, is meaningless) are united, the former being occasioned by the arrangement of the words, which is unfavourable to the imper. (comp. Ew. 229); moreover, the first verb gives the adverbial notion iterum, denuo to the second, according to Ges. 142, 3, a.
What follows, Job 17:11, is the confirmation of the fact that there is no wise man among them who might be able to give him efficient solace by a right estimate of the magnitude and undeservedness of his suffering. His life is indeed run out; and the most cherished plans and hopes which he had hedged in and fostered for the future in his heart, he has utterly and long since given up. The plur. (occurring only here) of , which occurs also sensu malo , signifies projects, as , Job 21:27; Job 42:2, from , to tie; Aben-Ezra refers to the Arab. zamam (a thread, band, esp. a rein). These plans which are now become useless, these cherished thoughts, he calls , peculia (from , to take possession of) of his heart. Thus, after Obad. Oba 1:17, Gecatilia (in Aben-Ezra) also explains, while, according to Ewald, Beitrge, S. 98, he understands the heart-strings, i.e., the trunks of the arteries (for thus is Arab. n’t to be explained), and consequently, as Ewald himself, and even Farisol, most improbably combines with ( ). Similarly the lxx , as though the joints (instead of the valves) of the heart were intended; probably with Middeldorpf, after the Syriac Hexapla, is to be read instead of ; this, however, rests upon a mistaking of for . While he is now almost dead, and his life-plans of the future are torn away ( ), the friends turn night into day ( , as Isa 5:20); light is (i.e., according to their opinion) nearer than the face of darkness, i.e., than the darkness which is in reality turned to him, and which is as though it stared at him from the immediate future. Thus Nolde explains it as comparative, but connecting Job 17:12 with , and considering (which is impossible by this compar. rendering) as meaningless: lucem magis propinquam quam tenebras . It is however possible that is used the same as in Job 23:17: light is, as they think near before darkness, i.e., while darkness sets in ( ingruentibus tenebris ), according to which we have translated. If we understand Job 23:12 from Job’s standpoint, and not from that of the friends, is to be explained according to the Arab. qrb mn , prope abest ab , as the lxx even translates , which Olympiodorus interprets by . But by this rendering makes the expression, which really needs investigation, only still lamer. Renderings, however, like Renan’s Ah! votre lumire resemble aux tenbres , are removed from all criticism. The subjective rendering, by which Job 17:12 is under the government of , is after all the most natural. That he has darkness before him, while the friends present to him the approach of light on condition of penitence, is the thought that is developed in the next strophe.
Fuente: Keil & Delitzsch Commentary on the Old Testament
| Job Reproves His Three Friends; Vanity of Worldly Expectations. | B. C. 1520. |
10 But as for you all, do ye return, and come now: for I cannot find one wise man among you. 11 My days are past, my purposes are broken off, even the thoughts of my heart. 12 They change the night into day: the light is short because of darkness. 13 If I wait, the grave is mine house: I have made my bed in the darkness. 14 I have said to corruption, Thou art my father: to the worm, Thou art my mother, and my sister. 15 And where is now my hope? as for my hope, who shall see it? 16 They shall go down to the bars of the pit, when our rest together is in the dust.
Job’s friends had pretended to comfort him with the hopes of his return to a prosperous estate again; now he here shows,
I. That it was their folly to talk so (v. 10): “Return, and come now, be convinced that you are in an error, and let me persuade you to be of my mind; for I cannot find one wise man among you, that knows how to explain the difficulties of God’s providence or how to apply the consolations of his promises.” Those do not go wisely about the work of comforting the afflicted who fetch their comforts from the possibility of their recovery and enlargement in this world; though that is not to be despaired of, it is at the best uncertain; and if it should fail, as perhaps it may, the comfort built upon it will fail too. It is therefore our wisdom to comfort ourselves, and others, in distress, with that which will not fail, the promise of God, his love and grace, and a well-grounded hope of eternal life.
II. That it would he much more his folly to heed them; for,
1. All his measures were already broken and he was full of confusion, Job 17:11; Job 17:12. He owns he had, in his prosperity, often pleased himself both with projects of what he should do and prospects of what he should enjoy; but now he looked upon his days as past, or drawing towards a period; all those purposes were broken off and those expectations dashed. He had had thoughts about enlarging his border, increasing his stock, and settling his children, and many pious thoughts, it is likely, of promoting religion in his country, redressing grievances, reforming the profane, relieving the poor, and raising funds perhaps for charitable uses; but he concluded that all these thoughts of his heart were now at an end, and that he should never have the satisfaction of seeing his designs effected. Note, The period of our days will be the period of all our contrivances and hopes for this world; but, if with full purpose of heart we cleave to the Lord, death will not break off that purpose. Job, being thus put upon new counsels, was under a constant uneasiness (v. 12): The thoughts of his heart being broken, they changed the night into day and shortened the light. Some, in their vanity and riot, turn night into day and day into night; but Job did so through trouble and anguish of spirit, which were a hindrance, (1.) To the repose of the night, keeping his eyes waking, so that the night was as wearisome to him as the day, and the tossings of the night tired him as much as the toils of the day. (2.) To the entertainments of the day. “The light of the morning is welcome, but, by reason of this inward darkness, the comfort of it is soon gone, and the day is to me as dismal as the black and dark night,” Deut. xxviii. 67. See what reason we have to be thankful for the health and ease which enable us to welcome both the shadows of the evening and the light of the morning.
2. All his expectations from this world would very shortly be buried in the grave with him; so that it was a jest for him to think of such mighty things as they had flattered him with the hopes of, Job 5:19; Job 8:21; Job 11:17. “Alas! you do but make a fool of me.”
(1.) He saw himself just dropping into the grave. A convenient house, an easy bed, and agreeable relations, are some of those things in which we take satisfaction in this world: Job expected not any of these above ground; all he felt, and all he had in view, was unpleasing and disagreeable, but under ground he expected them. [1.] He counted upon no house but the grave (v. 13): “If I wait, if there be any place where I shall ever be easy again, it must be in the grave. I should deceive myself if I should count upon any out-let from my trouble but what death will give me. Nothing is so sure as that.” Note, In all our prosperity it is good to keep death in prospect. Whatever we expect, let us be sure to expect that; for that may prevent other things which we expect, but nothing will prevent that. But see how he endeavours not only to reconcile himself to the grave, but to recommend it to himself: “It is my house.” The grave is a house; to the wicked it is a prison-house (Job 24:19; Job 24:20); to the godly it is Bethabara, a passage-house in their way home. “It is my house, mine by descent, I am born to it; it is my father’s house. It is mine by purchase. I have made myself obnoxious to it.” We must everyone of us shortly remove to this house, and it is our wisdom to provide accordingly; let us think of removing, and send before to our long home. [2.] He counted upon no quiet bed but in the darkness: “There,” says he, “I have made my bed. It is made, for it is ready, and I am just going to it.” The grave is a bed, for we shall rest in it in the evening of our day on earth, and rise from it in the morning of our everlasting day, Isa. lvii. 2. Let this make good people willing to die; it is but going to bed; they are weary and sleepy, and it is time that they were in their beds. Why should they not go willingly, when their father calls? “Nay, I have made my bed, by preparation for it, have endeavoured to make it easy, by keeping conscience pure, by seeing Christ lying in this bed, and so turning it into a bed of spices, and by looking beyond it to the resurrection.” [3.] He counted upon no agreeable relations but what he had in the grave (v. 14): I have cried to corruption (that is, to the grave, where the body will corrupt), Thou art my father (for our bodies were formed out of the earth), and to the worms there, You are my mother and my sister, to whom I am allied (for man is a worm) and with whom I must be conversant, for the worms shall cover us, ch. xxi. 26. Job complained that his kindred were estranged from him (ch. xix. 13, 14); therefore here he claims acquaintance with other relations that would cleave to him when those disowned him. Note, First, We are all of us near akin to corruption and the worms. Secondly, It is therefore good to make ourselves familiar with them, by conversing much with them in our thoughts and meditations, which would very much help us above the inordinate love of life and fear of death.
(2.) He saw all his hopes from this world dropping into the grave with him (Job 17:15; Job 17:16): “Seeing I must shortly leave the world, where is now my hope? How can I expect to prosper who do not expect to live?” He is not hopeless, but his hope is not where they would have it be. If in this life only he had hope, he was of all men most miserable. “No, as for my hope, that hope which I comfort and support myself with, who shall see it? It is something out of sight that I hope for, not things that are seen, that are temporal, but things not seen, that are eternal.” What is his hope he will tell us (ch. xix. 25), Non est mortale quod opto, immortale peto–I seek not for that which perishes, but for that which abides for ever. “But, as for the hopes you would buoy me up with, they shall go down with me to the bars of the pit. You are dying men, and cannot make good your promises. I am a dying man, and cannot enjoy the good you promise. Since, therefore, our rest will be together in the dust, let us all lay aside the thoughts of this world and set our hearts upon another.” We must shortly be in the dust, for dust we are, dust and ashes in the pit, under the bars of the pit, held fast there, never to loose the bands of death till the general resurrection. But we shall rest there; we shall rest together there. Job and his friends could not agree now, but they will both be quiet in the grave; the dust of that will shortly stop their mouths and put an end to the controversy. Let the foresight of this cool the heat of all contenders and moderate the disputers of this world.
Fuente: Matthew Henry’s Whole Bible Commentary
(10) But as for you all, do ye return.This is probably said with irony. Come again and renew the argument between us; but I shall not be able to find a wise man among you. I am willing to listen to your argument, but I am confident as to the result of it.
For I cannot find.Rather, and I shall not find: i.e., if ye renew the argument.
Fuente: Ellicott’s Commentary for English Readers (Old and New Testaments)
Third division JOB RESUMES THE REQUIEM (Job 17:11) WHICH AT Job 17:2 WAS INTERRUPTED BY THE SUPPLICATION THAT GOD SHOULD MEDIATE WITH GOD, Job 17:10-16.
The main thought of the elegy is the destruction of all hope for this life. This, as Ewald intimates, leads Job to look for justice beyond death; to seek in another life the fruitage of faith, hope, and charity. Job evidently reasons up to an eternal and immutable justice, from the framework of his moral being, which now resounds with testimonies to the purity of his conscience, inspiring him with the conviction that God would be his surety. This enables Job to triumph over sheol.
10. Return now “The friends of Job, irritated by his vehement words, threaten to retire.” Renan. He challenges his retreating friends to continue the argument, at least to hear what he has to say, in the meantime reminding them of the little understanding they have thus far displayed. (Job 17:4.)
For Nevertheless.
Job 17:10. But as for you all, &c. Now, therefore, recollect yourselves, all of you, and consider, I pray you: cannot I find one wise man among you? Heath and Houbigant. See ch. Job 6:28.
Job 17:10 But as for you all, do ye return, and come now: for I cannot find [one] wise [man] among you.
Ver. 10. But as for you all, do you return, &c. ] Change your minds, as Mal 3:18 , and close with me, lay aside your prejudiced opinions, deliver up yourselves to my discipline, who am ready to teach you things both weighty and necessary, Siquis culturae patientum accommodet aurem.
For I cannot find one wise man amongst you O (Theog.).
you. So some codices, with Syriac and “Vulgate, which Authorized Version and Revised Version followed. Other codices read “them”.
do ye return: Job 6:29, Mal 3:18
for I: Job 17:4, Job 15:9, Job 32:9, Job 42:7, 1Co 1:20, 1Co 6:5
Reciprocal: Job 15:27 – he covereth Job 18:3 – Wherefore Job 26:3 – counselled
Job 17:10. But as for you all Who have charged me so heavily. Do you return and come now Recollect yourselves: reflect on what I have said, and consider my cause again; peradventure your second thoughts may be wiser. For I cannot find one wise man among you Namely, as to this matter. None of you judge truly of my case; nor speak like wise and good men; but, like rash and inconsiderate persons, you censure me as a hypocrite, judge erroneously of Gods ways, and condemn the generation of his children on false grounds and frivolous pretences.
17:10 But as for {l} you all, do ye return, and come now: for I cannot find [one] wise [man] among you.
(l) Job speaks to the three who came to comfort him.
Fuente: Whedon’s Commentary on the Old and New Testaments
Fuente: Whedon’s Commentary on the Old and New Testaments
Fuente: Commentary on the Holy Bible by Thomas Coke
Fuente: John Trapp’s Complete Commentary (Old and New Testaments)
Fuente: Companion Bible Notes, Appendices and Graphics
Fuente: The Treasury of Scripture Knowledge
Fuente: Joseph Bensons Commentary on the Old and New Testaments
Fuente: Geneva Bible Notes