Exegetical and Hermeneutical Commentary of Mark 5:16
And they that saw [it] told them how it befell to him that was possessed with the devil, and [also] concerning the swine.
16. And they that saw it told themhow it befell to him that was possessed with the devil(“thedemonized person”).
and also concerning theswineThus had they the double testimony of the herdsmen andtheir own senses.
Fuente: Jamieson, Fausset and Brown’s Commentary Critical and Explanatory on the Whole Bible
And they that saw it,…. Not the keepers of the swine, for they were fled and gone; but others that were eyewitnesses of the whole affair, who lived in houses hard by, or were working in the fields; or the disciples of Christ:
told them how it befell to him that was possessed with the devil; gave a particular account, how, upon first sight of Christ, he ran to meet him, and fell down and worshipped him; how Christ ordered the unclean spirit to come out of him; and how he was dispossessed of a legion of devils by a word speaking:
and also concerning the swine; how, at the request of the devils, and by the leave of Christ, they entered into them; upon which they ran mad; and betaking themselves to the rocks by the sea side, fell down the precipice, and were suffocated in the sea.
Fuente: John Gill’s Exposition of the Entire Bible
1) “And they that saw it,” (kai hoi idontes) “And those who observed the incident,” both when the demon possessed man approached Jesus and the things that happened in connection with the event.
2) “Told them how it befell to him,” (diegesanto autois pos egeneto) “Related to them how it happened,” told it like it was, as it appeared to them, what they saw and what heard, how the man was cured.
3) “That was possessed by the devil,” (to diamonizomeno) “To the demon -possessed, deranged man,” who had cried out, acknowledged Jesus to be Son of the most high God, and begged permission (as a legion of demons), to leave the man and enter into the herd of swine, at which point the liberated man was cured, set free, Joh 8:32; Joh 8:26; became a new creature, 2Co 5:21.
4) “And also concerning the swine.” (kai peri ton choiron) “And about what happened to the pigs,” the herd of swine, as they stampeded ferociously down the mountainside and into the sea till the last one drowned.
Fuente: Garner-Howes Baptist Commentary
16. Also concerning the swine Our Lord had saved the man; the devils had destroyed the swine. The Gadarenes are thankless for the mercy, and hold our Lord responsible for the loss of the swine.
Fuente: Whedon’s Commentary on the Old and New Testaments
Mar 5:16. How it befell, &c. How it had befallen the demoniac.
Fuente: Commentary on the Holy Bible by Thomas Coke
DISCOURSE: 1425
THE GADARENE DEMONIAC
Mar 5:16-18. And they that saw it told them how it befell to him that was possessed with the devil, and also concerning the swine. And they began to pray him to depart out of their coasts. And when he was come into the ship, he that had been possessed with the devil, prayed him that he might be with him.
THE miracles of our blessed Lord were certainly intended in the first instance to attest the truth of his divine mission; in which view he himself frequently appeals to them. But they were also intended to shadow forth the benefits which he was to confer on the souls of men. In both these points of view the miracle before us is deserving of the most attentive consideration. True it is that infidels have attempted to reduce this miracle to a mere curing of a man of an epilepsy or falling sickness. But it is evident that devils were expelled from him by the power of our Lord, since it was by them that the herd of swine were impelled to rush into the sea. A single man, or two men (for St. Matthew tells us there were two [Note: Mat 8:28.], though St. Mark notices only one, as being by far the greater monument of our Lords power,) could not drive twenty swine into the sea, and much less two thousand, of which number this herd consisted [Note: ver. 13.]: and this destruction of the swine consequent upon the expulsion of the devils from the poor demoniac, shewed how great a deliverance had been effected for him, and how entirely all the hosts of hell were subject to the controul of our blessed Lord.
To enter into these events aright, we should consider them,
I.
As they occurred on that occasion
We notice,
1.
The miracle wrought
[Satan at that time had great power over the bodies of men: and a whole legion of devils had at that time occupied that poor unhappy man, whom they endued with a strength wholly supernatural; insomuch that no chains or fetters could confine him [Note: ver. 35.]. But at the command of Jesus they came forth and left their captive at perfect liberty. Fearing that Jesus would send them instantly into the abyss of hell, which is, and for ever will be, their appropriate abode, the devils requested permission to enter into the herd of swine; and, having gained permission, they instigated the whole herd to rush down into the sea, where they were all destroyed. Probably the devils hoped by this to incense the owners of the swine against the Lord Jesus; and in this they succeeded altogether according to their wish.]
2.
The effects produced
[The effect upon the Gadarenes, to whom the herd belonged, was, to make them all, even the whole city [Note: Mat 8:34.], anxious, that our Lord should leave both the place and neighbourhood. One would have supposed indeed that the mercy vouchsafed to the demoniac should rather make the Gadarenes anxious to retain our Lord, that they might obtain similar mercies at his hands: but a concern for their temporal interests swallowed up every other consideration, and united them all in one request, that Jesus would depart out of their coasts.
But how different was the effect upon the man whom Jesus had delivered! He followed Jesus to the ship, and entreated that he might be permitted to wait upon him as a constant follower and attendant. And, when Jesus, for wise and gracious reasons, forbade that, and told him rather to go home to his friends and relatives, and tell them what mercy God had vouchsafed unto him, he went home, and with fidelity and gratitude proclaimed to all around him the benefits he had received from his adorable Benefactor [Note: ver. 20.].]
But, not to dwell on the events which then took place, I wish you more particularly to view them,
II.
As renewed yet daily before our eyes
Of these things we may be well assured:
1.
Satan has still most dreadful power over men
[He no longer, I apprehend, possesses, as he once did, the bodies of men: but he has not one whit less power than he had over their souls. See to what an extent the whole race of mankind are subjected to his controul. All men without exception are risen up in rebellion against God. Nor will they submit to any restraint either from reason or conscience. Every one follows his own will and his own way, even to the great injury of all around him, and to the certain destruction of his own soul. Tell men of their fearful responsibility to God, and of the terrors that await them in the eternal world, and they make light of all, and say, like the devils in this poor demoniac, What have we to do with these things? or as Pharaoh, Who is the Lord, that we should serve him? We know not the Lord, neither will we obey his voice. Not even this poor demoniac acted a more insane part than the generality around us: he wounded and destroyed his body: but these, in all that they do, wound and destroy their immortal souls: so true is that declaration of Solomon, The heart of the sons of men is full of evil; madness is in their heart, while they live; and after that they go to the dead [Note: Ecc 9:3.]. And all this is by the instigation of the devil, who is the God of this world, and worketh in all the children of disobedience [Note: 2Co 4:4. Eph 2:2.].]
2.
But Jesus still exercises the same sovereign power over him
[Truly the word of the Lord is yet quick and powerful, nor can all the powers of hell withstand it. We see the effect, as visibly as ever the Gadarenes did, of the word going forth in the ministration of the Gospel. Are there not even here present some who have passed, as it were, from death unto life [Note: 1Jn 3:14.], and have been translated from the power of darkness into the kingdom of Gods dear Son [Note: Col 1:13.]? The Prodigal Son shews us what a change takes place in the soul when once it is enabled to recover itself out of the snare of the devil [Note: 2Ti 2:26.], and to assert its liberty. And if in him we behold all the madness of a life passed under the influence of the devil, and all the blessedness of a life consecrated to the service of the Most High, then may we behold the same in many, I trust, amongst ourselves, who have, by the preached Gospel, been turned from darkness unto light, and from the power of Satan unto God [Note: Act 26:18.].]
3.
But still is there the same enmity against the Saviour in the hearts of ungodly men
[When the power of divine grace is seen in the deliverance of sinners from the bonds of Satan, we should naturally suppose that all who behold the change should rejoice in it, and desire to become partakers of the same benefits. But the very reverse of this is found true in every place: and, as in the instance before us, an opposition to the Saviour is raised, and persons of every description unite in a desire to expel him from their coasts. In this, Herod and Pontius Pilate will unite [Note: Luk 23:12.]: in this will both Jews and Gentiles concur [Note: Act 4:27.]: in this will devout women be found in league with lewd fellows of the baser sort [Note: Act 13:50; Act 16:39; Act 17:5.]: the desire of all ranks and orders of ungodly men are in perfect harmony on this subject; they all with one voice exclaim, Depart from us, we desire not the knowledge of thy ways [Note: Job 21:14.].]
4.
Still however on the part of those who have experienced his saving benefits is there the same desire to glorify his name
[To commune with the Saviour, to enjoy his presence, to fulfil his will, and to obtain richer communications of his grace, are the leading desires of all who have been delivered by him from the power of the devil. Whatever be their situation in life, they will be as lights in a dark world [Note: Mat 5:14. Php 2:15.], and will so make their light to shine before men, that all who behold them shall glorify the name of Jesus [Note: Mat 5:16.].They feel themselves bound to stand up as witnesses for him, that he is that stronger man, who alone can bind the strong man armed [Note: Luk 11:22.], and deliver from his bonds the vassals whom he had led captive at his will. From a sense of gratitude to his heavenly Benefactor, he will, like this liberated maniac, commend him to all around him, saying with the Psalmist, Come and hear, all ye that fear God, and I will tell you what he hath done for my soul [Note: ver. 20. with Psa 66:16.].]
Address
1.
Those who have never yet been dispossessed of the devil
[It is humiliating to reflect on the state of our fallen world, of which Satan is the god, and we all without exception are his subjects. To all who live in sin of any kind it may be said, Ye are of your father the devil, and the lusts of your father ye do [Note: Joh 8:42.]. What have we to do with thee? was the one voice of all the devils in the man that was possessed by them: and all of them cried, Torment us not. And is not a similar apprehension expressed by men at this day, when the Lord Jesus Christ is, as it were, introduced amongst them, Speak not to us of him; do not make us melancholy? Does not the whole tenour of mens lives shew, whose they are, and whom they serve? It is not necessary that men should rush headlong into all manner of iniquity. Sin, whether of a more heinous or more specious kind, equally shews under whose influence they live [Note: 1Jn 3:8; 1Jn 3:10.], and that they need to be turned from idols to serve the living God. Satisfy not then yourselves, my brethren, with some good feelings and some general acknowledgments. The devils acknowledged Jesus as the Son of the living God; and they deprecated his wrath; and yet were they devils still. You must go much further than this if you would be partakers of Christs kingdom and glory. You must be made new creatures in Christ Jesus, and must evince the reality of this change by a corresponding and visible deportment.]
2.
Those who have been made monuments of Christs power and grace
[See what unbounded mercy has been vouchsafed unto you. See in the fate of that entire herd of swine what is the final destiny of all the vassals of sin and Satan. O bless your God for his distinguishing grace. And now, whilst you confess your obligations, arise to the duties imposed upon you. To that liberated man the Lord Jesus said, Go home to thy friends, and tell them how great things the Lord hath done for thee. And this he says to every one of you. Not that you are to do this in a way of boasting and self-complacency: God forbid: but you must do it in order to commend the Saviour to all around you, and, if possible, to bring them also to a participation of his saving benefits. And be attentive also to the whole of your life and conversation, that you may adorn the doctrine which you profess, and constrain all to glorify Him who has done such great things for you.]
Fuente: Charles Simeon’s Horae Homileticae (Old and New Testaments)
16 And they that saw it told them how it befell to him that was possessed with the devil, and also concerning the swine.
Ver. 16. They come to Jesus ] And, amazed with the miracle, they expostulate not an injury; but, acknowledging him Lord of all, they beg him to be gone, lest they should sustain further loss by him. The devil shall have his dwelling again in themselves rather than in their pigs (as the martyr Bradford phrased it): they will rather lose Christ than their porkers.
And in his right mind ] Sanguis medici factus est medicina phrenetici. The surgeon’s blood was the sick man’s salve.
Fuente: John Trapp’s Complete Commentary (Old and New Testaments)
Mar 5:16 . The eyewitnesses in further explanations to their employers now connect the two events together the cure and the catastrophe not representing the one as cause of the other, but simply as happening close to each other. The owners draw a natural inference: cure cause of catastrophe, and (Mar 5:17 ) request Jesus, as a dangerous person, to retire. , began to request, pointing to transition from vague awe in presence of a great change to desire to be rid of Him whom they believed to be the cause both of it and of the loss of their swine. Fritzsche takes as meaning that Jesus did not need much pressure, but withdrew on the first hint of their wish.
Fuente: The Expositors Greek Testament by Robertson
told = detailed.
concerning. Greek peri. App-104.
Fuente: Companion Bible Notes, Appendices and Graphics
6
The feeders explained what was done and what happened to the swine.
Fuente: Combined Bible Commentary
Mar 5:16. And they that saw it. Probably the swine herds who had returned, possibly those who had accompanied our Lord in the boat.
How it happened. Not merely the fact which those coming already perceived, but the way in which the cure had occurred.
Fuente: A Popular Commentary on the New Testament
Perhaps the people asked Jesus to leave their area because they reasoned that if He dealt so severely with evil He would eventually destroy them too. Rather than turning to Him in worship they turned from Him to the darkness they preferred (cf. Joh 1:11; Joh 3:19). Mark recorded that what happened to the pigs disturbed them, suggesting that economic loss played a part in their request.