Exegetical and Hermeneutical Commentary of Matthew 17:21
Howbeit this kind goeth not out but by prayer and fasting.
21. this kind goeth not out but by prayer and fasting ] Those only whose own spiritual life and faith are made strong by self-denial and by communion with God in prayer are able to cast forth this kind of evil spirit.
Fuente: The Cambridge Bible for Schools and Colleges
Howbeit, this kind … – This kind means this kind of devils – this species of possession. Where they have had long possession where they produce such painful, fixed, and alarming effects, they can be expelled only in connection with prayer and fasting.
Goeth not out but by prayer and fasting – That is, in order to work miracles of this kind to cast out devils in cases so obstinate and dreadful as this, faith of the highest kind is necessary. That faith is produced and kept vigorous only by much prayer, and by such abstinence from food as fits the mind for the highest exercises of religion, and leaves it free to hold communion with God.
Fuente: Albert Barnes’ Notes on the Bible
Mat 17:14; Mat 17:21
And when they were come to the multitude.
The healing of the lunatic child
I. The divinely appointed alternations of the Christian life. (Mar 9:2; Mar 9:17).
II. Spiritual work can be done only by spiritual men (Mar 9:28-29; Act 19:13-16). Correspondence in the worker to the work to be done is never overlooked in any other department of activity. Who employs a plague-stricken nurse to tend a plague-stricken patient? Christs own argument (Mat 12:25-28); Satan will not cast out Satan.
III. The weakness of the Christian apart from Christ.
IV. The absolute necessity of faith.
1. The disciples could do nothing without faith.
2. The father of the lunatic child could receive nothing without faith. How this is to be explained. Faith is more than belief; it is a consequent putting of ourselves into connection with God. The wire must be brought into connection with the battery before it can be charged with electricity. The pitcher must be placed in connection with the fountain before it can be filled.
V. The omnipotence of faith. By believing we place ourselves in connection with Almighty God. What pool cannot the ocean fill? What earthly space cannot the sun illumine? No man, then, who desires to be saved, need despair. You cannot expel sin from your own heart; but the word of Christ is omnipotent. (Anon.)
The contrast
Life is full of changes and contrast. The best of mans quality and character is what he is in, and how he meets these abrupt and broken changes.
I. Christs life was made up of contrasts. Not one more, marked or extreme than this, and nowhere is Christ so fully and truly supreme and sublimely himself. The contrast was painful to Him, painful to all His soul in its love of the beautiful and true and right. What a descent it was! Every true life has such contrasts, and in them the true man is revealed. Christ found His lifework, not in His glory, but in the valley, and was there truly and fully the Messiah. The value of the vision and glory is but their gift of fitness for work and endurance.
II. The confused scene which greets Christ is a true picture of life, into which with healing and order making, christ is ever entering.
1. A sad picture of the world to-day. We are perplexed and almost despairful.
2. A sad picture of our own inner life the home of so much strife, of so much unbelief. Our wondering question is often, Why could we not cast them out? (S. D. Thomas.)
The gracious welcome
Bring him hither to me.
1. Whose words are these?
2. To whom are they spoken?
3. Concerning whom are they spoken?
4. What do they teach us?
(1) Something as to Christ. He is the great Healer, the sinners one Physician.
(2) Something as to ourselves. Contact with Him is health, and life, and warmth. Into this close contact He invites us to bring others. And was any brought one ever sent away? (H. Bonar, D. D.)
A grain of faith
The boundaries of the province of faith.
I. Faiths limitations.
1. The different ages of the Church have called for different kinds of faith. The faith of a miraculous age would not be the same with the faith of a period when God worked by ordinary operations. But even in the same period, and at the same moment, not only the measure, but the character of the faith of different men must vary. A common man at the time of Christ would not have been reproved as the apostles were for not being able to cast out an evil spirit, because it was an authority only given to the apostles.
3. Faith and its achievements must be as God is pleased to give it to every one. It is a pure creation of God in mans soul.
4. Every mans responsibility is just to use the faith, whatever its measure may be, which God has given him; he cannot go beyond it. Nevertheless within this the state of every mans faith depends upon the condition of his heart, and the life which he is leading.
II. The ranges of faith.
1. It is plain that everything hinges upon faith, that the success of faith does not depend upon the quantity, but upon the quality-A grain. You may not be able to remove material mountains, but you can spiritual mountains of sin, care, and difficulty. God puts it into a mans mind to believe what He intends that man to do. But may we not mistake the leadings of faith? Yes: just as we may mistake the leadings of prayer and providence. The security is, in a scriptural mind, disciplined to know the still small voices of God. (J. Vaughan, M. A.)
Mysterious failure
I. That the honest efforts of Gods servants may sometimes end in failure. As Christian workers, we often think we succeed when we in reality fail, and the reverse. But in this case there could be no mistake.
1. It was a conscious failure-Could not.
2. It was a failure without a redeeming feature. In the pulpit we sometimes partially atone for failure in the end by the good impression we made at the beginning, and the reverse. The demon was only exasperated to ten-fold fury, till the lad was flung to the ground, and wallowed foaming.
3. It was a public failure. It was witnessed by the multitude, and among them the vindictive, sarcastic scribes.
4. It was a humiliating failure. This devil in the lad was too much for nine men, who were the divinely-credentialed ambassadors of Christ.
II. That the failure of Christian workers may sometimes be a mystery to themselves-Why could not we? They had honestly tried; had no doubt done the like before; certainly they did it afterward; why not now? Everything appeared to justify them in looking for success.
1. They were Christs chosen disciples.
2. They were His recognized ambassadors. He had confirmed their call by giving them the Divine gift of miracles.
3. They had not put their hands to a work which God designed for others. The very terms of their commission specified the work which they had tried to do and failed-raise the dead, cast out devils.
4. No reason to believe they used their own names instead of Christs on this occasion. No wonder they were humiliated and thunder-struck at such a failure. There is comfort here for all disappointed workers. The feeling of disappointment which prompted this question was a hopeful feature in their case. What we should be most concerned about is, not success, but downright honesty in our work.
III. The failure of many men in the pulpit and out of it need be no mystery even to themselves. Many of us fail because we forget to take aim. Have you tried to cast out devils, and failed? Tell Jesus about it. (T. Kelly.)
Hope in hopeless cases
I. The details of the deplorable case before us. Physical miracles of Christ typical of spiritual works.
1. The disease appeared every now and then in overwhelming attacks of mania, in which the man was utterly beyond his own control. So we have seen melancholy persons in whom distrust, despair have raged at times with unconquerable fury.
2. The patient at such times was filled with a terrible anguish.
3. The evil spirit sought his destruction by hailing him in different directions. So with distressed souls; fly to extremes.
4. This child was deaf.
5. He was dumb.
6. He was pining away. Men are a prey to their own unbelief.
7. All this had continued for years.
8. The disciples had failed to cast out the devil.
II. The one resource.
1. Jesus Christ is still alive.
2. Jesus lives in the place of authority.
3. Jesus lives in the place of observation, and He graciously interposes still.
4. Jesus expects us to treat Him as the living, powerful, interposing One, and to confide in Him as such.
III. The sure result. The word of Christ was sure; was opposed by the devil. (C. H. Spurgeon.)
Christs life made up of contrasts
None of them more marked and extreme than this; and nowhere is Christ so fully and truly supreme and sublimely Himself. He needs no pause to fittingly enter the clanging discord of anger, despairing sorrow and rude scorn. He is alike supreme, touching manhoods apex in the mount, and mingling with manhoods depravity in ignorance and evil in the valley. And that not because He lived above and indifferent to each, but because, identifying Himself with each, He was true and great enough to subordinate all to His lifes mission. The contrast was painful to Him, painful to all His soul in its love of the beautiful and true and right. From the peace of the Transfiguration glory-the hearts ecstasy touching heaven; touching God in its fellowship; the glad satisfaction of an ideal realized, His lifes meaning and appointment found, all Moses promised and Elijah wrought for consummated-to the discordant throng of- unhallowed passion and faithless failure. What a descent it was! And this even in a moment, as abrupt as from dream to waking. The change and contrast is infinitely sad. Suddenly Christ, from calm vision and peaceful vow, descending with the glory yet about Him, mantling face and form, is greeted with taunt and scorn, and the bitter cry of shame and despair. Hardly the cross was a sorer trial to the patience, earnestness, and love of Christ. Yet, in the midst He stands, all calm and good, all patiently laying aside His own pain to minister to others-His one concern the honour of the kingdom of man and God. Every true life has such contrasts, and in them the true man is revealed; they compel to the surface that which is most of a man-good or bad, weak or strong. In them we have the gauge of a mans piety and true devotion. It is easy to serve and worship and to be strong in our moments of vision and conscious contact with God, when His Spirit thrills us with joy and faith. It is possible even to brace ourselves up with ardour and enthusiasm for some notable and well-defined task; but to find swift following (all discordant) our vision, a bitter trial, and wake from peaceful resolve to stern reality of strife, and still be true, needs all our faith. It is possible only to the Christ-like man, and should be our aim and glory. (S. D. Thomas.)
The power of faith
When man has faith in God his nature so opens itself to be filled with God, that God and he make a new unity, different at once from pure heavenly divinity and from pure earthly humanity, the new unit of man inspired by God; and by that new unit, that new being, it is that the evil is to be conquered and the world is to be saved. Can we understand that? Let us take two simple illustrations which may make it plain. Look at the artists chisel. Most certainly it carves the statue. The artist cannot carve without his chisel. And yet imagine the chisel, conscious that it was made to carve and that that is its function, trying to carve alone. It lays itself against the hard marble, but it has neither strength nor skill; it has no force to drive itself in, and if it had it does not know which way it ought to go. Then we can imagine the chisel full of disappointment. Why cannot I carve? it cries. And then the artist comes and seizes it. The chisel lays itself into his hand, and is obedient to him. That obedience is faith. It opens the channels between the sculptors brain and the hard steel. Thought, feeling, imagination, skill, flow down from the deep chambers of the artists soul to the chisels edge. The sculptor and the chisel are not two, but one. It is the unit which they make that carves the statue. Then again, look at the army and its great commander. The army tries to fight the battle, and is routed. Then its scattered regiments gather themselves together, and put themselves into the hands of the great general, and obey him perfectly, and fight the battle once more and succeed. Why could not I succeed? the army cries; and the general answers, Because of your unbelief. Because you had no faith. You separated yourself from me. You are but half a power, not a whole power. The power which has won the battle now is not you and is not I; it is made up of you and me together, and the power which made us a unit was your obedient faith. (Phillips Brooks, D. D.)
Faith in action
It may be interesting and useful to consider in what way the apostles actually worked out the lessons which our Lord gave them concerning faith. The lessons which Christ gave them while He was yet with them were, doubtless, intended to guide them when they were left to themselves; He dropped into their minds many maxims, and precepts, and seeds of thought, which He knew that they would not understand at the time, intending that the things said should be brought to remembrance by the power of the Holy Ghost, and should then be comprehended in all their fulness, and be guides to their feet and lanterns to their paths. Well, then, how did they deal with the mountains of difficulty which they had to remove in order to lay the foundations of the Church? How did they put in practice the precept of their Lord, that they should command the mountains in faith to be removed? and in what way and to what degree did they realize the fulfilment of the promise that a command so given and backed by prayer should be forthwith obeyed, and that nothing should be impossible? It is plain that you may easily conceive a very wild and fanatical system of attempts to propagate the gospel being based upon our Lords words literally taken. You may conceive, e.g., of St. Peter on the Day of Pentecost, instead of arguing calmly with the people and declaring the facts connected with the life and death of Jesus of Nazareth, attempting some striking miracle which would batter down all opposition; or you can conceive of St. Paul at Ephesus, instead of pleading his cause in the theatre, commanding the great Temple of Diana to be removed and cast into the sea; in fact, you may conceive of a course of conduct as different as possible from that which the apostles with one consent and in their corporate capacity actually adopted. Look at the history contained in the Book of Acts, or at the incidental living history which comes out in the Epistles, and you will see that the whole work of the apostles is a combination of faith and prayer with judgment and calm, quiet, good sense; they were conspicuously what we should call good men of business; like all such men, they attended to small matters as well as great; when difficulties arose, they took counsel together, and discussed the difficulties at a general meeting; they framed rules when rules were necessary; they never forgot that in this world prudence is as necessary with regard to the kingdom of God as it is with regard to mere worldly success; this was the way in which the apostles founded and governed the Church of Christ. And yet the apostles would have been the last men to put trust in their own wisdom, or their business capacity, or their powers of organization. At all times of their ministry, in bright days and in dark, in the council chamber at Jerusalem or in prison for the name of Christ, in legislating for the churches or in dealing with individual hearts and consciences, in striving by all manner of means to cast out the legion of devils by which mankind was possessed, they would have in their minds such words as these. (Bishop Harvey Goodwin.)
Want of faith the source of weakness
How the whole story of humankind is like that scene which took place at the foot of Tabor, while Jesus was being transfigured on the top. You remember how, in Raphaels great painting, the whole story is depicted. Up above Christ is hovering in glory, lifted from earth and clothed in light and accompanied on each side by His saints. Down below, in the same picture, the father holds his frantic child, and the helpless disciples are gazing in despair at the struggles which their charms have wholly failed to touch. It is the peace of Divine strength above; it is the tumult and dismay of human feebleness below. But what keeps the great picture from being a mere painted mockery is that the puzzled disciples in the foreground are pointing the distressed parents of the child up to the mountain where the form of Christ is seen. They have begun to get hold of the idea that what they could not do He could do. So they are on the way to the faith which He described to them when they came to Him with their perplexity. Let the picture help to interpret them to us, and is not the meaning of Christs words to His disciples this? He claims the disciples for Himself. He tells them that the reason of their failure is that they have been trying to do by themselves what they can only do when He is behind them, when their natures are so open that His strength can freely flow out through them. That, I think, is what He means by faith. The man who is so open Christward that Christ is able to pour His strength out through him upon the tasks of life has faith in Christ. The man who is so closed Christward that nothing but his own strength gets utterance upon the tasks of life has not faith, and is weak because of his unbelief. (Phillips Brooks.)
Reason of failure
Whence comes it that, when assailed by temptation, we so seldom conquer and so often fail? It is because of our unbelief-because we are fools, and slow of heart to believe all that God Himself has told us. We do not go to Him first of all; we do not take His instructions, do not consult His revealed will as our first rule of action. Is it not so as regards that evil spirit whose name is Legion, whose accursed power we meet everywhere-not only in our streets, but in some of its manifold influences in our homes and hearts-the spirit of selfishness and sensuality, lust, intemperance, sarcasm, spite, hypocrisy, cheating, lying, meanness? We do not say, we have not faith to say, I command thee in the name of Jesus Christ to come out. We dare not say to impotence, In the name of Jesus Christ of Nazareth rise up and walk. We have more faith in ourselves; in clever legislation, compulsory education, commercial prosperity, in what we call progress, in the discoveries of science. We will not read, or we forget, history-how all the great empires of the Nile, the Euphrates, the Tiber, and the Tigris rose and fell as they realized that which was true and right hi the religion they professed; how the golden glory of Babylon, the silver sheen of Cyrus the Persian, the brazen splendour which gleamed on the victorious arms of Alexander, the iron strength of Rome, were ground into powder as the stone fell upon them, the stone which the builders rejected, but which became the head of the corner and the shadow of a great rock in a weary land-the kingdom of our Lord and of His Christ; and when in this season of decadence, and in the time of their visitation, they heard the war-cry of their conquerors, and staggered from the wine-cup and the harlots lap to put on the armour which they could hardly bear, and the sword which they could scarcely wield, it was as they asked in their defeat, Why could not we cast them out? that the answer came, Because of your unbelief; because you have ceased to believe in righteousness, and righteousness exalteth a nation. (S. R. Hole, M. A.)
Had these disciples been not faithless but believing; had they prayed more frequently and earnestly; had they shown more of that self-denial which He taught and set before them, distrusted themselves and humbled themselves instead of disputing which should be the greatest, they would Lave east out that evil spirit. But he perceived, and prevailed over, their want of faith. He said, Jesus I know, but who are ye that utter His name, but do not believe in its power? Perhaps the absence of the Master from those nine apostles made them doubtful and fearing among the unbelieving Jews; just as you and I, when we leave the church, or our place of prayer at home, or the company of those whom we most revere and who influence us most for good, are tempted to forget the omnipresent God, to be of the world worldly, and to set our affections upon the things of the earth. So to lose the power, the only true power over ourselves and others, which we have in exact proportion to our faith, our prayers, our self-denial; for they are inseparable, these three-trinity in unity.
I. It is impossible to believe in our heavenly Father and not to go to him always as children to rejoice in his love, to thank Him for His gifts, to be protected in danger, taught in ignorance, relieved in pain, and forgiven when we have done wrong.
II. We cannot really believe in his power and love without going to him and praying to him oft and earnestly; not from a mere impulse of fear, in some sudden terror, in the great storm, carried up to heaven and down again to earth, in the valley of the shadow of death; but always out of a pure heart and faith unfeigned. And this true prayer does not begin when we kneel, nor cease when we rise. God has not only given us a voice to pray with, but a mind with which to think about our prayers, and capacities, and means, and time, and money, with which we may fulfil them. True prayer is prayer in action. Duty is prayer, and work is worship.
III. So it is impossible to believe really in Christ, and not to practise self-denial. To believe is to love, and to love is to obey. (S. R. Hole, M. A.)
Spiritual failure-its cause and cure
nothing can be better than to being our spiritual failures to Christ himself, as did the disciples. Why could not we cast him out? So asked the baffled, eager disciples of old, and got their answer. So let us ask, and hear what Christ will say to us.
I. Cause of spiritual failure.
1. Whatever the peculiar character of the malady, the disciples had bad power given them to heal it (Mat 10:8), which they had already freely and successfully put forth (Luk 10:17). This power was not unconditionally exercised. Some of the conditions of success depended upon the sufferers, some upon themselves. The cause of failure lay, not in forms or methods, etc., the mischief lay deeper down-unbelief.
2. Are there none possessed with evil spirits within our ken? Do we not in this description recognize phenomena of our own life?
3. There are fair excuses enough; undue dwelling upon the evil to be cured; mere reasoning on the causes of evil; reserve and fastidiousness in dealing with religious topics; perfunctory methods of using the gospel means.
II. Christs cure. There is no unnecessary upbraiding in our Lords answer, no dwelling on the merely negative side of truth. From the mention of unbelief He passes at once to the power of faith.
1. Faith needs to be cultivated. In the Revised Version Christs answer reads, Because of your little faith. You may trust doubt to spring up readily and flourish easily, but the power to discern the invisible, and hold fast amidst a thousand discouragements our confidence in an unseen God, an unseen Saviour, and in the power of truth which as yet far from prevailing must receive due cultivation if it is to conquer.
2. Let it be clearly understood that while Gods power in Christ works the miracle, our faith in that power is a condition of its operation and success.
3. This is no question of fervid enunciation, excited gestures, display of emotion. Faith may be small at first.
4. Our Lords addition to this main answer to the disciples query has an importance of its own. Faith in all cases needs to be sustained, but in special cases it needs to be specially sustained by
(1) prayer;
(2) fasting-self-denial. (W. T. Darison, M. A.)
The influence of earnest faith upon men
And so for the most part it is not abstract truth that wins men. I can read abstract truth at home and go to sleep over it; argue it out by myself and never be moved to alter my course one jot. What moves me is the sight of a man who is himself moved by the truth of what he proclaims, and in this high region of religious truth a man adequately moved in proportion to the importance of the truth he announces. A true herald of Christ is one who, not in the mere announcing of doctrine, but who in mien, gesture, tone, life, shows that lie believes the God-in-Christ doctrine of the salvation of the worst of men who are willing to yield and obey. Such a herald of the gospel is everywhere a quickening power, a kindling flame. (W. T. Darison, M. A.)
Faith not emotion or formalism
Those who would cast out devils in Christs name are not like pagan exorcists to work themselves into a fever of excitement and imagine that obstacles will disappear before them because they shout and gesticulate. A mans manner may be as quiet or as impetuous as you please, but it should be the natural expression of the truth which animates all the powers of his being. There is electricity enough in nature, and at certain times the air is burdened with it, but a good conductor is needed if its energy is to be gathered and transmitted. And in this case the force is to be gathered, not that it may be dissipated in the earth, but that it may rend rocks and overturn mountains. A great problem of the day is the storage and use of electricity; but who is fit for a work like this, to be in any degree a vehicle of the Divine power to save men? Not the noisy assertor of self who reminds you of his own personality and agency at every turn. Not the formalist, the mechanical utterer of pious phrases, nor the mere excited rhapsodist; but only the man of single eye and pure heart, whose soul is inter-penetrated with the truth as it is in Jesus, and who believes with all his mind, and soul, and strength in its might and efficacy. (W. T. Darison, M. A.)
The secrets of victory
Christs power, first, last, middle; our faith in that power unhesitating, unshrinking, unwavering; earnest prayer to Him whose ear attends the softest prayer, accompanied by that self-discipline which the holiest saint knows he needs, and the humblest Christian should be the last to disdain, these are the secrets of victory. Constantine, before the great battle of the Milvian bridge, is said to have beheld in the sky a flaming cross, with the words. by this conquer. Only by the power of the Cross can the world be surbdued; but only by the faith of its followers can the power of the Cross reach the worlds heart and free it from the tyranny of the legion of evil spirits that now rule and riot there. Onward Christian soldiers, and by your faith help to win a world for Christ! (W. T. Darison, M. A.)
The spirit of worldliness rebuked
I. The evil. The efforts of Satan have been different at different times. Persecution; heresy; fashions of Men; worldliness. If. The remedy. Faith. By prayer faith is increased, also we shall be given less to luxury. (S. Robins, M. A.)
A man wholly consecrated to Christ
It is said that shortly before Mr. Moody began those labours which were so marvellously blessed, he was greatly impressed by the remark made by s Christian friend: It remains for the world to see what the Lord can do with a man wholly consecrated to Christ.
The secret of power
Consider the principles which flow from this text.
I. We have an unvarying power. A gospel which never can grow old. An abiding spirit. An unchanging Lord.
II. The condition of exercising, this power is faith. The Church to-day is asking the same question as the disciples. What is to blame? Not our modes of worship, etc. While leaving full scope for all improvements in subordinate conditions, the main thing which makes us strong for our Christian work is the grasp of living faith, which holds fast the strength of God. Faith has a natural operation on ourselves which tends to fit us for casting out the evil spirits. Faith has power over men who see it.
III. Our faith is ever threatened by subtle unbelief. All our activity tends to become mechanical, and to lose its connection with the motive which originated it. The atmosphere of scornful disbelief which surrounded the disciples made their faith falter. So with us.
IV. Our faith can only be maintained by constant devotion and rigid self-denial. (Dr. A. Maclaren.)
The secret of Christian failure and success
They were justified in undertaking to cast the demon out, and ought to have succeeded. It was the right and privilege of their discipleship, and they were guilty of the harmfulness of their failure. And so with us, our demons and the worlds demons have been subjected to us. Our duty and privilege is to master and exorcise them. And to the measure of our opportunity we are guilty of the worlds evilness and our hearts weakness. It should not be Christs direct act. Thank God it will be that if we fail, they shall at last be east out; but it should be ours through the Christ-life and power with us. He has committed the work and responsibility of evils overthrow to us, and sternly and awfully He will require at our hands the lives marred and wrecked by our failure. Our great need is faith in this power of ours. We want to know and feel we are not helplessly in sins grip, nor weak though despised before evils array and seeming sovereignty in the world. The world is ours as we are Christs-ours to be conquered and won. (S. D. Thomas.)
Eastern epilepsy and mania
In Sidon there are cases of epileptic fits which, in external manifestation, closely resemble that mentioned in this verse. These fits have seized a young man in my house repeatedly; And, lo! the spirit taketh him, and he suddenly crieth out, and foameth at the mouth, and gnasheth with his teeth, and is east down wherever he may be seized, and pineth away until you would think he was actually dead. Matthew calls him a lunatic, but, according to Mark, it was a dumb spirit. And there are eases in which the disease referred to accompanies, and in others it obviously occasions, dumbness. I will not say that such unfortunate creatures are tormented by an evil spirit, but I am sure that no cavilling sceptic can prove that they are not. (Dr. Thomson.)
Explanation of devil possessions
Many think that in the cases recorded we have but the symptoms of well-known diseases which, from their exceptionally painful character, involving loss of reason, involuntary or convulsive motions, and other abnormal phenomena, the imaginative and unscientific Easterns attributed, as the easiest mode of accounting for them, to a foreign power taking possession of the body and mind of the man. They say there is no occasion whatever to resort to an explanation involving an agency of which we know nothing from any experience of our own; that, as our Lord did not come to rectify mens psychological or physiological theories, He adopted the mode of speech common among them, but east out the evil spirits simply by healing the diseases attributed to their influences. There seems to me nothing unchristian in this interpretation. But I have no difficulty in receiving the old Jewish belief concerning possession; and I think it better explains the phenomena recorded than the growing modern opinion. (George Macdonald.)
Prayer for a wicked son
Speners prayer for his son:-Philip James Spener had a son of eminent talents, but perverse and extremely vicious. All means of love and persuasion were without success. The father could only pray, which he continued to do, that the Lord might yet be pleased to save his son at some time, and in some way. The son fell sick, and while lying on his bed in great distress of mind, nearly past the power of speech or motion, he suddenly started up, clasped his hands, and exclaimed, My fathers prayers, like mountains, surround me. Soon after, his anxiety ceased, a sweet peace spread over his face, his malady came to a crisis, and the son was saved in body and soul. He became another man.
A pitiable sight
Whoever has held in his arms his child in delirium, calling to his father for aid as if he were distant far, and beating the air in wild and aimless defence, will be able to enter a little into the trouble of this mans soul. To have the child, and yet see him tormented in some region inaccessible; to hold him to the heart, and yet be unable to reach the thick-coming fancies which distract him; to find himself with a great abyss between him and his child, across which the cry of the child comes, but back across which no answering voice can reach the consciousness of the sufferer-is terror and misery indeed. But imagine in the case before us the intervals as well-the stupidity, the vacant gaze, the hanging lip, the pale flaccid countenance and bloodshot eyes, idiocy alternated with madness-no voice of human speech, only the animal babble of the uneducated dumb-the misery of his falling down anywhere, now in the fire, now in the water, and the Divine shines out as nowhere else-for the father loves his own child even to agony. What was there in such a child to love? Everything. The human was there, else whence the torture of that which was not human? whence the pathos of those eyes, hardly up to the dogs in intelligence, yet omnipotent over the fathers heart? God was there. The misery was that the devil was there too. Hence came the crying and tears. Rescue the Divine; send the devil to the deep, was the unformed prayer in the fathers soul. (George Macdonald.)
This mountain as Hermon
There cannot be a doubt that the high mountain apart was one of the peaks of Hermon, which towers over Caesarea. On coming down again from the mountain the lunatic boy was healed; and in such a position the force of Christs rebuke to His disciples could be fully comprehended. If ye have faith as a grain of mustard seed, ye shall say unto this mountain [Hermen], Remove hence to yonder place [pointing down, perhaps, into the deep valley of the Jordan which lay below], and it shall remove. (Dr. J. L. Porter.)
Faith removing mountains
A grain of faith can remove spiritual mountains; mountains of guilt from the conscience, mountains of hardness from the will, mountains of earthliness from the affections. (E. Polhill.)
Faith that works wonders
All the marvels, all the apparent impossibilities, which men have wrought, have been wrought by the energy of faith. It is by his faith in the laws of nature, and in his interpretation of them, that the man of science has achieved the marvels which have altered the whole form and tone of modern life. It is by his faith both in the courage of his soldiers, and in his own power of handling them, that is, his system of tactics, that every great captain has won his victories, often snatching them from the very mouth of defeat. It is by his faith in men, and in his reading of the laws of social and political science, that every great statesman learns how to take occasion by the hand, and to make the bounds of freedom broader yet. It is by his faith in great religious principles and truths that every successful reformer of the Church, e.g., Luther, has purged the Church from its accretions of error and superstition, elevated and liberalized at once her creed, her ritual, and her morality, in the teeth of both priestly and imperial power. By faith the early Church put a new heart into the decrepit Roman empire. By faith the reformers put a new heart into the northern kingdoms of Europe, and suppressed some, at least, of the most flagrant vices and superstitions even of the southern kingdoms who rejected their teaching. (Almoni Peloni.)
Power in a mustard seed
The mustard seed is one of the tiniest of seeds, although in the fierce heat of the Jordan valley it will grow up into a herb as high as a man on horseback, and throw out sprays on which the birds of the air perch and feed, attracted by its pungent fruit. Take such a seed into your hand and consider it, and you will find it hard, round, dry, and apparently dead and inert. Pat it under a microscope and dissect it; and, small as it is, you will find that it contains a germ far smaller than itself in which its whole potency is summed up. Born in the air, nourished by the sunshine and the dew, it yet cannot live and appropriate their virtues while it remains in them, so long as it lies in the pod, or continues above the ground. But bury it in the soil, and soon a process of dissolution and disintegration sets in which is also a process of vitality and growth. Its main bulk rots, but rots only that it may feed the tiny germ of quickened life which resides within it, for even a seed must lose itself to find itself, must die that it may live. Through death it rises into a new life, pushes its way through what, compared to itself in size and weight, are whole mountains of obstruction and resistance, piercing clod after clod, and compelling each to yield its virtues, and to minister to its needs; until, at last, it rises into that fellowship with the air and the sunshine and the dew for which it yearned and was designed. The mountains of the earth are dead in comparison with its life. Hence it commands them to be removed, and they obey. So astonishing is the vital energy of even the smallest seeds that mushroom spores, which singly are almost invisible, have been known to lift large paving stones an inch or two from the earth in the course of a single night. (Almoni Peloni.)
The power of faith
I. The text speaks To those who have no faith. The disciples had failed through lack of faith. If we could but believe we should see difficulties vanish.
1. The sphere of faith. Faith has relation to mans spiritual needs; temporal needs not overlooked. The boundaries of faith are to be looked for in the promises.
2. How faith operates. By laying hold on Gods power. To make His work serviceable to us it must be done in some way through our instrumentality. But the excellency of the power is His.
3. Its necessity. Gods work cannot be done without our faith, He has so appointed.
II. Of comfort to those of little faith.
1. It may be little in two senses: in its object, or in its intensity.
2. Weak faith is faith. It lays hold on God like a thin wire touching a strong battery.
3. It can remove mountains. God will honour faith as such and not because of its strength merely. (G. T. Horton.)
Power through faith
That power is put forth according to our faith. You have, perhaps, seen a steam-hammer, or clipper, which is most mighty to crush or cut thick iron like shavings. The force applied is steam, which seems almost omnipotent. But how is it applied? By a simple tube of connexion and a common valve, by which the steam is let in upon the ponderous apparatus. An infant could turn the tap. So faith simply turns on to any work we have to do the whole power of deity; yet He hath appointed us fellow-workers with Him, by entrusting to us this prerogative of faith. (G. T. Horton.)
Fuente: Biblical Illustrator Edited by Joseph S. Exell
Mat 17:21
By prayer and fasting.
Fasting a means of subduing sin
I. This duty of fasting admits of several kinds and degrees. For in fasting as well as in feasting we may find variety.
1. The first kind is of constant, universal exercise. It obliges at all times and extends to all persons. This is a temperate use of the creature; in abridging the appetites of nature for the designs of religion.
2. The second kind of fast is of a total abstinence, when for some time we wholly abstain from bodily repasts. The remedy to be successful must bear some proportion to the distemper. Necessity gives place to extremity.
3. The third kind of fast is an abstinence from bodily refreshments in respect of a certain degree, for some space of time. We must distinguish between murder and mortification; Christ never destroys the body to save the soul. Self-denial is a duty, but not self-murder. The height of prudence is in all precepts, laws, and institutions to distinguish persons, times, and occasions, and accordingly to discriminate the obligation.
II. The qualifications that must render this duty of fasting both acceptable to God, and efficacious to this great purpose.
1. The first is, that it is to be used, not as a duty either necessary or valuable for itself, but only as an instrument. There is no excelling in fasting itself; is any spiritual design carried on in it?
2. The second condition of a religious fast is, that it be done with a hearty detestation of the body of sin, for the weakening of which it is designed. Fasting means war against sin; who ever fought valiantly against him whom he did not first hate?
3. The third condition of a duly qualified fast is that it be quickened and enlivened with prayer. The reason of the fast requires the society of prayer for the procuring of good or deprecation of evil. David, Daniel, took this course.
4. The fourth condition of a truly religious fast is that it be attended with alms and works of charity (Isa 58:4; Isa 58:7).
III. Show how this duty of fasting comes to have such a peculiar influence in dispossessing the evil spirit, and subduing our corruptions. That it does not effect this work-
1. Either by any casual force naturally inherent in itself, for if it did, fasting would constantly and certainly have this effect upon all who used it.
2. Nor does fasting effect this great change by way of merit, as procuring and enjoying the help of that grace that does effect it, it is impossible for a created nature to merit anything from God by way of reward.
From whence then does this duty derive this great virtue?
1. It receives it from Divine institution.
2. Fasting comes to be effectual to dispossess the evil spirit, by being a direct defiance to that disposition of body and mind upon which especially he works.
1. It is a notable act of self-revenge.
2. It corrects the ill temper of pride. (R. South, D. D.)
Constant temperance better than occasional fasting
And whosoever struggles with any unruly corruption, will perhaps find, that the constant turn of a well-guided abstinence will, in the issue, give a surer despatch to it, than those extraordinary instances of total abstinence and higher severities, only undertaken for a time. As a land flood, it carries a bigger stream and comes with a mightier force and noise, yet presently dries up and disappears; but the emissions of a fountain, though gentle and silent, yet are constant and perpetual; and whereas the other, being gone, leaves nothing behind it but slime and mud, this, wheresoever it flows, gently soaks into verdure and fertility. This constant temperance, therefore, is by all means intended by the rules of Christianity; the constancy of which, running through our whole lives, makes abstinence our diet, and fasting our meat and drink. (R. South, D. D.)
Obstinate sin to be overcome by strict fasting
Every remedy is successful according to the proportion it bears to the distemper: and certainly a cure is not likely to be wrought where an ordinary remedy encounters an extraordinary disease; where the plaster is narrow and the wound broad. Temperance is good, but that is to be our continual diet; and surely, that man is not like to recover who makes his food his physic. Where the humour is strong and predominant, there the prescription must be rugged, and the evacuation violent. We must leave the road of nature when nature itself is disordered, and the principles of life in danger. (R. South, D. D.)
Necessity must give place to extremity
And the physician is merciful, if he pines his patient into a recovery. In this case we encounter sin in the body, like a besieged enemy: and such a one, when he has once engarrisoned himself in a strong hold, will endure a storm and repel assaults: you must cut off his supplies of provision, and never think to win the fort, till hunger breaks through the walls, and starves him into a surrender. (R. South, D. D.)
Fasting a help to virtue
Now, by all that has been said it appears, that fasting is required, not as a virtue, but as a help to virtue; and that by controlling its hindrance, removing its impediments, subduing the emulations of a contrary principle, and so enabling it to act with freedom. Otherwise, were there no reluctancy from the inferior appetites against a virtuous and a pious course, these arts and stratagems against the flesh would be superfluous, and we should have no more need of fasting than the angels or the blessed spirits have of eating. Could the mariner sail with as much ease and safety in a storm, as he does in a calm, he would never empty or unlade his vessel. (R. South, D. D.)
Fasting joined with hatred of sin
If we have not first wrought our minds to a settled dislike and a bitter disgust of sin as our mortal enemy, all our attempts against it will be faint and heartless, our mortifications treacherous, and our lastings frustraneous; much like Davids sending an army against Absalom with a design to save him, and to deal with him gently. It will be only an alarm to sin to put itself into a posture of defence, to retreat further into the soul, and there to rally together its strengths, and to secure itself by a firmer possession. (R. South, D. D.)
Fasting joined with humility
It is not a mournful expression, a solemn dress, or a thin table, that God so much regards. It is the heart, and not the stomach, that He would have empty; and, therefore, if a man carries a luxurious soul in a pining body, or the aspiring mind of a Lucifer in the hanging head of a bulrush, he fasts only to upbraid his Maker, and to disgrace his religion, and to heighten his final reckoning, till he becomes ten times more the son of perdition than those who own their inward love of sin by the open undissembled enmities of a suitable behaviour. (R. South, D. D.)
Fasting and prayer
Prayer, joined with fasting, is like an apple of gold set off with a picture of silver. Now we have it at its best advantage; it shines bright, and it flames pure, like fire without the incumbrances of smoke, or the allay of contrary blasts. (R. South, D. D.)
Fasting
No doubt the primary meaning of the word translated fasting, is that abstinence from food which was practised by the saints of the Old Testament, by our Lord Himself, His apostles, and His Church in all times and climes, for the subjection of the flesh to the spirit. But the Church of England, while she commends and commands this Scriptural discipline, makes no severe definitions and lays down no rigid rule, for many and righteous reasons.
I. Because no rules could be applicable to all, the young, the old, the weak, the poor.
II. Because, if it were compulsory, it would become a mere form or evasion; e.g., a fast from flesh meat might be only a feast on other dainties.
III. Because a fast kept ostentatiously in direct disobedience to our Lords warning that we appear not unto men to fast, would only be a feast of pride-the pride which apes humility.
IV. Because under the gospel, in the liberty wherewith Christ has made us free, we fast by the love of virtue and our own choice, rather than by the coercion of any law.
V. Because the best form of abstinence is to be temperate in all things.
VI. Because bodily fasting is but a part of that self-denial which Christianity teaches, and which has a far more definite and comprehensive scope. True fasting is, to spend less upon ourselves, that we may have more to spend upon others; less upon luxuries and dainties, that others may have common food. (S. R. Hole, M. A.)
Fasting
When the greatest speed of a horse is to be tested, the trainer does not allow him to run at will over in the pasture, nor does he simply put him on a wholesale diet. He almost counts the straws that he gives the horse. He cleans and sifts the oats, and gives him the very best kinds. He measures the horses exercise, and every part of the horse is under the trainers watch and care, that he may be in the finest condition when he puts forth his energy in competition. And shall a man do so much for his horse and nothing for himself? Shall there be no preparation, no discipline, no care as to diet, no training, nothing but going on through the linked year, Sabbath joined to Sabbath, taking things as they come, allowing themselves to move about as the current sweeps them along? Is that the wisest method of spiritual culture? (H. W. Beecher.)
Extraordinary means necessary
When the Christian is buffeted with any temptation, or overpowered with a corruption, and cannot by the use of ordinary means quench the one or mortify the other; when the short dagger of ordinary prayer will not reach the heart of a lust, then it is time to draw out the long sword of extraordinary prayer upon it. Some poor souls complain that they have come to the Word in their daily prayers, begged power over such a lust, resolved against it many a time, and none of these means cure it; what can they now do more? Here thou art told: bring thy condition to Christ in this solemn ordinance of prayer and fasting; this hath been the happy means of strengthening many a poor Christian, to be avenged on those spiritual enemies which have outbraved all his former efforts, and, like Samson, to pull down the devils house upon his head. (Gurnall.)
National fasting
If we are not to expect that the devil should go out of a particular person, under a bodily possession, without extraordinary prayer, or prayer and fasting; how much less should we expect to have him cast out of the land and the world without it! (President Edward.)
Fuente: Biblical Illustrator Edited by Joseph S. Exell
Verse 21. This kind goeth not out but by prayer, c.] , this kind, some apply to the faith which should be exercised on the occasion, which goeth not out, doth not exert itself, but by prayer and fasting but this interpretation is, in my opinion, far from solid. However, there is great difficulty in the text. The whole verse is wanting in the famous Vatican MS., one of the most ancient and most authentic perhaps in the world; and in another one of Colbert’s, written in the 11th or 12th century. It is wanting also in the Coptic, Ethiopic, Syriac, Hieros., and in one copy of the Itala. But all the MSS. acknowledge it in the parallel place, Mr 9:29, only the Vatican MS. leaves out , fasting. I strongly suspect it to be an interpolation; but, if it be, it is very ancient, as Origen, Chrysostom, and others of the primitive fathers, acknowledged it. But while candour obliges me to acknowledge that I cannot account for the fact here alleged, that a certain class or genus of demons cannot be expelled but by prayer and fasting, while others may be ejected without them, I can give a sense to the passage which all my readers will easily understand: viz. that there are certain evil propensities, in some persons, which pampering the flesh tends to nourish and strengthen; and that self-denial and fasting, accompanied by prayer to God, are the most likely means, not only to mortify such propensities, but also to destroy them. For other remarkable circumstances relative to this case, See Clarke on Mr 9:17, &c.
Fuente: Adam Clarke’s Commentary and Critical Notes on the Bible
Howbeit, this kind goeth not out,…. The Vulgate Latin renders it, “is not cast out”; and so do the Arabic version, and Munster’s Hebrew Gospel; and which confirm the more commonly received sense of these words, that they are to be understood of that kind of devils, one of which was cast out of the lunatic, and was of the worst sort, of a fierce and obstinate kind; and having had long possession, was not easily ejected: and that there is a difference in devils, some are worse and more wicked than others, is clear from Mt 12:45 and not of that kind of miracles, or kind of faith to the working of such miracles. Moreover, the above versions, as they fitly express the word , here used; see Mr 9:17 compared with Mt 15:17. So they pertinently set forth the dispossession of devils, who do not go out voluntarily, but by force; and this sort could not be ejected,
but by fasting and prayer: that is, in the exercise of a miraculous faith, expressed in solemn prayer to God, joined with fasting. It seems that Christ not only suggests, that faith was greatly wanting in his disciples; for which reason they could not cast out the devil, and heal the lunatic; but they had been wanting in prayer to God, to assist them in the exercise of their miraculous gifts; and that whilst Christ, and the other three disciples were on the mount, they had been feasting and indulging themselves with the people, and so were in a very undue disposition of mind, for such extraordinary service, for which our Lord tacitly rebukes them. This agrees with the notions of the Jews, who think that, by fasting, a divine soul f , “may obtain that which is sought for”; and that among other things, for which a private person may afflict himself with fasting, this is one, , “because of an evil spirit” g; which they think may be got rid of this way.
f Jacchiades in Dan. x. 3. g T. Bab. Taanith, fol. 22. 2. Maimon. Hilch. Taaniot, c. 1. sect. 6.
Fuente: John Gill’s Exposition of the Entire Bible
21. This kind goeth not out, (492) By this expression Christ reproved the negligence of certain persons, in order to inform them that it was not an ordinary faith which was required; for otherwise they might have replied that they were not altogether destitute of faith The meaning therefore is, that it is not every kind of faith that will suffice, when we have to enter into a serious conflict with Satan, but that vigorous efforts are indispensably necessary. For the weakness of faith he prescribes prayer as a remedy, to which he adds fasting by way of an auxiliary. “You are effeminate exorcist,” said he, “and seem as if you were engaged in a mock-battle got up for amusement; (493) but you have to deal with a powerful adversary, who will not yield till the battle has been fought out. Your faith must therefore be excited by prayer, and as you are slow and languid in prayer, you must resort to fasting as an assistance.” (494) Hence it is very evident how absurdly the Papists represent fasting to be the specific method of driving away devils, since our Lord refers to it for no other reason than to stimulate the earnestness of prayer. When he says that this kind of devils cannot be cast out in any other way than by prayer and fasting, he means that, when Satan has taken deep root in any one, and has been confirmed by long possession, or when he rages with unbridled fury, the victory is difficult and painful, and therefore the contest must be maintained with all our might.
(492) “ Cest espece [de diablos] ne sort point;” — “this kind [of devils] goeth not out.”
(493) “ Vous y venez ainsi qu’a un combat de petits enfans, et comme s’il n’estoit question que de s’escarmoucher pour passe-temps.” — “You come to it as if it were to a fight of little children, and as if you had nothing to do but to skirmish for amusement.”
(494) “ Comme une aide pour vous exciter et enflamber;” — “as an assistance to excite and inflame you.”
Fuente: Calvin’s Complete Commentary
(21) This kind goeth not out but by prayer and fasting.The words imply degrees in the intensity of the forms of evil ascribed to demons amounting to a generic difference. Some might yield before the energy of a human will, and the power of the divine Name, and the prayers even of a weak faith. Some, like that which comes before us here, required a greater intensity of the spiritual life, to be gained by the prayer and fasting of which our Lord speaks. The circumstances of the case render it probable that our Lord himself had vouchsafed to fulfil both the conditions. The disciples, we know, did not as yet fast (Mat. 9:14-15), and the facts imply that they had been weak and remiss in prayer. The words are noticeable as testifying to the real ground and motive for fasting, and to the gain for the higher life to be obtained, when it was accompanied by true prayer, by this act of conquest over the lower nature. So St. Peters vision (Act. 10:9-10), and the appointment of Paul and Barnabas by the direct guidance of the Spirit (Act. 13:2), are both connected with fasting. And St. Paul, besides the hunger and thirst that came upon him as the incidents of his mission-work, speaks of himself as in fastings often (2Co. 11:27).
Fuente: Ellicott’s Commentary for English Readers (Old and New Testaments)
21. This kind The word kind may mean the entire species of evil spirits, and then our Lord would mean to say that to cast out evil spirits requires prayer and fasting. Or it may mean that this special kind of evil spirits which infested this child requires special faith, or special effort to give effect to that faith. The latter is the more obvious, and therefore the more probable meaning. That there are various grades of spirits of evil is not improbable in itself; and the idea is sustained by many proofs. The very fact that Beelzebub is prince of devils, shows this. Mark, by his glowing description of the fierceness both of this demon and of the demons at Gadara, evidently means to convey the idea that there are demons of more than ordinary fierceness. Matthew tells us (Mat 12:45) of one who took “seven other spirits more wicked than himself.” And Paul (Eph 6:12) evidently describes divers orders of evil. We may safely conclude, therefore, that our Lord meant to say that this sort of demon required more than ordinary spiritual vigour to expel him. And here we have a solemn intimation that we have all, nigh unto us, spiritual foes of various power, whose force can be overcome by the vigorous use of the means of training our spiritual strength.
Fuente: Whedon’s Commentary on the Old and New Testaments
Mat 17:21. This kind goeth not out, &c. Prayer and fasting could have no relation to the ejection of demons, but so far only as they had a tendency to increase the faith of miracles in him who had that power formerly conferred upon him. For example, prayer, by impressing a man’s mind with a more intimate sense that all things whatsoever depend upon the infinite and incomprehensible power of God, raises his idea of that power to a greater sublimity than can be done in the way of ordinary speculation. And as for fasting, by weakening the animal life, it subdues such passions as are nourished by continual repletion of body. Hence fasting has a tendencyto free the mind from the dominion of passion, which never fails to occasion a great inward perturbation, and at times has been found to make even holy men inattentive, at least to the more silent impressions of God’s Spirit. Fasting therefore produces an inward quietness and calm, very favourable to the growth of faith
Fuente: Commentary on the Holy Bible by Thomas Coke
Mat 17:21 . ] this species of demons to which the one just expelled belongs . Otherwise, Euth. Zigabenus: . So Chrysostom, Theophylact, Elsner, Fritzsche, Bleek. But the , used with special reference to the fact of its being a case of epilepsy, must be intended to specify a kind of demons which it is peculiarly difficult to exorcise.
. ] inasmuch as the is thereby strengthened and elevated, and attains to that pitch which is necessary in order to the casting out of such demons. The climax in Mat 17:20-21 may be represented thus: If you have only a slender amount of faith, you will, no doubt, be able to accomplish things of an extraordinary and seemingly impossible nature; but, in order to expel spirits of so stubborn a character as this, you require to have such a degree of faith as can only be reached by means of prayer and fasting. You have neglected the spiritual preparation that is necessary to the attainment of so lofty a faith. Comp. Act 14:23 . Prayer and fasting are here represented as means for promoting faith, not as good works , which are of themselves effectual in dealing with the demons (Schegg and the older Catholics). Paulus and Ammon incorrectly suppose that the prayer and fasting are required of the sick persons themselves , with a view to some dietetic and psychological effect or other being produced upon their bodies; while Chrysostom, Theophylact, and Euth. Zigabenus are of opinion that they are demanded not merely from the healer , but also from the patient , as necessary weapons to be used against the demon. Inasmuch as is, according to the context, the correlative of , Mat 17:19 (comp. also , Mat 17:18 ), we must likewise discard the view of Ewald, who thinks that in Matthew there is an allusion to a class of men whose character is such that they cannot be induced to set to work but with fasting and prayer. Comp. on the contrary, ., Act 19:12 (and Mar 9:29 : ).
Those who adopt the mythical view of the whole incident (Strauss) pretend to find the origin of the legend in 2Ki 4:29 ff., which is no less unwarrantable than the interpretation, according to which it is treated as a symbolical narrative, intended to rebuke the want of faith on the part of the disciples (Scholten), or as a didactic figure as an admonition of the hidden Christ for an increase of faith amid the violent demoniacal excesses of the time (Volkmar). Moreover, the somewhat more circumstantial account of Mark is of a stamp so peculiar, is so clear and full of meaning, that it is not to be regarded as a later amplification, but the account in Matthew (and Luke) is rather to be looked upon as an abridgment of the former.
Fuente: Heinrich August Wilhelm Meyer’s New Testament Commentary
21 Howbeit this kind goeth not out but by prayer and fasting.
Ver. 21. This kind goeth not out ] Some devils then are not so potent, political, vile, villanous, as others: so neither are wicked men all alike wicked; some stigmatical Belialists face the heavens, burden the earth, please not God, and are contrary to all men, 1Th 2:15 . Others are more tame and tractable, as the young man on whom Christ looked and loved him. Yet, as when one commended the pope’s legate at the Council of Basil, Sigismund the emperor answered, Tamen Romanus est: yet I am a Roman: so though the devil or his slaves seem never so fair conditioned, they are neither to be liked nor trusted. He is a devil still, and will do his kind: they are wicked still, and “wickedness proceedeth from the wicked,” as saith the proverb of the ancients,1Sa 24:131Sa 24:13 . I have read of one that would haunt the taverns, theatres, and whore houses in London all day, but he dared not go forth without private prayer in the morning, and then would say at his departure, Now, devil, do thy worst; and so used his prayers as charms and spells against the weak, cowardly devil. This was not that prayer and fasting our Saviour here speaks of; men must not go forth to this spiritual fight, , with their breakfast, as the Greeks in Homer, but praying and fasting from sin especially: for otherwise they do but light a candle before the devil, as the proverb hath it.
Fuente: John Trapp’s Complete Commentary (Old and New Testaments)
Mat 17:21 . ide on Mar 9:29 .
Fuente: The Expositors Greek Testament by Robertson
this kind. Implying different kinds. See Mat 12:45. Act 16:17. 1Jn 4:1. T Tr. [A] WH R omit this verse; but not the Syriac.
but = except.
prayer. Greek. proseuche. See App-134.
Fuente: Companion Bible Notes, Appendices and Graphics
Mat 17:21. , …, but this kind, etc.) Our Lord does not in this passage speak of the whole race of devils, but of this particular kind or class of them; from whence it appears that there are more than one kind of devils. The disciples had before this cast out devils even without prayer and fasting;[795] but this kind of devils has a disposition especially opposed to, and reducible by, prayer and fasting. The disciples were not accustomed to fasting (see ch. Mat 9:14); and they appear to have been somewhat sell-indulgent (sobrietatem minus servare) during their Lords absence.
[795] Since by [prayers and] fastings faith is increased.-V. g.
Fuente: Gnomon of the New Testament
Howbeit The two best MSS. omit Mat 17:21.
Fuente: Scofield Reference Bible Notes
this: Mat 12:45
but: 1Ki 17:20, 1Ki 17:21, Dan 9:3, Mar 9:29, Act 13:2, Act 13:3, Act 14:23, 1Co 7:5, 2Co 11:27, Eph 6:18
Reciprocal: Luk 9:40 – and they Luk 17:6 – If Jam 5:15 – the prayer
Fuente: The Treasury of Scripture Knowledge
Seeing Christ in Matthew
Mat 17:21-27
INTRODUCTORY WORDS
In Matthew we have decided to address ourselves to Christ’s relationship to His people. For our introduction we will center our thought on a verse of Scripture found in Mat 17:27. Peter had been troubled about the tax money.
1. Let us look at it this way. Christ is with us in the hour of every difficulty. He seemed to be saying to Peter, You need money to pay the taxes, Me and thee for it. This spirit of comradeship in every undertaking is breathed forth throughout the whole Gospel. Christ is with His disciples to back them up, and to provide for them in every time of need.
The very last thing we have in the Gospel of Matthew is the great commission to the disciples to “teach all nations, baptizing them in the Name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost: teaching them to observe all things whatsoever I have commanded you.” This commission was preceded by a statement, “All power is given Me in Heaven and in earth”; and it was followed by the other statement, “Lo, I am with you alway, even unto the end of the world.” Once more, the Lord is saying: Me and thee for it.
Should we not rejoice in the fact that He is still with us to enable us, and to supply all of our needs?
2. Let us look at it another way. Everything that Christ has is also ours. He is saying to us; It is FOR Me and for thee. No matter what is His, it is also ours.
As we see Him in birth, He is saying it is for Me and for thee. As we see Him in life, moving among the people every act bears the testimony, for Me and for thee. As we see Him in death; again, He says “For Me and thee.” When we pass to the empty tomb, it is vocal with the cry, “For Me and for thee.” When we view Him at the Father’s right hand, or coming back in the clouds of Heaven, it is all “for Me and for thee.”
We can hear the Spirit saying, “All things are yours; whether * * things present, or things to come; all are yours; and ye are Christ’s.”
3. Let us remember, in all of this there is the indescribable glory of an indissoluble union. We drop the word “for” and now we read, “Me and thee.” The little word “and” is a conjunction, and it seems to us to marry the Me, to the thee; and the thee to the Me, and so, we journey together, we two.
We were quickened together, raised up together, and made to sit together in the Heavenly places. The word “together” seems to say, “Each for the other and both for God.” It seems to say, Together we will journey from earth to Heaven. Then, we shall dwell together forevermore.
I. TOGETHER WITH CHRIST AND THE CHILDREN (Mat 18:2-6)
1. The little child in the midst. Unafraid and unabashed, because Jesus was near, a little one was lifted by the Master’s side in the midst of the disciples. As the child stood there, Jesus said: “Except ye be converted, and become as little children, ye shall not enter into the Kingdom of Heaven.” He also said: “Whoso shall receive one such little child in My Name receiveth Me.” Then He added: “But whoso shall offend one of these little ones which believe in Me, it were better for him that a millstone were hanged about his neck, and that he were drowned in the depth of the sea.”
Thus did Christ show how close the little children were to the great heart of His love. He knew how to take the little ones in His arms and to bless them. When the disciples wanted to send them away, He said: “Suffer little children to come unto Me, and forbid them not.”
Beloved, if we have the love of God in our heart, we will love the little children. Have the responsibilities of parenthood gripped us? Have we weighed the possibility of love toward our little brothers and sisters?
2. Loving and trusting as little children do. Our Lord not only loved the children, but He said: “Except ye * * become as little children.” We must have, then, that same trusting heart if we would like to nestle up close to our Lord.
‘E’en as a child, both meek and mild
With simple trust
Believes the Lord, accepts His Word,
So trust we must.
The Apostle John delighted to address the saints as, “Little Children.” May we approach our Lord in that same spirit.
II. TOGETHER WITH CHRIST ON THE MOUNT OF TRANSFIGURATION (Mat 17:1-4)
1. We wonder if we would have had an invitation to go with Christ, to the scene of His transfiguration? The Bible says that He took Peter and James and John and brought them up into an high mountain apart. We wonder if the word “apart” had any connection with the nine whom He left behind. He did not take them with Him. Would He take us? Do we live in His presence? Do we walk with Him and talk with Him? Then we are children of the light and in us there is no darkness.
2. As we sit on the mount with Him we behold His glory. He was transfigured before them and His face did shine as the sun, and His raiment was white as the light.
It is wonderful indeed to have fellowship with One who is so full of glory, and whose raiment is so spotlessly white.
3. As we sit with Him we are taken into the secret of the things which concern Him most. On the mountain height there appeared unto them Moses and Elias talking with Him. The three disciples had not alone the privilege of seeing the Lord in His glory but they had also the privilege of hearing Him discuss His coming death at Jerusalem.
4. As we sit on the mountain with Him we have fellowship with others. How wonderful it will be to sit down in the Kingdom of Heaven with Abraham and with Isaac and with Jacob, and with the Prophets and seers of old.
We do not marvel that Peter said: “Lord, it is good for us to be here.”
III. TOGETHER WITH CHRIST ON THE MOUNT OF BEATITUDES (Mat 5:1)
“‘And seeing the multitude, He went up into the mountain: and when He was set, His disciples came unto Him.”
1. Let us sit at Jesus’ feet as He teaches us His Word. We read of Mary who chose that better part that should not be taken from her. As we take our place with Mary and with the twelve, we marvel at the gracious words which proceed out of His mouth. We are struck with the wonderful blesseds. Read Mat 5:3-11.
These are not all the things which we hear, but these are the words which befall the righteous.
2. Let us sit at Jesus’ feet as an exponent of the Scriptures. The Lord Jesus Christ said of the words of Moses, “Have ye not read that which was spoken unto you by God?” Whatever else we may think of Christ and the Bible, we must acknowledge that He acclaimed the Bible the Word of God. When the Lord met the devil in the wilderness and three insinuating temptations were thrust upon Him, He quickly reached back into the Old Testament Scriptures and pulling out the Sword of the Spirit, He said: “It is written.”
3. Let us behold Christ as the Teacher of illustrative truth. He delighted as He taught to appeal to the things of nature which lay around Him. He could say, “Consider the lilies * * how they grow.” He could speak of the sower, who went forth to sow his seed. He could tell how He was the Door. He spoke of the sun and of Himself as the light of the world. Everything to Him seemed ablaze with implied truth.
IV. TOGETHER WITH CHRIST AS HE FED THE MULTITUDE (Mat 14:15)
As we slip out for a moment into the desert, we behold a great multitude flocking around the Lord. He was moved with compassion toward them, and He healed their sick. As the shades of evening fell the twelve urged the Master saying, “This is a desert place, * * send the multitude away, that they may go into the villages, and buy themselves victuals.” But Jesus said unto them: “They need not depart; give ye them to eat.”
We are about to learn some wonderful things relative to our Lord.
1. His heart of compassion toward the hungry. It was for this very thing that Christ came from Heaven above. Not because He saw men physically hungry, but because He saw them without the Bread of Life. Therefore, He gave His own flesh that they might have the Bread of Life. In this respect our Lord is still saying unto us, “Give ye them to eat.”
2. His method of supplying their need. He took the. five loaves and the two fishes, and looking up to Heaven He blessed and brake and gave the loaves to His disciples. There was another time that Christ took the loaf and blessed and brake. It was the time when He said in the upper room: “This is My body, which is broken for you: this do in remembrance of Me.”
We wonder, somehow, as Christ broke the bread in the desert if He did not have this later scene in mind.
3. The bounty. After the multitude had eaten and were filled they took up of the fragments that remained twelve baskets full, and they that had eaten were about five thousand men beside the women and children. There was another time just after Pentecost when we read of five thousand who had been filled-filled with joy and peace in eternal life. Was there anything left over that day in the desert? Yea, there were twelve baskets full. Was there anything left over after the days of the early Church? Yes, there is a bountiful and unlimited supply of grace still here.
There are still hungry multitudes. Let us give them to eat.
V. TOGETHER WITH CHRIST AS HE YEARNED OVER JERUSALEM (Mat 23:37)
We are now asking you to journey with us to one of those climactic scenes in the life of our Lord.
1. We stand in the midst of the curse. The Lord Jesus Christ had uttered his strongest anathemas and His woes against the scribes and the Pharisees. In Christ’s mind, they stood as the leaders of a rebellious people. As we read these words they seem, on the surface, to be full of indignation and wrath, of tribulation and anguish. They do not merely seem so to be, but they are what they seem. The Lord Jesus is Judge, and as Judge He is faithful and true.
2. We stand in the midst of a compassionate Judge. After Christ had said: “All these things shall come upon this generation,” it was then that His heart of compassion gave way, as He cried out, “O Jerusalem, Jerusalem, thou that killest the Prophets, and stonest them which are sent unto thee, how often would I have gathered thy children together, even as a hen gathered her chickens under her wings, and ye would not.”
In those words we fathom the inner throbbings of the Son of God. We can understand now why it was that He wept over Jerusalem as He was entering it during the Passion week.
We wonder if He still weeps. The Prophet Daniel prayed with his face toward Jerusalem. Does Jesus not pray at this moment in the glory with His face toward the holy but downtrodden city?
VI. TOGETHER WITH CHRIST AT THE EMPTY TOMB (Mat 28:9)
1. Journeying with the women to the grave of Christ. It was in the end of the Sabbath as it began to dawn toward the first day of the week that the women started to the sepulcher. As they journeyed along, there was a great earthquake for the angel of the Lord descended from Heaven, and came and rolled back the stone from the door, and sat upon it. The keepers of the tomb became as dead men, as the angel with a countenance like lightning, and with his raiment white as snow, burst upon them.
As the women approached, the angel said unto them, “Fear not ye: for I know that ye seek Jesus, which was crucified. He is not here: for He is risen, as He said. Come see the place where the Lord lay.”
We stand with the women looking in at the empty tomb and our hearts are beating with a startled joy. The One who was dead is alive again.
2. The command of the angel to the women. He said, “Go quickly, and tell.” Somehow or other that command lies heavily on our heart. We must fly with the message of the Risen Christ. We must tell it the world around. Christ lives.
Yes, the stone as they came was gone that day,
For an angel had rolled it back, they say,
And the Lord Himself had slipped away,
The tomb could not hold Him there
The resurrection was the great joy note of the early Church. It was the resurrection of Christ that placed God’s seal and approbation upon the Cross of Christ.
3. The meeting with the Lord Himself. As the women went to tell His disciples, “Behold, Jesus met them, saying, All Hail.” The words, All Hail, mean, All Joy. We could not stand together with Christ in any place that could bring to us a greater joy.
VII. TOGETHER WITH CHRIST IN HIS LAST GREAT COMMAND (Mat 28:19-20)
The disciples met the Lord by appointment. When they saw Him they worshiped Him, but some doubted. Then Jesus came and spake unto them, saying, “Go * *, and teach all nations.”
1. The plan of evangelization. We have seen a painting of Alexander studying the plan of march before he went forth to battle. We can almost see our Lord with the chart lying before Him. It is a chart, with a world lying in darkness. To the disciples, Christ gives His marching orders saying: Go; go teach; go teach all nations; go teach them baptizing; go, teach, baptizing, and “teaching them to observe all things whatsoever I have commanded you.” Thus did the Lord outline the task which He committed unto the disciples, and which is now committed unto us. God grant that we may not prove truant to the plan.
2. The promise of help. The Lord Jesus Christ has not sent us out unpanoplied for preaching. He has said, “All power is given unto Me in Heaven and in earth. Go ye, therefore.” The word “therefore” links every ambassador to the power which lies behind the command. Christ also said: “I am with you.” What need we fear. The One with all power has not only commanded us to go, but He journeys with us in the way. He is with us as He was with them because He said: “I am with you alway, even unto the end of the world.”
Time flieth; I will fly
Lest some one droop and die
Undone by sin and strife,
Ere comes the Word of life.
As the end of the age draws nigh and our upgoing comes on apace, let us bestir ourselves to our utmost activity for souls.
AN ILLUSTRATION
If we lose Christ from our vision and break communion with Him, we have lost all. More than anything else, the Church and the individual need the presence and the power of Christ. One morning, as the students of an old artist filed into his studio, one of their number cried out in tones of great joy, “The master has come! The master has come!” And when they asked him how he knew, he replied, “Look at that picture: I tell you no one but the master could do a thing like that.” The old artist had gone away for a time, and had left his students to work alone as best they could. In the soul of one of them there had been formed a noble picture, and even before the master went away he had been trying to produce it on the canvas. He had done the best he could, but the picture was imperfect, and he knew it.
One evening, saddened by his failure, weary and disappointed, he retired to his lodgings. That night the old artist had unexpectedly returned, and before going to his sleep, he passed through the studio to see what his pupils had been doing while he was away. He saw the painting upon which the young artist had wrought. He, too, knew that it was imperfect, but he knew also just wherein the imperfection lay; taking the brush, he supplied with a few strokes what was lacking, and then passed on. In the morning the students came back, each one to his work. The young painter paused a moment in wonder before his easel and then the glad shout fell from his lips, “The master has come! The master has come!” “No one but the master could do that.”
The presence and power of the Master is what we need. * * Without Him our best is weakness and futility; but if we are only willing and ready He will come, and where we have failed He will succeed and in His power we can do all things.”-From Illustrations From Art.
Fuente: Neighbour’s Wells of Living Water
7:21
Howbeit is an obsolete word meaning “nevertheless,” indicating that some special point is about to be made. This kind is from GENOS which Thayer defines, “The aggregate of many individuals, of the same nature, sort, species.” Goeth out is from EKPOREUOMAI which Thayer defines, “To go forth, go out, depart.” He explains the definition to mean, “demons, when expelled, are said to go out (to wit from the human body): Mat 17:21.” Robinson defines the word, “To go out of, to go or come forth,” and he explains it to mean, “Spoken of demons, absolutely Mat 17:21.” We do not know why this class of devils required the special performance of prayer and fasting before yielding and coming out of human beings. We are certain, however, that at some time Jesus had given his apostles the instructions that should have induced them to show the faith necessary to be patient and use the weapons of prayer and fasting against the devil. Their faith had not led them that far and hence they failed to overcome the devil.
Fuente: Combined Bible Commentary
Howbeit this kind goeth not out but by prayer and fasting.
[This kind goeth not out but by prayer and fasting.] It is not much unlike this, which is said, By reason of an evil spirit a singular or religious man may afflict himself with fastings.
Fuente: Lightfoot Commentary Gospels
Mat 17:21. The two oldest manuscripts, the best of the later ones (cursives), some very ancient versions, omit this verse, and there are other reasons for doubting its genuineness. If retained: Howbeit should be changed to but. See notes on Mar 9:29, where the passage is to be retained.
Fuente: A Popular Commentary on the New Testament
Mat 17:21. This kind Of devils, goeth not out but by prayer and fasting Joined with an eminent degree of the faith he had been describing. He intended by this to excite them to intercede with God for his more abundant co-operation; and by such extraordinary devotions to endeavour to prepare their souls for his further influences. What a testimony have we here of the efficacy of fasting, when added to fervent prayer! Some kinds of devils the apostles had east out before this without fasting.
Fuente: Joseph Bensons Commentary on the Old and New Testaments
17:21 {4} Howbeit this kind goeth not out but by {h} prayer and fasting.
(4) The remedy against distrust.
(h) To help us to understand the watchfulness and diligence of earnest prayer, which cannot be without sobriety.