Exegetical and Hermeneutical Commentary of 2 Samuel 10:18
And the Syrians fled before Israel; and David slew [the men of] seven hundred chariots of the Syrians, and forty thousand horsemen, and smote Shobach the captain of their host, who died there.
18. seven hundred chariots forty thousand horsemen ] The present text of Chronicles has seven thousand chariots forty thousand footmen. It seems best to retain the reading seven hundred chariots, and follow Chronicles in reading footmen. But the omission of horsemen in the one and footmen in the other makes it likely that there is some further corruption.
Fuente: The Cambridge Bible for Schools and Colleges
Seven hundred chariots – More probable than the seven thousand of 1Ch 19:18. The frequent errors in numbers arise from the practice of expressing numerals by letters, with one or more dots or dashes to indicate hundreds, thousands, etc.
Fuente: Albert Barnes’ Notes on the Bible
Verse 18. SEVEN HUNDRED chariots – and forty thousand HORSEMEN] In the parallel place, 1Ch 19:18, it is said, David slew of the Syrians SEVEN THOUSAND men, which fought in chariots. It is difficult to ascertain the right number in this and similar places. It is very probable that, in former times, the Jews expressed, as they often do now, their numbers, not by words at full length, but by numeral letters; and, as many of the letters bear a great similarity to each other, mistakes might easily creep in when the numeral letters came to be expressed by words at full length. This alone will account for the many mistakes which we find in the numbers in these books, and renders a mistake here very probable. The letter zain, with a dot above, stands for seven thousand, nun for seven hundred: the great similarity of these letters might easily cause the one to be mistaken for the other, and so produce an error in this place.
Fuente: Adam Clarke’s Commentary and Critical Notes on the Bible
The men of seven hundred chariots; Heb. seven hundred chariots, i.e. the men belonging to them, that fought in or with them; as plainly appears,
1. Because the men only, and not the chariots, were capable of being killed, as these are said to have been.
2. Because it is thus explained in the Book of Chronicles, which was written after this book, for this end, to explain what was dark or doubtful, and to supply what was omitted here; where, instead of these words, are seven thousand men which fought in chariots, 1Ch 19:18. And this is a very common metonymy; of which see above, 2Sa 8:4, and the notes on 1Sa 13:5. Although there might be seven thousand chariots in all, whereof seven hundred where chosen ones; according to the distinction made Exo 14:7.
Forty thousand horsemen; for which in 1Ch 19:18, is forty thousand footmen; which may be reconciled divers ways.
1. Both these may be true, that he slew forty thousand horsemen, which being the most considerable part and strength of the army, it might seem sufficient to name them, and every one could easily understand that the footmen in that case were certainly cut off; and that he slew also forty thousand footmen, as is said in 1 Chronicles where he mentions them only, because they were omitted in 2 Samuel, and the horsemen being expressed here, it was needless to repeat them in 1Ch 2. The horsemen may be here called footmen, in opposition to those that fought in chariots; because they sometimes fought on horseback, and sometimes came down from their horses, and fought on foot, when the place of the battle was more commodious for footmen than for horsemen; which it is not improbable was their case here; for David being a soldier of great prudence and experience, and understanding the great numbers of the Syrian horsemen, whereas the Israelites had but very few, Deu 17:16, would doubtless endeavour to choose a place as inconvenient for their horsemen as he could.
3. Peradventure the Syrians designed to bring the war into Davids country, and therefore hastened their march, and for that end put their footmen on horseback, (as hath been frequently done in like cases,) who, when they came to the place of battle, carne down from their horses, and fought on foot. So there is no need of acknowledging an error of the scribe in the sacred text; which yet if it were granted in such historical passages of no moment to the doctrine of faith and good life, it would not shake the foundation of our faith in matters of great importance, which it might reasonably be presumed the providence of God would more watchfully preserve from all depravation or corruption.
Fuente: English Annotations on the Holy Bible by Matthew Poole
And the Syrians fled before Israel,…. After an obstinate and bloody fight between them:
and David slew [the men of] seven hundred chariots of the Syrians; the word “men” is rightly supplied, for chariots could not be said to be slain, but the men in them; in 1Ch 19:17, they are said to be seven thousand, here seven hundred; which may be reconciled by observing, that here the chariots that held the men are numbered, there the number of the men that were in the chariots given, and reckoning ten men in a chariot, seven hundred chariots held just seven thousand men; though Kimchi takes another way of reconciling the two places, by observing that here only the choicest chariots are mentioned, there all of them, but the former way seems best:
and forty thousand horsemen; in 1Ch 19:17; it is forty thousand “footmen”, and so Josephus c; and the same may be called both horse and foot, be cause though they might come into the field of battle on horseback, yet might dismount and fight on foot; and so one historian calls them horsemen, and the other footmen; or the whole number of the slain, horse and foot mixed together, were forty thousand; Kimchi makes use of another way of removing this difficulty, and which perhaps is the best, that here only the horsemen are numbered that were slain, and there the footmen only, and both true; an equal number of each being slain, in all eighty thousand, besides the seven thousand in the chariots:
and smote Shobach the captain of their host, who died there; of his wounds upon the spot.
c Ut supra. (Antiqu. l. 7. c. 6. sect. 3.)
Fuente: John Gill’s Exposition of the Entire Bible
(18) Seven hundred chariots.In this campaign David delivered a crushing blow upon his foes, from which they did not recover during the rest of his reign or that of his son. For the seven hundred here 1Ch. 19:18 has seven thousand, which is almost an incredible number of chariots, and the number here is evidently the more correct; but the same place has forty thousand footmen, while here it is forty thousand horsemen. Probably both statements are meant to include both infantry and cavalry, though only one of them is especially mentioned in each case. Comp. Note on 2Sa. 10:6.
Fuente: Ellicott’s Commentary for English Readers (Old and New Testaments)
18. Seven hundred chariots In 1Ch 19:18, we have seven thousand. The discrepancy is doubtless the error of a copyist.
Forty thousand horsemen In Chronicles forty thousand footmen, another discrepancy resulting either from the carelessness of some early copyist, or the fragmentary character of these accounts. A fully detailed history of this war would doubtless give us many facts and figures now unknown.
Fuente: Whedon’s Commentary on the Old and New Testaments
2Sa 10:18. Slew the men of seven hundred chariots, &c. Though this reading is the same in the Vulgate, LXX, and Chaldee, yet in the Syriac it is seven hundred chariots, and four thousand horse: in the Arabic, one thousand six hundred chariots, and four thousand horse. The parallel place, 1Ch 19:18 reads, seven thousand men that fought in chariots, and fifty thousand footmen. Dr. Kennicott says, that the verse should be read thus: David destroyed seven thousand horsemen, seven hundred chariots, and forty thousand foot.
Fuente: Commentary on the Holy Bible by Thomas Coke
2Sa 10:18 And the Syrians fled before Israel; and David slew [the men of] seven hundred chariots of the Syrians, and forty thousand horsemen, and smote Shobach the captain of their host, who died there.
Ver. 18. And David slew the men of seven hundred chariots. ] Heb., Slew seven hundred chariots; that is, seven thousand men that fought in chariots a 1Ch 19:18
And forty thousand horsemen.
a Equites curules.
Fuente: John Trapp’s Complete Commentary (Old and New Testaments)
seven hundred. =1Ch 19:187; 1Ch 19:000. But Hebrew j = 7 and j = 7,000, probably a scribe’s
infirmity. Compare 2Sa 8:4 and 1Ch 18:4.
Fuente: Companion Bible Notes, Appendices and Graphics
fled: 2Sa 8:4, Psa 18:38, Psa 46:11
horsemen: 1Ch 19:18, footmen
Shobach: Jdg 4:2, Jdg 4:22, Jdg 5:26
Reciprocal: 1Ki 20:29 – an hundred thousand 2Ch 12:3 – twelve hundred Psa 20:7 – Some trust Psa 76:6 – both
Fuente: The Treasury of Scripture Knowledge
10:18 And the Syrians fled before Israel; and David slew [the men of] {g} seven hundred chariots of the Syrians, and forty thousand horsemen, and smote Shobach the captain of their host, who died there.
(g) Who were the chief and most principal: for in all he destroyed 7000, as in 1Ch 19:18, or the soldiers who were in 700 chariots.